4.5 Article

Overcoming the principal-agent problem: The need for alignment of tools and methods in collaborative project delivery

Journal

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROJECT MANAGEMENT
Volume 40, Issue 7, Pages 750-762

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.ijproman.2022.08.003

Keywords

Agency theory; Collaborative project delivery model; Integrated project delivery; Principal -agent; Stewardship theory; Tools

Categories

Funding

  1. Research Council of Norway [273700]
  2. Sorlandets kompetansefond

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study aims to explore the impact of organizational tools and methods on the relationship between principal and agent, and the importance of overcoming the principal-agent problem. The empirical analysis supports the significance of the alignment of organizational tools and methods for the success of CPDM and deepens the theoretical understanding of CPDM delivery.
Despite the focus on collaborative project delivery models (CPDMs) in the construction industry, it remains unclear how it promises bases for delivering better value for money than many traditional models. In view of the importance of knowledge about CPDM delivery, this study aims to explore governance mechanisms that un-derline the relationship between principal and agent and how this relationship is impacted by the alignment of organisational tools and methods. We argue that there is an interrelationship between agency theory and stewardship theory that provides an important theoretical foundation for CPDMs; additionally, alignment of organisational tools and methods can contribute to overcoming the principal-agent problem in projects if aligned with the functions in CDPMs. An empirical analysis of an exploratory case study supports these assumptions and highlights how CPDM's success can occur through removing and reducing the fundamental principal-agent problem and illustrates the performance and dangers of CPDM tools. Our findings deepen the theoretical un-derstanding of CPDM delivery and provide new insights into the strategic fit in CPDMs alignment in projects.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Sustainable Infrastructure Projects: Systemic versus Traditional Delivery Models

Magnus Hellstrom, Kim Wikstrom, Kent Eriksson

Summary: This study explores the comprehensive analysis required for sustainable development, highlighting the importance of delivery models in infrastructure investments. By comparing traditional delivery models with systemic ones, the research found that sustainability is currently under-researched in the systemic infrastructure delivery field, despite its substantial potential in delivering benefits to PPP infrastructures.

SUSTAINABILITY (2021)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Circular business models for lithium-ion batteries-Stakeholders, barriers, and drivers

Benedikte Wralsen, Vanessa Prieto-Sandoval, Andres Mejia-Villa, Reyn O'Born, Magnus Hellstrom, Bernhard Faessler

Summary: Research on circular business models focusing on battery recycling and second use is growing. The preferred circular business model includes multiple strategies, with national and international regulations and policies being the key driver, financial viability as the major barrier, and governments and vehicle manufacturers as critical stakeholders.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2021)

Article Business

Creating value through product-service-software systems in institutionalized ecosystems-The case of autonomous ships

Anastasia Tsvetkova, Magnus Hellstrom, Henrik Ringbom

Summary: This study examines the challenges and barriers encountered when introducing product-service-software systems (PSSS) to the market, using institutional theory and autonomous ships as a case study. The research identifies institutional barriers related to regulatory, normative, and cultural-cognitive pillars that affect the formation of ecosystem around PSSS. The main contribution is the analysis of early ecosystem dynamics and the mutual adaptation between PSSS value proposition and the structure of the incumbent ecosystem.

INDUSTRIAL MARKETING MANAGEMENT (2021)

Article Transportation

Creating value through autonomous shipping: an ecosystem perspective

Anastasia Tsvetkova, Magnus Hellstrom

Summary: The article analyzes the different aspects of value creation by Maritime Autonomous Surface Ships (MASS), including the impact of crew reduction and increased ship intelligence on costs, earnings, safety, and system value, as well as the actors for whom this value is created. The article also highlights the changing roles of different actors in the maritime logistics ecosystem and the need to develop complementary infrastructure and activities.

MARITIME ECONOMICS & LOGISTICS (2022)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Sustainable Cruise Tourism: Systematic Literature Review and Future Research Areas

Ignat Kulkov, Magnus Hellstrom, Anastasia Tsvetkova, Johan Malmberg

Summary: Sustainability is a new trend in the cruise shipping industry that requires further research on the changes and processes impacting the industry. However, there is currently a lack of comprehensive and systematic reviews of academic literature on this topic. Our research sample includes 56 articles, covering themes such as corporate social responsibility, territory management, and sustainable behavior training. These themes explore various use cases for sustainable cruise tourism and provide a conceptual framework for understanding industry trends. We identify several areas for further research.

SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Review Education & Educational Research

A systematic review on the use of serious games in project management education

Magnus Mikael Hellstrom, Dominique Jaccard, Knut Erik Bonnier

Summary: Project management education can effectively use serious games for active learning. This study aims to understand the objectives of using serious games in project management education. A systematic review of 43 articles revealed that serious games are used for pedagogical reasons to develop specific skills and for practical reasons to provide a risk-free trial environment. This research suggests a taxonomy of reasons for using project management games in higher education and highlights the need for further research on their implementation in pedagogical scenarios.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SERIOUS GAMES (2023)

Article Transportation

Customer perceptions of COVID-19 countermeasures on passenger ships during the pandemic

Johnny Langstedt, Jonas Spohr, Magnus Hellstrom, Anastasia Tsvetkova, Erik Niemela, Joakim Sjoblom, John E. Eriksson, Kim Wikstrom

Summary: This study, using a mixed-methods research design, reveals the factors considered by cruiseferry operators in their responses to the pandemic and customers' attitudes towards countermeasures, providing insights into reducing customers' perceived health risks.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH INTERDISCIPLINARY PERSPECTIVES (2022)

Article Management

Struggling with conservatism: entrepreneurships' challenges in business model design

Ignat Kulkov, Magnus Hellstrom, Kim Wikstrom

Summary: The paper aims to investigate conservative business ecosystems and identify opportunities for new companies to create value. A design-oriented case study was conducted, focusing on a start-up commercializing university research. Results suggest that cooperation between product suppliers and opinion leaders is crucial for supporting biomedical business ecosystems, and the success of new products depends on the interest of professional communities.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF VALUE CHAIN MANAGEMENT (2021)

Article Business

Navigating uncharted waters: Designing business models for virtual and augmented reality companies in the medical industry

Ignat Kulkov, Bjorn Berggren, Magnus Hellstrom, Kim Wikstrom

Summary: New technologies such as virtual and augmented reality are fundamentally changing the medical industry by providing new ways of communication, treatment, education, and specialized training. However, there is limited research on the business models of new ventures targeting the medical industry. Through multiple case studies, this research analyzes how virtual and augmented reality companies create value for their customers in the medical industry, identifying key design elements and themes of their business models.

JOURNAL OF ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY MANAGEMENT (2021)

Article Business

Innovations in veterinary markets: opinion leaders' social capital

Ignat Kulkov, Wilhelm Barner-Rasmussen, Maria Ivanova-Gongne, Anastasia Tsvetkova, Magnus Hellstrom, Kim Wikstrom

Summary: This study explores how the personal social capital of opinion leaders contributes to the market adoption of start-up innovations through a case study approach. The findings suggest that social capital facilitates collaboration between start-ups and opinion leaders based on specific parameters.

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS & INDUSTRIAL MARKETING (2021)

Article Business

Identifying the role of business accelerators in the developing business ecosystem: the life science sector

Ignat Kulkov, Magnus Hellstrom, Kim Wikstrom

Summary: This study aims to investigate the role and characteristics of life science accelerators in the business ecosystem. The findings suggest that cooperation, entrepreneurial skill development among participants, and demand-based project approach are key factors that influence the existing business ecosystems.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF INNOVATION MANAGEMENT (2021)

Article Management

SERVICE-ORIENTED BUSINESS MODELS IN MANUFACTURING IN THE DIGITAL ERA: TOWARD A NEW TAXONOMY

Tor Helge Aas, Karl Joachim Breunig, Magnus Mikael Hellstrom, Katja Maria Hydle

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF INNOVATION MANAGEMENT (2020)

Article Business

The importance of financial resources and ownership of intellectual property rights for university spin-offs: the cases of Finland and Sweden

Ignat Kulkov, Bjorn Berggren, Kent Eriksson, Magnus Hellstrom, Kim Wikstrom

JOURNAL OF SMALL BUSINESS AND ENTERPRISE DEVELOPMENT (2020)

Article Management

Governance of Projects: Generating value by linking projects with their permanent organisation

Eva Riis, Magnus Mikael Hellstrom, Kim Wikstrom

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROJECT MANAGEMENT (2019)

No Data Available