4.7 Article

Renewable energy targets and unintended storage cycling: Implications for energy modeling

Journal

ISCIENCE
Volume 25, Issue 4, Pages -

Publisher

CELL PRESS
DOI: 10.1016/j.isci.2022.104002

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. German Federal Ministry of Education and Research [FKZ 01LA1810B]
  2. German Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Climate Action [FKZ 03EI1019D]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

To decarbonize the economy, governments have set targets for renewable energy sources. However, implementing these targets in energy models is a delicate issue that may result in excessive use of energy storage. This paper provides an analysis of different approaches for implementing minimum renewable share constraints and offers recommendations to avoid unintended storage cycling in energy modeling.
To decarbonize the economy, many governments have set targets for the use of renewable energy sources. These are often formulated as relative shares of electricity demand or supply. Implementing respective constraints in energy models is a surprisingly delicate issue. They may cause a modeling artifact of excessive electricity storage use. We introduce this phenomenon as unintended storage cycling'', which can be detected in case of simultaneous storage charging and discharging. In this paper, we provide an analytical representation of different approaches for implementing minimum renewable share constraints in energy models, and show how these may lead to unintended storage cycling. Using a parsimonious optimization model, we quantify related distortions of optimal dispatch and investment decisions as well as market prices, and identify important drivers of the phenomenon. Finally, we provide recommendations on how to avoid the distorting effects of unintended storage cycling in energy modeling.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Economics

Prosumage of solar electricity: Tariff design, capacity investments, and power sector effects

Claudia Gunther, Wolf-Peter Schill, Alexander Zerrahn

Summary: As fixed parts of retail tariffs increase, households have lower incentives for self-consumption, leading to smaller optimal battery capacities and self-generation, and increased contribution to non-energy power sector costs.

ENERGY POLICY (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

An open tool for creating battery-electric vehicle time series from empirical data, emobpy

Carlos Gaete-Morales, Hendrik Kramer, Wolf-Peter Schill, Alexander Zerrahn

Summary: This paper explores the interaction between future fleets of battery-electric vehicles and the power sector, introducing the open-source tool emobpy for generating time series data that can be applied in various models. By analyzing physical properties and mobility statistics, 200 vehicle profiles for Germany were created and characterized, with a demonstration of the smoothing effect of balanced charging strategies on grid electricity demand.

SCIENTIFIC DATA (2021)

Article Computer Science, Software Engineering

DIETERpy: A Python framework for the Dispatch and Investment Evaluation Tool with Endogenous Renewables

Carlos Gaete-Morales, Martin Kittel, Alexander Roth, Wolf-Peter Schill

Summary: DIETERpy is a new framework built on the existing DIETER model, combining the flexibility of Python with the algebraic formulation in GAMS. It offers a user-friendly graphical interface and simplifies model operation for users without deep knowledge of GAMS, while ensuring transparency and reproducibility of data and code.

SOFTWAREX (2021)

Article Thermodynamics

Temporal aggregation of time series to identify typical hourly electricity system states: A systematic assessment of relevant cluster algorithms

Martin Kittel, Hannes Hobbie, Constantin Dierstein

Summary: Comprehensive numerical models are crucial for analyzing the decarbonization of electricity systems. However, the increasing system complexity and limited computational resources pose limitations on model-based analyses. To reduce computational burden, one approach is to use a minimum yet representative set of system states for model simulation, which characterize fluctuating renewable generation and variable demand for electricity at a specific point in time. This paper presents a systematic multi-stage evaluation approach to compare different cluster analysis configurations in order to support the selection of a cluster algorithm. Results show that electricity demand and renewable energy generation time series can be compressed to less than 1% while maintaining global characteristics of the original data. Two effective cluster configurations, utilizing k-Means and WARD algorithms, are identified. The methodology can also be applied to various types of time-dependent input data.

