4.7 Review

A meta-analysis of pulse-protein extraction technologies: Impact on recovery and purity

Journal

JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING
Volume 327, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.jfoodeng.2022.111048

Keywords

Pulses; Protein extraction; Protein purity; Protein recovery; Meta-analysis

Funding

  1. National Research Council Canada [SPP130-A1-019784, 58292]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Protein extraction from pulses has gained attention in the food processing industry, but there is a lack of comprehensive data analysis on the status quo of pulse-protein extraction technologies. This study conducted a meta-analysis of data from 41 published studies to assess the efficiency of three main extraction processes and highlighted the impact of processing conditions on purity and recovery levels.
Protein extraction from pulses has received significant attention in the food processing industry, and as such, several studies have been conducted to develop new methods and to improve upon the conventional methods. In all these, a broad data synthesis to pool and analyze data from these studies to assess and understand the status quo of the pulse-protein extraction technologies, is still wanting. Therefore, there is the need to synthesize data reported by the extensive collection of studies to inform stakeholders on the right pathways for development, critical understanding, and optimization purposes. A meta-analysis was conducted to assess the efficiency of three main extraction processes under two performance indicators of efficiency-protein purity and protein recovery with data points from 41 published studies. The meta-analysis showed that processing conditions affect purity and recovery levels. Several investigations are still to be conducted to understand critical aspects of the pulse extraction processes. Challenges and hotspots requiring further research for a better understanding of some aspects of the extraction process are also presented.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Chemistry, Applied

Starch modification for non-food, industrial applications: Market intelligence and critical review

Peter Adewale, Marziehossadat Shokrolllahi Yancheshmeh, Edmond Lam

Summary: Consumer demand for starch is increasing, leading starch producers to explore non-food, industrial applications for revenue generation. The market value of modified starch exceeds that of native starch and is anticipated to grow further through next-generation applications enabled by emerging technologies. Opportunities for using alternative botanical starch sources besides corn are also identified in the global market.

CARBOHYDRATE POLYMERS (2022)

Article Chemistry, Applied

Exploring the functional attributes and in vitro starch and protein digestibility of pea flours having a wide range of amylose content

Gexiao Sun, Peiji Ni, Edmond Lam, Sabahudin Hrapovic, Dengjin Bing, Bianyun Yu, Yongfeng Ai

Summary: This study characterized ten pea flours with different amylose contents and found that as the amylose content increased, the starch content decreased while the protein and total dietary fiber content increased. Higher amylose content resulted in higher starch gelatinization temperatures and reduced in vitro starch digestibility. These findings are valuable for developing new flour, starch, and protein ingredients from diverse pea lines.

FOOD CHEMISTRY (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

An integrated environmental nutrition model for dietary sustainability assessment

Raphael Aidoo, Chetanjot K. Romana, Ebenezer M. Kwofie, Jamie I. Baum

Summary: Environmental nutrition is replacing siloed sustainability assessment models to promote sustainable dietary decisions. The newly developed EIWDVs model provides a comprehensive and replicable approach for assessing the sustainability of nutrition. Plant-based alternatives are found to be sustainable choices with environmental nutrition benefits.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2023)

Article Polymer Science

Carboxylated Cellulose Nanocrystals Decorated with Varying Molecular Weights of Poly(diallyldimethylammonium chloride) as Sustainable Antibacterial Agents

Eliskander Rabia, Beza Tuga, Jose de Ondarza, Saleen M. M. Ramos, Edmond Lam, Sabahudin Hrapovic, Yali Liu, Rajesh Sunasee

Summary: Cationic nanomaterials coated with poly(diallyldimethylammonium chloride) were developed as effective antibacterial agents. The carboxylated cellulose nanocrystals derived from softwood pulp were coated with cationic poly(diallyldimethylammonium chloride) of varying molecular weights. The resulting cationic carboxylated cellulose nanocrystals coated with poly(diallyldimethylammonium chloride) (cCNCs-PDDA) showed marked antibacterial activity, especially against Gram-positive Staphylococcus aureus.

POLYMERS (2023)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Controlled Chitosan Molecular Weight Reduction by Mechanochemical and Aging-Based Phosphoric Acid Hydrolysis

Galen Yang, Edmond Lam, Audrey Moores

Summary: This study explores the use of mechanochemistry and aging as effective methods to control the molecular weight of commercial high molecular weight chitosan. Compared to conventional solution-based methods, this new mechanochemical method has improved process mass intensity and produces low molecular weight chitosan samples with a range of 200 to 19.5 kDa and a polydispersity of 1.8.

