4.6 Article

A meta-analysis contrasting active versus passive restoration practices in dryland agricultural ecosystems

Journal

PEERJ
Volume 8, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

PEERJ INC
DOI: 10.7717/peerj.10428

Keywords

Agricultural drylands; Deserts; Human-modified ecosystems; Intervention; Meta-analysis; Restoration

Funding

  1. The Nature Conservancy
  2. York University
  3. NSERC DG Grant in Canada
  4. NCEAS
  5. CONICET

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Restoration of agricultural drylands globally, here farmlands and grazing lands, is a priority for ecosystem function and biodiversity preservation. Natural areas in drylands are recognized as biodiversity hotspots and face continued human impacts. Global water shortages are driving increased agricultural land retirement providing the opportunity to reclaim some of these lands for natural habitat. We used meta-analysis to contrast different classes of dryland restoration practices. All interventions were categorized as active and passive for the analyses of efficacy in dryland agricultural ecosystems. We evaluated the impact of 19 specific restoration practices from 42 studies on soil, plant, animal, and general habitat targets across 16 countries, for a total of 1,427 independent observations. Passive vegetation restoration and grazing exclusion led to net positive restoration outcomes. Passive restoration practices were more variable and less effective than active restoration practices. Furthermore, passive soil restoration led to net negative restoration outcomes. Active restoration practices consistently led to positive outcomes for soil, plant, and habitat targets. Water supplementation was the most effective restoration practice. These findings suggest that active interventions are necessary and critical in most instances for dryland agricultural ecosystems likely because of severe anthropogenic pressures and concurrent environmental stressors-both past and present.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Plant Sciences

A synthesis of local adaptation to climate through reciprocal common gardens

Christopher J. Lortie, Jose L. Hierro

Summary: This study explored plant climate adaptation and ecotypic differentiation in reciprocal common gardens, demonstrating plant adaptation to climate change through meta-analysis. The need for future studies to clearly define ecotypic testing in common garden experiments and the importance of reciprocal climatic gardens were emphasized.

JOURNAL OF ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Ecology

A keystone mutualism promotes resistance to invasion

Agustin Vitali, Diego P. Vazquez, Maria F. Miguel, Yamila Sasal, Mariano A. Rodriguez-Cabal

Summary: This study found that a keystone mutualism can enhance community resistance against the impacts of a non-native invasive pollinator by increasing species diversity and promoting interaction rewiring in the community.

JOURNAL OF ANIMAL ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Ecology

The disruption of a keystone interaction erodes pollination and seed dispersal networks

Agustin Vitali, Yamila Sasal, Diego P. Vazquez, M. Florencia Miguel, Mariano A. Rodriguez-Cabal

Summary: Understanding the impacts of global change on ecological communities is a major challenge in modern ecology. Disruption of the hummingbird-mistletoe-marsupial mutualism can lead to cascading effects on both pollination and seed dispersal networks in Patagonia. The disruption of this mutualism by non-native species can result in less complex ecological networks.

ECOLOGY (2022)

Editorial Material Evolutionary Biology

The Little Prince is an ecologist

Christopher J. Lortie

Summary: Stories play a significant role in shaping the human experience, with tales like "The Little Prince" emphasizing the importance of ecology and connection. They provide moral guidance from different cultures and eras, while also being utilized in science education and promoting justice and openness.

IDEAS IN ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2021)

Article Ecology

Drivers of plant individual-based pollinator visitation network topology in an arid ecosystem

Jenna Braun, Christopher J. Lortie

Summary: Interactions with pollinators are crucial for the structure and function of plant communities, and inter-individual variation plays a role in the sharing of pollinators in visitation networks.

ECOLOGICAL COMPLEXITY (2022)

Article Ecology

Net plant interactions are highly variable and weakly dependent on climate at the global scale

Xuejun Yang, Lorena Gomez-Aparicio, Christopher J. Lortie, Miguel Verdu, Lohengrin A. Cavieres, Zhenying Huang, Ruiru Gao, Rong Liu, Yonglan Zhao, Johannes H. C. Cornelissen

Summary: This study uses a global database to examine the patterns of plant interactions and their effects on climate. It finds that competition occurs more frequently than facilitation in plant communities worldwide and that plant interactions show weak relationships with latitude and climate. The study highlights competition as a fundamental mechanism structuring plant communities globally.

