4.5 Article

An AHP-based indoor Air Pollution Risk Index Method for cultural heritage collections

Journal

JOURNAL OF CULTURAL HERITAGE
Volume 16, Issue 3, Pages 352-360

Publisher

ELSEVIER FRANCE-EDITIONS SCIENTIFIQUES MEDICALES ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.culher.2014.06.012

Keywords

Risk Condition Index; Cultural heritage; Risk management; Indoor air quality; Collection management; Istanbul

Funding

  1. TUBITAK [109Y272]
  2. General Secretariat of TBMM (Turkish Grand National Assembly)
  3. Department of National Palaces
  4. Dolmabahce Palace management and personnel

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The identification of risk factors and levels for cultural heritage collections in museums, archives, and libraries is an important part of their risk management plans. Air pollutants are some of the most important risk factors, and their synergic impacts on material deformations are well known; thus, they have become important criteria in collection risk management plans. Pollution levels and their potential sources should be identified, monitored, and assessed within such risk management plans. Although pollution identification and monitoring methods are well-known practices, the assessment methodologies are not yet sufficiently developed. In this study, a novel air pollution condition indexing assessment method based on an analytical hierarchy process (AHP), the so-called Air Quality Risk Condition Index (AQRCI), is suggested. It quantifies the relative potential synergic impacts (e.g., soiling and color change, salt crystallization, metal corrosion, biodegradation, swelling/shrinkage, loss of strength, cracking, and embrittlement) of measured pollution levels on collection materials in any selected location. The proposed method is based on quantitative (gaseous and particulate pollutant levels) and qualitative (pairwise comparison scores for associated risks) data. Dolmabahce Palace was selected as a study site, and the proposed AQRCI method was used to present the relative risk levels for five different categories in several indoor locations where the Dolmabahce Palace collections are being presented. (C) 2014 Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Readiness Assessment of Green Building Certification Systems for Residential Buildings during Pandemics

Aidana Tleuken, Galym Tokazhanov, Mert Guney, Ali Turkyilmaz, Ferhat Karaca

Summary: This study evaluates the readiness of selected green building certification systems for assessing the sustainability of residential buildings in a post-pandemic world, finding that none of the reviewed systems are fully prepared to cover all proposed indicators. Different systems have varying focuses on specific sustainability pillars, which impacted their responses to pandemic-resilient categories.

SUSTAINABILITY (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Environmental Partitioning, Spatial Distribution, and Transport of Atmospheric Mercury (Hg) Originating from a Site of Former Chlor-Alkali Plant

Mert Guney, Aiganym Kumisbek, Zhanel Akimzhanova, Symbat Kismelyeva, Kamila Beisova, Almagul Zhakiyenova, Vassilis Inglezakis, Ferhat Karaca

Summary: The study conducted measurements of total gaseous mercury in Pavlodar, Kazakhstan to predict its spatial distribution, estimated the environmental repartition of mercury deposited by a former Hg-cell chlor-alkali plant using three fugacity models, and predicted long-range mercury transport through trajectory-based cluster analysis.

ATMOSPHERE (2021)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Which qualities should built environment possess to ensure satisfaction of higher-education students with remote education during pandemics?

Aidana Tleuken, Ali Turkyilmaz, Kristina Unger, Galym Tokazhanov, Idriss El-Thalji, Mohamad Y. Mostafa, Mert Guney, Ferhat Karaca

Summary: The COVID-19 pandemic has led to a shift in education processes to remote mode, and this study aims to identify the impact of the residential built environment on students' satisfaction and academic performance during this time. The study was conducted in Kazakhstan and Norway using an online survey, and the results showed that the built environment affects both satisfaction and performance in remote education. Differences were observed between urban and non-urban living areas, with health and safety being more important for urban areas and comfort facilities being more important for non-urban residents.

BUILDING AND ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Assessment of Distribution of Potentially Toxic Elements in Different Environmental Media Impacted by a Former Chlor-Alkali Plant

Mert Guney, Zhanel Akimzhanova, Aiganym Kumisbek, Symbat Kismelyeva, Almira Guney, Ferhat Karaca, Vassilis Inglezakis

Summary: Former industrially contaminated sites still pose environmental risks and need to be evaluated for pollution by Hg and other selected PTEs, especially in the vicinity of Lake Balkyldak where persistent Hg pollution is present.

SUSTAINABILITY (2021)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Potential Human Exposure to Mercury (Hg) in a Chlor-Alkali Plant Impacted Zone: Risk Characterization Using Updated Site Assessment Data

Symbat Kismelyeva, Rustem Khalikhan, Aisulu Torezhan, Aiganym Kumisbek, Zhanel Akimzhanova, Ferhat Karaca, Mert Guney

Summary: Industrial activities have caused severe environmental contamination, posing unacceptable health risks to rural and urban populations. The chlor-alkali plant in Pavlodar, Kazakhstan has historically contributed to mercury contamination, with elevated levels found in soil, water, air, and biota. While the current study suggests acceptable risks from exposure to mercury contamination in the region, further assessment is needed for worker exposure scenarios and consumption of contaminated fish from Lake Balkyldak.

