4.8 Review

A critical review of Real Options thinking for valuing investment flexibility in Smart Grids and low carbon energy systems

Journal

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS
Volume 56, Issue -, Pages 261-271

Publisher

PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.rser.2015.11.071

Keywords

Real Options; Flexibility; Renewable energy; Energy systems investment; Low carbon technologies; Smart Grid

Funding

  1. Autonomic Power Systems project within the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) [EP/I031650/1]
  2. EPSRC [EP/I031650/1] Funding Source: UKRI
  3. Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council [EP/I031650/1] Funding Source: researchfish

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This paper aims at serving as a critical analysis of Real Options (RO) methodologies that have so far been applied to the flexible evaluation of smart grid developments and as a practical guide to understanding the benefits but more importantly the limitations of RO methodologies. Hence, future research could focus on developing more practical RO tools for application to the energy industry, thus making the utilization of powerful real options thinking for decision making under uncertainty more widespread. This is particularly important for applications in low carbon power and energy systems with increasing renewable and sustainable energy resources, given the different types of uncertainty they are facing in the transition towards a truly Smart Grid. In order to do so, and based on an extensive relevant literature review, the analogies with financial options are first presented, with various assumptions and their validity being clearly discussed in order to understand if, when, and how specific methods can be applied. It is then argued how option theory is in most cases not directly applicable to investment in energy systems but requires the consideration of their physical characteristics. The paper finally gives recommendations for building practical RO approaches to energy system (and potentially all engineering) project investments under uncertainty, regardless of the scale, time frame, or type of uncertainty involved. (C) 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.8
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Energy & Fuels

Power system stability in the transition to a low carbon grid: A techno-economic perspective on challenges and opportunities

Lasantha Meegahapola, Pierluigi Mancarella, Damian Flynn, Rodrigo Moreno

Summary: The global increase in power system stability challenges due to transitioning to low-carbon grids with PEC-interfaced RESs and DERs requires integration of new technologies within a market framework to ensure an economically feasible optimal technology mix without burdening electricity consumers. The complexity of system services and the need for careful integration of new grid codes and market mechanisms in order to exploit the full benefits of emerging technologies in the transition towards ultra-low carbon futures are emphasized.

WILEY INTERDISCIPLINARY REVIEWS-ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENT (2021)

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

From Security to Resilience: Technical and Regulatory Options to Manage Extreme Events in Low-Carbon Grids

Julian Eggleston, Christiaan Zuur, Pierluigi Mancarella

Summary: Extreme events are increasingly affecting power systems worldwide, requiring new and effective ways to deal with these high-impact, low-probability events. The transition to low-carbon grids, with systems dominated by inverter-based resources, including various types of variable renewable energy sources and distributed energy resources, has further complicated the assessment of operational uncertainty and risk profiles.

IEEE POWER & ENERGY MAGAZINE (2021)

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

Co-Optimizing Virtual Power Plant Services Under Uncertainty: A Robust Scheduling and Receding Horizon Dispatch Approach

James Naughton, Han Wang, Michael Cantoni, Pierluigi Mancarella

Summary: This paper introduces a framework that co-optimizes the VPP provision of multiple market, system, and local network services with the aim of maximizing its revenue, broken down into three sequentially coordinated optimization problems. The framework enables effective deployment of VPP flexibility to maximize its multi-service value stack within an uncertain operating environment and technical limits.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS (2021)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Fast Frequency Response From Utility-Scale Hydrogen Electrolyzers

Mehdi Ghazavi Dozein, Ahvand Jalali, Pierluigi Mancarella

Summary: This paper introduces the modelling foundations to study the fast frequency response from utility-scale hydrogen electrolyzers, illustrating how grid-scale HEs could support a more secure and resilient operation of low-carbon systems through dynamic simulations and case studies.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON SUSTAINABLE ENERGY (2021)

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

Modelling and Characterisation of Flexibility From Distributed Energy Resources

Shariq Riaz, Pierluigi Mancarella

Summary: This paper proposes a comprehensive DER flexibility modelling and characterization framework that is based on the concept of nodal operating envelope (NOE). It identifies capacity, ramp, duration, and cost as key flexibility metrics and associates them with different but consistent NOEs describing capability, feasibility, ramp, duration, economic, technical, and commercial flexibility features.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS (2022)