ECOLOGY LETTERS (2022)

Article Ecology

A workflow for selecting seeding density in desert species experiments

Christopher J. Lortie, Nargol Ghazian, Mario Zuliani

Summary: Seeds and seed banks play a crucial role in plant community theory and experimental design in desert ecosystems. It was observed that the choice of seeding density was often arbitrary and lacked key components needed for calculating seed density in desert experiments, leading to limitations in reproducibility and comparability between studies. A proposed workflow of 5 steps aims to address these challenges by improving data-checking processes and fostering higher levels of consistency and replication in experimental design, ultimately benefiting scientific syntheses for arid ecosystems.

JOURNAL OF ARID ENVIRONMENTS (2022)

Editorial Material Plant Sciences

What common-garden experiments tell us about climate responses in plants

Susanne Schwinning, Christopher J. Lortie, Todd C. Esque, Lesley A. DeFalco

Summary: These papers highlight the trends in common garden experiments, including the relationship between climate-related traits and fitness optima, as well as discussing various methods for improving common garden studies.

JOURNAL OF ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Ecology

Restoration richness tipping point meta-analysis: finding the sweet spot

Christopher J. Lortie, Maria Florencia Miguel, Alessandro Filazzola, Harry Scott Butterfield

Summary: This study used meta-analysis to examine the impact of local species richness on restoration outcomes in dryland areas, and found that the most effective restoration outcomes were observed at sites with intermediate to relatively low species richness. Therefore, restoring degraded or low diversity arid grasslands should be prioritized during the UN Decade on Ecosystem Restoration, and plant species richness can serve as a crucial factor in decision-making.

RESTORATION ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Ecology

A comment on the protect-manage-then-restore workflow

Christopher J. Lortie

Summary: Decisions and judgment are complex processes due to the profound pressures exerted by global change on natural systems. A hierarchical approach is proposed to prioritize interventions based on implementation timing, with protecting first, managing second, and restoring last. This optimization workflow is considered reasonable for addressing various global challenges, not limited to climate mitigation through restoration.

RESTORATION ECOLOGY (2023)

Editorial Material Ecology

Teach different: The CREATE pedagogy for ecology and evolution

C. J. Lortie

Summary: Globally, teaching has undergone significant changes and innovations in the past three years, allowing for more seamless integration of technology and active visual teaching online or in-person. The CREATE pedagogy, originally proposed years ago and recently applied to ecology and evolution courses, offers a framework for engaging students in active reading and critical thinking. This approach not only enhances student engagement in various courses but also has a profound impact on how educators deliver content in lecture settings.

ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

Article Evolutionary Biology

Trait evolution during a rapid global weed invasion despite little genetic differentiation

Ramona E. Irimia, Daniel Montesinos, Anurag Chaturvedi, Ian Sanders, Jose L. Hierro, Gaston Sotes, Lohengrin A. Cavieres, Ozkan Eren, Christopher J. Lortie, Kristine French, Adrian Christopher Brennan

Summary: Invasive species have a high capacity to adapt to new environments, resulting in spatial trait variation. We examined the geographic differentiation of phenotypic traits in the invasive Centaurea solstitialis by comparing genetic differentiation and phenotypic differentiation. We found that native plants were more fecund, while non-native plants had larger seed mass. There was little overall genetic differentiation between native and non-native ranges, suggesting rapid evolution has contributed to the success of C. solstitialis.

EVOLUTIONARY APPLICATIONS (2023)

Editorial Material Ecology

Reproducibility in ecology and evolution: Minimum standards for data and code

Gareth B. Jenkins, Andrew P. Beckerman, Celine Bellard, Ana Benitez-Lopez, Aaron M. Ellison, Christopher G. Foote, Andrew L. Hufton, Marcus A. Lashley, Christopher J. Lortie, Zhaoxue Ma, Allen J. Moore, Shawn R. Narum, Johan Nilsson, Bridget O'Boyle, Diogo B. Provete, Orly Razgour, Loren Rieseberg, Cynthia Riginos, Luca Santini, Benjamin Sibbett, Pedro R. Peres-Neto

Summary: We urge journals to mandate archiving open data in a user-friendly format for readers. Consistent implementation will allow contributors to receive recognition through open data citation and promote scientific advancements.

ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

Article Ecology

Shrub density effects on the presence of an endangered lizard of the Carrizo Plain National Monument, California

Mario Zuliani, Nargol Ghazian, Malory Owen, Michael F. F. Westphal, H. Scott Butterfield, Christopher J. J. Lortie

Summary: Positive associations between animals and foundational shrub species are frequent in desert ecosystems. This study investigated the impact of shrub density on the presence and habitat use of the federally endangered lizard species, Gambelia sila. The findings suggest that both shrub density and shrub cover are key factors for some desert lizards.

ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

No Data Available