3.8 Article

Paramedic educational program attrition accounts for significant loss of potential EMS workforce

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1002/emp2.12917

Keywords

attrition; certification; emergency medical services; paramedic education; workforce

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study focuses on the educational pathway of EMS clinicians and identifies factors that contribute to their loss. The findings show that attrition during the educational program and failure to pass the certifying exam are the main reasons for EMS clinician loss, which are associated with longer program duration, smaller class sizes, and regional locations.
ObjectiveRecent concerns for the strength and stability of the emergency medical services (EMS) workforce have fueled interest in enhancing the entry of EMS clinicians into the workforce. However, the educational challenges associated with workforce entry remain unclear. Our objective was to evaluate the educational pathway of entry into the EMS workforce and to identify factors that lead to the loss of potential EMS clinicians. MethodsThis is a cross-sectional evaluation of all US paramedic educational programs, with enrolled students, in the 2019 Committee on Accreditation of Educational Programs for the EMS Professions annual report survey. This data set includes detailed program characteristics and metrics including program attrition rate (leaving before completion), and certifying exam pass rates. Descriptive statistics were calculated, and multivariable logistic regression analysis was conducted to evaluate the association between high program attrition rates (>30%) and program specific characteristics. ResultsIn 2019, 640 accredited programs met inclusion with 17,457 students enrolled in paramedic educational programs. Of these, 13,884 students successfully graduated (lost to attrition, 3,573/17,457 [21%]) and 12,002 passed the certifying exam on the third attempt (lost to unable to certify, 1,882/17,457 [11%]). High program attrition rates were associated with longer programs (>12 months), small class sizes (<12 students), and regional locations. ConclusionsNearly 1 in 3 paramedic students were lost from the potentially available workforce either owing to attrition during the educational program or failure to certify after course completion. Attrition represented the largest loss, providing an avenue for future targeted research and interventions to improve EMS workforce stability.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

3.8
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Emergency Medicine

Evidence-Based Guidelines for Prehospital Pain Management: Recommendations

George Lindbeck, Manish Shah, Sabina Braithwaite, Jonathan R. Powell, Ashish R. Panchal, Lorin R. Browne, Eddy S. Lang, Brooke Burton, Jeffrey Coughenour, Remle P. Crowe, Hannah Degn, Mary Hedges, James Gasper, Kyle Guild, Connie Mattera, Sandra Nasca, Peter Taillac, Mark Warth

Summary: This project aimed to develop evidence-based guidelines for the administration of analgesics in EMS settings. The panel made several recommendations, highlighting the importance of non-opioid analgesics in the management of acute pain.

PREHOSPITAL EMERGENCY CARE (2023)

Article Emergency Medicine

Evidence-Based Guidelines for Prehospital Pain Management: Literature and Methods

Jonathan R. Powell, Lorin R. Browne, Kyle Guild, Manish Shah, Remle P. Crowe, George Lindbeck, Sabina Braithwaite, Eddy S. Lang, Ashish R. Panchal

Summary: This study describes a protocol that used established evidence-based guideline (EBG) development techniques, the GRADE framework, and a previous AHRQ systematic review to develop treatment recommendations for prehospital pain management. The process utilized virtual and electronic communication to mitigate confounders and may inform future guideline development and enhance transparency in the prehospital recommendations development processes.

PREHOSPITAL EMERGENCY CARE (2023)

Article Emergency Medicine

A Proposed Theoretical Framework for Clinical Judgment in EMS

Mihaiela R. Gugiu, Kim D. McKenna, Thomas E. Platt, Ashish R. Panchal

Summary: This article discusses the challenges faced by EMS clinicians in the prehospital setting and proposes a theoretical framework for clinical judgment to address these challenges.

PREHOSPITAL EMERGENCY CARE (2023)

Article Emergency Medicine

State Requirements for Medical Directors in the United States

Travis Sharkey-Toppen, Jordan D. Kurth, Osama Saadoon, Betty Yang, Emily Gibbons, Jonathan R. Powell, Ashish R. Panchal

Summary: This study aims to describe the requirements to be an EMS medical director in different states of the US. The results show that the requirements for EMS medical direction are not standardized across different states, with many states only requiring a medical license without emergency medicine board certification.

PREHOSPITAL EMERGENCY CARE (2023)

Article Emergency Medicine

Differences in Characteristics between EMS Clinicians with Patient Care and Non-Patient Care Roles

Alix Delamare Fauvel, Jonathan R. Powell, Jordan D. Kurth, Henry E. Wang, Ashish R. Panchal

Summary: Emergency medical services (EMS) are crucial in providing prehospital emergency care. This study found that 17% of EMS clinicians are in non-patient care roles, and the likelihood of working in these roles is associated with demographic and workforce experience characteristics.

PREHOSPITAL EMERGENCY CARE (2023)

Article Emergency Medicine

Recommendations for Improving the Quality of Prehospital Evidence-Based Guidelines

Christian Martin-Gill, Ashish R. Panchal, Rebecca E. Cash, Christopher T. Richards, Kathleen M. Brown, P. Daniel Patterson

Summary: Evidence-based guidelines are increasingly being published to inform the EMS community, but their quality varies. This can negatively impact dissemination, education, and implementation efforts. This article describes the current state of published guidelines, provides a description of key elements and methods to assess their quality, and offers recommendations for improving evidence evaluation, guideline development, and reporting.

