4.6 Article

Thresholds and relations for soil-hydraulic and soil-physical properties as a function of burn severity 4years after the 2011 Las Conchas Fire, New Mexico, USA

Journal

HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES
Volume 32, Issue 14, Pages 2263-2278

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1002/hyp.13167

Keywords

burn severity; dNBR; Las Conchas Fire; soil-hydraulic properties; soil-physical properties; Wildfire; wildland fire

Funding

  1. USGS Southwest Region Wildfire Science Project Funds
  2. USGS Water Availability and Use Science Program
  3. USGS National Water Quality Program

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Wildfire effects on soil-physical and -hydraulic properties as a function of burn severity are poorly characterized, especially several years after wildfire. A stratified random sampling approach was used in 2015 to sample seven sites representing a spectrum of remotely sensed burn severity in the area impacted by the 2011 Las Conchas Fire in New Mexico, USA. Replicate samples from each site were analysed in the laboratory. Linear and linear indicator regression were used to assess thresholds in soil-physical and -hydraulic properties and functional relations with remotely sensed burn severity. Significant thresholds were present for initial soil-water content ((i)) at 0-6cm depth between the change in the Normalized Burn Ratio (dNBR) equal to 618-802, for bulk density ((b)) at 3-6cm between dNBR equal to 416-533, for gravel fraction at 0-1cm between dNBR equal to 416-533, for fines (the silt+clay fraction) at 0-1cm for dNBR equal to 416-533, and for fines at 3-6cm for dNBR equal to 293-416. Significant linear relations with dNBR were present between (b) at 0-1cm, loss on ignition (LOI) at 0-1cm, gravel fraction at 0-1cm, and the large organic fraction at 1-3cm. No thresholds or effects on soil-hydraulic properties of field-saturated hydraulic conductivity or sorptivity were observed. These results suggest that (b) and LOI at 0-1cm have residual direct impacts from the wildfire heat impulse. The (i) threshold is most likely from delayed groundcover/vegetation recovery that increases evaporation at the highest burn severity sites. Gravel and silt+clay thresholds at 0-1cm at the transition to high burn severity suggest surface gravel lag development from hydraulic erosion. Thresholds in (b) from 3 to 6cm and in silt+clay fraction from 3 to 6cm appear to be the result of soil variability between sites rather than wildfire impacts. This work suggests that gravel-rich soils may have increased resilience to sustained surface runoff generation and erosion following wildfire, with implications for assessments of postwildfire hydrologic and erosion recovery potential.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Environmental Sciences

Fates and fingerprints of sulfur and carbon following wildfire in economically important croplands of California, US

Anna L. Hermes, Brian A. Ebel, Sheila F. Murphy, Eve-Lyn S. Hinckley

Summary: The study investigated the bio-geochemical fingerprints of sulfur and carbon in the Napa River Watershed in California, showing the interacting effects of wildfire and land use on watershed sulfur and carbon cycling.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Postwildfire Soil-Hydraulic Recovery and the Persistence of Debris Flow Hazards

Matthew A. Thomas, Francis K. Rengers, Jason W. Kean, Luke A. McGuire, Dennis M. Staley, Katherine R. Barnhart, Brian A. Ebel

Summary: This study analyzes the potential for debris flows after wildfires over time and proposes a method to improve awareness of post-wildfire debris flow hazards. The research finds that rainfall intensity and duration are closely related to the types of debris flows following wildfires, while factors such as soil moisture, rainfall climatology, and root reinforcement may also impact the probability of debris flows.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-EARTH SURFACE (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Rapid-Response Unsaturated Zone Hydrology: Small-Scale Data, Small-Scale Theory, Big Problems

John R. Nimmo, Kim S. Perkins, Michelle R. Plampin, Michelle A. Walvoord, Brian A. Ebel, Benjamin B. Mirus

Summary: The unsaturated zone plays a crucial role in land and water resource management by controlling water flow and reducing vulnerability to contaminants. Rapid flow and transport in the unsaturated zone are becoming more common due to extreme hydroclimatic events, yet they are poorly understood. Scaling issues pose challenges in accurately representing these processes at larger spatial scales.

FRONTIERS IN EARTH SCIENCE (2021)

Review Engineering, Civil

Post-wildfire hydrologic recovery in Mediterranean climates: A systematic review and case study to identify current knowledge and opportunities

Joseph W. Wagenbrenner, Brian A. Ebel, Kevin D. Bladon, Alicia M. Kinoshita

Summary: Research on post-fire hydrologic recovery in Mediterranean climates shows uncertainty in recovery time and lacks a consistent definition. Studies reveal that 18 sites were considered recovered within seven years, but recovery time varied inconsistently across locations, unrelated to location, response variable, or study design.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Post-fire temporal trends in soil-physical and -hydraulic properties and simulated runoff generation: Insights from different burn severities in the 2013 Black Forest Fire, CO, USA