SUSTAINABILITY (2021)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Legislative, Institutional, Industrial and Governmental Involvement in Circular Economy in Central Asia: A Systematic Review

Aidana Tleuken, Galym Tokazhanov, Kebir Mohammed Jemal, Ramazan Shaimakhanov, Magzhan Sovetbek, Ferhat Karaca

Summary: As the world grapples with the negative impacts of human activity on the environment, the circular economy is gaining attention as a means to preserve the value of resources. This research reviews the available literature on sustainability, green economy, and circularity development, and assesses the barriers and opportunities to circular economy development in CACs. The study finds that CACs face similar challenges (such as reliance on fossil fuels, water scarcity, and inadequate waste management) and opportunities (such as a focus on sustainable development, international cooperation, and green financing) in their circular economy development. Effective strategic plans, stakeholder involvement, and sufficient funding are recommended to promote circular economy in CACs.

SUSTAINABILITY (2022)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Analytical Methods for Physicochemical Characterization and Toxicity Assessment of Atmospheric Particulate Matter: A Review

Akmaral Agibayeva, Mert Guney, Ferhat Karaca, Aiganym Kumisbek, Jong Ryeol Kim, Egemen Avcu

Summary: This review aims to comprehensively assess the toxicity and composition of particle-bound pollutants, evaluate different methods for characterizing particles, and provide recommendations for enhancing human health risk assessment. The study found that the cellular response to particles is complex and requires a combination of morphological and chemical data for a comprehensive assessment. The recommended method for single-particle analysis is SEM-EDS, followed by dry or wet chemical analysis techniques for studying the bulk chemistry of particles. Using bioaccessible/soluble fractions can improve the accuracy of human health risk assessment.

SUSTAINABILITY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Neuropsychological Assessment of Community-Dwelling Older Adults in Almaty, Kazakhstan

Mukhtar Kulimbet, Natalya Glushkova, Beth Snitz, Radmila Tsoy, Shalkar Adambekov, Evelyn Talbott, Alibek Mereke, Minjie Wu, Abzal Zhumagaliuly, Ferhat Karaca, Yuefang Chang, Saule Turuspekova, Akira Sekikawa, Kairat Davletov

Summary: This study aimed to investigate cognitive impairment in older adults in Kazakhstan. By administering neuropsychological tests to 276 adults aged 60+, the study found associations between demographic factors such as age, education, gender, and ethnicity with cognitive performance. The findings provide a foundation for future research on dementia and cognitive impairment in the aging population of Kazakhstan.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH AND PUBLIC HEALTH (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Facilitating Circular Economy Strategies Using Digital Construction Tools: Framework Development

Kebir Mohammed Jemal, Marzhan Kabzhassarova, Ramazan Shaimkhanov, Dinara Dikhanbayeva, Ali Turkyilmaz, Serdar Durdyev, Ferhat Karaca

Summary: This study aims to investigate the impact of digital tools on circular economy implementation in the construction sector and proposes a new research framework through a three-step approach. The study found that advanced digital tools can be used to enhance circular economy implementation in construction. The contribution of this study includes the integration of circular economy and digitalization concepts in construction, filling the existing research gap, and the investigation of critical barriers, providing insights for construction practitioners.

SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

An Air Quality Modeling and Disability-Adjusted Life Years (DALY) Risk Assessment Case Study: Comparing Statistical and Machine Learning Approaches for PM2.5 Forecasting

Akmaral Agibayeva, Rustem Khalikhan, Mert Guney, Ferhat Karaca, Aisulu Torezhan, Egemen Avcu

Summary: This study successfully predicts PM2.5 concentrations in Astana, Kazakhstan during heating and non-heating periods using multiple linear regression (MLR) and random forest (RF) algorithms, and estimates the Disability-Adjusted Life Years (DALY) risk. The RF model shows higher accuracy compared to the MLR model. PM10 and carbon monoxide concentrations have the most significant impact on PM2.5 prediction, while meteorological parameters have a weaker association. The developed methodology can be applied to locations with similar air pollution and climate characteristics.

SUSTAINABILITY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Cities of Central Asia: New hotspots of air pollution in the world

Madina Tursumbayeva, Aset Muratuly, Nassiba Baimatova, Ferhat Karaca, Aiymgul Kerimray

Summary: This study investigated PM2.5 temporal variations and the influence of meteorological parameters on PM2.5 concentrations in six major cities in Central Asia. The results show severe air quality deterioration with annual PM2.5 concentrations up to tenfold higher than the limits. Coal combustion is identified as the primary source of PM2.5 pollution in most cities.

