JOURNAL OF ANALYTICAL AND APPLIED PYROLYSIS

The editor, Curt Wentrup, from the University of Queensland School of Chemistry and Molecular Bioscience, is very professional. The invited reviewers have carefully reviewed the manuscript and provided valuable and targeted comments, showing their genuine intention to optimize the article. However, if the submitted article involves novel techniques or experimental techniques that have not been fully introduced in this journal, it is necessary to be prepared for detailed inquiries from the reviewers.

2021.2.20: Submission
2021.3.12: Received reviewer comments - one major revision and one minor revision. The reviewer asked many technical questions for the major revision. The editor's overall assessment was given to the minor revision, and there is a two-month period for revisions.
2021.5.8: Revised submission
2021.5.12: The editor discovered a submission oversight and requested a minor revision.
2021.5.12: Revised submission
2021.5.18: No re-review was requested, and the editor directly accepted the manuscript.

2022.10.18 Submitted to the Journal
2022.10.20 With Editor
2022.10.26 Under Review
2022.12.2 Major Revision
2022.12.20 Revision Submitted to the Journal
2023.1.8 Under Review
2023.1.31 Accepted

Compared to previous articles submitted to this journal, the review process for this article is noticeably longer. The Italian editor, Francesca Modugno, is more cautious in reviewing and evaluating submissions. The requirements for revisions are also higher, with only 15 days given for major revisions, in contrast to the more lenient Australian editor who often allows 2 months for revisions. However, once accepted, the article can be published online almost the next day, which is one of the clear advantages of this journal.