4.7 Article

Vulnerability matrix of the food system: Operationalizing vulnerability and addressing food security

Journal

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION
Volume 135, Issue -, Pages 1242-1255

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.07.018

Keywords

Vulnerability matrix; Vulnerability drivers; Vulnerable systems; Food security; Operationalization; Finland

Funding

  1. Kone Foundation [46-8967]
  2. EU [KBBE.2013.2.5-01, 613532]
  3. Foundation for Economic Education (Finland) [5-3144]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Food security is the major desired outcome of any food system, but its realization may be prevented by vulnerabilities in a food system. By shifting the focus of their vulnerability analysis from the discrete components of the food system to the food system as a whole, the authors of this article were able to develop a qualitative food system vulnerability matrix. The objective of the research was to make the concept of food system vulnerability operational by identifying vulnerability drivers, vulnerable systems and vulnerable subclasses in light of food security. The vulnerability matrix was set up with five classes of vulnerable systems ('Vulnerability of what?') on the horizontal axis and vulnerability drivers ('Vulnerability to what?') on the vertical axis. The authors analyzed the relationship between vulnerability drivers and vulnerable systems by using qualitative, abductive content analysis within the context of the Finnish food system. The data consists of public documents collected from the web pages of key organizations within the Finnish food system including ministries and their administration, interest groups and non-governmental organizations. It therefore covers various types of content related to food policy and management. Excerpts from the documentation data were coded according to which vulnerable system subclasses they addressed. The key findings of the study highlight the importance of using a systems approach that takes into account social, ecological and technical considerations. Such a framework covers multiple stressors, including exogenous natural drivers and endogenous social drivers, as well as the coalescence of vulnerability and food security discourses. The benefits of the proposed vulnerability framework for public food policy and food supply chain management include the explicit recognition of vulnerability drivers and vulnerable systems, a higher degree of specificity when speaking about food security, and opportunities for the identification of vulnerability-based innovations. (C) 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Is there a convincing case for climate veganism?

Teea Kortetmaki, Markku Oksanen

Summary: Climate change has prompted a reevaluation of the ethics behind dietary choices, with advocates of veganism finding a new reason to promote their cause due to the high greenhouse gas emissions of animal-based foods. The 'climatic argument(s) for veganism' may persuade individuals concerned about climate change to adopt a plant-based diet, even if they are not initially motivated by animal welfare. This new approach adds to the traditional arguments for veganism based on moral considerations for nonhuman animals, and raises questions about the broader implications of dietary choices on agriculture and food ethics.

AGRICULTURE AND HUMAN VALUES (2021)

Article Agricultural Economics & Policy

Developing a matrix framework for protein transition towards more sustainable diets

Ari Paloviita

Summary: This study proposes a matrix framework to understand the interdependencies of protein transition towards diets based on plants and alternative sources of proteins. It highlights the interactions between public and private governance activities at different scales, domains, and governed levels, showing how micro-level activities are linked with broader governance activities.

BRITISH FOOD JOURNAL (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Social vulnerability to climate policies: Building a matrix to assess policy impacts on well-being

Teea Kortetmaki, Marja Jarvela

Summary: This article introduces a matrix tool for assessing social vulnerability to climate policies, emphasizing the importance of addressing social vulnerability in climate policy design and research. The tool is flexible and adaptable to different policy contexts and governance levels, as demonstrated in the Nordic welfare states that serve as the test bed for the tool.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2021)

Article Geography

Finnish dairy farmers' perceptions of justice in the transition to carbon-neutral farming

Antti Puupponen, Annika Lonkila, Anni Savikurki, Kaisa Karttunen, Suvi Huttunen, Anna Ott

Summary: This study examines the experiences and perceptions of dairy farmers in Finland in transitioning to carbon-neutral agriculture. The results indicate that three key justice issues - profitability of farming, blaming of farmers, and use of agricultural peatlands - need consideration from the farmers' perspective.

JOURNAL OF RURAL STUDIES (2022)

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

Disparities in Nutritional Adequacy of Diets between Different Socioeconomic Groups of Finnish Adults

Liisa M. Valsta, Heli Tapanainen, Teea Kortetmaki, Laura Sares-Jaske, Laura Paalanen, Niina E. Kaartinen, Peppi Haario, Minna Kaljonen

Summary: This study evaluated the differences in nutritional adequacy of diets among Finnish adults in different population groups based on education, income, and urbanization levels. The results showed that about half of the studied nutrients had adequate intake levels, but deficiencies were observed in folate and vitamins A, D, B1, B2, and C for almost all groups. Higher education and income, living in urban areas, and being female were associated with closer adherence to recommended food consumption and nutrient intake. However, the challenges posed by the Finnish diet were common to all groups, and only certain dietary features were associated with socioeconomic differences in terms of nutritional adequacy.

