4.7 Article

Observing the Observers: How Participants Contribute Data to iNaturalist and Implications for Biodiversity Science

Journal

BIOSCIENCE
Volume 71, Issue 11, Pages 1179-1188

Publisher

OXFORD UNIV PRESS
DOI: 10.1093/biosci/biab093

Keywords

citizen science; iNaturalist; biodiversity

Categories

Funding

  1. National Science Foundation [EF-1702708, EF-1703048]
  2. University of Florida Biodiversity Institute fellowship

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The availability and use of citizen science data, particularly on platforms like iNaturalist, have increased in biodiversity science applications. However, a study on iNaturalist observations revealed spatial and temporal biases, as well as user behaviors where individuals tend to specialize on specific taxonomic groups and rarely observe the same species twice. Biodiversity scientists should be cautious of potential systematic biases in their analyses when utilizing iNaturalist data.
The availability of citizen science data has resulted in growing applications in biodiversity science. One widely used platform, iNaturalist, provides millions of digitally vouchered observations submitted by a global user base. These observation records include a date and a location but otherwise do not contain any information about the sampling process. As a result, sampling biases must be inferred from the data themselves. In the present article, we examine spatial and temporal biases in iNaturalist observations from the platform's launch in 2008 through the end of 2019. We also characterize user behavior on the platform in terms of individual activity level and taxonomic specialization. We found that, at the level of taxonomic class, the users typically specialized on a particular group, especially plants or insects, and rarely made observations of the same species twice. Biodiversity scientists should consider whether user behavior results in systematic biases in their analyses before using iNaturalist data.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Anthropogenic drivers of avian community turnover from local to regional scales

Grace J. Di Cecco, Allen H. Hurlbert

Summary: Anthropogenic change has significantly impacted ecological communities globally, leading to a need for studies on community compositional change and the influence of anthropogenic drivers. Research on avian communities in North America showed that at local scales, land use change had a greater impact on turnover than climate change, with temperature variables becoming more influential at larger scales. Individual species undergoing population shifts were found to drive compositional change in avian communities in the region, highlighting the importance of selecting appropriate community turnover metrics.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2022)

Article Ecology

Global geographical and latitudinal variation in butterfly species richness captured through a comprehensive country-level occurrence database

Stefan Pinkert, Vijay Barve, Rob Guralnick, Walter Jetz

Summary: This study presents a comprehensive data product of the geographic distributions of extant butterflies, based on literature sources and occurrence records. The database provides insights into the richness and latitudinal gradients of butterfly diversity, highlighting the importance of leveraging multiple distribution information for ecological and conservation analysis.

GLOBAL ECOLOGY AND BIOGEOGRAPHY (2022)

Article Ecology

Expert range maps of global mammal distributions harmonised to three taxonomic authorities

Charles J. Marsh, Yanina V. Sica, Connor J. Burgin, Wendy A. Dorman, Robert C. Anderson, Isabel del Toro Mijares, Jessica G. Vigneron, Vijay Barve, Victoria L. Dombrowik, Michelle Duong, Robert Guralnick, Julie A. Hart, J. Krish Maypole, Kira McCall, Ajay Ranipeta, Anna Schuerkmann, Michael A. Torselli, Thomas Lacher, Russell A. Mittermeier, Anthony B. Rylands, Wes Sechrest, Don E. Wilson, Agustin M. Abba, Luis F. Aguirre, Joaquin Arroyo-Cabrales, Diego Astua, Andrew M. Baker, Gill Braulik, Janet K. Braun, Jorge Brito, Peter E. Busher, Santiago F. Burneo, M. Alejandra Camacho, Paolo Cavallini, Elisandra de Almeida Chiquito, Joseph A. Cook, Tamas Cserkesz, Gabor Csorba, Erika Cuellar Soto, Valeria da Cunha Tavares, Tim R. B. Davenport, Thomas Demere, Christiane Denys, Christopher R. Dickman, Mark D. B. Eldridge, Eduardo Fernandez-Duque, Charles M. Francis, Greta Frankham, William L. Franklin, Thales Freitas, J. Anthony Friend, Elizabeth L. Gadsby, Guilherme S. T. Garbino, Philippe Gaubert, Norberto Giannini, Thomas Giarla, Jason S. Gilchrist, Jaime Gongora, Steven M. Goodman, Sharon Gursky-Doyen, Klaus Hacklander, Mark S. Hafner, Melissa Hawkins, Kristofer M. Helgen, Steven Heritage, Arlo Hinckley, Stefan Hintsche, Mary Holden, Kay E. Holekamp, Rodney L. Honeycutt, Brent A. Huffman, Tatyana Humle, Rainer Hutterer, Carlos Ibanez Ulargui, Stephen M. Jackson, Jan Janecka, Mary Janecka, Paula Jenkins, Rimvydas Juskaitis, Javier Juste, Roland Kays, C. William Kilpatrick, Tigga Kingston, John L. Koprowski, Boris Krystufek, Tyrone Lavery, Thomas E. Lee, Yuri L. R. Leite, Roberto Leonan M. Novaes, Burton K. Lim, Andrey Lissovsky, Raquel Lopez-Antonanzas, Adria Lopez-Baucells, Colin D. MacLeod, Fiona G. Maisels, Michael A. Mares, Helene Marsh, Stefano Mattioli, Erik Meijaard, Ara Monadjem, F. Blake Morton, Grace Musser, Tilo Nadler, Ryan W. Norris, Agustina Ojeda, Nicte Ordonez-Garza, Ulyses F. J. Pardinas, Bruce D. Patterson, Ana Pavan, Michael Pennay, Calebe Pereira, Joyce Prado, Helder L. Queiroz, Matthew Richardson, Erin P. Riley, Stephen J. Rossiter, Daniel I. Rubenstein, Dennisse Ruelas, Jorge Salazar-Bravo, Stephanie Schai-Braun, Cody J. Schank, Christoph Schwitzer, Lori K. Sheeran, Myron Shekelle, Georgy Shenbrot, Pipat Soisook, Sergio Solari, Richard Southgate, Mariella Superina, Andrew B. Taber, Mauricio Talebi, Peter Taylor, Thong Vu Dinh, Nelson Ting, Diego G. Tirira, Susan Tsang, Samuel T. Turvey, Raul Valdez, Victor Van Cakenberghe, Geraldine Veron, Janette Wallis, Rod Wells, Danielle Whittaker, Elizabeth A. Williamson, George Wittemyer, John Woinarski, Dietmar Zinner, Nathan S. Upham, Walter Jetz

