4.8 Article

Empirical analysis of large-scale bio-succinic acid commercialization from a technoeconomic and innovation value chain perspective: BioAmber biorefinery case study in Canada

Journal

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS
Volume 137, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.rser.2020.110587

Keywords

Bio-succinic acid; Technoeconomic analysis; BioAmber sarnia plant; Profitability analysis; Innovation value chain

Funding

  1. Science and Technology Branch (Federal Government of Canada) under the ABase Bioproducts and Bioprocesses National Science Program

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study evaluated the commercialization of bio-succinic acid from a technoeconomic and innovation value chain perspective, revealing that lack of cost competition and market demand led to the failure of the production plant. It provides benchmarks for understanding risks in technology commercialization strategies and helping to avoid similar mistakes.
Succinic acid from carbohydrates is increasingly being recognized as a renewable biochemical for deriving a wide range of sustainable value-added products. However, in spite of earlier efforts to commercialize bio-succinic acid on an industrial scale, the product's entry into the market has been severely constrained, leading to the demise of the business. This study evaluates the commercialization of bio-succinic acid from a technoeconomic and innovation value chain perspective, using BioAmber's carbohydrate-based succinic acid as a case study. A 30,000-tonne annum(-1) bio-succinic acid production plant was designed and simulated using SuperPro (R) Designer. The estimated fixed capital cost of the Sarnia Plant was $147 million which was similar to BioAmber's expense but the calculated cost of succinic acid production was $2.23 kg(-1) which was much higher than of BioAmber's original projection. The analysis revealed a number of factors that may have contributed to the demise of BioAmber Sarnia Plant. Lacking of cost competition and market demand, the Sarnia plant could not operate at full capacity and was unable to generate profit. The sensitivity analysis showed the derived coproducts such as 1,4-butanediol would not be profitable under current succinic acid prices. This study provides benchmarks for understanding risks in technology commercialization strategies and assisting in eliminating similar mistakes associated with the translation of a research invention into a successful commercial product.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.8
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Agricultural Engineering

Technoeconomic analysis of biojet fuel production from camelina at commercial scale: Case of Canadian Prairies

Xue Li, Edmund Mupondwa, Lope Tabil

BIORESOURCE TECHNOLOGY (2018)

Article Agricultural Engineering

Integrated bioethanol production from triticale grain and lignocellulosic straw in Western Canada

Edmund Mupondwa, Xue Li, Lope Tabil

INDUSTRIAL CROPS AND PRODUCTS (2018)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Commercial feasibility of an integrated closed-loop ethanol-feedlot-biodigester system based on triticale feedstock in Canadian Prairies

Xue Li, Edmund Mupondwa

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2018)

Article Energy & Fuels

Microwave Torrefaction of Oat Hull: Effect of Temperature and Residence Time

Esteban Valdez, Lope G. Tabil, Edmund Mupondwa, Duncan Cree, Hadi Moazed

Summary: Microwave torrefaction of oat hull enhances its physicochemical properties, with high temperature and short residence time showing positive effects on calorific values but negative effects on mass yield. Moderate and severe torrefaction significantly improve biomass fuel properties.

ENERGIES (2021)

Article Energy & Fuels

Comparative Study on Quality of Fuel Pellets from Switchgrass Treated with Different White-Rot Fungi

Onu Onu Olughu, Lope G. Tabil, Tim Dumonceaux, Edmund Mupondwa, Duncan Cree

Summary: The study demonstrated that fungal pretreatment of switchgrass can significantly improve pellet tensile strength, especially when treated with PC. Fungal pretreatment also enhances the microstructural properties of the pellets, reducing pores and enhancing particle bonding.

ENERGIES (2021)

Article Energy & Fuels

Torrefaction and Pelleting of Wheat and Barley Straw for Biofuel and Energy Applications

Obiora S. Agu, Lope G. Tabil, Edmund Mupondwa, Bagher Emadi

Summary: Microwave-assisted torrefaction and pelleting with HDPE as a binder improved the quality of wheat and barley straw pellets, increasing density and tensile strength while reducing ash content. High heating values also increased with biochar mix and HDPE blend, showing potential for enhancing biomass fuel properties.

