4.5 Article

Little samplers, big fleet: eDNA metabarcoding from commercial trawlers enhances ocean monitoring

Journal

FISHERIES RESEARCH
Volume 249, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.fishres.2022.106259

Keywords

Marine biodiversity; Fish communities; Fisheries; Mediterranean Sea; Environmental DNA

Categories

Funding

  1. University of Rome Tor Vergata
  2. UK Natural Environment Research Council [NE/T007028/1]
  3. NERC [NE/T007028/1] Funding Source: UKRI

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study tests an easy-to-use device for monitoring marine resources, which can quickly collect environmental DNA during normal fishing operations on bottom trawl fishing vessels. Through sample collection and genetic analysis, the study accurately identifies fish assemblages at different depths and discovers mesopelagic species that are not caught by bottom trawls. This promising method has the potential to be a valuable tool for monitoring catch composition, assessing stock distribution, and documenting changes in fish communities in the oceans.
The global need to monitor the status of marine resources is a priority task in marine management, but most ocean surveys still rely on costly and time-consuming capture-based techniques. Here we test a novel, easy-to use device to collect eDNA on board of bottom trawl fishing vessels, during normal fishing operations, quickly and easily: custom-made rolls of gauze tied to a hollow perforated spherical probe (the 'metaprobe') that placed inside the fishing net aims to gather traces of genetic material from the surrounding environment. We collected six samples from three central Tyrrhenian sites. Using an established fish-specific metabarcoding marker, we recovered over 70% of the caught species and accurately reconstructed fish assemblages typical of the different bathymetric layers considered. eDNA metabarcoding data also returned a biodiversity 'bonus' of mostly mesopelagic species, not catchable by bottom trawls. Further investigation is needed to upscale this promising approach as a powerful tool to monitor catch composition, assess the distribution of stocks, and generally record changes in fish communities across the oceans.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Environmental Sciences

Image processing tools in the study of environmental contamination by microplastics: reliability and perspectives

Tommaso Valente, Daniele Ventura, Marco Matiddi, Alice Sbrana, Cecilia Silvestri, Raffaella Piermarini, Carlo Jacomini, Maria Letizia Costantini

Summary: Microplastic pollution is a significant environmental concern, and the lack of standardized analytical approaches hinders comparability among studies. This study explores the potential of two image processing tools to accurately characterize microplastic shape and investigates the effects of different treatments on microplastic shape. The results show variations in surface area and vulnerability to digestive solutions, suggesting the reliability of the methods used. The study discusses the analytical perspectives enabled by accessible and low-cost equipment.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE AND POLLUTION RESEARCH (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

From inshore to offshore: distribution of microplastics in three Italian seawaters

Alice Sbrana, Tommaso Valente, Jessica Bianchi, Simone Franceschini, Raffaella Piermarini, Flavia Saccomandi, Andrea Giuseppe de Lucia, Andrea Camedda, Marco Matiddi, Cecilia Silvestri

Summary: The study aims to investigate the composition, quantity, and spatial distribution of microplastics in Italian seawaters, as well as the distribution of microplastics between surface and subsurface water layers. The results show that microplastics concentrations decrease with coastal distance, and the amount of surface microplastics is almost four times that of subsurface microplastics.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE AND POLLUTION RESEARCH (2023)

Article Fisheries

DNA metabarcoding of trawling bycatch reveals diversity and distribution patterns of sharks and rays in the central Tyrrhenian Sea

Linda Albonetti, Giulia Maiello, Alessia Cariani, Paolo Carpentieri, Alice Ferrari, Alice Sbrana, Peter Shum, Lorenzo Talarico, Tommaso Russo, Stefano Mariani

Summary: Conservation and management of chondrichthyans are important due to their vulnerability to fishing activities, and using eDNA metabarcoding can accurately assess bycatch composition and detect rare species. Chondrichthyan diversity is influenced by environmental variables and fishing effort. As DNA metabarcoding becomes a staple tool for biodiversity monitoring, it can provide additional insights into threatened and elusive megafauna.