ENERGY (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Modeling flexibility in energy systems-comparison of power sector models based on simplified test cases

Hans Christian Gils, Hedda Gardian, Martin Kittel, Wolf-Peter Schill, Alexander Zerrahn, Alexander Murmann, Jann Launer, Alexander Fehler, Felix Gaumnitz, Jonas van Ouwerkerk, Christian Bussar, Jennifer Mikurda, Laura Torralba-Diaz, Tomke Janssen, Christine Krueger

Summary: This paper presents a systematic comparison of nine power sector models with sector coupling, analyzing the impact of differences in technology representation, optimization approaches, and other model features on model outcomes. It identifies structural differences in the optimization approach between models and substantial differences in technology modeling, particularly for battery electric vehicles, reservoir hydro power, power transmission, and demand response. The study highlights the importance of being aware of potential effects of chosen modeling approaches in relevant technology analyses.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Model-related outcome differences in power system models with sector coupling-Quantification and drivers

Hans Christian Gils, Hedda Gardian, Martin Kittel, Wolf-Peter Schill, Alexander Murmann, Jann Launer, Felix Gaumnitz, Jonas van Ouwerkerk, Jennifer Mikurda, Laura Torralba-Diaz

Summary: This study presents the results of a multi-model comparison to determine outcome deviations resulting from differences in power system models. The findings show that model choice has a robust impact on system operation and investment decisions, while differences in modeling approach and specific technologies lead to comparatively small deviations. The results provide important guidance for modelers and decision-makers in properly evaluating power system model results.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Impacts of power sector model features on optimal capacity expansion: A comparative study

Jonas van Ouwerkerk, Hans Christian Gils, Hedda Gardian, Martin Kittel, Wolf-Peter Schill, Alexander Zerrahn, Alexander Murmann, Jann Launer, Laura Torralba-Diaz, Christian Bussar

Summary: The study reveals that inaccurate assumptions about the availability of technologies can lead to deviations between model results, fixed energy-to-power ratios of storage can change optimal expansion outcomes, and initial and final-period storage levels can affect seasonal storage use.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Geographical balancing of wind power decreases storage needs in a 100% renewable European power sector

Alexander Roth, Wolf -Peter Schill

Summary: To reduce greenhouse gas emissions, many countries are planning to expand wind power and solar photovoltaic capacities. However, these renewable energy sources require additional flexibility in the power sector. This study focuses on the geographical balancing between countries in a 100% renewable energy scenario and reveals that interconnection can reduce the need for electricity storage by about 30%, with the differences in wind power profiles being the main contributing factor.

ISCIENCE (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Reducing energy system model distortions from unintended storage cycling through variable costs

Maximilian Parzen, Martin Kittel, Daniel Friedrich, Aristides Kiprakis

Summary: Energy system models are important for policy decisions and technology designs, but their misuse can lead to implausible outputs and mislead decision-making. Through 124 simulations, we explore the impact of variable cost allocation and solver accuracy on unintended storage cycling, and provide recommendations to reduce its occurrence.

ISCIENCE (2023)

Review Chemistry, Physical

Overcoming the disconnect between energy system and climate modeling

Michael T. Craig, Jan Wohland, Laurens P. Stoop, Alexander Kies, Bryn Pickering, Hannah C. Bloomfield, Jethro Browell, Matteo De Felice, Chris J. Dent, Adrien Deroubaix, Felix Frischmuth, Paula L. M. Gonzalez, Aleksander Grochowicz, Katharina Gruber, Philipp Haertel, Martin Kittel, Leander Kotzur, Inga Labuhn, Julie K. Lundquist, Noah Pflugradt, Karin Van der Wiel, Marianne Zeyringer, David J. Brayshaw

Summary: Energy system models need to integrate climate factors in order to effectively mitigate climate risks and meet climate mitigation goals. This requires interdisciplinary research and collaboration between energy system and climate modeling communities.

JOULE (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Optimal supply chains and power sector benefits of green hydrogen

Fabian Stoeckl, Wolf-Peter Schill, Alexander Zerrahn

Summary: Green hydrogen production can help reduce carbon emissions in the transportation sector, but its interactions with the power sector need further study. There is a trade-off between energy efficiency and temporal flexibility in hydrogen supply chains, with different production methods optimal depending on the share of renewables and hydrogen. Large-scale hydrogen supply chains can deliver substantial power sector benefits by reducing renewable curtailment.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2021)

No Data Available