4.4 Review

Barriers to the conduct of randomised clinical trials within all disease areas

Journal

TRIALS
Volume 18, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

BMC
DOI: 10.1186/s13063-017-2099-9

Keywords

Randomised clinical trials; Challenges; Barriers; Bottlenecks; Hindrances; Evidence based clinical practice; Evidence based medicine

Funding

  1. European Commission [284395]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Background: Randomised clinical trials are key to advancing medical knowledge and to enhancing patient care, but major barriers to their conduct exist. The present paper presents some of these barriers. Methods: We performed systematic literature searches and internal European Clinical Research Infrastructure Network (ECRIN) communications during face-to-face meetings and telephone conferences from 2013 to 2017 within the context of the ECRIN Integrating Activity (ECRIN-IA) project. Results: The following barriers to randomised clinical trials were identified: inadequate knowledge of clinical research and trial methodology; lack of funding; excessive monitoring; restrictive privacy law and lack of transparency; complex regulatory requirements; and inadequate infrastructures. There is a need for more pragmatic randomised clinical trials conducted with low risks of systematic and random errors, and multinational cooperation is essential. Conclusions: The present paper presents major barriers to randomised clinical trials. It also underlines the value of using a pan-European-distributed infrastructure to help investigators overcome barriers for multi-country trials in any disease area.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Infectious Diseases

One-month humoral response following two or three doses of messenger RNA coronavirus disease 2019 vaccines as primary vaccination in specific populations in France: first results from the Agence Nationale Recherche contre le Sida (ANRS)0001S COV-POPART cohort

Paul Loubet, Linda Wittkop, Laetitia Ninove, Mathieu Chalouni, Benoit Barrou, Jean-Yves Blay, Maryvonne Hourmant, Eric Thouvenot, Martine Laville, Bruno Laviolle, Jean-Daniel Lelievre, Jacques Morel, Stephanie Nguyen Quoc, Jean-Philippe Spano, Benjamin Terrier, Anne Thiebaut, Jean-Francois Viallard, Francois Vrtovsnik, Sophie Circosta, Laure Esterle, Axel Levier, Philippe Vanhems, Eric Tartour, Beatrice Parfait, Xavier de Lamballerie, Odile Launay

Summary: This study aimed to investigate the 1-month humoral response to two or three doses of mRNA COVID-19 vaccine in specific populations compared with healthy adults. The results showed a lower humoral response in the specific populations. However, the third dose of the vaccine had a positive effect on the immune response.

CLINICAL MICROBIOLOGY AND INFECTION (2023)

Review Critical Care Medicine

Molecular Function and Contribution of TBX4 in Development and Disease

Justyna A. Karolak, Carrie L. Welch, Christian Mosimann, Katarzyna Bzdega, James D. West, David Montani, Melanie Eyries, Mary P. Mullen, Steven H. Abman, Matina Prapa, Stefan Graf, Nicholas W. Morrell, Anna R. Hemnes, Frederic Perros, Rizwan Hamid, Malcolm P. O. Logan, Jeffrey Whitsett, Csaba Galambos, Pawel Stankiewicz, Wendy K. Chung, Eric D. Austin

Summary: Over the past decade, the significance of the TBX4 gene in respiratory diseases has been recognized. TBX4 is associated with congenital disorders involving respiratory and skeletal structures, but its exact role in human development is not fully understood. Through human and animal studies, we discuss the developmental, tissue-specific, and pathological functions of TBX4, as well as review the published TBX4 variants that result in different disease phenotypes. We also outline future research directions to enhance our understanding of TBX4 function and the impact of TBX4 disruption on development.

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF RESPIRATORY AND CRITICAL CARE MEDICINE (2023)

Review Nutrition & Dietetics

Nutritional status and the risk of malnutrition in older adults with chronic kidney disease- implications for low protein intake and nutritional care: A critical review endorsed by ERN-ERA and ESPEN

Giorgina Barbara Piccoli, Tommy Cederholm, Carla Maria Avesani, Stephan J. L. Bakker, Vincenzo Bellizzi, Cristina Cuerda, Adamasco Cupisti, Alice Sabatino, Stephane Schneider, Massimo Torreggiani, Denis Fouque, Juan Jesus Carrero, Rocco Barazzoni

Summary: Increased life expectancy presents significant challenges to healthcare systems globally, including the rise in chronic kidney disease (CKD) and malnutrition-protein-energy wasting (PEW) in older adults, leading to poor clinical outcomes. A critical review paper by ESPEN and ERN-ERA aims to summarize key concepts in preventing and treating CKD progression and impaired nutritional status, and provide guidance on defining optimal protein and energy intake in varying CKD severity. Careful assessment and individualized approach are necessary, considering malnutrition-PEW status, kidney function, and patient preferences. Greater awareness and research are needed to improve nutritional care for this growing patient subgroup.

