Join the Reviewer Roulette Hub
Share your experience with a Peer Review Champion or Peer Review Antagonist. Select the category that best describes your experience, and then provide the quote, context, and the journal you submitted to. Please refrain from publishing any personal information, including names or email addresses.
Peer Review Champion Helpful
Reviewer #2: In the revised version the author has reasonably replied to my previous comment. I still recommend a revision of the maintext, since ther...
- Comment from Annals of Physics reviewer
Peer Review Champion Helpful
I would recommend considering PCA as a viable alternative for your dimensionality reduction needs. This would not only align your work with convention...
- Comment from Aquaculture International reviewer
Peer Review Champion Helpful
We appreciate the careful work the authors put into these research studies. Most consistently, the reviewers note that the data collection and analysi...
- Comment from ACM CompEd 2023 Conference reviewer