4.7 Article

The relative profitability of dairy, sheep, beef and grain farm enterprises in southeast Australia under selected rainfall and price scenarios

Journal

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS
Volume 117, Issue -, Pages 35-44

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.agsy.2013.01.002

Keywords

Dryland farming; Farm enterprises; Climate variability; Price variability

Funding

  1. University of Melbourne
  2. Future Farm Industries Cooperative Research Centre

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Dryland farming and its profitability is directly affected by the amount and timing of rainfall that influence and consequently impacts on pasture and crop yields. Yet rainfall is not the sole determinant of farm enterprise profitability; prices of farm inputs and commodities produced also affect farm profits. This study draws on farm commodity prices and input prices from the past 9 years to form correlated price and cost datasets that are then used in examining the profitability of a range of farm enterprises in south eastern Australia under low, average and high rainfall scenarios. Fourteen representative farm enterprises were examined that included the production of Merino fine wool, prime lamb, beef cattle, milk, wheat and canola. The spread of profitability of these farm enterprises against the backdrop of price variability and rainfall scenarios was compared. The results show that profitability of the enterprises studied is currently affected more by changes in rainfall than by commodity prices and that dairy enterprises are the most profitable on a $/ha basis but that the profitability of wheat, steer and prime lamb enterprises are least affected by low rainfall scenarios. The self-replacing cow-calf beef systems, canola and dairy enterprises are the most vulnerable to reduced rainfall and may benefit by reducing profit risk through changes such as expanding the enterprise or diversifying across other types of enterprises. Farm diversification involving combinations of enterprises with negatively correlated profits will enable the variance in farm profits to be reduced. Such actions could form part of farms' adaptation strategies to climate and price variability. (C) 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Agricultural Economics & Policy

Agriculture's carbon neutral challenge: The case of Western Australia*

Ross Kingwell

Summary: Agriculture is being encouraged to become carbon neutral, with agricultural land seen as a potential source of carbon sequestration. However, achieving local carbon neutrality in agricultural regions comes with an economic cost, influenced by current greenhouse gas emissions patterns and spatial costs. A study on Western Australia's agricultural region estimates the cost of achieving carbon neutrality through reforestation, with considerations for social and political pressures limiting reforestation of farmland. The annual cost of achieving regional carbon neutrality through prescribed regional reforestation is estimated to range from AUD216 million to AUD250 million, suggesting commercial feasibility but potentially reducing farm business profits by 15% without additional incentives.

AUSTRALIAN JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURAL AND RESOURCE ECONOMICS (2021)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Economic implications of the loss of glyphosate and paraquat on Australian mixed enterprise farms

Alison Walsh, Ross Kingwell

Summary: Glyphosate and paraquat, widely used non-selective herbicides in Australian agriculture, are facing the threat of bans due to potential negative impacts on farming systems and profitability. If banned, Australia may see increased production costs, decreased profits, and a shift towards sheep production rather than cropping. However, a global ban on these herbicides could actually benefit Australian farm businesses due to their lower reliance on glyphosate-tolerant crops.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2021)

Article Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

Automated feeding of sheep. 2. Feeding behaviour influences the methane emissions of sheep offered restricted diets

S. K. Muir, R. Behrendt, M. Moniruzzaman, G. Kearney, M. Knight

Summary: Research showed that methane emissions in sheep were correlated with daily DMI and time since the last meal. Sheep fed at lower feeding levels tended to produce less methane. The impact of feeding behavior and time since the last meal should be considered in feeding protocols.

ANIMAL PRODUCTION SCIENCE (2022)

Article Business

The choice of efficiency benchmarking metric in evaluating firm productivity and viability

S. C. West, A. W. Mugera, R. S. Kingwell

Summary: The Debreu-Farrell measure of technical efficiency is limited in providing policy insights for achieving the best possible productivity level, and alternative measures such as total factor productivity efficiency should be considered.

JOURNAL OF PRODUCTIVITY ANALYSIS (2022)

Review Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

Optimal sheep stocking rates for broad-acre farm businesses in Western Australia: a review

Michael Young, Philip E. Vercoe, Ross S. Kingwell

Summary: The stocking rate of sheep has a significant impact on farm profit, making it a challenging task to determine the optimal rate. Inconsistent definitions of stocking rate can lead to misunderstandings. Determining the optimal rate involves considering various factors, such as feed availability, nutritional requirements, costs, and prices. While farmers often rely on personal judgement, it is not an easy decision due to the complexities involved.

