4.7 Article

Debris flow initiation by runoff in a recently burned basin: Is grain-by-grain sediment bulking or en masse failure to blame?

Journal

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS
Volume 44, Issue 14, Pages 7310-7319

Publisher

AMER GEOPHYSICAL UNION
DOI: 10.1002/2017GL074243

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) Landslide Hazards Program

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Postwildfire debris flows are frequently triggered by runoff following high-intensity rainfall, but the physical mechanisms by which water-dominated flows transition to debris flows are poorly understood relative to debris flow initiation from shallow landslides. In this study, we combined a numerical model with high-resolution hydrologic and geomorphic data sets to test two different hypotheses for debris flow initiation during a rainfall event that produced numerous debris flows within a recently burned drainage basin. Based on simulations, large volumes of sediment eroded from the hillslopes were redeposited within the channel network throughout the storm, leading to the initiation of numerous debris flows as a result of the mass failure of sediment dams that built up within the channel. More generally, results provide a quantitative framework for assessing the potential of runoff-generated debris flows based on sediment supply and hydrologic conditions.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Editorial Material Geography, Physical

Wildfire and earth surface processes

F. K. Rengers, Luke A. McGuire

Summary: Wildfire is a landscape-scale disturbance that affects the rate and magnitude of earth surface processes, with impacts varying depending on site-specific conditions. Studying the effects of fire on earth surface processes helps scientists and land managers better predict and manage the negative impacts of wildfires.

EARTH SURFACE PROCESSES AND LANDFORMS (2021)

Article Engineering, Geological

Modeling hydrologic processes associated with soil saturation and debris flow initiation during the September 2013 storm, Colorado Front Range

Sujana Timilsina, Jeffrey D. Niemann, Sara L. Rathburn, Francis K. Rengers, Peter A. Nelson

Summary: During a seven-day extreme rainfall event in September 2013 in the Colorado Front Range, it was observed that south-facing slopes were more prone to experiencing debris flows compared to north-facing slopes. By analyzing soil moisture patterns and hydrologic processes, it was determined that differences in interception and deep drainage were the primary factors leading to the saturation of south-facing slopes. The final model predicted instability at around 72% of observed debris flow initiation sites.

LANDSLIDES (2021)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Time Since Burning and Rainfall Characteristics Impact Post-Fire Debris-Flow Initiation and Magnitude

Luke A. Mcguire, Francis K. Rengers, Nina Oakley, Jason W. Kean, Dennis M. Staley, Hui Tang, Marian de Orla-Barile, Ann M. Youberg

Summary: The study combines measurements of soil-hydraulic properties with vegetation survey data and numerical modeling to predict changes in debris-flow properties and initiation thresholds in steep, burned watersheds following wildfires. Numerical modeling suggests that the intensity-duration threshold for debris flows varies depending on rainfall distribution within a storm, and that debris-flow volumes are significantly reduced after 1 year of recovery. Moreover, the threshold for debris flows increases from post-fire year 1 to year 3 in the San Gabriel Mountains region.

ENVIRONMENTAL & ENGINEERING GEOSCIENCE (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Forecasting the Frequency and Magnitude of Postfire Debris Flows Across Southern California

Jason W. Kean, Dennis M. Staley

Summary: Southern California has a long history of damaging debris flows after wildfires, but forecasts of the frequency and magnitude of postfire debris flows are not as readily available as they are for earthquakes. Research shows that small debris flows can be expected almost every year, while major debris flows capable of damaging 40 or more structures have a recurrence interval between 10 and 13 years.

EARTHS FUTURE (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Extreme Precipitation Across Adjacent Burned and Unburned Watersheds Reveals Impacts of Low Severity Wildfire on Debris-Flow Processes

Luke A. McGuire, Ann M. Youberg, Francis K. Rengers, Nathan S. Abramson, Indujaa Ganesh, Alexander N. Gorr, Olivia Hoch, Justin C. Johnson, Patt Lamom, Alexander B. Prescott, Jessica Zanetell, Brendan Fenerty

Summary: In steep landscapes, wildfire-induced changes to soil and vegetation can lead to extreme and hazardous geomorphic responses, including debris flows. Factors such as regional climate, vegetation, soil texture, and soil burn severity play a significant role in determining the heightened geomorphic responses post-wildfire. The study highlights the differences in debris flows between burned and unburned areas, providing insights into the impact of wildfires on geomorphic processes in steep terrain.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-EARTH SURFACE (2021)

Article Water Resources

The timing and magnitude of changes to Hortonian overland flow at the watershed scale during the post-fire recovery process

Tao Liu, Luke A. McGuire, Haiyan Wei, Francis K. Rengers, Hoshin Gupta, Lin Ji, David C. Goodrich

Summary: This study uses a hydrological model to investigate the changes in hydraulic parameters following a wildfire in the Arroyo Seco watershed in California. Results show that saturated hydraulic conductivity is lowest in the first year post-fire and increases at an average rate of about 4.2 mm/h/year during the first 5 years of recovery. Channel hydraulic roughness was lowest in the first year post-fire, but doubled after one year of recovery, with changes related to grain roughness and vegetation in channels.

HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Postwildfire Soil-Hydraulic Recovery and the Persistence of Debris Flow Hazards

Matthew A. Thomas, Francis K. Rengers, Jason W. Kean, Luke A. McGuire, Dennis M. Staley, Katherine R. Barnhart, Brian A. Ebel

Summary: This study analyzes the potential for debris flows after wildfires over time and proposes a method to improve awareness of post-wildfire debris flow hazards. The research finds that rainfall intensity and duration are closely related to the types of debris flows following wildfires, while factors such as soil moisture, rainfall climatology, and root reinforcement may also impact the probability of debris flows.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-EARTH SURFACE (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Movement of Sediment Through a Burned Landscape: Sediment Volume Observations and Model Comparisons in the San Gabriel Mountains, California, USA

F. K. Rengers, Luke A. McGuire, Jason W. Kean, Dennis M. Staley, Mariana Dobre, Peter R. Robichaud, Tyson Swetnam

Summary: Post-wildfire changes in sediment redistribution were measured using terrestrial and airborne lidar in the San Gabriel Mountains in southern California. The study found that hillslope erosion dominated the overall sediment budget in the first rainy season after the wildfire, and post-wildfire erosion rates in the area were comparable to millennial time scale bedrock erosion rates.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-EARTH SURFACE (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Multi-Model Comparison of Computed Debris Flow Runout for the 9 January 2018 Montecito, California Post-Wildfire Event

K. R. Barnhart, R. P. Jones, D. L. George, B. W. McArdell, F. K. Rengers, D. M. Staley, J. W. Kean

Summary: The study focused on hazard assessment for post-wildfire debris flows in steep terrain, emphasizing the importance of reducing uncertainty in pre-event estimates of flow volume. Three debris flow runout models were tested using observations from the 2018 Montecito event, showing that model performance was most sensitive to flow volume and less sensitive to flow properties. This highlights the significance of accurately estimating flow volume for effective hazard assessment.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-EARTH SURFACE (2021)

Article Engineering, Geological

A progressive flow-routing model for rapid assessment of debris-flow inundation

Alexander N. Gorr, Luke A. McGuire, Ann M. Youberg, Francis K. Rengers

Summary: The study presents a computationally efficient debris-flow inundation model, ProDF, calibrated using data from five watersheds near Montecito, California to demonstrate its effectiveness in simulating debris-flow inundation.

LANDSLIDES (2022)

Review Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

A review of common natural disasters as analogs for asteroid impact effects and cascading hazards

Timothy Titus, D. Robertson, J. B. Sankey, L. Mastin, F. Rengers

Summary: Modern civilization lacks collective experience in dealing with the potential wide-ranging effects of a medium-sized asteroid impact. While efforts have been made to model the initial effects of meteor impacts or airbursts, the long-term cascading hazards are often overlooked. This paper reviews the initial and cascading effects of more common natural disasters and discusses their relevance to the expected long-term effects of an asteroid impact. A framework linking multiple hazard models could greatly benefit emergency managers, resource planners, and research scientists involved in mitigation and recovery efforts.

NATURAL HAZARDS (2023)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

Simulating Debris Flow and Levee Formation in the 2D Shallow Flow Model D-Claw: Channelized and Unconfined Flow

Ryan P. P. Jones, Francis K. K. Rengers, Katherine R. R. Barnhart, David L. L. George, Dennis M. M. Staley, Jason W. W. Kean

Summary: Debris flow runout is a dangerous phenomenon that poses risks to human life and infrastructure. By modifying a flow model to include the effects of segregation on permeability, we found that it improved the accuracy of predicting debris flow depth and runout distance. Therefore, considering segregation is important in predicting and mitigating debris flow hazards.

EARTH AND SPACE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

The Rainfall Intensity-Duration Control of Debris Flows After Wildfire

Matthew A. A. Thomas, Donald N. N. Lindsay, David B. B. Cavagnaro, Jason W. W. Kean, Scott W. W. McCoy, Andrew P. P. Graber

Summary: Increased wildfire activity in the western United States has revealed gaps in understanding postfire debris-flow generation. By characterizing flows in an unstudied area, we found that short-duration, high-intensity rainfall is more likely to initiate runoff-generated debris flows compared to total storm rainfall. This finding suggests the need for a focus on localized thunderstorms or bands of intense rainfall during prolonged rainstorms for hazard assessment and warning.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2023)

Article Forestry

Predicting burn severity for integration with post-fire debris-flow hazard assessment: a case study from the Upper Colorado River Basin, USA

Adam G. Wells, Todd J. Hawbaker, J. Kevin Hiers, Jason Kean, Rachel A. Loehman, Paul F. Steblein

Summary: This study aimed to predict burn severity using pre-fire conditions and estimate the potential post-fire debris flow to unburned areas. Fuels, pre-fire weather, and topography were important predictors of burn severity. Predicted burn severity can be used to predict fire effects and identify potential hazards for prioritizing response and mitigation.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF WILDLAND FIRE (2023)

No Data Available