FRONTIERS IN ENERGY RESEARCH (2021)

Article Energy & Fuels

Investigation of Steam Explosion Pretreatment of Sawdust and Oat Straw to Improve Their Quality as Biofuel Pellets

Chukwuka Onyenwoke, Lope G. Tabil, Tim Dumonceaux, Duncan Cree, Edmund Mupondwa, Phani Adapa, Chithra Karunakaran

Summary: Steam explosion pretreatment improves the quality of biomass pellets made from sawdust and oat straw. The mechanical properties of the pellets are influenced by temperature, time, and moisture content. The treated biomass has higher heating value and tensile strength, and exhibits a more compact and cemented microstructure.

ENERGIES (2022)

Article Energy & Fuels

Combined Effects of Torrefaction and Binders on the Quality of Pellets Produced from Oat Straw

Chukwuka Onyenwoke, Lope G. Tabil, Tim Dumonceaux, Duncan Cree, Edmund Mupondwa

Summary: This study investigated the effects of torrefaction and binders on the quality of oat straw pellets. The results showed that torrefaction improved the physiochemical and thermal properties of the pellets, but not the tensile strength. The addition of binders during pelletization increased the tensile strength and improved several other properties of the pellets.

BIOENERGY RESEARCH (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

Technoeconomic Feasibility of Bioenergy Production from Wood Sawdust

Peyman Alizadeh, Lope G. G. Tabil, Edmund Mupondwa, Xue Li, Duncan Cree

Summary: This study simulates and compares the technoeconomic feasibility of bioenergy production from sawdust under four different scenarios. The results show that the approach of producing torrefied pellets, furfural, and acetic acid, along with co-generated heat and electricity, is more advantageous in terms of multiproducts and profitability compared to other alternatives.

ENERGIES (2023)

Review Energy & Fuels

Actualization and Adoption of Renewable Energy Usage in Remote Communities in Canada by 2050: A Review

Obiora S. Agu, Lope G. Tabil, Edmund Mupondwa

Summary: Remote community initiatives for renewable energy in Canada are rapidly increasing, but with different numbers, success rates, and strategies. Coordinating technology deployment and long-term policies is critical to meet low-carbon transition goals. Renewable resources can provide subsidized energy, create sustainable infrastructure, and enhance economic viability in integration with social values. The transition to renewable energy is crucial for sustaining remote and indigenous communities in Canada by providing local, clean, and low-carbon emission energy. This paper identifies 635 renewable resource projects deployed to improve electricity supply and highlights the achievable goal of balancing demand and sustainable development before and after 2050 through energy efficiency and social value.

ENERGIES (2023)

Article Microbiology

Modeling the microbial pretreatment of camelina straw and switchgrass by Trametes versicolor and Phanerochaete chrysosporium via solid-state fermentation process: A growth kinetic sub-model in the context of biomass-based biorefineries

Cuong Ngoc Dao, Lope G. Tabil, Edmund Mupondwa, Tim Dumonceaux

Summary: Advancing microbial pretreatment of lignocellulose offers the opportunity to reduce environmental impacts, increase biomass valorization, and support the bioeconomy. Mathematical modeling provides insights into microbial metabolism and facilitates the optimization of solid-state-fermentation (SSF) bioreactors. This study investigated the growth of three fungal strains on camelina straw and switchgrass during SSF, and provided a baseline for developing large-scale SSF systems for agricultural residue utilization in biofuel production.

FRONTIERS IN MICROBIOLOGY (2023)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Technoeconomic analysis of a fungal pretreatment-based cellulosic ethanol production

Onu Onu Olughu, Lope G. Tabil, Tim Dumonceaux, Edmund Mupondwa, Duncan Cree, Xue Li

Summary: This paper presents a technoeconomic analysis of a fungal pretreatment-based cellulosic ethanol plant, which reveals that commercial production of cellulosic ethanol is economically challenging at the current state of technology, despite its clear benefits in terms of greenhouse gas mitigation and bioproduct potential.

RESULTS IN ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Steam Explosion Pre-Treatment of Sawdust for Biofuel Pellets

Peyman Alizadeh, Tim Dumonceaux, Lope G. G. Tabil, Edmund Mupondwa, Majid Soleimani, Duncan Cree

Summary: This study explores steam explosion pre-treatment of wood sawdust for high-quality biofuel pellets. Optimal conditions were determined for steam-treated biomass, resulting in improved pellet density and tensile strength, as well as lower nitrogen and sulfur contents for cleaner energy production.

