4.0 Article

The Interactions of CO2, Ethanol, Hop Acids and Sweetener on Flavour Perception in a Model Beer

Journal

CHEMOSENSORY PERCEPTION
Volume 4, Issue 1-2, Pages 42-54

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s12078-011-9087-3

Keywords

Beer; Carbonation; Ethanol; Hop acids; Multimodal interactions; Sweetener

Funding

  1. BBSRC
  2. SABMiller

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Beer is a complex beverage. Beer flavour is a multisensory experience in which, in addition to aroma volatiles, CO2, ethanol, bitterness (hop acids) and sweetness all contribute. To investigate the interactions between these fundamental components, a model beer system was developed using representative ingredients. Samples, selected according to a D-optimal design, were assessed by sensory profiling techniques by a trained panel. Predictive polynomial models generated from mean panel data described variations in the attributes as a function of design factors. Results show that CO2 significantly impacted on all discriminating attributes, including suppression of sweetness and modification of bitterness. A number of complex interactions with design factors showed the effects of CO2 to be dependent upon component concentration and level of carbonation. CO2 interacted with hop acids to increase carbonation and tingly perception, which increased linearly with hop acid addition but only at low levels of CO2. Ethanol was the main driver of warming perception and complexity. In agreement with other studies, ethanol enhanced sweet perception and also formed some complex interactions with hop acids and CO2 to modify various attributes, illustrating its ability to interact with both gustatory and trigeminal stimuli. Whether the mechanisms behind these interactions originate at the gustatory periphery or at higher centres in the brain is an area for further investigation. This study provides an in-depth assessment of important flavour components in beer and advances the limited data available on the effects of CO2 on sensory perception using a commonly carbonated beverage.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.0
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Understanding the lost functionality of ethanol in non-alcoholic beer using sensory evaluation, aroma release and molecular hydrodynamics

Imogen Ramsey, Vlad Dinu, Rob Linforth, Gleb E. Yakubov, Stephen E. Harding, Qian Yang, Rebecca Ford, Ian Fisk

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2020)

Article Chemistry, Applied

Physicochemical design rules for the formulation of novel salt particles with optimised saltiness

Katherine E. Hurst, Charfedinne Ayed, Ivan N. Derbenev, Louise Hewson, Ian D. Fisk

Summary: The study found that the size, density, and flow properties of particles have significant effects on adhesion, loss, dissolution, and saltiness perception of salt crystals. Future ingredient design for the food industry can be guided by these findings.

FOOD CHEMISTRY (2021)

Article Food Science & Technology

Comparing temporal sensory product profile data obtained from expert and consumer panels and evaluating the value of a multiple sip TCATA approach

Maheeka N. R. P. Weerawarna, A. Jonathan R. Godfrey, Ashling Ellis, Joanne Hort

Summary: Data from consumer and expert TCATA panels for the same products are not interchangeable, and choice of panel type should be determined in accordance with project objectives. Effects on sensory attributes varied significantly by panel type and product, indicating findings cannot be generalized across products and further research on other products is needed. Multiple-sip evaluations revealed significant changing dynamics in the perception of several attributes over and within sips, emphasizing the importance of understanding consumer product experience beyond single-sip studies.

FOOD QUALITY AND PREFERENCE (2021)

Review Food Science & Technology

A narrative review of the impact of digital immersive technology on affective and sensory responses during product testing in digital eating contexts

Caroline Giezenaar, Joanne Hort

Summary: Studies have shown that using digital immersion techniques for consumer testing can make emotional response more similar to real life, increase consumer engagement and reliability, thus improving ecological validity.

FOOD RESEARCH INTERNATIONAL (2021)

Article Food Science & Technology

Effect of sipping method on sensory response to single and multiple sips of vanilla milkshake using temporal-check-all-that-apply

Maheeka N. R. P. Weerawarna, A. Jonathan R. Godfrey, Ashling Ellis, Joanne Hort

Summary: This study aimed to investigate the effects of different drinking methods on product characteristics and discrimination. The results showed that sipping through a straw resulted in more pronounced sweetness, vanilla, astringency, and liquorice attributes, while sipping from a cup showed greater attribute discriminations across products. Additionally, attribute discrimination increased across multiple sips.

JOURNAL OF SENSORY STUDIES (2022)

Article Food Science & Technology

On-the-Pack Voluntary Well-Being Messaging for Milks Targeting Chinese Older Adults: A Content Analysis

Ao Chen, Saleh Moradi, Joanne Hort

Summary: China is facing severe population aging and milk products targeting older adults are popular. This study investigated the voluntary well-being messaging on the packaging of milk products for Chinese older adults. The results showed that different brands and milk sources highlighted different well-being aspects, and there were compliance issues with nutrition labeling regulations.

FOODS (2022)

Article Food Science & Technology

The who, what, where, when, why and how of measuring emotional response to food. A systematic review

Julia Y. Q. Low, Nathalie Janin, Rachel M. Traill, Joanne Hort

Summary: Traditional consumer acceptance and preference testing struggles to accurately predict food choice behavior. This review explores various tools used to capture consumer emotional response to food and provides recommendations for measuring food-evoked emotions. No single method has been identified as the optimal approach, highlighting the need for further research to understand the impact of emotions on food choice.