ICES JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Fisheries

An approach to map and quantify the fishing effort of polyvalent passive gear fishing fleets using geospatial data

Nuno Henriques, Tommaso Russo, Luis Bentes, Pedro Monteiro, Antonio Parisi, Ramiro Magno, Frederico Oliveira, Karim Erzini, Jorge M. S. Goncalves

Summary: The use of tracking devices has allowed for an expansion in our understanding of fishing activities. This paper proposes a methodology to map and quantify the fishing effort of passive fishing gears used by a multi-gear fleet. This approach can be adapted to other passive fisheries and provides valuable information for improved management.

ICES JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Fisheries

Population structure and connectivity in the genus Molva in the Northeast Atlantic

L. McGill, A. D. McDevitt, B. Hellemans, F. Neat, H. Knutsen, S. Mariani, H. Christiansen, T. Johansen, F. A. M. Volckaert, I Coscia

Summary: This study focuses on two commercially important gadoid species, the common ling and the blue ling, which have overlapping geographical distribution but different depth habitats. Genotyping-by-sequencing analysis revealed genetic differentiation in both species, with two major groups identified for each species. Fine-scale genetic structure was found along the coast of Norway for the common ling, while the blue ling showed stronger signals of differentiation related to adaptation to different depth habitats and cold temperatures.

ICES JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Fish eDNA detections in ports mirror fishing fleet activities and highlight the spread of non-indigenous species in the Mediterranean Sea

Giorgio Aglieri, Federico Quattrocchi, Stefano Mariani, Charles Baillie, Davide Spatafora, Antonio Di Franco, Gabriele Turco, Marco Tolone, Rosalia Di Gerlando, Marco Milazzo

Summary: By combining eDNA surveys, public registers, and Automatic Identification Systems data, we found significant positive relationships between fishing fleet activities and the taxonomic fish assemblage composition in eleven Mediterranean fishing ports. We identified 160 fish and 123 invertebrate OTUs, including non-indigenous species, suggesting that eDNA assessments of fishing harbours' waters can rapidly monitor marine biodiversity and reconstruct underreported fishing catches.

MARINE POLLUTION BULLETIN (2023)

Article Biology

High taxonomic diversity and miniaturization in benthic communities under persistent natural CO2 disturbances

Sara Gonzalez-Delgado, Owen S. Wangensteen, Carlos Sangil, Celso A. Hernandez, Beatriz Alfonso, Ana Z. Soto, Rocio Perez-Portela, Stefano Mariani, Jose Carlos Hernandez

Summary: Metabarcoding techniques have revolutionized ecological research by revealing hidden biodiversity. This study used DNA metabarcoding to assess the effects of ocean acidification on marine benthic communities. The results show that subtropical communities are expected to maintain high biodiversity levels under future ocean acidification.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY B-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES (2023)

Article Ecology

Exploring fishing threat at fleet segment and subregional scale: Least expert knowledge and a resilience versus disturbance-based approach as conservation's tools for cartilaginous fish

Umberto Scacco, Simone Di Crescenzo, Alice Sbrana

Summary: Based on expert estimates, a new method for smart and fast fishery-related risk assessments was developed, which provided qualitative and quantitative results on fishing threats to various species and fishing segments. The method performed best on a small geographic scale and could be a valuable tool for preliminary assessment of species of conservation concern in regions with limited data availability.

ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

Article Zoology

Population structure, genetic diversity and demographic patterns unveil massive Mediterranean brown trout manipulations in a protected area of the northern Apennines (Italy)

L. Talarico, R. Caniglia, A. Carosi, M. Lorenzoni, C. Greco, A. Padula, S. D'Antoni, D. Alberti, A. de Paoli, L. Casali, M. Ruocco, G. Tedaldi, C. Pedrazzoli, N. Mucci

Summary: This study investigated the genetic composition of brown trout populations in two river catchments in the northern Apennines, Italy. The results showed a widespread hybridization between domestic-Atlantic strains and native Mediterranean brown trout populations, as well as evidence of human-mediated introductions of allochthonous Mediterranean trout and translocations between slopes. The study highlights the need for conservation efforts to protect and preserve the genetic distinctiveness and stability of native populations of this endangered taxon.

