Join the Reviewer Roulette Hub
Share your experience with a Peer Review Champion or Peer Review Antagonist. Select the category that best describes your experience, and then provide the quote, context, and the journal you submitted to. Please refrain from publishing any personal information, including names or email addresses.
Peer Review Antagonist Impractical
Referee 1: However, I believe that the authors have a considerable misunderstanding of the research on microwave absorbing materials. Referee 2: the a...
- Comment from Physica Scripta reviewer
Peer Review Antagonist Impractical
Reviewer #1: I am sorry but the paper was not really improved. The construction of the sentences is grammatically and semantically incorrect. Then, in...
- Comment from Annals of Physics reviewer