Summary: This article introduces a database of global mammal species' native range maps, including various tools for integration with other data. These expert maps provide basic information for broad-scale research and conservation.

JOURNAL OF BIOGEOGRAPHY (2022)

Article Ecology

Selection of sampling sites for biodiversity inventory: Effects of environmental and geographical considerations

Claudia Nunez-Penichet, Marlon E. Cobos, Jorge Soberon, Tomer Gueta, Narayani Barve, Vijay Barve, Adolfo G. Navarro-Siguenza, A. Townsend Peterson

Summary: Biodiversity inventory is a major challenge for conservation biology due to global change. This study explores the implications of using different methods to select locations for biodiversity inventories based on the distribution of species in geographical space and ecological niches in environmental space. The results show that considering both environmental and geographical conditions when selecting sites for inventories can lead to more effective sampling of known biodiversity in regions of interest.

METHODS IN ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2022)

Article Ecology

More individuals or specialized niches? Distinguishing support for hypotheses explaining positive species-energy relationships

Grace J. Di Cecco, Sara J. Snell Taylor, Ethan P. White, Allen H. Hurlbert

Summary: In two datasets of avian communities in North America, we assessed support for two hypotheses explaining productivity-richness relationships. The results suggest that landscape diversity may affect the strength of productivity-richness relationships. Although the More Individuals Hypothesis (MIH) and the Niche Specialization Hypothesis (NSH) may not be mutually exclusive, the level of support for each hypothesis differs.

JOURNAL OF BIOGEOGRAPHY (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

LepTraits 1.0 A globally comprehensive dataset of butterfly traits

Vaughn Shirey, Elise Larsen, Andra Doherty, Clifford A. Kim, Faisal T. Al-Sulaiman, Jomar D. Hinolan, Micael Gabriel A. Itliong, Mark Arcebal K. Naive, Minji Ku, Michael Belitz, Grace Jeschke, Vijay Barve, Gerardo Lamas, Akito Y. Kawahara, Robert Guralnick, Naomi E. Pierce, David J. Lohman, Leslie Ries

Summary: Here we present the largest and most comprehensive dataset of Lepidopteran traits, focusing on butterflies. The dataset provides information on wing size, phenology, voltinism, diapause/overwintering stage, hostplant associations, and habitat preferences. This dataset will facilitate comparative research on butterfly ecology and evolution.

SCIENTIFIC DATA (2022)

Article Ecology

Multiple dimensions of niche specialization explain changes in species' range area, occupancy, and population size

Grace J. J. Di Cecco, Allen H. H. Hurlbert

Summary: Species may experience changes in population size, range limits, and range occupancy in response to environmental change. Climate generalist species are more likely to expand their range area, while species with declining population trends are likely to contract their range area.

FRONTIERS IN ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2022)

Article Ecology

A global phylogeny of butterflies reveals their evolutionary history, ancestral hosts and biogeographic origins