EUROPEAN ZOOLOGICAL JOURNAL (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Macrobenthos of the Tortoli Lagoon: A Peculiar Case of High Benthic Biodiversity among Mediterranean Lagoons

Jacopo Giampaoletti, Alice Sbrana, Paolo Magni, Maria Flavia Gravina

Summary: In this study, historical datasets were used to investigate the spatiotemporal variation in the macrobenthic community of the Tortol ì Lagoon in Sardinia, Italy. The results showed high biodiversity and the presence of marine species, indicating the unique characteristics of this lagoon compared to other Mediterranean lagoons. The environmental variables did not explain the zonation of the macrobenthic community, highlighting the influence of the nearby sea.

DIVERSITY-BASEL (2023)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Spineless and overlooked: DNA metabarcoding of autonomous reef monitoring structures reveals intra- and interspecific genetic diversity in Mediterranean invertebrates

Anna Thomasdotter, Peter Shum, Francesco Mugnai, Marina Vingiani, Marco Abbiati, Federica Costantini

Summary: The ability to use DNA metabarcoding of bulk samples to gather genetic information directly from the environment is crucial for understanding biodiversity and population dynamics in the marine realm. In this study, we use bioinformatics tools to investigate intraspecific genetic variability for marine invertebrates in the Mediterranean Sea. By analyzing samples from Autonomous Reef Monitoring Structures (ARMS), we identify diverse haplotypes and emphasize the spatial scale of genetic variability.

MOLECULAR ECOLOGY RESOURCES (2023)

Article Fisheries

Characterizing Antarctic fish assemblages using eDNA obtained from marine sponge bycatch specimens

Gert-Jan Jeunen, Miles Lamare, Jennifer Devine, Stefano Mariani, Sadie Mills, Jackson Treece, Sara Ferreira, Neil J. Gemmell

Summary: Given the challenges of monitoring the Southern Ocean through visual observations, this study explores the potential of marine sponge eDNA monitoring to assess the fish community in the region. The findings show that eDNA provides a more comprehensive view of the fish community compared to catch records, highlighting its potential for improving our understanding of this understudied ecosystem and aiding conservation efforts.

REVIEWS IN FISH BIOLOGY AND FISHERIES (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Tracing the route: Using stable isotope analysis to understand microplastic pathways through the pelagic-neritic food web of the Tyrrhenian Sea (Western Mediterranean)

Tommaso Valente, Maria Letizia Costantini, Giulio Careddu, Daniela Berto, Raffaella Piermarini, Federico Rampazzo, Alice Sbrana, Cecilia Silvestri, Daniele Ventura, Marco Matiddi

Summary: This study investigates the relationship between microplastic ingestion and the trophic ecology of three pelagic fish species from the Tyrrhenian Sea. Results show that different fish species play different ecological roles and that microplastic ingestion is influenced by the trophic position of the fish. The study provides new insights into the impact of microplastic contamination on the pelagic community.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Shark-dust: Application of high-throughput DNA sequencing of processing residues for trade monitoring of threatened sharks and rays

Andhika P. Prasetyo, Joanna M. Murray, Muh. Firdaus A. K. Kurniawan, Naiara G. Sales, Allan D. McDevitt, Stefano Mariani

Summary: Illegal fishing, unregulated bycatch, and market demand for certain products are causing a rapid decline in shark and ray populations. Controlling the trade of endangered species is challenging due to various factors, but a new genetic approach using trace DNA fragments retrieved from trade leftovers shows promise in identifying traded species, even those that are difficult to recover from tissue samples. This approach could become a powerful and cost-effective monitoring tool in wildlife trade.