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

Dynamics of Inverter-Based Resources in Weak Distribution Grids

Mehdi Ghazavi Dozein, Bikash Chandra Pal, Pierluigi Mancarella

Summary: This paper presents the modeling fundamentals for studying the dynamics of inverter-based resources (IBRs) in weak distribution grids and proposes disturbance performance characteristics and control requirements. Specifically, it investigates voltage violations caused by low system strength in response to small-signal disturbances and proposes design requirements for IBR d-q current control. In terms of large-signal disturbances, it discusses limitations of active power-voltage control and the enhancement of phase-locked loop stability through IBR reactive power control.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS (2022)

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

Iterative LP-Based Methods for the Multiperiod Optimal Electricity and Gas Flow Problem

Sleiman Mhanna, Isam Saedi, Pierluigi Mancarella

Summary: This paper introduces two novel iterative methods for efficiently solving the multiperiod optimal electricity and gas flow problem. Both methods have fast convergence speed and high solution quality, with significant improvement in computation time.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS (2022)

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

An Exact Sequential Linear Programming Algorithm for the Optimal Power Flow Problem

Sleiman Mhanna, Pierluigi Mancarella

Summary: Despite advancements in nonlinear programming and convex relaxations, linear programming is still widely used by system operators due to its reliability and computational efficiency. This paper proposes a sequential linear programming approach that combines the advantages of LP and NLP methods, providing feasible and high-quality solutions for the nonconvex AC OPF problem.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS (2022)

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

Simultaneous Provision of Dynamic Active and Reactive Power Response From Utility-Scale Battery Energy Storage Systems in Weak Grids

Mehdi Ghazavi Dozein, Oriol Gomis-Bellmunt, Pierluigi Mancarella

Summary: This paper conducts a comprehensive analysis of the challenges faced by BESS in providing FFR and dynamic active/reactive responses under low system strength conditions, proposing relevant solutions and verifying their feasibility through mathematical modeling and dynamic simulations.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS (2021)

Article Computer Science, Information Systems

Frequency Response From Solar PV: A Dynamic Equivalence Closed-Loop System Identification Approach

Mehdi Ghazavi Dozein, Gilles Chaspierre, Pierluigi Mancarella, Patrick Panciatici, Thierry Van Cutsem

Summary: This article proposes converter-based dynamic equivalent models for both distributed and large-scale PV units in integrated transmission-distribution networks, identifying unknown model parameters through closed-loop identification to improve overall frequency response model accuracy. Validation with real data demonstrates excellent performance, paving the way for adoption in frequency stability analysis in low-carbon grids dominated by frequency-responsive renewables.

IEEE SYSTEMS JOURNAL (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Quantifying the Impacts of Modelling Assumptions on Accuracy and Computational Efficiency for Integrated Water-Energy System Simulations Under Uncertain Climate

Eduardo Alejandro Martinez Cesena, Yutian Zhou, Jose Nicolas Melchor Gutierrez, Wentao Zhu, Mathaios Panteli, Joseph Mutale, Pierluigi Mancarella, James Tomlinson, Rasheed Baisie, Emmanuel Obuobie, Julien J. Harou

Summary: This paper proposes a simulation methodology for integrated water-energy systems using Mixed Integer Linear Programming (MILP). The methodology aims to adapt and quantify different modelling assumptions under various weather-related conditions. The study demonstrates the benefits of customisable simulations in terms of computational costs and modelling accuracy, and provides guidance for selecting adequate modelling assumptions. The methodology is applied to the Ghanaian integrated water-energy system.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON SUSTAINABLE ENERGY (2022)

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

Virtual Inertia Response and Frequency Control Ancillary Services From Hydrogen Electrolyzers

Mehdi Ghazavi Dozein, Antonella Maria De Corato, Pierluigi Mancarella

Summary: This article presents a modeling foundation for studying the capabilities of hydrogen electrolyzers (HEs) to provide frequency control ancillary services (FCAS) such as virtual inertia and frequency response. A general, unified HE dynamic model is proposed to account for the electrolyzer stack circuit, power-electronics interface (PEI), and converter-level control loops. The model considers current transfer function, physical nonlinearities, and operational constraints. Additionally, a virtual synchronous machine (VSM) control approach is introduced to study the HE's virtual inertia response. The modeling is applied to alkaline and proton exchange membrane (PEM) technologies, and the FCAS performance is assessed through dynamic simulation.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS (2023)

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

Co-Optimizing Substation Hardening and Transmission Expansion Against Earthquakes: A Decision-Dependent Probability Approach

Diego Alvarado, Rodrigo Moreno, Alexandre Street, Mathaios Panteli, Pierluigi Mancarella, Goran Strbac