CLEAN TECHNOLOGIES (2022)

Proceedings Paper Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Irrigation and seed-type effects on tuber yield, culinary attributes, and economic performance of French fry, chipping, and fresh market potato under short growing conditions of the Canadian Prairies

J. Wahab, B. Bizimungu, E. Mupondwa, G. Larson

INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON SENSING PLANT WATER STATUS - METHODS AND APPLICATIONS IN HORTICULTURAL SCIENCE (2018)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

3E analysis of a virtual hydrogen valley supported by railway-based H2 delivery for multi-transportation service

M. Genovese, F. Piraino, P. Fragiacomo

Summary: This research proposes the concept of a hydrogen valley in southern Italy, where hydrogen is produced centrally and delivered via fuel cell hybrid trains to refueling stations, providing transportation services. The analysis from both technical and economic perspectives shows that the cost of hydrogen and energy efficiency reached competitive levels, and hydrogen rail transport offers significant benefits in terms of emissions reduction and economic gains compared to conventional diesel trains and fully electric trains.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

A critical review of windcatcher ventilation: Micro-environment, techno-economics, and commercialisation

Miaomiao Liu, Payam Nejat, Pinlu Cao, Carlos Jimenez-Bescos, John Kaiser Calautit

Summary: This article provides a critical review of the performance of windcatchers, pointing out the current research gaps and issues, and proposing directions for further investigation and market prospects.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

A comprehensive review on wind energy in Africa: Challenges, benefits and recommendations

Solomon Boadu, Ebenezer Otoo

Summary: Despite Africa's vast energy resources, including wind energy, the continent faces challenges in developing its wind energy industry. Northern African countries and South Africa currently dominate the wind energy sector in Africa. To uplift Africa's socio-economic status, strong political will, supportive policies, and institutional frameworks are needed to drive the development of wind energy and overcome existing challenges.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Optimized agrivoltaic tracking for nearly-full commodity crop and energy production

E. K. Grubbs, S. M. Gruss, V. Z. Schull, M. J. Gosney, M. V. Mickelbart, S. Brouder, M. W. Gitau, P. Bermel, M. R. Tuinstra, R. Agrawal

Summary: As the global population grows, the demand for food, energy, and water will increase significantly. However, limited land availability and competition for solar resources pose challenges to resource generation technologies. In the United States, both agriculture and solar energy production have adopted densification schemes to improve yields and energy output per unit of land. This research proposes an Agrivoltaic food and energy coproduction architecture that optimizes power generation while maintaining crop productivity by implementing ideal anti-tracking during critical growth periods. This technology offers a viable pathway for widespread solar implementation throughout the contiguous United States.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Power quality monitoring in electric grid integrating offshore wind energy: A review

Han Shao, Rui Henriques, Hugo Morais, Elisabetta Tedeschi

Summary: The integration of offshore wind energy into the electric grid provides opportunities in terms of environmental sustainability and cost efficiency, but poses challenges to power quality. This survey offers a deeper understanding of disturbance detection and classification tools, exploring root causes, disturbance locations, and algorithmic solutions. It highlights synchronized waveform measurement and discusses evaluation metrics for detection and classification algorithms. Additionally, a novel system-wide monitoring framework is proposed.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Resilience of the higher education sector to future climates: A systematic review of predicted building energy performance and modelling approaches

Eleni Davidson, Yair Schwartz, Joe Williams, Dejan Mumovic

Summary: A continued upward trend in global greenhouse gas emissions poses risks to global infrastructure and built assets. Maintaining high indoor environmental quality standards is a challenge for higher education institutions under future climates. Passive cooling mechanisms may be insufficient to tolerate predicted temperature increases. Different building typologies have varying energy demand projections.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Long-term microgrid expansion planning with resilience and environmental benefits using deep reinforcement learning

Kexin Pang, Jian Zhou, Stamatis Tsianikas, David W. Coit, Yizhong Ma

Summary: This study proposes a new framework for long-term microgrid expansion planning, using deep reinforcement learning method to consider various uncertainties and constraints. The framework aims to enhance the effectiveness of microgrid expansion planning from the perspectives of economy, resilience, and greenhouse gas emission reduction.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

How does energy poverty eradication affect global carbon neutrality?