Akito Y. Kawahara, Caroline Storer, Ana Paula S. Carvalho, David M. Plotkin, Fabien L. Condamine, Mariana P. Braga, Emily A. Ellis, Ryan A. St Laurent, Xuankun Li, Vijay Barve, Liming Cai, Chandra Earl, Paul B. Frandsen, Hannah L. Owens, Wendy A. Valencia-Montoya, Kwaku Aduse-Poku, Emmanuel F. A. Toussaint, Kelly M. Dexter, Tenzing Doleck, Amanda Markee, Rebeccah Messcher, Y-Lan Nguyen, Jade Aster T. Badon, Hugo A. Benitez, Michael F. Braby, Perry A. C. Buenavente, Wei-Ping Chan, Steve C. Collins, Richard A. Rabideau Childers, Even Dankowicz, Rod Eastwood, Zdenek F. Fric, Riley J. Gott, Jason P. W. Hall, Winnie Hallwachs, Nate B. Hardy, Rachel L. Hawkins Sipe, Alan Heath, Jomar D. Hinolan, Nicholas T. Homziak, Yu-Feng Hsu, Yutaka Inayoshi, Micael G. A. Itliong, Daniel H. Janzen, Ian J. Kitching, Krushnamegh Kunte, Gerardo Lamas, Michael J. Landis, Elise A. Larsen, Torben B. Larsen, Jing V. Leong, Vladimir Lukhtanov, Crystal A. Maier, Jose I. Martinez, Dino J. Martins, Kiyoshi Maruyama, Sarah C. Maunsell, Nicolas Oliveira Mega, Alexander Monastyrskii, Ana B. B. Morais, Chris J. Mueller, Mark Arcebal K. Naive, Gregory Nielsen, Pablo Sebastian Padron, Djunijanti Peggie, Helena Piccoli Romanowski, Szabolcs Safian, Motoki Saito, Stefan Schroeder, Vaughn Shirey, Doug Soltis, Pamela Soltis, Andrei Sourakov, Gerard Talavera, Roger Vila, Petr Vlasanek, Houshuai Wang, Andrew D. Warren, Keith R. Willmott, Masaya Yago, Walter Jetz, Marta A. Jarzyna, Jesse W. Breinholt, Marianne Espeland, Leslie Ries, Robert P. Guralnick, Naomi E. Pierce, David J. Lohman

Summary: Butterflies are believed to have evolved alongside plants and dispersed globally in response to geological events, according to a new comprehensive phylogenetic study. The study sequenced genes from nearly 2,300 butterfly species and reconstructed a phylogenomic tree representing 92% of all genera, resulting in the reclassification of 36 butterfly tribes. The research also revealed that butterflies first fed on Fabaceae plants and originated in the Americas.

NATURE ECOLOGY & EVOLUTION (2023)

Article Biology

Identifying the identifiers: How iNaturalist facilitates collaborative, research-relevant data generation and why it matters for biodiversity science

C. J. Campbell, Vijay Barve, Michael W. Belitz, Joshua R. Doby, Elizabeth White, Carrie Seltzer, Grace Di Cecco, Allen H. Hurlbert, Robert Guralnick

Summary: The iNaturalist platform generates millions of research-grade biodiversity records by involving users in taxonomic identification. This article investigates the role of identifiers and their efforts in supporting data generation, finding that a small subset of highly active users play a crucial role in processing observations. The experience of identifiers determines the quality and time required to reach research-grade records, which has been greatly reduced with the use of computer vision. Although identifications are generally stable, biases still exist. Suggestions for improving identification quality and enhancing equitable credit and trust among observers, identifiers, and data users are provided.

BIOSCIENCE (2023)

Article Entomology

Building a community-based taxonomic resource for digitization of parasites and their hosts

Kathryn A. Sullivan, Erika M. Tucker, Nicolas J. Dowdy, Julie M. Allen, Vijay Barve, James H. Boone, Sarah E. Bush, Neal L. Evenhuis, Michael Hastriter, Jessica E. Light, Teresa Mayfield-Meyer, Barry M. Oconnor, Jorrit H. Poelen, Gabor R. Racz, Katja C. Seltmann, Jennifer M. Zaspel

Summary: Classifying the biological diversity on Earth is essential for natural science research. However, sharing and updating these resources remains a challenge, especially for high diversity groups. This study developed a workflow that aligns and publishes expert-verified taxonomic names, providing a model for standardizing digital specimen identification data in the future.

INSECT SYSTEMATICS AND DIVERSITY (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

rangemap: AN R PACKAGE TO EXPLORE SPECIES GEOGRAPHIC RANGES

Marlon E. Cobos, Vijay Barve, Narayani Barve, Alberto Jimenez-Valverde, Claudia Nunez-Penichet

Summary: This article introduces rangemap, an R package that provides tools for exploring species' geographic distributions. The package includes analysis tools and visualization tools that can generate simple summaries and figures of species' ranges. It also allows for the generation of extents of occurrence and areas of occupancy based on IUCN criteria.

BIODIVERSITY INFORMATICS (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

BEST PRACTICES FOR DATA MANAGEMENT IN CITIZEN SCIENCE: AN INDIAN OUTLOOK

Thomas Vattakanten, Vijay Barve, Geetha Ramaswami, Priya Singh, Suneha Jagannathan, Balasubramanian Dhandapani

Summary: Citizen science has been practiced since the 1800s and serves as a valuable data source for scientists. It promotes scientific democratization, provides equitable access to participation and data, enhances participants' skills, fosters scientific curiosity, and encourages conservation awareness. Citizen science, particularly in biodiversity, has experienced rapid growth thanks to smartphones and internet access. India has also witnessed an increase in citizen science projects and participation. This article fills the gap by examining best practices for managing biodiversity-focused citizen science projects in an Indian context.

BIODIVERSITY INFORMATICS (2022)

No Data Available