A systematic literature review on meta sustainability labeling e What do we (not) know?

Nudging consumers to make sustainable consumption decisions is what sustainability labeling is all about. However, the current sustainability labeling landscape is up against the challenge of too much, too complex, too similar, and too ambiguous information. Therefore, sustainability labeling schemes are looked upon as failing to support sustainability-involved consumers sufficiently. Meta sustainability labeling has been proposed as a means to reduce these challenges and strengthen the benefits of sus-tainability labeling. However, there is a need for systematically taking stock of and synthesizing what is known and what is yet unknown about meta sustainability labeling as input to decisions and devel-opment work regarding this instrument. This systematic literature review investigates how a meta sustainability label has been defined and assessed compared to existing, single-issue sustainability labels. First, four characteristic elements of a meta sustainability label are identified: multi-dimensionality, meta, multi-level, and universal. Second, a distinction between a meta sustainability label scheme and an integrated sustainability label scheme is proposed, the distinguishing characteristic being the (graphical) communication to the consumer. Third, benefits and disadvantages as well as facilitators of and impediments to implementing a meta sustainability scheme are identified. There is no consensus in the literature about the likelihood of a meta sustainability label doing a better job than existing sus-tainability labeling schemes. Perhaps the most important finding is that the debate regarding meta sustainability labeling is still in its infancy and lacks a proper evidence base. Thus, we encourage mar-keting and sustainability researchers to continue investigating meta sustainability labeling as a poten-tially useful tool for sustainability transformation. (C) 2021 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Automated summary

Sustainability labeling aims to guide consumers towards making sustainable consumption decisions, but faces challenges of information overload and complexity. Meta sustainability labeling has been proposed as a solution, characterized by multi-dimensionality and universal applicability. Despite debates on its effectiveness compared to single-issue labels, research shows that the discussion on meta sustainability labeling is still in its early stages and lacks solid evidence.