4.5 Article

Postwildfire Soil-Hydraulic Recovery and the Persistence of Debris Flow Hazards

Journal

Publisher

AMER GEOPHYSICAL UNION
DOI: 10.1029/2021JF006091

Keywords

debris flows; infiltration; landslides; rainfall thresholds; runoff; wildfire

Funding

  1. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) National Integrated Drought Information System (NIDIS) [1332KP-20FNRMT0012]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study analyzes the potential for debris flows after wildfires over time and proposes a method to improve awareness of post-wildfire debris flow hazards. The research finds that rainfall intensity and duration are closely related to the types of debris flows following wildfires, while factors such as soil moisture, rainfall climatology, and root reinforcement may also impact the probability of debris flows.
Deadly and destructive debris flows often follow wildfire, but understanding of changes in the hazard potential with time since fire is poor. We develop a simulation-based framework to quantify changes in the hydrologic triggering conditions for debris flows as postwildfire infiltration properties evolve through time. Our approach produces time-varying rainfall intensity-duration thresholds for runoff- and infiltration-generated debris flows with physics-based hydrologic simulations that are parameterized with widely available hydroclimatic, vegetation reflectance, and soil texture data. When we apply our thresholding protocol to a test case in the San Gabriel Mountains (California, USA), the results are consistent with existing regional empirical thresholds and rainstorms that caused runoff- and infiltration-generated debris flows soon after and three years following a wildfire, respectively. We find that the hydrologic triggering mechanisms for the two observed debris flow types are coupled with the effects of fire on the soil saturated hydraulic conductivity. Specifically, the rainfall intensity needed to generate debris flows via runoff increases with time following wildfire while the rainfall duration needed to produce debris flows via subsurface pore-water pressures decreases. We also find that variations in soil moisture, rainfall climatology, median grain size, and root reinforcement could impact the median annual probability of postwildfire debris flows. We conclude that a simulation-based method for calculating rainfall thresholds is a tractable approach to improve situational awareness of debris flow hazard in the years following wildfire. Further development of our framework will be important to quantify postwildfire hazard levels in variable climates, vegetation types, and fire regimes.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Groundwater Affects the Geomorphic and Hydrologic Properties of Coevolved Landscapes

David G. Litwin, Gregory E. Tucker, Katherine R. Barnhart, Ciaran J. Harman

Summary: This study developed a new model to explore how runoff generation affects long-term catchment evolution, focusing on hydrologic processes dominating in humid climates. The results showed the interplay between surface and subsurface water, with implications on landscape evolution and runoff generation.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-EARTH SURFACE (2022)

Editorial Material Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Reply to Comment by Anand et al. on Groundwater Affects the Geomorphic and Hydrologic Properties of Coevolved Landscapes

David G. Litwin, Gregory E. Tucker, Katherine R. Barnhart, Ciaran J. Harman

Summary: This article discusses the importance of domain size in a simple landscape evolution model and shows that it has little impact on the results in the examined parameter space. The authors also demonstrate that using landscape evolution process rates rather than domain size for nondimensionalization allows for a clearer understanding of the intrinsic features of the results.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-EARTH SURFACE (2022)

Review Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

A review of common natural disasters as analogs for asteroid impact effects and cascading hazards

Timothy Titus, D. Robertson, J. B. Sankey, L. Mastin, F. Rengers

Summary: Modern civilization lacks collective experience in dealing with the potential wide-ranging effects of a medium-sized asteroid impact. While efforts have been made to model the initial effects of meteor impacts or airbursts, the long-term cascading hazards are often overlooked. This paper reviews the initial and cascading effects of more common natural disasters and discusses their relevance to the expected long-term effects of an asteroid impact. A framework linking multiple hazard models could greatly benefit emergency managers, resource planners, and research scientists involved in mitigation and recovery efforts.

NATURAL HAZARDS (2023)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

Simulating Debris Flow and Levee Formation in the 2D Shallow Flow Model D-Claw: Channelized and Unconfined Flow

Ryan P. P. Jones, Francis K. K. Rengers, Katherine R. R. Barnhart, David L. L. George, Dennis M. M. Staley, Jason W. W. Kean

Summary: Debris flow runout is a dangerous phenomenon that poses risks to human life and infrastructure. By modifying a flow model to include the effects of segregation on permeability, we found that it improved the accuracy of predicting debris flow depth and runout distance. Therefore, considering segregation is important in predicting and mitigating debris flow hazards.

EARTH AND SPACE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

The Rainfall Intensity-Duration Control of Debris Flows After Wildfire

Matthew A. A. Thomas, Donald N. N. Lindsay, David B. B. Cavagnaro, Jason W. W. Kean, Scott W. W. McCoy, Andrew P. P. Graber

Summary: Increased wildfire activity in the western United States has revealed gaps in understanding postfire debris-flow generation. By characterizing flows in an unstudied area, we found that short-duration, high-intensity rainfall is more likely to initiate runoff-generated debris flows compared to total storm rainfall. This finding suggests the need for a focus on localized thunderstorms or bands of intense rainfall during prolonged rainstorms for hazard assessment and warning.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

Wildfire-induced shifts in groundwater discharge to streams identified with paired air and stream water temperature analyses

David M. Rey, Martin A. Briggs, Michelle A. Walvoord, Brian A. Ebel

Summary: Increasingly severe and frequent wildfires in the western United States may change the quantity, timing, and quality of water exported by streams from burned areas. However, the effects of wildfires on groundwater recharge, changes in subsurface routing, and their consequences for stream low flows sourced predominantly by baseflow are poorly understood. This study demonstrates the use of temperature signals to identify changes in watershed subsurface flow contributions after fire and provides a framework for water management, impacts on aquatic habitat, and post-wildfire response planning.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

