Materials Today Physics

A purely simulated work was first rejected after submitting to MD. It took several weeks to carefully revise according to the reviewers' comments. Later, it was submitted to Mater Today Nano, with three reviewers: two positive and one slightly negative. Although it was rejected, the work received recognition from the top experts. After carefully revising according to the reviewers' comments, it was submitted to MTP. After over a month, the reviewers provided nine major revisions, which were challenging to address despite the limited number of comments. A significant amount of additional work was added. During this period, another paper needed to be revised urgently. It was hurriedly completed in 20 days and fortunately received unanimous recognition from the reviewers. I am grateful to Prof. Shuo Chen and the reviewers for their recognition of the work, and I hope that MTP can successfully return to the top tier.

submit 2022/3/7 - This means that something was submitted on March 7, 2022.
with editor 2022/3/14 - This indicates that the submission was received by the editor on March 14, 2022.
under review 2022/3/16 - This indicates that the submission is currently being reviewed as of March 16, 2022.
decision 2022/4/15 major - This means that a decision has been made regarding the submission on April 15, 2022, and it is a significant decision.
reversion submitted 2022/4/25 - This indicates that a revision or updated version was submitted on April 25, 2022.
under review 2022/4/26 - This means that the revised version is currently being reviewed as of April 26, 2022.