4.7 Article

Legume dreams: The contested futures of sustainable plant-based food systems in Europe

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2021.102321

Keywords

Legumes; Food systems; Futures; Promissory narrative; Livestock; Europe

Funding

  1. University of Oxford's LEAP (Livestock Environment and People) Programme
  2. Wellcome Trust's `Our Planet Our Health' Programme

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This paper examines the historic low of legume production and consumption in Europe due to agricultural intensification and changing dietary demands, while exploring the potential role of legumes in addressing environmental and health issues. It identifies six food futures made possible through the increased use of legumes, theorizing them as contrasting responses to key debates in the food systems literature. Consensus points include the nitrogen fixing capacity, high protein content, and historical significance of legumes, guiding discussions on the future of plant-based food in Europe.
With the intensification of agriculture, the simplification of crop rotations, and the rise in demand for meat, dairy and cereal products, legume production and consumption are at an historic low in Europe. But as the environmental consequences of agriculture (biodiversity loss, high greenhouse gas emissions, water pollution) and the health outcomes of modern diets (heart disease, cancer, diabetes, obesity) become better known, so great and varied hopes are being expressed about the future role of legumes in the food system. This paper catalogues and scrutinises these hopes, mapping the promissory narratives now orbiting around legumes. It identifies six food futures, each of which is made possible through the greater use of legumes in various production, processing, marketing and consumption contexts. These promissory narratives are theorised as contrasting responses to three major areas of contestation in the food systems literature. Namely i) the sustainability of livestock management, ii) the role of technology in different visions of the 'good diet', and iii) the merits of different models for how to make agricultural management more sustainable. It identifies the promiscuity of legumes - in terms of the range of food futures they permit - before distilling three points of consensus amongst advocates of the potential of legumes. These points of consensus relate to their nitrogen fixing capacity, their high protein content, and their long-standing historical role in the context of European food and farming. This map of legume dreams serves to guide deliberations amongst researchers, policymakers and industry stakeholders about the futures of plantbased food in Europe.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Editorial Material Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

The microbiome and its publics: A participatory approach for engaging publics with the microbiome and its implications for health and hygiene

Timothy Hodgetts, Richard Grenyer, Beth Greenhough, Carmen McLeod, Andrew Dwyer, Jamie Lorimer

EMBO REPORTS (2018)

Review Multidisciplinary Sciences

Meat consumption, health, and the environment

H. Charles J. Godfray, Paul Aveyard, Tara Garnett, Jim W. Hall, Timothy J. Key, Jamie Lorimer, Ray T. Pierrehumbert, Peter Scarborough, Marco Springmann, Susan A. Jebb

SCIENCE (2018)

Review Engineering, Environmental

Dairy intensification: Drivers, impacts and alternatives

Nathan Clay, Tara Garnett, Jamie Lorimer

AMBIO (2020)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Palatable disruption: the politics of plant milk

Nathan Clay, Alexandra E. Sexton, Tara Garnett, Jamie Lorimer

AGRICULTURE AND HUMAN VALUES (2020)

Article Geography

Vegan food geographies and the rise of Big Veganism

Alexandra E. Sexton, Tara Garnett, Jamie Lorimer

Summary: Veganism has received increasing attention in social scientific research, but has been relatively understudied in geography. This article argues that food geographers are well positioned to examine the mainstreaming of veganism and the rise of corporate veganism. The authors propose a 'vegan food geographies' program that builds on existing research in food geographies to advance critical geographic work on veganism and its contemporary implications.

PROGRESS IN HUMAN GEOGRAPHY (2022)

Editorial Material Geography

Is this the humanism we have been looking for?

Jamie Lorimer

Summary: This response provides a critique of Buscher's argument on the definition of the human in environmental geography and argues for a more inclusive understanding of humanity that does not oppose nature or view it as universally fallen.

DIALOGUES IN HUMAN GEOGRAPHY (2022)

Article Geography

Green rebranding: Regenerative agriculture, future-pasts, and the naturalisation of livestock

George Cusworth, Jamie Lorimer, Jeremy Brice, Tara Garnett

Summary: This paper reviews the place of beef and dairy farming in a sustainable food system and examines the feasibility of regenerative agriculture as a nature-based solution. Research findings indicate that the naturalisation of ruminant methane emissions and the optimization of soil carbon sequestration through ruminant grazing are two prominent green rebranding strategies. Additionally, the paper proposes political strategies such as post-pastoral storytelling, political ecological baselining, and a probiotic model of bovine biopolitics to achieve this naturalisation.

TRANSACTIONS OF THE INSTITUTE OF BRITISH GEOGRAPHERS (2022)

Article Geography

Anthropause environmentalisms: Noticing natures with the Self-Isolating Bird Club

Jonathon Turnbull, Adam Searle, Jamie Lorimer

Summary: This paper offers a detailed empirical account of how human-environment relations were reconfigured during the COVID-19 lockdowns in the UK and Ireland, introducing the concept of Anthropause and exploring its potential positive impacts on human-nature relationships. By examining an online birdwatching community, the Self-Isolating Bird Club, the paper identifies three key changes to human-nature relations: connection, community, and cultivation. The conclusions of the paper provide insights for geographers, environmentalists, and conservationists.

TRANSACTIONS OF THE INSTITUTE OF BRITISH GEOGRAPHERS (2023)

Article History & Philosophy Of Science

When you wish upon a (GWP) star: Environmental governance and the reflexive performativity of global warming metrics

George Cusworth, Jeremy Brice, Jamie Lorimer, Tara Garnett

Summary: The metrics used in environmental management have performative characteristics, interacting with the objects they observe. The performative nature of metrics reveals their influential power in measurement and auditing practices. Global warming metrics, such as GWP100, play a crucial role in managing anthropogenic climate change and impact the allocation of responsibility and capital in climate policy and markets. The introduction of a new warming metric, GWP*, has sparked a controversy, as stakeholders seek to influence the metrological regime that governs their lives. The concept of reflexive performativity emerges from this analysis, where actors strategically engage with metrics.

SOCIAL STUDIES OF SCIENCE (2023)

Article Geography

Animals' mobilities

Timothy Hodgetts, Jamie Lorimer

PROGRESS IN HUMAN GEOGRAPHY (2020)

Article Environmental Studies

The bones beneath the streets: drifting through London's Quaternary

David Overend, Jamie Lorimer, Danielle Schreve

CULTURAL GEOGRAPHIES (2020)

Article Environmental Studies

Framing the future of food: The contested promises of alternative proteins

Alexandra E. Sexton, Tara Garnett, Jamie Lorimer

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING E-NATURE AND SPACE (2019)

Article Geography

Parasites, ghosts and mutualists: a relational geography of microbes for global health

Jamie Lorimer

TRANSACTIONS OF THE INSTITUTE OF BRITISH GEOGRAPHERS (2017)

Article Environmental Sciences

Private provisioning of public adaptation: Integration of cognitive-behavioral, adaptive capacity, and institutional approaches

Hallie Eakin, Nadine Methner, Gina Ziervogel

Summary: There is a growing need to involve private actors in public adaptation in urban systems. Urban administrators have limited control over urban dynamics, and the actions of private actors have a significant influence. A conceptual framework combining cognitive and behavioral theory, institutional analysis, adaptive capacity, and research on urban adaptation governance is used to understand the potential for private provisioning. The case of Cape Town's response to drought illustrates the complex interactions that shape private actors' willingness to engage in public-oriented adaptation.

GLOBAL ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGE-HUMAN AND POLICY DIMENSIONS (2024)