On Transient Semi-Arid Ecosystem Dynamics Using Landlab: Vegetation Shifts, Topographic Refugia, and Response to Climate

Sai S. Nudurupati, Erkan Istanbulluoglu, Gregory E. Tucker, Nicole M. Gasparini, Daniel E. J. Hobley, Eric W. H. Hutton, Katherine R. Barnhart, Jordan M. Adams

Summary: Projecting the response of arid and semi-arid ecosystems to global change involves integrating various analytical and numerical models. This study used the Landlab earth surface modeling toolkit to investigate the controls of exogenous drivers and endogenous grass-fire feedback mechanisms in New Mexico. The simulations showed that shrubs occupy cooler slopes in dry conditions and shift to warmer slopes as regional moisture increases. The expansion of woody plant encroachment is predicted to occur in three phases, with the second phase requiring the removal of positive grass-fire feedback by grazing or fire suppression.

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2023)

Review Environmental Sciences

Modeling Post-Wildfire Hydrologic Response: Review and Future Directions for Applications of Physically Based Distributed Simulation

Brian A. Ebel, Zachary M. Shephard, Michelle A. Walvoord, Sheila F. Murphy, Trevor F. Partridge, Kim S. Perkins

Summary: Wildfires are an increasing concern due to climate change, and their hydrologic effects are being studied using numerical models. This review examines the use of physically based distributed models to understand water resources after wildfires, focusing on geographic/ecohydrologic distribution, representation of hydrologic processes, model parameterization, and model performance. There are opportunities for improvement, such as applying models in underrepresented regions, incorporating all streamflow generation mechanisms, and integrating vegetation regrowth models with hydrologic models.

EARTHS FUTURE (2023)

Article Water Resources

A call for strategic water-quality monitoring to advance assessment and prediction of wildfire impacts on water supplies

Sheila F. Murphy, Charles N. Alpers, Chauncey W. Anderson, J. Ryan Banta, Johanna M. Blake, Kurt D. Carpenter, Gregory D. Clark, David W. Clow, Laura A. Hempel, Deborah A. Martin, Michael R. Meador, Gregory O. Mendez, Anke B. Mueller-Solger, Marc A. Stewart, Sean E. Payne, Cara L. Peterman, Brian A. Ebel

Summary: Wildfires pose a risk to water supplies due to potential degradation of water quality, but a lack of data hinders prediction and assessment of post-wildfire impacts. Strategic monitoring and selection of sampling locations based on specific criteria can enhance assessment and prediction of post-wildfire water quality. Improved estimates of post-wildfire effects on water quality would help mitigate impacts on water supplies.

FRONTIERS IN WATER (2023)

Article Forestry

Predicting burn severity for integration with post-fire debris-flow hazard assessment: a case study from the Upper Colorado River Basin, USA

Adam G. Wells, Todd J. Hawbaker, J. Kevin Hiers, Jason Kean, Rachel A. Loehman, Paul F. Steblein

Summary: This study aimed to predict burn severity using pre-fire conditions and estimate the potential post-fire debris flow to unburned areas. Fuels, pre-fire weather, and topography were important predictors of burn severity. Predicted burn severity can be used to predict fire effects and identify potential hazards for prioritizing response and mitigation.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF WILDLAND FIRE (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Debris-Flow Process Controls on Steepland Morphology in the San Gabriel Mountains, California

William T. Struble, Luke A. McGuire, Scott W. McCoy, Katherine R. Barnhart, Odin Marc

Summary: Steep landscapes are largely shaped by debris flows, which incise valley bottoms and transport significant sediment volumes. However, the exact contribution of debris flows to the formation of steepland morphology is still uncertain, limiting the development of accurate erosion rate formulations. In the San Gabriel Mountains, the transition from steepland valleys to fluvial channels is correlated with erosion rates, and a one-dimensional landform model incorporating debris-flow erosion successfully reproduces these relationships. The model also highlights the critical role of debris flow incision in shaping steepland form, even as fluvial incision becomes dominant.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-EARTH SURFACE (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

The influence of large woody debris on post-wildfire debris flow sediment storage

Francis K. Rengers, Luke A. McGuire, Katherine R. Barnhart, Ann M. Youberg, Daniel Cadol, Alexander N. Gorr, Olivia J. Hoch, Rebecca Beers, Jason W. Kean

Summary: This study investigated the impact of post-fire large woody debris (LWD) on debris flow velocity and volume retention in four small watersheds in the Gila National Forest, New Mexico. The results showed that significant sediment storage was created by LWD upstream from the terminal fan, which was comparable to the total debris flow volume stored at the terminal fans. The study also proposed a method for estimating debris flow velocity based on estimates of the critical velocity required to break wood.

NATURAL HAZARDS AND EARTH SYSTEM SCIENCES (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

CSDMS: a community platform for numerical modeling of Earth surface processes

Gregory E. Tucker, Eric W. H. Hutton, Mark D. Piper, Benjamin Campforts, Tian Gan, Katherine R. Barnhart, Albert J. Kettner, Irina Overeem, Scott D. Peckham, Lynn McCready, Jaia Syvitski

Summary: Computational modeling plays a unique role in Earth and environmental sciences, serving as both scientific technology and infrastructure and as containers of the scientific community's understanding. To promote a flexible, interoperable, and ever-improving research software ecosystem, the Community Surface Dynamics Modeling System (CSDMS) has developed design principles, protocols, and tools.

GEOSCIENTIFIC MODEL DEVELOPMENT (2022)

No Data Available