CLINICAL NUTRITION (2023)

Article Endocrinology & Metabolism

Early humoral response to COVID-19 vaccination in patients living with obesity and diabetes in France. The COVPOP OBEDIAB study with results from the ANRS0001S COV-POPART cohort

Benedicte Gaborit, Sara Fernandes, Paul Loubet, Laetitia Ninove, Anne Dutour, Bertrand Cariou, Muriel Coupaye, Karine Clement, Sebastien Czernichow, Claire Carette, Noemie Resseguier, Laure Esterle, Sabrina Kali, Marie Houssays, Xavier de Lamballerie, Linda Wittkop, Odile Launay, Martine Laville

Summary: Patients with diabetes and obesity have weaker immune responses to COVID-19 vaccines, especially one month after the second dose. Post-vaccination serological checks are necessary for these high-risk populations.

METABOLISM-CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL (2023)

Article Urology & Nephrology

Rapid Waning of Immune Memory Against SARS-CoV-2 in Maintenance Hemodialysis Patients After mRNA Vaccination and Impact of a Booster Dose

Maxime Espi, Xavier Charmetant, Cyrille Mathieu, Alexandre Lalande, Didier Decimo, Laetitia Koppe, Caroline Pelletier, Anne Ovize, Alexia Barbry, Emmanuel Morelon, Emilie Kalbacher, Denis Fouque, Olivier Thaunat

KIDNEY INTERNATIONAL REPORTS (2023)

Article Cardiac & Cardiovascular Systems

Prognostic impact of precipitated cardiac decompensation in symptomatic heart failure with reduced ejection fraction and severe secondary mitral regurgitation

Nathan Mewton, Erwan Donal, Francois Picard, Francois Derimay, Daniel Grinberg, Delphine Maucort Boulch, Thomas Bochaton, Nicolas Piriou, Amelie De Lorgeril, Geraldine Samson, Frederic Rouleau, Benjamin Riche, Jean Noel Trochu

Summary: The study aimed to assess the distribution of primary and secondary heart failure events in a severe heart failure population and their association with 2-year all-cause mortality. The results showed that primary heart failure decompensations were three times more frequent than secondary decompensations, but both types had a similar impact on mortality risk. Patients with only primary or only secondary decompensation had a significantly increased risk of death.

AMERICAN HEART JOURNAL (2023)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

PedCRIN tool for the biosamples management in pediatric clinical trials

Viviana Giannuzzi, Lucia Ruggieri, Rosa Conte, Cristina Manfredi, Mariagrazia Felisi, Christine Kubiak, Mihaela Matei, Salma Malik, Jacques Demotes, Adriana Ceci, Donato Bonifazi

Summary: In pediatric clinical research, implementing ethical and regulatory requirements, training, and facilities are crucial for proper management of specimens. The Pediatric Clinical Research Infrastructure Network (PedCRIN) has developed a tool to guide investigators and sponsors in managing specimens and data in compliance with European rules. This tool addresses the specific need for guidance in managing biosamples in pediatric trials.

CTS-CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL SCIENCE (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Lympho-hematopoietic malignancies risk after exposure to low dose ionizing radiation during cardiac catheterization in childhood

Kossi D. Abalo, Sophie Malekzadeh-Milani, Sebastien Hascoet, Serge Dreuil, Tiphaine Feuillet, Cecilia Damon, Helene Bouvaist, Ivan Bouzguenda, Sarah Cohen, Claire Dauphin, Sylvie Di Filippo, Stephanie Douchin, Francois Godart, Patrice Guerin, Pauline Helms, Clement Karsenty, Bruno Lefort, Pierre Mauran, Caroline Ovaert, Jean-Francois Piechaud, Jean-Benoit Thambo, Choonsik Lee, Mark P. Little, Damien Bonnet, Marie-Odile Bernier, Estelle Rage

Summary: Pediatric patients with congenital heart disease who undergo cardiac catheterization (CC) may be exposed to low dose ionizing radiation (LDIR). However, this study found no increased risk of lympho-hematopoietic malignancies and lymphoma associated with LDIR in these patients.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY (2023)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Lenient rate control versus strict rate control for atrial fibrillation: a statistical analysis plan for the Danish Atrial Fibrillation (DanAF) randomized clinical trial

Isak Mazanti Cold, Joshua Buron Feinberg, Axel Brandes, Ulla Davidsen, Ulrik Dixen, Helena Dominguez, Uffe Jakob Ortved Gang, Christian Gluud, Rakin Hadad, Kit Engedal Kristensen, Doan Tuyet van Le, Emil Eik Nielsen, Michael Hecht Olsen, Ole Dyg Pedersen, Ilan Esra Raymond, Ahmad Sajadieh, Anne Merete Boas Soja, Janus Christian Jakobsen

Summary: This study aims to compare strict rate control with lenient rate control in patients with atrial fibrillation. The primary outcome is the physical component score of the SF-36 questionnaire. All secondary outcomes will be hypothesis-generating. The analysis will be based on the intention-to-treat principle and use linear regression for adjustment.