Brian A. Ebel, John A. Moody, Deborah A. Martin

Summary: Burn severity has a significant impact on soil-hydraulic properties after wildfires, influencing soil-physical properties and ground cover composition. However, the trends in soil-hydraulic properties were found to be less affected by initial burn severity, highlighting the complex relationships between burn severity, soil properties, and infiltration models.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Heterogeneous Patterns of Aged Organic Carbon Export Driven by Hydrologic Flow Paths, Soil Texture, Fire, and Thaw in Discontinuous Permafrost Headwaters

Joshua C. Koch, Matthew J. Bogard, David E. Butman, Kerri Finlay, Brian Ebel, Jason James, Sarah Ellen Johnston, M. Torre Jorgenson, Neal J. Pastick, Robert G. M. Spencer, Robert Striegl, Michelle Walvoord, Kimberly P. Wickland

Summary: Climate change is causing the thawing of permafrost soils in northern circumpolar landscapes, potentially releasing large quantities of organic carbon (OC) into the environment. However, the extent and mechanisms of OC mobilization and terrestrial-aquatic transfer are not well understood.

GLOBAL BIOGEOCHEMICAL CYCLES (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Linking fire-induced evapotranspiration shifts to streamflow magnitude and timing in the western United States

Natalie M. Collar, Samuel Saxe, Brian A. Ebel, Kathryn S. Boden, Ashley J. Rust, Terri S. Hogue

Summary: The impact of wildfire on water availability is a critical issue in the western United States. The study found that fire-induced reductions in actual evapotranspiration (ETa) can lead to increased post-fire discharge. The effect of wildfire on streamflow magnitude varies seasonally and is more pronounced in basins with larger burned areas. The results highlight the higher relative risk of fire-induced hydro-modification for water providers with small source-water collection areas.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

The statistical power of post-fire soil-hydraulic property studies: Are we collecting sufficient infiltration measurements after wildland fires

Brian A. Ebel

Summary: More measurements are needed in post-fire infiltration studies; effect size is the primary control on statistical power; steady state rainfall simulation method has greater statistical power compared to other measurement methods.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Wildfire-induced shifts in groundwater discharge to streams identified with paired air and stream water temperature analyses

David M. Rey, Martin A. Briggs, Michelle A. Walvoord, Brian A. Ebel

Summary: Increasingly severe and frequent wildfires in the western United States may change the quantity, timing, and quality of water exported by streams from burned areas. However, the effects of wildfires on groundwater recharge, changes in subsurface routing, and their consequences for stream low flows sourced predominantly by baseflow are poorly understood. This study demonstrates the use of temperature signals to identify changes in watershed subsurface flow contributions after fire and provides a framework for water management, impacts on aquatic habitat, and post-wildfire response planning.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2023)

Review Environmental Sciences

Modeling Post-Wildfire Hydrologic Response: Review and Future Directions for Applications of Physically Based Distributed Simulation

Brian A. Ebel, Zachary M. Shephard, Michelle A. Walvoord, Sheila F. Murphy, Trevor F. Partridge, Kim S. Perkins

Summary: Wildfires are an increasing concern due to climate change, and their hydrologic effects are being studied using numerical models. This review examines the use of physically based distributed models to understand water resources after wildfires, focusing on geographic/ecohydrologic distribution, representation of hydrologic processes, model parameterization, and model performance. There are opportunities for improvement, such as applying models in underrepresented regions, incorporating all streamflow generation mechanisms, and integrating vegetation regrowth models with hydrologic models.

EARTHS FUTURE (2023)

Article Water Resources

A call for strategic water-quality monitoring to advance assessment and prediction of wildfire impacts on water supplies

Sheila F. Murphy, Charles N. Alpers, Chauncey W. Anderson, J. Ryan Banta, Johanna M. Blake, Kurt D. Carpenter, Gregory D. Clark, David W. Clow, Laura A. Hempel, Deborah A. Martin, Michael R. Meador, Gregory O. Mendez, Anke B. Mueller-Solger, Marc A. Stewart, Sean E. Payne, Cara L. Peterman, Brian A. Ebel

Summary: Wildfires pose a risk to water supplies due to potential degradation of water quality, but a lack of data hinders prediction and assessment of post-wildfire impacts. Strategic monitoring and selection of sampling locations based on specific criteria can enhance assessment and prediction of post-wildfire water quality. Improved estimates of post-wildfire effects on water quality would help mitigate impacts on water supplies.

FRONTIERS IN WATER (2023)

Article Water Resources

Hydrologic recovery after wildfire: A framework of approaches, metrics, criteria, trajectories, and timescales

Brian A. Ebel, Joseph W. Wagenbrenner, Alicia M. Kinoshita, Kevin D. Bladon

Summary: Deviations in hydrologic processes caused by wildfires can impact streamflow, affecting peak flows and low flows. These changes can have consequences for water supplies, including quantity, quality, and timing. Post-fire shifts in hydrologic processes can also alter the timing and magnitude of floods and debris flows. The duration of hydrologic recovery is a critical concern for land, water, and emergency managers.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY AND HYDROMECHANICS (2022)

No Data Available