ANIMAL PRODUCTION SCIENCE (2022)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Reducing farming system emissions via spatial application of payoff functions

S. Kharel, C. d'Abbadie, A. Abadi, R. Kingwell

Summary: This study used bioeconomic modelling to analyze the impact of land use changes on greenhouse gas emissions in the agricultural region of south-western Australia, revealing cost-effective reduction strategies for emissions in different locations.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2022)

Article Agricultural Economics & Policy

Representing weather-year variation in whole-farm optimisation models: Four-stage single-sequence vs eight-stage multi-sequence

Michael Young, John Young, Ross S. Kingwell, Philip E. Vercoe

Summary: The trade-off between accuracy and complexity is a common issue in farm systems analysis. This study compares the performance of two optimization models in representing weather-year sequence in farm modeling. The results show that single-year stochastic programming generates similar expected profit and strategic management as multi-year stochastic programming. However, optimal tactical farm management is affected by the outcome of the previous year. Technology changes over the last decade have made it easier to construct and apply the optimization models, but choosing the best framework for a specific issue or opportunity remains a challenge.

AUSTRALIAN JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURAL AND RESOURCE ECONOMICS (2023)

Article Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

Comparative enteric-methane emissions of dairy farms in northern Victoria, Australia

Sineka Munidasa, Brendan Cullen, Richard Eckard, Saranika Talukder, Lachlan Barnes, Long Cheng

Summary: This study compared methane emissions and emission intensity of milk production across different feeding systems in northern Victoria, Australia. The results show that Feeding-system 4-5 had higher methane emissions but lower emission intensity than pasture-based systems, which suggests that a move towards Feeding-system 4-5 could help reduce methane emission.

ANIMAL PRODUCTION SCIENCE (2023)

Review Environmental Sciences

Grazing management for soil carbon in Australia: A review

Sarah E. Mcdonald, Warwick Badgery, Simon Clarendon, Susan Orgill, Katrina Sinclair, Rachelle Meyer, Dominique Bowen Butchart, Richard Eckard, David Rowlings, Peter Grace, Natalie Doran-Browne, Steven Harden, Ainslie Macdonald, Anibal Nahuel Alejandro Pachas, Michael Wellington, Rowan Eisner, Martin Amidy, Matthew Tom Harrison

Summary: The livestock industry in Australia has a significant impact on agricultural greenhouse gas emissions. Increasing soil carbon storage in grazing lands can help achieve the net-zero emissions goal, while also potentially improving production and providing other ecosystem services. This review and meta-analysis found no significant impact of stocking intensity or method on soil carbon sequestration, but lower stocking intensity and rotational grazing had positive effects on herbage mass and ground cover.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

Making Agriculture Carbon Neutral Amid a Changing Climate: The Case of South-Western Australia

Ross Kingwell

Summary: Several agricultural organisations in Australia aim to make Australian agriculture carbon neutral by 2050. However, projected adverse climate change may increase the cost of achieving carbon neutrality through reforestation in southwest Australia. Despite the potential cost increase, research and innovation in agricultural R & D are crucial in reducing agricultural emissions and achieving carbon neutrality.
Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Factors influencing Australian sugarcane irrigators' adoption of solar photovoltaic systems for water pumping

J. W. Powell, J. M. Welsh, D. Pannell, R. Kingwell

Summary: The study found that there is a potential for 50% of Australian sugarcane farmers to adopt solar PV systems for irrigation in the next 10 years. Farmers’ decisions are predicted to be influenced by factors such as economic and environmental benefits, ease of use, existing knowledge, business risk, and financial position.

CLEANER ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY (2021)

Article Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

Automated feeding of sheep. 1. Changes in feeding behaviour in response to restricted and ad libitum feeding

R. Behrendt, S. K. Muir, M. Moniruzzaman, G. Kearney, M. I. Knight

Summary: The study found that sheep can quickly adapt and respond to changes in daily allowance and offered meal size, but the similar number of non-feeding events at different proportions of maintenance feeding suggest that non-feeding events may not reflect levels of hunger.

ANIMAL PRODUCTION SCIENCE (2021)

Article Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

Effect of defoliation on spring-sown winter-type canola (Brassica napus) grain yield, quality and morphology

M. C. Raeside, J. Byron, F. Cameron, C. MacDonald, D. L. Partington, G. A. Kearney, R. Behrendt

Summary: The research found that grazing spring-sown winter-type canola during summer and autumn in southern Australia does not result in a grain-yield penalty, but further grazing or defoliation during winter when bud elongation commences can lead to significant reductions in grain yield.