ACS SUSTAINABLE CHEMISTRY & ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Immunology

Sulfated Lactosyl Archaeol Archaeosome-Adjuvanted Vaccine Formulations Targeting Rabbit Hemorrhagic Disease Virus Are Immunogenic and Efficacious

Bassel Akache, Andrew J. Read, Renu Dudani, Blair A. Harrison, Dean Williams, Lise Deschatelets, Yimei Jia, Vandana Chandan, Felicity C. Stark, Gerard Agbayani, Shawn R. Makinen, Usha D. Hemraz, Edmond Lam, Sophie Regnier, Wei Zou, Peter D. Kirkland, Michael J. McCluskie

Summary: The study found that using a vaccine adjuvant containing sulfated lactosyl archaeol (SLA) can enhance the immune response to rabbit hemorrhagic disease virus (RHDV), resulting in increased antibody levels and improved survival rates, demonstrating its potential value in veterinary applications.

VACCINES (2023)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Life cycle sustainability assessment outlook of plant-based protein processing and product formulations

Derrick K. Allotey, Ebenezer M. Kwofie, Peter Adewale, Edmond Lam, Michael Ngadi

Summary: The increasing popularity of plant-based proteins as alternative sources has led to the need for assessing their sustainability. Researchers have used various tools and metrics including TEA, LCC, LCA, and S-LCA to analyze the sustainability of plant-based protein food ingredients and products. This review summarizes and discusses the methodologies and findings of previous studies in this field. The review highlights the minimal attention given to LCC, TEA, and S-LCA, and the lack of complete sustainability assessment covering all dimensions. more evidence and comprehensive studies are needed to compare the sustainability performance of plant-based proteins with traditional animal-based proteins.

SUSTAINABLE PRODUCTION AND CONSUMPTION (2023)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Effect of Surface Functionality on the Rheological and Self-Assembly Properties of Chitin and Chitosan Nanocrystals and Use in Biopolymer Films

Madison Santos, Olivia Del Carlo, Jasmine Hong, Ziruo Liu, Shuaibing Jiang, Sabahudin Hrapovic, Edmond Lam, Tony Jin, Audrey Moores

Summary: By tuning the chemical functionality of chitin nanocrystals (ChNCs), their macrscopic properties can be heavily impacted. In this study, two types of ChNCs were made using acid hydrolysis and oxidative pathways, and deacetylation was utilized to create chitosan nanocrystals (ChsNCs) with varying degree of deacetylation (DDA). The nanocrystals were then studied for their rheological behavior and liquid crystalline ordering. Additionally, they were incorporated into biodegradable pectin-alginate films as a physical reinforcement, showing increased tensile strength and Young's modulus values.

BIOMACROMOLECULES (2023)

Article Agricultural Engineering

The potential of Burkholderia thailandensis E264 for co-valorization of C5 and C6 sugars into multiple value-added bio-products

Warren Blunt, Catherine Blanchard, Christopher Doyle, Vinicio Vasquez, Mengwei Ye, Peter Adewale, Yali Liu, Krista Morley, Fanny Monteil-Rivera

Summary: This study found that Burkholderia thailandensis can simultaneously uptake glucose and xylose and accumulate up to 64% of its dry mass as poly(3-hydroxyalkanoate) (PHA) biopolymers, with a PHA titer of up to 3.8 g L-1 in shake flasks. Concomitantly, it also produced rhamnolipids, mainly Rha-Rha-C14-C14, with a titer typically in the range of 0.2-0.4 g L-1. Gluconic and xylonic acids were detected in titers of up to 5.3 g L-1, with xylonic acid being the major end product. This co-production of three products from mixed sugars using B. thailandensis can improve biorefinery economics.

BIORESOURCE TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Food Science & Technology

Overview of single cell protein: Production pathway, sustainability outlook, and digital twin potentials

Raphael Aidoo, Ebenezer M. Kwofie, Peter Adewale, Edmond Lam, Michael Ngadi

Summary: Single-cell protein (SCP) is an evolving biotechnological concept that aligns protein production with global sustainability goals. This review provides an overview of SCP's current outlook, discussing production, commercial prospects, and sustainability. It also explores the potential of the emerging digital twin concept in enhancing SCP production's efficiency and sustainability.

TRENDS IN FOOD SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Food Science & Technology

Nutritional-environmental trade-offs in potato storage and processing for a sustainable healthy diet

Aubin Payne, Ebenezer M. Kwofie, Prince Agyemang, Jamie I. Baum

Summary: Poor diets and limited access to nutritious foods have led to micronutrient deficiency in human health. While food fortification has helped in developed countries, over a quarter of the world's population still suffers from deficiency. This study investigates the loss of micronutrients in potato storage, processing, and consumption, revealing the optimal pathway for a sustainable healthy diet.