NUTRIENTS (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Just transition principles and criteria for food systems and beyond

Theresa Tribaldos, Teea Kortetmaki

Summary: This article proposes a framework for just transitions in food systems, which addresses the potential side effects and justice issues of transitions. The article also reflects on the future development of this framework.

ENVIRONMENTAL INNOVATION AND SOCIETAL TRANSITIONS (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

Responsibilities for just transition to low-carbon societies: a role-based framework

Teea Kortetmaki, Suvi Huttunen

Summary: Low-carbon transitions in industrialized societies will have significant impacts on social, economic, and environmental aspects, raising concerns about justice. It is crucial to understand the responsibilities and roles of different actors in advancing low-carbon transitions and ensuring their fairness.

ENVIRONMENTAL POLITICS (2023)

Article Business

Particularizing Nonhuman Nature in Stakeholder Theory: The Recognition Approach

Teea Kortetmaki, Anna Heikkinen, Ari Jokinen

Summary: Stakeholder theory, a common approach to organizational sustainability, often treats nonhuman nature as a unified and ambiguous entity. This article introduces the concept of "recognition" to provide a normative foundation for stakeholder theorizing on nonhuman nature, enabling a more comprehensive understanding of the stakeholder status and particularization of nonhuman entities. By reducing anthropocentric bias, this approach enhances stakeholder theorizing's capacity to address ecological crisis challenges.

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS ETHICS (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Ethics in biodiversity conservation: The meaning and importance of pluralism

Gonzalo Cortes-Capano, Anna Hausmann, Enrico Di Minin, Teea Kortetmaki

Summary: Addressing the global biodiversity crisis requires recognizing and navigating the ethical landscape, by acknowledging multiple legitimate values and ethical perspectives. However, the ethical pluralism in biodiversity conservation has not been fully considered, which overlooks the importance of diverse ethical positions.

BIOLOGICAL CONSERVATION (2022)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Action-oriented knowledge for sustainable management of organic soils in Finnish agriculture

Ellen Huan-Niemi, Suvi Huttunen, Ari Paloviita, Antti Puupponen, Heikki Lehtonen, Jyrki Niemi

Summary: Unsustainable changes in land use with the usage of peatlands for food production in Finland contribute to climate change. Multistakeholder and participatory approaches to policy development, implementation, and evaluation are necessary for managing peatlands sustainably and reducing greenhouse gas emissions. The study integrates qualitative and quantitative methods to produce action-oriented knowledge for supporting sustainable peatland management and greenhouse gas reduction. It emphasizes the need for shared understanding among relevant actors and stakeholders, as well as the identification of incentives from both the public and private sectors to remove peatlands from food production.

AGRICULTURAL AND FOOD SCIENCE (2023)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Right to Food and Geoengineering

Teea Kortetmaki, Markku Oksanen

Summary: Climate change poses serious risks to food security, and current actions to mitigate and adapt have been insufficient to reduce the risk of climate-induced violations of the right to food. This article explores the potential justification for certain forms of geoengineering in safeguarding the right to food. The study reveals that different forms of geoengineering have varied impacts on the components of food security, with some failing to respect the right to food while others may become necessary for its protection.

JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURAL & ENVIRONMENTAL ETHICS (2023)

Editorial Material Environmental Sciences

Introduction to the special issue on just food system transition: Tackling inequalities for sustainability

Minna Kaljonen, Teea Kortetmaki, Theresa Tribaldos

Summary: This special issue examines specific dynamics in food system transitions to enhance the understanding of just transitions. The articles emphasize a multi-dimensional understanding of justice, highlighting the importance of not only distributional matters but also recognition and procedural justice. The existing injustices in the food system underscore the interconnectedness of these dimensions. With case studies from Finland to Brazil and from farm-level decision-making to the UN food system summit, the papers demonstrate the centrality of recognition justice in interpreting contestations around sustainability transitions and draw attention to power imbalances that impact alternative visions of sustainability and require procedural justice. In the future, power analysis and normative frameworks are needed to identify trade-offs and blind spots in just transition.

