4.6 Article

The comparability of consumers' behavior in virtual reality and real life: A validation study of virtual reality based on a ranking task

Journal

FOOD QUALITY AND PREFERENCE
Volume 87, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.foodqual.2020.104071

Keywords

Virtual reality; Healthiness evaluation; Consumer behavior; Research tool validation; Food ranking task

Funding

  1. Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF) under the project Digital Lives [10DL11_183171/1]
  2. Swiss National Science Foundation (SNF) [10DL11_183171] Funding Source: Swiss National Science Foundation (SNF)

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study found that participants' behavior in virtual reality and real life were comparable, indicating the validity of VR technology for data acquisition in consumer behavior research.
The comparability or similarity of consumers' behavior in virtual reality (VR) and in real life (RL) is indispensable to successfully take advantage of VR technology in consumer behavior (CB) research. This study investigated the comparability of participants' behavior in a virtual environment and in RL to validate VR for data acquisition in CB research. Participants (N = 98) were randomly assigned to a RL condition or a VR condition in which the settings were chosen to mimic a RL environment as closely as possible. In both conditions, participants ranked 20 types of commercial breakfast cereal by their perceived healthiness from healthy to unhealthy. We observed that the perceived healthiness of the 20 cereals in the VR and RL conditions were highly correlated (r(s) = 0.91, p < .001, N = 20). The information-seeking behavior was not different between the two conditions, t (96) = - 1.11, p = .27. Furthermore, the attributes employed by the participants to evaluate the healthiness of the cereals did not vary between the two conditions. The presence level of the participants in the virtual environment was also examined. The results illustrate that the participants' behavior in the virtual environment and in the real world were comparable, which provides robust evidence for the validity of VR as a beneficial and promising tool for data acquisition in CB research.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

The Social Amplification of Risk Framework: A Normative Perspective on Trust?

Angela Bearth, Michael Siegrist

Summary: This article questions the deficit view of public trust and advocates for a more positive outlook in future research. By using the Social Amplification of Risk Framework to discuss trust as a fundamental aspect of social interactions and to challenge normative approaches to public trust and risk perception, the authors argue for overcoming the current trust deficit model and focusing on the opportunities of the digital informational environment for risk communication in future research.

RISK ANALYSIS (2022)

Article Engineering, Manufacturing

Consumer Assessment of 3D-Printed Food Shape, Taste, and Fidelity Using Chocolate and Marzipan Materials

Stefania Chirico Scheele, Christina Hartmann, Michael Siegrist, Martin Binks, Paul F. Egan

Summary: This study examines the impact of 3D-printed food design shapes, tastes, and fidelity on consumers through ratings, revealing that participants prefer complex shapes, chocolate flavor, and high fidelity in 3D-printed food designs.

3D PRINTING AND ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING (2022)

Article Agronomy

An approach for comparing agricultural development to societal visions

Julian Helfenstein, Vasco Diogo, Matthias Burgi, Peter H. Verburg, Beatrice Schupbach, Erich Szerencsits, Franziska Mohr, Michael Siegrist, Rebecca Swart, Felix Herzog

Summary: It is important to consider the normative dimension of different societal visions when assessing the sustainability of agricultural development. This approach, which compares observed development with various societal visions, helps to track the progress of agricultural development and identify mismatches between desired and actual development. By informing the wider public on the extent to which current developments are consistent with different visions, this approach can pave the way for designing new policies.

AGRONOMY FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT (2022)

Article Transportation

The perceived costs and benefits that drive the acceptability of risk-based security screenings at airports

Tamara Stotz, Angela Bearth, Michael Siegrist, Signe Maria Ghelfi

Summary: Due to the increase in air travel, traditional airport security checks have reached capacity limits. Finding efficient and less inconvenient security procedures is a major challenge. Risk-based security checks, although controversial, can potentially reduce screening for low-risk passengers by targeting high-risk ones.

JOURNAL OF AIR TRANSPORT MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Agronomy

Farmer surveys in Europe suggest that specialized, intensive farms were more likely to perceive negative impacts from COVID-19

Julian Helfenstein, Matthias Burgi, Niels Debonne, Thymios Dimopoulos, Vasco Diogo, Wenche Dramstad, Anna Edlinger, Maria Garcia-Martin, Jozef Hernik, Thanasis Kizos, Angela Lausch, Christian Levers, Franziska Mohr, Gerardo Moreno, Robert Pazur, Michael Siegrist, Rebecca Swart, Claudine Thenail, Peter H. Verburg, Tim G. Williams, Anita Zarina, Felix Herzog

Summary: The COVID-19 pandemic had varying impacts on different agricultural systems, with specialized and intensive farms being more vulnerable to disruptions in supply chains. Supporting farmers in diversifying their production systems and reducing dependence on supply chains can increase their resilience to future shocks.