TRIALS (2023)

Article Gastroenterology & Hepatology

Iterative antibody-induced bile salt export pump deficiency after successive liver transplantations successfully treated with plasmapheresis and rituximab

Emma Wischlen, Noemie Laverdure, Domitille Erard, Barbara Rohmer, Olivier Boillot, Remi Dubois, Alain Lachaux, Sophie Collardeau-Frachon, Valerie Hervieu, Jerome Dumortier

Summary: Post-transplantation evolution of progressive familial intrahepatic cholestasis type 2 patients can be complicated by antibody-induced bile salt export pump deficiency (AIBD). There is no consensus on its management. We describe a patient who presented two episodes, 9 years apart. The first episode was refractory to plasmapheresis and intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG) started 2 months after AIBD onset, leading to graft loss. The second episode responded to plasmapheresis, IVIG and rituximab initiated less than 2 weeks after the beginning of symptoms, allowing for long-term recovery. This case suggests that intensive treatment with minimum delay after symptoms onset could sponsor a better evolution.

CLINICS AND RESEARCH IN HEPATOLOGY AND GASTROENTEROLOGY (2023)

Editorial Material Cardiac & Cardiovascular Systems

′Outside-the-box′ therapeutic solutions for ischaemia-reperfusion myocardial protection

Thomas Bochaton, Nathan Mewton

EUROPEAN HEART JOURNAL-ACUTE CARDIOVASCULAR CARE (2023)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Cerebral oximetry monitoring versus usual care for extremely preterm infants: a study protocol for the 2-year follow-up of the SafeBoosC-III randomised clinical trial

Marie Isabel Rasmussen, Mathias Luhr Hansen, Adelina Pellicer, Christian Gluud, Eugene Dempsey, Jonathan Mintzer, Simon Hyttel-Sorensen, Anne Marie Heuchan, Cornelia Hagmann, Ebru Ergenekon, Gabriel Dimitriou, Gerhard Pichler, Gunnar Naulaers, Guoqiang Cheng, Jakub Tkaczyk, Hans Fuchs, Monica Fumagalli, Saudamini Nesargi, Siv Fredly, Tomasz Szczapa, Anne Mette Plomgaard, Bo Molholm Hansen, Janus Christian Jakobsen, Gorm Greisen

Summary: The SafeBoosC-III follow-up study aims to assess mortality, neurodevelopmental disability, or any harm in trial participants at 2 years of corrected age. The lack of funding for trial-specific assessment local costs is a challenge that needs to be addressed.

TRIALS (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Centre for Statistical and Methodological Excellence (CESAME): A Consortium Initiative for Improving Methodology in Randomised Clinical Trials

Caroline Kamp Jorgensen, Markus Harboe Olsen, Niklas Nielsen, Theis Lange, Lawrence Mbuagbaw, Lehana Thabane, Laurent Billot, Nadine Binder, Silvio Garattini, Rita Banzi, Jacques Demotes, Elena Biagioli, Eliana Rulli, Guido Bertolini, Giovanni Nattino, Ole Mathiesen, Valter Torri, Christian Gluud, Janus Christian Jakobsen

Summary: The Centre for Statistical and Methodological Excellence (CESAME) aims to improve the accuracy and reliability of clinical trial results by developing standardized methods and guidelines. CESAME's work will benefit patients worldwide in various medical specialties by enhancing the internal and external validity of randomized clinical trials.

HEALTH SERVICES INSIGHTS (2023)

Article Critical Care Medicine

Fluid balance control in critically ill patients: results from POINCARE-2 stepped wedge cluster-randomized trial

Pierre-Edouard Bollaert, Alexandra Monnier, Francis Schneider, Laurent Argaud, Julio Badie, Claire Charpentier, Ferhat Meziani, Michel Bemer, Jean-Pierre Quenot, Marie Buzzi, Herve Outin, Cedric Bruel, Laurent Ziegler, Sebastien Gibot, Jean-Marc Virion, Camille Alleyrat, Guillaume Louis, Nelly Agrinier

Summary: The POINCARE-2 trial aimed to assess the effectiveness of a fluid balance control strategy on mortality in critically ill patients. However, the conservative strategy did not reduce mortality in these patients.

CRITICAL CARE (2023)

No Data Available