ATMOSPHERIC ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Assessing the Impact of Combined Heat and Power Plants (CHPPs) in Central Asia: A Case Study in Almaty for PM2.5 Simulations Using WRF-AERMOD and Ground Level Verification

Theophilus Bright Ogbuabia, Mert Guney, Nassiba Baimatova, Ismail Ulusoy, Ferhat Karaca

Summary: Kazakhstan is one of the most polluted countries in the world, with high concentrations of PM2.5 pollutants. The government's measures to reduce pollution have been ineffective, prompting a need to investigate the sources of PM2.5. The study found that controlled CHPP emissions have a negligible impact on the total concentration, while uncontrolled CHPP emissions contribute significantly.

ATMOSPHERE (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Household Water and Energy Consumption Changes during COVID-19 Pandemic Lockdowns: Cases of the Kazakhstani Cities of Almaty, Shymkent, and Atyrau

Aidana Tleuken, Galym Tokazhanov, Aray-Bibi Serikbay, Kuanysh Zhalgasbayev, Mert Guney, Ali Turkyilmaz, Ferhat Karaca

Summary: The COVID-19 pandemic has led people to spend more time at home, impacting the consumption of water and energy. This study in Kazakhstan evaluates the effects of lockdowns on residential water and energy consumption in cities of different sizes. Results show that energy and water consumption increased during lockdown periods, but the growth was not significantly higher compared to non-pandemic times, posing a risk for sustainable resources consumption and supply companies.

BUILDINGS (2021)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Circular Economy: Challenges and Opportunities in the Construction Sector of Kazakhstan

Beibut Torgautov, Asset Zhanabayev, Aidana Tleuken, Ali Turkyilmaz, Mohammad Mustafa, Ferhat Karaca

Summary: This research investigates the potential application of circular economy principles in the construction sector in Kazakhstan, identifying stakeholders' focus on virtualization opportunities.

BUILDINGS (2021)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Adoption of Green Building Assessment Systems to Existing Buildings under Kazakhstani Conditions

Alexey Remizov, Aizhan Tukaziban, Zhuldyz Yelzhanova, Tokzhan Junussova, Ferhat Karaca

Summary: The construction industry plays a significant role in the global economy, but contributes significantly to energy consumption and carbon emissions. Promoting green building concepts is crucial for all countries, and each country needs to develop assessment tools tailored to local needs. The construction industry in Kazakhstan faces sustainability challenges, while the application of green certification systems is hindered by limited knowledge and awareness.

BUILDINGS (2021)

Article Archaeology

A new and 'riveting' method: Micro-CT scanning for the documentation, conservation, and reconstruction of the Gjellestad ship

Justin J. L. Kimball, Ruben With, Christian Lochsen Rodsrud

Summary: Micro-CT (μCT) has been increasingly used in the cultural heritage sector to understand past cultures and their materials. In the case of the Gjellestad ship from the Viking Age, μCT was used to document and conserve the deteriorated organic and metallic materials. A georeferencing system was developed to retain important stratigraphic and position information, allowing for spatial positioning using 3D GIS. The use of μCT has shown positive impact on the documentation, conservation, and reconstruction of cultural heritage.

JOURNAL OF CULTURAL HERITAGE (2024)

Review Archaeology

From physical to virtual art exhibitions and beyond: Survey and some issues for consideration for the metaverse

S. Sylaiou, P. Dafiotis, D. Koukopoulos, K. Koukoulis, R. Vital, A. Antoniou, Chr. Fidas

Summary: This manuscript discusses the growing importance of Extended Reality (XR) in art exhibitions. It explores the technologies used, design issues, evaluation metrics, and aims of XR exhibitions. The research focuses on the current types of technologies used, primary design considerations, and methods to enhance user experience. The paper also examines evaluation criteria and the use of virtual humans for increased engagement. Additionally, it thoroughly discusses parameters affecting user experience and offers suggestions for optimizing design and future directions.

JOURNAL OF CULTURAL HERITAGE (2024)

Article Archaeology

Automatic generation of synthetic heritage point clouds: Analysis and segmentation based on shape grammar for historical vaults

Carlo Battini, Umberto Ferretti, Giorgia De Angelis, Roberto Pierdicca, Marina Paolanti, Ramona Quattrini

Summary: This research presents a method for recognizing historical building elements using a deep learning system. By leveraging synthetic point clouds to generate 3D models, the proposed approach achieves high accuracy in the experiments conducted on a newly synthetic dataset.

JOURNAL OF CULTURAL HERITAGE (2024)

Article Archaeology

A conceptual model for ancient Chinese ceramics based on metadata and ontology: A case study of collections in the Nankai University Museum

Jingwen Zhang, Tianlin Ren

Summary: In the era of digital information, metadata and ontology technology have promoted the management and utilization of museum collections. This study focused on ancient Chinese ceramics and proposed solutions for the shortcomings in their information management through metadata analysis and ontology construction. The structure of the ontology was visualized to provide a clearer understanding of ancient Chinese ceramics.

JOURNAL OF CULTURAL HERITAGE (2024)