AGRONOMY FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT (2022)

Article Food Science & Technology

You are what you drink: Stereotypes about consumers of alcoholic and non-alcoholic beer

Cornelia Staub, Robin Contiero, Noah Bosshart, Michael Siegrist

Summary: People make inferences about someone's character based on their food and drink choices. This study explores the stereotypes associated with alcoholic and non-alcoholic beer consumption. It found that choosing non-alcoholic beer may be motivated by health-consciousness and other social factors, but negative perceptions and subjective norms of drinking alcoholic beer may prevent people from choosing non-alcoholic beer.

FOOD QUALITY AND PREFERENCE (2022)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Household chemicals and pre-schoolers: Caretakers' beliefs and perspectives on risks and responsibilities

Angela Bearth, Noah Bosshart, Stephanie Wermelinger, Moritz Daum, Michael Siegrist

Summary: This study investigates the beliefs and perspectives of parents and caretakers on risks and responsibilities. The findings suggest that some parents have misconceptions about the risks of natural products and the safety of child-protective caps. The study also uncovered relationships between psychological factors and caretakers' beliefs about household chemicals.

SAFETY SCIENCE (2022)

Article Ergonomics

Seeing household chemicals through the eyes of children-Investigating influential factors of preschoolers' perception and behavior

Noah Bosshart, Angela Bearth, Stephanie Wermelinger, Moritz Daum, Michael Siegrist

Summary: This study aimed to understand the factors that influence children's attention and decision-making regarding household chemicals. The results indicated that product attributes such as labels and packaging, storage context, and parental beliefs play a role in children's choices and decisions.

JOURNAL OF SAFETY RESEARCH (2022)

Article Food Science & Technology

Palm oil and the Roundtable of Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO) label: Are Swiss consumers aware and concerned

Bianca Wassmann, Michael Siegrist, Christina Hartmann

Summary: Palm oil is widely used in many products but is associated with ecological, social, and health-related issues. The RSPO label aims to guide consumers towards sustainable palm oil. However, consumers' awareness and knowledge of the RSPO label and unsustainable ingredients in products need improvement. Targeted interventions and effective marketing, along with transparent sustainability standards, are necessary to address this discrepancy.

FOOD QUALITY AND PREFERENCE (2023)

Article Education, Scientific Disciplines

A questionnaire for quality control in postgraduate medical education in Switzerland

Larissa Luchsinger, Anne Berthold, Monika Brodmann Maeder, Max Giger, Werner Bauer, Michael Siegrist

Summary: This article describes the development and longitudinal analysis of a questionnaire used to evaluate the quality of postgraduate medical education in Switzerland. The questionnaire has been administered annually to all residents since 2003, with a response rate of 70% in 2020. Results show that the mean values of the eight scales remained stable or slightly increased over the years, with the decision-making culture scale rated highest by residents and the evidence-based medicine scale rated lowest. The work environment and leadership culture scales are identified as the most important factors affecting residents' satisfaction with a training site. The directors perceive the evaluation to be fair and useful.

MEDICAL TEACHER (2023)

Article Food Science & Technology

Experimental validation of the food disgust scale using olfactory stimuli

Jeanine Ammann, Aisha Egolf, Jeannette Nuessli Guth, Michael Siegrist

Summary: This study aimed to validate the food disgust scale using olfactory stimuli related to food. Through rating different odours for the level of disgust evoked, two factors of food disgust sensitivity were identified. The first factor included seven more disgusting items, while the second factor included two less disgusting items. The study found a significant correlation between the first factor score and the FDS short questionnaire, supporting the incremental validity of the questionnaire. This is the first study to validate the FDS short using olfactory stimuli, indicating potential for the creation of a food disgust odour scale.

FOOD QUALITY AND PREFERENCE (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

The role of heuristics for composing an environmentally friendly meal

Bianca Wassmann, Michael Siegrist, Christina Hartmann

Summary: Our food choices have a significant negative impact on the environment. Understanding consumers' environmentally friendly food selection behavior is important. Our study found that heuristics played a role in consumers' ability to compose an environmentally friendly meal, with the eco group choosing less meat and fish, more meat substitutes, and foods that were regional, seasonal, and organic.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2023)

Article Food Science & Technology

Perceived degree of food processing as a cue for perceived healthiness: The NOVA system mirrors consumers' perceptions

Alenica Hassig, Christina Hartmann, Luisma Sanchez-Siles, Michael Siegrist

Summary: Demand for processed food is increasing, but some of these products have been criticized for causing non-communicable diseases. This study examined consumers' perceptions of food processing and ultra-processed foods, and its relationship with food classification systems and nutritional value. The results showed that consumers have negative associations with food processing and use the perceived degree of processing as a cue for evaluating the healthiness of foods. Furthermore, there was strong agreement between laypeople's perceived level of processing and the NOVA classification system.