Summary: Given the increasing frequency and impact of natural hazards on power systems, planning resilient network investments is of growing importance. This study proposes an optimization approach that considers investment propositions to harden existing infrastructure and determines optimal portfolios of resilient network investments. The model takes into account decision-dependent probabilities and considers distributed energy resources as potential alternatives to costly network investments. Additionally, the lack of fully accurate fragility curves and the inherent uncertainty associated with fragility modeling are addressed through a global-convergent exact algorithm. The case studies conducted in Chile demonstrate the benefits of the proposed network planning approach.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Grid-Forming Services From Hydrogen Electrolyzers

Saman Dadjo Tavakoli, Mehdi Ghazavi Dozein, Vinicius A. Lacerda, Marc Cheah Mane, Eduardo Prieto-Araujo, Pierluigi Mancarella, Oriol Gomis-Bellmunt

Summary: This paper suggests using hydrogen electrolyzers to provide grid-forming services to the grid and studies the impacts of these services on the electrolyzer. The effectiveness and practical feasibility of the proposed concept are demonstrated through simulations and experiments.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON SUSTAINABLE ENERGY (2023)

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

Assessment of the Capacity Credit of Renewables and Storage in Multi-Area Power Systems

Guanchi Liu, Maria Vrakopoulou, Pierluigi Mancarella

Summary: Capacity credit refers to the ability of renewable energy sources and/or other resources to replace conventional generators without reducing system reliability. Locational aspects are crucial in assessing supply adequacy from transmission, storage, and renewable energy sources in multi-area power systems. The proposed methodology quantifies the capacity credit of renewable energy sources and storage in a multi-area power system, aiming to inform integrated system planning for large-scale interconnected low-carbon power systems.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS (2021)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

3E analysis of a virtual hydrogen valley supported by railway-based H2 delivery for multi-transportation service

M. Genovese, F. Piraino, P. Fragiacomo

Summary: This research proposes the concept of a hydrogen valley in southern Italy, where hydrogen is produced centrally and delivered via fuel cell hybrid trains to refueling stations, providing transportation services. The analysis from both technical and economic perspectives shows that the cost of hydrogen and energy efficiency reached competitive levels, and hydrogen rail transport offers significant benefits in terms of emissions reduction and economic gains compared to conventional diesel trains and fully electric trains.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

A critical review of windcatcher ventilation: Micro-environment, techno-economics, and commercialisation

Miaomiao Liu, Payam Nejat, Pinlu Cao, Carlos Jimenez-Bescos, John Kaiser Calautit

Summary: This article provides a critical review of the performance of windcatchers, pointing out the current research gaps and issues, and proposing directions for further investigation and market prospects.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

A comprehensive review on wind energy in Africa: Challenges, benefits and recommendations

Solomon Boadu, Ebenezer Otoo

Summary: Despite Africa's vast energy resources, including wind energy, the continent faces challenges in developing its wind energy industry. Northern African countries and South Africa currently dominate the wind energy sector in Africa. To uplift Africa's socio-economic status, strong political will, supportive policies, and institutional frameworks are needed to drive the development of wind energy and overcome existing challenges.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Optimized agrivoltaic tracking for nearly-full commodity crop and energy production

E. K. Grubbs, S. M. Gruss, V. Z. Schull, M. J. Gosney, M. V. Mickelbart, S. Brouder, M. W. Gitau, P. Bermel, M. R. Tuinstra, R. Agrawal

Summary: As the global population grows, the demand for food, energy, and water will increase significantly. However, limited land availability and competition for solar resources pose challenges to resource generation technologies. In the United States, both agriculture and solar energy production have adopted densification schemes to improve yields and energy output per unit of land. This research proposes an Agrivoltaic food and energy coproduction architecture that optimizes power generation while maintaining crop productivity by implementing ideal anti-tracking during critical growth periods. This technology offers a viable pathway for widespread solar implementation throughout the contiguous United States.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Power quality monitoring in electric grid integrating offshore wind energy: A review

Han Shao, Rui Henriques, Hugo Morais, Elisabetta Tedeschi

Summary: The integration of offshore wind energy into the electric grid provides opportunities in terms of environmental sustainability and cost efficiency, but poses challenges to power quality. This survey offers a deeper understanding of disturbance detection and classification tools, exploring root causes, disturbance locations, and algorithmic solutions. It highlights synchronized waveform measurement and discusses evaluation metrics for detection and classification algorithms. Additionally, a novel system-wide monitoring framework is proposed.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Resilience of the higher education sector to future climates: A systematic review of predicted building energy performance and modelling approaches