ANIMAL PRODUCTION SCIENCE (2021)

Article Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

The impact of ewe lamb mating and different feeding strategies over summer-autumn on profit and risk: a case study in south-west Victoria

Jonathon Tocker, Ralph Behrendt, Margaret Raeside, Bill Malcolm

Summary: Mating ewe lambs at around 7 months of age is considered a way to increase profits and reduce risks in sheep farms in south-west Victoria, Australia. Utilizing spring-sown canola or lucerne forage for ewe-lamb mating provides the best returns on capital relative to the risks involved.

ANIMAL PRODUCTION SCIENCE (2021)

Article Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

Effect of grazing different forage systems prior to and during mating on the liveweight, condition score, conception and reproductive rate of maternal-composite ewe lambs

M. C. Raeside, J. Byron, F. Cameron, C. MacDonald, S. Rochfort, D. L. Partington, G. A. Kearney, R. Behrendt

Summary: The research aimed to determine the impact of grazing summer-active pastures or brassica forages on ewe lamb liveweight, condition score, conception, and reproductive rate during mating compared to a system using perennial ryegrass plus supplement. Results showed that ewe lambs grazing canola or forage brassica had higher liveweight gains during mating compared to those grazing perennial ryegrass, indicating the potential for improved reproductive performance with certain forage options.

ANIMAL PRODUCTION SCIENCE (2021)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

A methodology based on territorial metabolism analysis to assess the multi-criteria sustainability of African village terroirs with contrasted crop-livestock systems

Elise Audouin, Mariana Odru, Dominique Masse, Gualbert Seraphin Dorego, Valerie Delaunay, Philippe Lecomte, Jonathan Vayssieres

Summary: Agricultural intensification is important for food security and limiting rural exodus in sub-Saharan Africa. Livestock farming has the potential to improve the sustainability of farming systems, but landscape-level studies are rare. By considering the interactions between animals, crops, and trees, the landscape level is the only level where the impacts of livestock farming can be fully understood. This study developed a methodology to compare different livestock systems based on territorial metabolism and sustainability indicators.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Collective action, replanting and resilience; Key lessons from 40 years of smallholder oil palm cultivation in the Ophir plantation, Indonesia

Idsert Jelsma, Turinah, Frederic Gay, Jean Ollivier, Bruno Rapidel

Summary: Our study aims to analyze the resilience of farmer organizations in the Ophir plantation during replanting. By examining a 40-year period in five farmer cooperatives, we provide unique insights on the dynamics that influence the resilience of farmer organizations, shed light on smallholder oil palm replanting strategies, and draw several key lessons from this case.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

What determines the acceptance of Climate Smart Technologies? The influence of farmers' behavioral drivers in connection with the policy environment

Maria Rodriguez-Barillas, Laurens Klerkx, P. Marijn Poortvliet

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Effects of fertilization practices and understory on soil health and oil palm performances in smallholdings: An Indonesian case study

Alexis Thoumazeau, Romane Mettauer, Turinah, Heri Junedi, Victor Baron, Cecile Cheron-Bessou, Jean Ollivier

Summary: This study investigates the effects of fertilization and understory vegetation management on soil health and oil palm performances. It aimed to isolate and decipher the specific effects of some key practices on the overall plantation performances.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Review Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Assessing the role of agriculture-forestry-livestock nexus in improving farmers' food security in South Asia: A systematic literature review

Pritha Datta, Bhagirath Behera, Dil Bahadur Rahut

Summary: This study aims to evaluate the potential of South Asian agroforestry systems as a viable agroecological approach for ensuring farmers' food security. A systematic literature review found that out of 95 reviewed studies, only nine focused on food security and none of them examined all four dimensions of food security simultaneously. Moreover, the majority of studies were skewed towards the Himalayan belt and lacked quantitative measurement, making it challenging to determine the significance of this field.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Modeling the effect of multiple pests on ecosystem services provided by fruit crops: Application to apple

Octave Lacroix, Francoise Lescourret, Michel Genard, Mohamed-Mahmoud Memah, Gilles Vercambre, Pierre Valsesia, Daniele Bevacqua, Isabelle Grechi