FOOD QUALITY AND PREFERENCE (2023)

Article Psychology, Clinical

The Positive Eating Scale: Associations with eating behavior, food choice, and body mass index

Cynthia Sob, Michael Siegrist, Christina Hartmann

Summary: In this study, the effects of positive eating on eating behaviors, food intake, and BMI were investigated in a large sample of the general Swiss population. The results showed that restrained and reward eating were negatively correlated with the Positive Eating Scale (PES) subscales, while intuitive eating, diet-related health consciousness, and perceived health status were positively related to the PES subscales. BMI was negatively related to the PES subscale Satisfaction with Eating and positively related to the subscale Pleasure when Eating. No significant effects of the PES subscales on change in BMI were detected over the two-year period. Overall, positive eating may be associated with more balanced eating habits and better perceived health status.

EATING BEHAVIORS (2023)

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

A quantitative synthesis study on body mass index and associated factors among adult men and women in Switzerland

Katarina L. Matthes, Christina Hartmann, Michael Siegrist, Michel Burnier, Murielle Bochud, Marcel Zwahlen, Nicole Bender, Kaspar Staub

Summary: Excess weight has been increasing rapidly in Switzerland since the 1990s, posing challenges to both health and the economy. This study is the first to synthesize nationwide evidence on the importance of socio-demographic and lifestyle factors as risk factors for excess weight.

JOURNAL OF NUTRITIONAL SCIENCE (2022)

Article Food Science & Technology

Sensory characteristics of a place: The development of the sensory walk questionnaire

Terhi Pohjanheimo, Pauliina Ojansivu, Anu Hopia

Summary: The surrounding environment plays a significant role in well-being and behavior, and the sensory experience of a place has not been systematically measured and characterized. The current study developed the Sensory Walk Questionnaire and tested it in a restaurant environment. The results showed differences in perceived odour and sound intensity, pleasantness of odours, sounds, and visual environment, as well as sensory descriptors between different areas in the restaurant.

FOOD QUALITY AND PREFERENCE (2024)

Article Food Science & Technology

Does more information mean better choices? A study on calorie display and consumer behavior in restaurants

Dae Hee Chung, Doo Bong Han, Rodolfo M. Nayga Jr, Sang Hyeon Lee

Summary: This study investigates the effects of calorie-related information on food choices and reveals that presenting either daily calorie recommendations or specific calorie information can reduce consumers' calorie consumption. However, when both types of information are presented concurrently, this effect is nullified. The study also finds that personality traits, such as extroversion and self-esteem, influence food choices, with extroverts more likely to choose lower-calorie options. Good self-restraint is also linked to lower-calorie choices. These findings highlight the importance of strategic calorie information policies in promoting healthier choices.

FOOD QUALITY AND PREFERENCE (2024)

Article Food Science & Technology

Remote testing for PROP taster status assessment using solutions and paper disks

C. Rorandelli, A. Lippi, S. Spinelli, L. Pierguidi, E. Monteleone, C. Dinnella

Summary: This study aimed to validate a protocol for assessing PROP status in remote conditions and to compare the results obtained using solutions and paper disks. The results showed that PROP ratings did not vary across remote and lab conditions. The classification in remote-solution and lab-disk conditions was comparable to the lab-solution reference condition, while the classification in remote-disk condition was not fully comparable.

FOOD QUALITY AND PREFERENCE (2024)

Article Food Science & Technology

Exploring the intricacies of food disgust: Unveiling links between gender, healthy eating obsession, and disgust propensity

Sule Kocabas, Nevin Sanlier

Summary: This study explored how the disgust emotion affected adults' obsession with healthy eating. The results showed that women exhibited higher disgust tendencies than men, and men had a lower tendency toward healthy eating obsession. There was a negative correlation between BMI and disgust propensity and sensitivity. People's disgust propensity and obsession with healthy eating increased with age.

FOOD QUALITY AND PREFERENCE (2024)

Article Food Science & Technology

Which factors affect the Italian consumer's intention to insect-eating? An application of an integrated attitude-intention-eating model

Valentina Maria Merlino, Oriana Mosca, Ferdinando Fornara, Rocco Roma, Elisabetta Bonerba, Achille Schiavone, Rosa Laura Passaro, Martina Tarantola

Summary: This research explores the impact of key socio-psychological dimensions on individuals' intention to eat insect-based foods. The findings indicate that individuals with higher concern for environmental and ethical sustainability are more open to eating insects, particularly if they are treated ethically. The integrated attitude-food-intention model used in this study represents an innovative approach in consumer behavior research.

FOOD QUALITY AND PREFERENCE (2024)