Jun Zhao, Kangyin Dong, Xiucheng Dong

Summary: The continuous growth of global electricity penetration has provided modern energy for alleviating energy poverty, but its impact on carbon neutrality has been overlooked. The research reveals that clean electricity from traditional fossil energy and renewable energy has a positive influence on the greenhouse effect. Eradicating energy poverty can effectively alleviate the greenhouse effect, especially in non-Belt and Road Initiative (B&RI) nations.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Biomass to biofuels using hydrothermal liquefaction: A comprehensive review

Hossein Shahbeik, Hamed Kazemi Shariat Panahi, Mona Dehhaghi, Gilles J. Guillemin, Alireza Fallahi, Homa Hosseinzadeh-Bandbafha, Hamid Amiri, Mohammad Rehan, Deepak Raikwar, Hannes Latine, Bruno Pandalone, Benyamin Khoshnevisan, Christian Sonne, Luigi Vaccaro, Abdul-Sattar Nizami, Vijai Kumar Gupta, Su Shiung Lam, Junting Pan, Rafael Luque, Bert Sels, Wanxi Peng, Meisam Tabatabaei, Mortaza Aghbashlo

Summary: This review explores the production of biocrude oil from biomass feedstocks through the process of hydrothermal liquefaction (HTL). It discusses the impact of process parameters on the quality, quantity, cost, and environmental impacts of biofuels. The review also highlights the challenges and prospects for the future development of biocrude oil.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Marine energy digitalization digital twin's approaches

Meysam Majidi Nezhad, Mehdi Neshat, Georgios Sylaios, Davide Astiaso Garcia

Summary: Digital twins promise innovation for the marine renewable energy sector by using modern technological advances and the existing maritime knowledge frameworks. This research presents critical aspects of digital twin implementation challenges in marine energy digitalization approaches that use and combine data systems.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Multi-area economic dispatch problem: Methods, uncertainties, and future directions

Yeganeh Sharifian, Hamdi Abdi

Summary: This paper discusses the background and objectives of the multi-area economic dispatch problem, as well as various techniques and methods applied in this field. It also covers comprehensive formulations of the problem and important issues in the field of probabilistic MAED, along with some related concepts and suggestions.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

A review on the production and application of tall oil with a focus on sustainable fuels

J. G. B. Churchill, V. B. Borugadda, A. K. Dalai

Summary: The increasing global energy demand and the need to reduce fossil fuel reliance have created a demand for renewable and sustainable fuel sources. This review explores the potential of tall oil, a by-product of the pulping industry, as a feedstock for biofuels. The review provides an overview of tall oil production, purification, and treatment, and investigates recent trends and barriers towards tall oil-derived biofuels.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

District cooling services: A bibliometric review and topic classification of existing research

David C. Broadstock, Xiangnan Wang

Summary: This study provides a general review of research on district cooling, identifying key topics and themes and highlighting potential research priorities for future studies.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Barriers to demand response in the commercial and industrial sectors - An empirical investigation

L. Scharnhorst, D. Sloot, N. Lehmann, A. Ardone, W. Fichtner

Summary: This study investigates and analyzes the barriers to demand response in industrial and commercial sectors, highlighting their significance. Concerns about diminished product quality, disruptions to production processes, human resource management, and revenue uncertainty are identified as the most frequently cited barriers. Overcoming these barriers requires bridging knowledge gaps, allocating sufficient resources, and adapting external incentives and policies.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Air pollution control policies and impacts: A review

Tong Feng, Yuechi Sun, Yating Shi, Jie Ma, Chunmei Feng, Zhenni Chen

Summary: Air pollution is a significant global challenge, and policymakers have implemented policies to reduce it. Evaluating the effectiveness of these policies is critical, and our study reveals trends and gaps in air pollution policy research. We found that research has shifted from focusing solely on air pollutants to including methodologies, policies, and health implications. China has emerged as a major contributor in this field of research.

RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS (2024)