PREHOSPITAL EMERGENCY CARE (2023)

Article Emergency Medicine

Association between EMS Workforce Density and Population Health Outcomes in the US

Rebecca E. Cash, Scott A. Goldberg, Jonathan R. Powell, Gregory A. Peters, Ashish R. Panchal, Carlos A. A. Camargo Jr

Summary: This study examined the geographic distribution and density of EMS personnel in the U.S. It found that EMS personnel density is higher in rural areas compared to urban areas. There were significant associations between EMS density and life expectancy and all-cause mortality, but these associations became non-significant after adjusting for population characteristics and other health resources.

PREHOSPITAL EMERGENCY CARE (2023)

Review Clinical Neurology

Prehospital Stroke Care Part 2: On-Scene Evaluation and Management by Emergency Medical Services Practitioners

Christopher T. T. Richards, J. Adam Oostema, Sherita N. N. Chapman, Lauren E. E. Mamer, Ethan S. S. Brandler, Anne W. W. Alexandrov, Alexandra L. L. Czap, Juan Carlos Martinez-Gutierrez, Christian Martin-Gill, Ashish R. R. Panchal, Jason T. T. McMullan, Kori S. S. Zachrison

Summary: This topical review discusses the current state of prehospital acute stroke screening and transport, as well as new and emerging advances in prehospital diagnosis and treatment of acute stroke. Topics include prehospital stroke screening, stroke severity screening, emerging technologies to aid in the identification and diagnosis of acute stroke in the prehospital setting, prenotification of receiving emergency departments, decision support for destination determination, and the capabilities and opportunities for prehospital stroke treatment in mobile stroke units. Further evidence-based guideline development and implementation of new technologies are critical for ongoing improvements in prehospital stroke care.

STROKE (2023)

Article Cell Biology

Enhanced evasion of neutralizing antibody response by Omicron XBB.1.5, CH.1.1, and CA.3.1 variants

Panke Qu, Julia N. Faraone, John P. Evans, Yi-Min Zheng, Claire Carlin, Mirela Anghelina, Patrick Stevens, Soledad Fernandez, Daniel Jones, Ashish R. Panchal, Linda J. Saif, Eugene M. Oltz, Baoshan Zhang, Tongqing Zhou, Kai Xu, Richard J. Gumina, Shan-Lu Liu

Summary: This study demonstrates the nearly complete escape of XBB.1.5, CH.1.1, and CA.3.1 variants from neutralizing antibodies stimulated by mRNA vaccine or BA.4/5 wave infection, but neutralization can be rescued by a bivalent booster containing BA.5. CH.1.1 and CA.3.1 also show strong immune escape from monoclonal antibody S309. Furthermore, the spike proteins of XBB.1.5, CH.1.1, and CA.3.1 exhibit enhanced fusogenicity and processing compared to BA.2.

CELL REPORTS (2023)

Article Emergency Medicine

Consensus Standard for Evidence Integration into EMS Education and High-Stakes Testing

Christopher B. Gage, Mark Terry, Kim D. McKenna, Jonathan R. Powell, Megan Hollern, Matt Ozanich, Christopher T. Richards, Christian Martin-Gill, Ashish R. Panchal

Summary: To reflect evidence-based out-of-hospital care, it is important to incorporate emerging knowledge into Emergency Medical Service (EMS) competency assessments. A framework, called the Table of Evidence, has been developed using a Delphi method to define the sources and quality of EMS evidence and provide integration recommendations.

PREHOSPITAL AND DISASTER MEDICINE (2023)

Article Cell Biology

Neutralization escape of Omicron XBB, BR.2, and BA.2.3.20 subvariants

Julia N. Faraone, Panke Qu, John P. Evans, Yi-Min Zheng, Claire Carlin, Mirela Anghelina, Patrick Stevens, Soledad Fernandez, Daniel Jones, Gerard Lozanski, Ashish Panchal, Linda J. Saif, Eugene M. Oltz, Richard J. Gumina, Shan-Lu Liu

Summary: New Omicron subvariants are continuously emerging worldwide. The XBB subvariant, a recombinant virus between BA.2.10.1.1 and BA.2.75.3.1.1.1, as well as the BA.2.3.20 and BR.2 subvariants with distinct mutations from BA.2 and BA.2.75, are increasing in proportion. Antibodies induced by 3-dose mRNA booster vaccination and previous BA.1-and BA.4/5-wave infection effectively neutralize BA.2, BR.2, and BA.2.3.20, but have reduced efficiency against XBB. The BA.2.3.20 subvariant exhibits enhanced infectivity in lung-derived CaLu-3 cells and 293T-ACE2 cells. Continued monitoring of immune escape and tissue tropism of emerging Omicron subvariants is crucial.

CELL REPORTS MEDICINE (2023)

Article Emergency Medicine

Medical Directors, Facilities, and Finances: Resource Deficiencies in Accredited Paramedic Programs

Michael Kaduce, Jonathan R. Powell, Lisa Collard, Christopher B. Gage, Michael G. Miller, Ashish R. Panchal

Summary: In our analysis of the 2018 annual report of paramedic programs in the US, we found common deficiencies in resources for graduating paramedic students, such as lack of medical director engagement, facility issues, and inadequate financial resources.

PREHOSPITAL EMERGENCY CARE (2023)

Article Critical Care Medicine

Secular trends in airway management of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest in the National Emergency Medical Services Information System (NEMSIS) dataset

Christopher B. Gage, Jonathan R. Powell, Michelle Nassal, Henry Wang, Ashish R. Panchal

Summary: This study in the US found that over the past decade, the use of advanced airways in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest has increased, with endotracheal intubation remaining the primary airway choice for adults, but supraglottic airway use has been steadily increasing. In urban settings, there was a significant increase in supraglottic airway usage, while rural and suburban areas remained stable in their usage.

RESUSCITATION (2023)

No Data Available