FOOD QUALITY AND PREFERENCE (2022)

Article Food Science & Technology

Development of a consumer-led emotion lexicon for meat and plant-based burger patties using digitally recreated eating contexts

Rebekah E. E. Orr, Caroline Giezenaar, A. Jonathan R. Godfrey, Joanne Hort

Summary: The decision to consume novel foods is influenced by emotional response. A specific emotion lexicon for meat and plant-based burger patties was developed. The lexicon contained 24 emotion categories, capturing nuanced emotions associated with food neophobia, uncertainty, and deception.

JOURNAL OF SENSORY STUDIES (2023)

Article Food Science & Technology

Identifying temporal drivers of product acceptance and rejection across sips during whole product consumption

Maheeka N. R. P. Weerawarna, A. Jonathan R. Godfrey, Ashling Ellis, Joanne Hort

Summary: This research examined the temporal dynamics of sensory, liking, and emotional responses to milkshakes and found associations between them. The study suggested that emotional responses are related to the evolution of sensory attributes and can provide deeper insights into consumer affective response.

JOURNAL OF SENSORY STUDIES (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Perceptions of Cultivated Meat in Millennial and Generation X Consumers Resident in Aotearoa New Zealand

Caroline Giezenaar, A. Jonathan R. Godfrey, Olivia J. J. Ogilvie, Petra Coetzee, N. R. P. Maheeka Weerawarna, Meika Foster, Joanne Hort

Summary: Evidence shows that consumer perceptions and acceptance of cultivated meat (CM) vary across different countries, cultures, and consumer groups. This study analyzed survey responses from 592 residents of Aotearoa New Zealand (A-NZ) to examine CM awareness, willingness to engage with CM, and perceived CM attributes compared to conventional meat and plant-based meat alternatives (PBMA). Factors such as gender, age, meat/PBMA consumption frequency, CM awareness, and food neophobia were found to influence CM perceptions. The findings indicate that increasing awareness and familiarity with CM will be crucial in promoting engagement with CM in A-NZ.

SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Article Food Science & Technology

Exploring Consumer and Producer Views of Verjuice: A Grape-Based Product Made from Viticultural Waste

Amanda Dupas de Matos, Robyn Maggs, Joanne Hort

Summary: The wine sector is actively working towards increasing value, sustainability, and waste reduction. This includes utilizing thinned grapes to produce verjuice, which provides an opportunity for innovation. However, there is currently a lack of understanding about consumer preferences and needs when it comes to sensory characteristics, packaging, and labeling of verjuice. This study explores consumer and producer views to bridge this gap and offers insight into potential product diversification and optimization for the wine industry.

AUSTRALIAN JOURNAL OF GRAPE AND WINE RESEARCH (2023)

Article Food Science & Technology

Comparing traditional check-all-that-apply (CATA) and implicit response time Go/No-go approaches for profiling consumer emotional response when tasting food

N. R. P. Maheeka Weerawarna, Jonathan R. Godfrey, Malcolm Loudon, Meika Foster, Joanne Hort

Summary: Adapting implicit approaches to capture consumer responses in food tasting is currently a popular topic in sensory and consumer science. This study compared an implicit response time (IRT) Go/No-go approach with traditional CATA to profile consumer emotional responses. The results showed high data consistency and comparable emotion selection frequency between IRT and CATA. CATA was more effective in differentiating cow's milk products, while fewer participants provided different responses under time pressure in the IRT Go/No-go. Further investigations are needed to determine the best approach for capturing consumer product experience.

FOOD QUALITY AND PREFERENCE (2023)

Article Chemistry, Applied

Understanding the sensory and physicochemical differences between commercially produced non-alcoholic lagers, and their influence on consumer liking

Imogen Ramsey, Qian Yang, Ian Fisk, Rebecca Ford

Summary: This study explored the sensory and physicochemical differences among a variety of commercial non-alcoholic lagers and their impact on overall liking. Different clusters of samples with identifiable characteristics were found, suggesting the need for a wide range of non-alcoholic lagers to satisfy all consumers' preferences. Production methods were investigated as a possible explanation for the differences, but other factors such as pre or post processing methods may also play a role.

FOOD CHEMISTRY-X (2021)

Article Food Science & Technology

Brewing with Unmalted Cereal Adjuncts: Sensory and Analytical Impacts on Beer Quality

Joanna Yorke, David Cook, Rebecca Ford

Summary: Using unmalted cereal adjuncts in brewing can reduce costs and improve sustainability, but high adjunct rates may lead to significant sensory differences in beer. This study found that at 30% adjunct incorporation, the flavor profile remained similar, while at 60% incorporation, specific sensory differences were observed, along with impacts on fermentation volatile profiles. Understanding and minimizing these flavor differences will aid in cost-efficient and sustainable brewing solutions.

BEVERAGES (2021)

Review Food Science & Technology

The multisensory perception of hop essential oil: a review

Christina Dietz, David Cook, Margaux Huismann, Colin Wilson, Rebecca Ford

JOURNAL OF THE INSTITUTE OF BREWING (2020)

No Data Available