Summary: In this study, a pest-crop model was developed to examine the impact of multiple pests on fruit tree functioning and ecosystem services provided by orchards. Through simulations and analysis, it was found that pests significantly affected indicators such as fruit sugar content, marketable yield, carbon sequestration, and water drainage.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

How to find alternative crops for climate-resilient regional food production

Malve Heinz, Valeria Galetti, Annelie Holzka

Summary: This paper presents an innovative approach for identifying climate-adapted alternative food crops that can help diversify existing cropping systems, increase their climate resilience, and contribute to nutritious plant-based regional diets with reduced emissions.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Technical efficiency drivers of farmer-led restoration strategies, and how substantial is the unrealised potential for farm output?

Vianny Ahimbisibwe, Eliza Zhunusova, Habtemariam Kassa, Sven Guenter

Summary: This study examines the technical efficiency levels of home gardens and woodlot systems in Ethiopia and investigates the factors that contribute to technical efficiency.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Farm typologies for understanding farm systems and improving agricultural policy

Robert Huber, Bartosz Bartkowski, Calum Brown, Nadja El Benni, Jan-Henning Feil, Pascal Grohmann, Ineke Joormann, Heidi Leonhardt, Hermine Mitter, Birgit Mueller

Summary: Farm typologies help identify patterns in farm systems and support agricultural policy design, but they are often developed without much connection to previous studies and policy making.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Opportunities to close wheat yield gaps in Nepal's Terai: Insights from field surveys, on-farm experiments, and simulation modeling

Mina Devkota, Krishna Prasad Devkota, Gokul Prasad Paudel, Timothy J. Krupnik, Andrew James McDonald

Summary: Wheat production in the Terai region of Nepal has not met the increasing demand, with low average productivity and high spatial and temporal variability. This study identifies strategies for closing yield gaps through field surveys, on-farm experiments, and simulation models. The results suggest that improving agronomic practices, such as fertilization and irrigation management, can significantly increase wheat productivity.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Importance of (semi)natural vegetation on farms for achieving multiple objectives: A conceptual model based on temperate southern Australia

Angie Haslem, Andrew F. Bennett, James Q. Radford

Summary: This study integrates knowledge on the benefits and disbenefits of (semi)natural vegetation on farms for achieving six objectives, and develops a conceptual model of the relationships between these objectives and different types of vegetation. The results show that (semi)natural vegetation provides more benefits than disbenefits, with greater support for the benefits of native vegetation. Farm-level restoration contributes towards reversing vegetation loss, but the process takes time. Management practices play a role in enhancing the benefits of (semi)natural vegetation.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Trade-offs between higher productivity and lower environmental impacts for biodiversity-friendly and conventional cattle-oriented systems

Aymeric Mondiere, Michael S. Corson, Julie Auberger, Daphne Durant, Sylvain Foray, Jean-Francois Glinec, Penny Green, Sandra Novak, Frederic Signoret, Hayo M. G. van der Werf

Summary: This study assessed the productivity and environmental impacts of different livestock production systems and found that biodiversity-friendly systems perform better in terms of environmental impact. The results emphasize the importance of considering the multiple functions and overall environmental performance of these systems.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Introducing sheep for agroecological weed management on banana plantations in Guadeloupe: A co-design process with farmers

Nadine Andrieu, Elodie Dorey, Steewy Lakhia, Paul Meynard, Esther Hatil, Loic Normand, Jean-Luc Gourdine, Jean-Christophe Bambou

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Evaluation of nitrogen balances and nitrogen use efficiencies on farm level of the German agricultural sector

Philipp Loew, Bernhard Osterburg

Summary: This study evaluated the nitrogen performance of the German agricultural sector and identified the potential for nitrogen utilization in different farm types. The study also revealed the relationships between nitrogen performance and independent variables such as soil fertility, crop selection and diversity, production type, operating profit, and consulting services received.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Farmer Options and Risks in Complex Ecological-Social systems: The FORCES game designed for agroforestry management of upper watersheds

Rika Ratna Sari, Lisa Tanika, Erika N. Speelman, Danny Dwi Saputra, Arief Lukman Hakim, Danae M. A. Rozendaal, Kurniatun Hairiah, Meine van Noordwijk

Summary: This study aims to clarify the design principles of the FORCES game and apply it to diverse watershed contexts. The game design balances generic and site-specific information, and the performance and impact of the game are evaluated through testing and assessment.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)