Eleni Davidson, Yair Schwartz, Joe Williams, Dejan Mumovic

Summary: A continued upward trend in global greenhouse gas emissions poses risks to global infrastructure and built assets. Maintaining high indoor environmental quality standards is a challenge for higher education institutions under future climates. Passive cooling mechanisms may be insufficient to tolerate predicted temperature increases. Different building typologies have varying energy demand projections.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Long-term microgrid expansion planning with resilience and environmental benefits using deep reinforcement learning

Kexin Pang, Jian Zhou, Stamatis Tsianikas, David W. Coit, Yizhong Ma

Summary: This study proposes a new framework for long-term microgrid expansion planning, using deep reinforcement learning method to consider various uncertainties and constraints. The framework aims to enhance the effectiveness of microgrid expansion planning from the perspectives of economy, resilience, and greenhouse gas emission reduction.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

How does energy poverty eradication affect global carbon neutrality?

Jun Zhao, Kangyin Dong, Xiucheng Dong

Summary: The continuous growth of global electricity penetration has provided modern energy for alleviating energy poverty, but its impact on carbon neutrality has been overlooked. The research reveals that clean electricity from traditional fossil energy and renewable energy has a positive influence on the greenhouse effect. Eradicating energy poverty can effectively alleviate the greenhouse effect, especially in non-Belt and Road Initiative (B&RI) nations.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Biomass to biofuels using hydrothermal liquefaction: A comprehensive review

Hossein Shahbeik, Hamed Kazemi Shariat Panahi, Mona Dehhaghi, Gilles J. Guillemin, Alireza Fallahi, Homa Hosseinzadeh-Bandbafha, Hamid Amiri, Mohammad Rehan, Deepak Raikwar, Hannes Latine, Bruno Pandalone, Benyamin Khoshnevisan, Christian Sonne, Luigi Vaccaro, Abdul-Sattar Nizami, Vijai Kumar Gupta, Su Shiung Lam, Junting Pan, Rafael Luque, Bert Sels, Wanxi Peng, Meisam Tabatabaei, Mortaza Aghbashlo

Summary: This review explores the production of biocrude oil from biomass feedstocks through the process of hydrothermal liquefaction (HTL). It discusses the impact of process parameters on the quality, quantity, cost, and environmental impacts of biofuels. The review also highlights the challenges and prospects for the future development of biocrude oil.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Marine energy digitalization digital twin's approaches

Meysam Majidi Nezhad, Mehdi Neshat, Georgios Sylaios, Davide Astiaso Garcia

Summary: Digital twins promise innovation for the marine renewable energy sector by using modern technological advances and the existing maritime knowledge frameworks. This research presents critical aspects of digital twin implementation challenges in marine energy digitalization approaches that use and combine data systems.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Multi-area economic dispatch problem: Methods, uncertainties, and future directions

Yeganeh Sharifian, Hamdi Abdi

Summary: This paper discusses the background and objectives of the multi-area economic dispatch problem, as well as various techniques and methods applied in this field. It also covers comprehensive formulations of the problem and important issues in the field of probabilistic MAED, along with some related concepts and suggestions.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

A review on the production and application of tall oil with a focus on sustainable fuels

J. G. B. Churchill, V. B. Borugadda, A. K. Dalai

Summary: The increasing global energy demand and the need to reduce fossil fuel reliance have created a demand for renewable and sustainable fuel sources. This review explores the potential of tall oil, a by-product of the pulping industry, as a feedstock for biofuels. The review provides an overview of tall oil production, purification, and treatment, and investigates recent trends and barriers towards tall oil-derived biofuels.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

District cooling services: A bibliometric review and topic classification of existing research

David C. Broadstock, Xiangnan Wang

Summary: This study provides a general review of research on district cooling, identifying key topics and themes and highlighting potential research priorities for future studies.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Barriers to demand response in the commercial and industrial sectors - An empirical investigation

L. Scharnhorst, D. Sloot, N. Lehmann, A. Ardone, W. Fichtner

Summary: This study investigates and analyzes the barriers to demand response in industrial and commercial sectors, highlighting their significance. Concerns about diminished product quality, disruptions to production processes, human resource management, and revenue uncertainty are identified as the most frequently cited barriers. Overcoming these barriers requires bridging knowledge gaps, allocating sufficient resources, and adapting external incentives and policies.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Air pollution control policies and impacts: A review

Tong Feng, Yuechi Sun, Yating Shi, Jie Ma, Chunmei Feng, Zhenni Chen

Summary: Air pollution is a significant global challenge, and policymakers have implemented policies to reduce it. Evaluating the effectiveness of these policies is critical, and our study reveals trends and gaps in air pollution policy research. We found that research has shifted from focusing solely on air pollutants to including methodologies, policies, and health implications. China has emerged as a major contributor in this field of research.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)