NPJ SCIENCE OF FOOD (2023)

Article Food Science & Technology

Sustainable healthy diet modeling for a plant-based dietary transitioning in the United States

Raphael Aidoo, Vincent Abe-Inge, Ebenezer M. Kwofie, Jamie I. Baum, Stan Kubow

Summary: This study investigates the environmental and nutritional performances of different dietary scenarios and finds a non-linear relationship between these two factors. The results suggest that including 10% legumes, 0.11% red meat, 0.28% processed meat, and 2.81% white meat in a composite diet can significantly reduce global warming and achieve a high diet quality.

NPJ SCIENCE OF FOOD (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Effect of high-voltage electrical discharge (HVED) at high frequency on vacuum freeze-drying time and physicochemical properties of blueberries

R. Diaz-Alvarez, S. Carpentieri, G. Ferrari, G. Pataro, L. Segura-Ponce

Summary: This study evaluated the effect of high voltage electrical discharge (HVED) on the freeze-drying process of blueberries, and found that HVED pretreatment can enhance freeze-drying rates and improve the quality of the final product.

JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Process engineering of semi-continuous boiling of massecuites based on Digital Twin of sucrose crystallization

V. I. Tuzhilkin, S. M. Petrov, N. M. Podgornova, N. D. Lukin

Summary: The study aims to simulate the process of isobaric evaporative crystallization of sucrose and propose a three-stage crystallization technology for semi-continuous boiling of massecuites. Through computer simulation and experimental verification, optimal parameters were determined to enhance the efficiency of crystallization.

JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Combination of nanoparticles and gelatin-genipin hydrogel enhances the antioxidant activity, stability, and release properties of curcumin

Seong Hwan Yu, Do-Yeong Kim, Youjin Baek, Hyeon Gyu Lee

Summary: This study investigated the effects of nanoencapsulation and gel incorporation on the antioxidant activity, stability, and release profile of curcumin. The results showed that CUR-loaded nanoparticles and CUR NPs-filled gelatin-genipin gels had significantly higher antioxidant activity, stability, and in vitro release profile compared to free CUR. The GL/GP-CUR NPs exhibited the highest antioxidant activity and increased stability, while the CUR NPs had a faster release rate. These findings suggest that GL/GP-CUR NPs have potential as an effective delivery system for CUR in the food industry.

JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Influence of polysaccharide-based co-encapsulants on efficiency, stability, and release of vitamins B12 and D3 in multilayered microcapsules

Linlin He, Shihong Hu, Gang Zhang, Xiao Wang, Yanna Zhao, Qingpeng Wang, Min Liu, Zhengping Wang, Prakash Sangeeta, Zhuang Ding

Summary: This study developed solid microcapsules containing co-loaded vitamin B12 and D3 using a W1/O/W2 emulsions and spray-drying method. The addition of polysaccharides as co-encapsulants improved the morphological characteristics, encapsulation efficiency, storage stability, and gastrointestinal simulation of the microcapsules. The electrostatic bonding with chitosan and multilayer protection from the W1/O/W2 structure contributed to the high encapsulation efficiency of vitB12. Incorporating polysaccharides into W2 enhanced the particle integrity of the dried powders and improved the retention rate and encapsulation efficiency of vitamins. Sodium carboxymethylcellulose showed the best protection for vitB12 and lower degradation rates for vitD3, while sodium alginate exhibited controlled release and the highest cumulative release under simulated gastric and intestinal conditions, respectively.

JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

A novel simulation model to analyze rice intermittent drying considering glass transition concept

Ehsan Nasrnia, Morteza Sadeghi, Ali Raeisi Isa-Abadi, Seyed Ahmad Mireei

Summary: A novel mathematical model considering the concept of glass transition was developed for rice intermittent drying process. The model utilized the real 3D body-fitted geometry of rice kernel and was validated through experiments. The glass transition behavior of the rice kernels and the distributions of temperature and moisture at each stage were analyzed.

JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Portable organophosphorus pesticide detection device based on controllable microfluidic and luminol composite nanofibers

Haoran Pang, Jiaqing Xie, Xiaoyu Meng, Ruqian Sun, Jun Chen, Chengli Guo, Tianfeng Zhou

Summary: A portable organophosphorus pesticide detection device equipped with microfluidic and luminol composite nanofibers was developed in this study. By optimizing the microfluidic chip design and the mass fraction of luminol particles, efficient detection of pesticide residues was achieved.

JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Band selection pipeline for maturity stage classification in bell peppers: From full spectrum to simulated camera data

J. Munoz-Postigo, E. M. Valero, M. A. Martinez-Domingo, F. J. Lara, J. L. Nieves, J. Romero, J. Hernandez-Andres

Summary: This paper presents a workflow for classifying the maturity of bell peppers using hyperspectral imaging and machine learning. The approach utilizes spectral reflectance to determine the number of maturity stages and employs optimized bands for accurate classification, achieving satisfactory results.

JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Optical measurement of the shear stress and velocity distribution in an idealized deglutition process

Artem Skrypnik, Sascha Heitkam, Christoph Gerstenberg, Eric Morelle, Christopher McHardy, Cornelia Rauh

Summary: The rheological properties of food play a crucial role in the physical interaction between food and the mouth during chewing and swallowing. This study focuses on the compression of liquid foams to simulate the idealized swallowing process and investigates the flow conditions and their impact on foam properties. The results provide insights into the haptic perception in the mouth during swallowing.

JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Modelling swelling effects in real espresso extraction using a 1-dimensional coarse-grained model

Chaojie Mo, Luciano Navarini, Furio Suggi Liverani, Marco Ellero

Summary: This study investigates the effects of swelling on espresso extraction by incorporating a particle-level swelling model into a one-dimensional bed-level extraction model. The results show that swelling only slightly affects the yield and strength at a fixed flow rate, but considerably enhances the strength at a fixed pressure drop. The finer the coffee particles, the more pronounced the enhancement. It is suggested that better control of yield and strength can be achieved by fixing the flow rate in an espresso machine. It is also indicated that numerical extraction simulations, when properly incorporated with relevant physical effects, can be used to predict the extraction kinetics and guide the design and production of espresso machines.

JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Characterization of methyltetrahydrophthalic anhydride esterified corn starch and their ability in stabilizing Pickering emulsion

Yang Zhong, Yi Lin, Mingxing Yang, Xiaodan Zeng, Dayu Liu, Wenlong Liu, Weijun Chen

Summary: Methyltetrahydrophthalic anhydride (MeTHPA) esterified corn starches (MeCS) with degrees of substitution (DS) ranging from 0.0066 to 0.072 were prepared and found to be effective in stabilizing Pickering emulsion. The modification of MeTHPA damaged the crystal structure of corn starch, roughened its surface structure, and increased its contact angle, which were positively correlated with the DS of MeCS. The particle size of MeCS increased and then decreased with increasing DS, with the smallest size observed for MeCS with a DS of 0.072. The Pickering emulsions stabilized by MeCS with a DS of 0.072 exhibited better stability compared to those stabilized by MeCS with lower DS, which can be attributed to their smaller particle size and higher viscosity. MeCS with a DS of 0.072, at a concentration of 3% (w/v), could maintain emulsion stability even after 50 days of storage. These findings suggest that MeCS with appropriate DS and concentration levels could be effective particle stabilizers for Pickering emulsions.

JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Vacuum impregnation assisted simultaneous micronutrients fortification and phytic acid reduction in lentils

Shubhajit Sarkhel, Anupam Roy

Summary: This study developed a vacuum impregnation technique to enhance the micronutrient content and bioavailability in lentils and reduce phytic acid. The results showed that vacuum impregnation led to higher migration of micronutrients and significantly reduced phytic acid without impacting the quality characteristics. The developed process achieved a substantial reduction in phytic acid-to-mineral molar ratio.

JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Biorefining of liquid insect fractions by microfiltration to increase functionality

L. J. H. Sweers, C. M. M. Lakemond, V. Fogliano, R. M. Boom, M. Mishyna, J. K. Keppler

Summary: This study investigated the use of microfiltration as a gentle processing technique for decontamination and fractionation of edible insects. The results showed that microfiltration effectively removed contaminants and produced distinct fractions with improved properties.

JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Prediction of mixture pelleting based on compression parameters

Wanfeng Sun, Yu Sun, Yu Wang, Haomeng He

Summary: In this study, a prediction model for the pelleting performance of multi-component mixed powders was proposed, and it was validated by conducting single pelleting experiments on mixtures of different edible powders.

JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Active film strips to extend the shelf life of fruits: Multibranched PLA-gallic acid as an antioxidant/oxygen scavenger in a case study of bananas (Musa AAA group)

Saowaluk Taechutrakul, Thananchai Piroonpan, Wanvimol Pasanphan

Summary: This original research developed active polylactic acid (PLA) film strips functionalized with gallic acid (GA) to extend the shelf-life of bananas. The PLA/mPLA-GA film strips exhibited a homogeneous matrix with improved mechanical properties and showed outstanding antioxidant and oxygen scavenging effects. The results suggest that PLA/mPLA-GA film strips show promise as an active bioplastic for extending the shelf-life of bananas and other fruits.

JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Experimental study on the impact of key material properties on flowability of sucrose and maltodextrin

Julien Dupas, Florent Baldeweck, Vincent Meunier

Summary: The flow performance of food powders is crucial in product development, as it can affect the dosing and filling processes. This study investigates the influence of various parameters on the flowability of carbohydrate powders, such as particle size and moisture content.

JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING (2024)