CONSERVATION LETTERS (2023)

Article Fisheries

Lack of independence: An insidious and subtle pitfall in model fitting

Miguel Petrere Jr, Davi Butturi-Gomes

Summary: This short communication aims to raise awareness about the misuse of confidence intervals in Ecology and Fisheries statistical models that ignore the lack of independence.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Inclusion of ageing error and growth variability using a bootstrap estimation of age composition and conditional age-at-length input sample size for fisheries stock assessment models

Peter-John F. Hulson, Benjamin C. Williams

Summary: This study evaluates the impact of considering ageing error and growth variability on the determination of input sample size (ISS) in statistical catch-at-age assessment models. The results show that including these sources of uncertainty decreases the ISS determined through bootstrap methods. This indicates that there is more variability in age composition and conditional age-at-length data than previously accounted for. Including these sources of uncertainty improves the estimation of ISS and subsequently improves the quality of stock assessment models.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

The good practices of practicable alchemy in the stock assessment continuum: Fundamentals and principles of analytical methods to support science-based fisheries management under data and resource limitations

Jason M. Cope

Summary: Fishery resource assessment is a complex and challenging task, but with the use of different analysis methods and tools, effective management guidance can be provided even with limited data and resources.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Genomics goes deeper in fisheries science: The case of the blackspot seabream (Pagellus bogaraveo) in the northeast Atlantic

Regina L. Cunha, Joana I. Robalo, Sara M. Francisco, Ines Farias, Rita Castilho, Ivone Figueiredo

Summary: Recent advances in genomics have greatly contributed to the assessment of fish stocks by providing precise identification of genetic boundaries. This study used a genotyping-by-sequencing approach to reveal the existence of an additional genetic cluster of blackspot seabream in the northeast Atlantic, which was not previously identified. Factors such as ocean circulation patterns and local upwelling may play a role in the genetic differentiation observed in this study.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Good Practices for estimating and using length-at-age in integrated stock assessments

Huihua Lee, Mark N. Maunder, Kevin R. Piner

Summary: Estimating growth is important for fish population assessment. Integrated assessment models and the influence of misfitting size composition data have renewed interest in how growth is modeled. The available data types control how the length-at-age relationship is estimated. Estimating length-at-age is complex due to multiple sources of biological variability and difficulties in obtaining representative samples.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Role of material properties in acoustical target strength: Insights from two species lacking a swimbladder

A. Ladino, I. Perez-Arjona, V. Espinosa, M. Chillaron, V. Vidal, L. M. Godinho, G. Moreno, G. Boyra

Summary: This study examines the acoustic properties of skipjack tuna and Atlantic mackerel, both bladderless pelagic fish species, and explains the significant differences observed. The research shows that the differences in material properties of their tissues predict a more than 10 dB greater reduced target strength in skipjack compared to mackerel at certain frequencies.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Marine megafauna interactions with the Peruvian artisanal purse-seine fleet

Nelly Pena-Cutimbo, Cristel Cordero-Maldonado, Clara Ortiz-Alvarez, Joanna Alfaro-Shigueto, Jeffrey C. Mangel

Summary: Bycatch is a global problem for marine megafauna. This study assessed the bycatch interactions of the Peruvian artisanal purse-seine fishery in 2019 and found that all taxa groups were affected by bycatch. Dusky dolphins, guanay cormorants, and eagle rays were the most frequently reported bycatch species.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Analysis of the positioning factors affecting the sustainable fishing gear-Set net

Jen-Ming Liu, Po-Yuk So

Summary: The set-net fishery is an environmentally friendly fishery posing little risk to the marine ecosystem. This study identified ocean temperature, sea surface factors, and climatic factors as the main factors affecting the installation of set-nets.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Behavioural patterns, spatial utilisation and landings composition of a small-scale fishery in the eastern Mediterranean

Josie L. Palmer, Carina Armstrong, Hasan D. Akbora, Damla Beton, Cigdem Caglar, Brendan J. Godley, Kristian Metcalfe, Meryem Ozkan, Robin T. E. Snape, Annette C. Broderick

Summary: Small-scale fisheries are vital for global food security and cultural heritage, but the lack of information hampers effective management and mitigation of ecological impacts. This study provides the first comprehensive overview of the small-scale fishery fleet in Northern Cyprus. The fleet operates mainly over the continental shelf, using static and demersal gear types, and catches a diverse range of species, some of which are threatened. The findings can be used to improve fisheries management and conservation measures.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)