Join the Reviewer Roulette Hub
Share your experience with a Peer Review Champion or Peer Review Antagonist. Select the category that best describes your experience, and then provide the quote, context, and the journal you submitted to. Please refrain from publishing any personal information, including names or email addresses.
Peer Review Antagonist Clueless
Here he authors' response to my comments (I am a reviewer, Q), the antagonists are the authors (Responses). Enjoy! "Ignorant reviewers, I respond once...
- Comment from Processes (ISSN 2227-9717) reviewer
Peer Review Antagonist Clueless
The current version of the paper, from the reviewer’s point of view, stands more for the overview/survey report than a research paper. Therefore, it i...
- Comment from Proceedings of the 15th International Congre... reviewer