ENVIRONMENTAL INNOVATION AND SOCIETAL TRANSITIONS (2023)

Letter Food Science & Technology

A rebalanced discussion of the roles of livestock in society

Irina Herzon, Rachel Mazac, Maijaliisa Erkkola, Tara Garnett, Helena Hansson, Minna Kaljonen, Teea Kortetmaki, Annika Lonkila, Malin Jonell, Mari Niva, Anne-Maria Pajari, Theresa Tribaldos, Marjaana Toivonen, Hanna L. Tuomisto, Kari Koppelmaki, Elin Roos

NATURE FOOD (2023)

Article Humanities, Multidisciplinary

Planetary well-being

Teea Kortetmaki, Mikael Puurtinen, Miikka Salo, Riikka Aro, Stefan Baumeister, Remi Duflot, Merja Elo, Panu Halme, Hanna-Mari Husu, Suvi Huttunen, Katriina Hyvonen, Sanna Karkulehto, Saana Kataja-aho, Kirsi E. Keskinen, Inari Kulmunki, Tuuli Makinen, Annukka Nayha, Mari-Anne Okkolin, Tommi Perala, Jenna Purhonen, Kaisa J. Raatikainen, Liia-Maria Raippalinna, Kirsi Salonen, Katri Savolainen, Janne S. Kotiaho

Summary: Tensions between the well-being of present humans, future humans, and nonhuman nature have led to the current ecological crisis, prompting the proposal of the concept of planetary well-being to address the crisis and promote societal and cultural transformation. This concept shifts focus from individuals to Earth system and ecosystem processes underlying all well-being, aiming to ensure the integrity of these processes for species and populations to persist into the future.

HUMANITIES & SOCIAL SCIENCES COMMUNICATIONS (2021)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Relative evaluation of probabilistic methods for spatio-temporal wind forecasting

Lars odegaard Bentsen, Narada Dilp Warakagoda, Roy Stenbro, Paal Engelstad

Summary: This study investigates uncertainty modeling in wind power forecasting using different parametric and non-parametric methods. Johnson's SU distribution is found to outperform Gaussian distributions in predicting wind power. This research contributes to the literature by introducing Johnson's SU distribution as a candidate for probabilistic wind forecasting.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Comparison of ethane recovery processes for lean gas based on a coupled model

Xing Liu, Qiuchen Wang, Yunhao Wen, Long Li, Xinfang Zhang, Yi Wang

Summary: This study analyzes the characteristics of process parameters in three lean gas ethane recovery processes and establishes a prediction and multiobjective optimization model for ethane recovery and system energy consumption. A new method for comparing ethane recovery processes for lean gas is proposed, and the addition of extra coolers improves the ethane recovery. The support vector regression model based on grey wolf optimization demonstrates the highest prediction accuracy, and the multiobjective multiverse optimization algorithm shows the best optimization performance and diversity in the solutions.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

A novel deep-learning framework for short-term prediction of cooling load in public buildings

Cairong Song, Haidong Yang, Xian-Bing Meng, Pan Yang, Jianyang Cai, Hao Bao, Kangkang Xu

Summary: The paper proposes a novel deep learning-based prediction framework, aTCN-LSTM, for accurate cooling load predictions. The framework utilizes a gate-controlled multi-head temporal convolutional network and a sparse probabilistic self-attention mechanism with a bidirectional long short-term memory network to capture both temporal and long-term dependencies in the cooling load sequences. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness and superiority of the proposed method, which can serve as an effective guide for HVAC chiller scheduling and demand management initiatives.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

The impact of social interaction and information acquisition on the adoption of soil and water conservation technology by farmers: Evidence from the Loess Plateau, China

Zhe Chen, Xiaojing Li, Xianli Xia, Jizhou Zhang

Summary: This study uses survey data from the Loess Plateau in China to evaluate the impact of social interaction on the adoption of soil and water conservation (SWC) technology by farmers. The study finds that social interaction increases the likelihood of farmers adopting SWC, and internet use moderates this effect. The positive impact of social interaction on SWC adoption is more pronounced for farmers in larger villages and those who join cooperative societies.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Study on synergistic heat transfer enhancement and adaptive control behavior of baffle under sudden change of inlet velocity in a micro combustor

Chenghua Zhang, Yunfei Yan, Kaiming Shen, Zongguo Xue, Jingxiang You, Yonghong Wu, Ziqiang He

Summary: This paper reports a novel method that significantly improves combustion performance, including heat transfer enhancement under steady-state conditions and adaptive stable flame regulation under velocity sudden increase.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2024)