4.7 Article

Assessing the fishing footprint using data integrated from different tracking devices: Issues and opportunities

Journal

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS
Volume 69, Issue -, Pages 818-827

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCIENCE BV
DOI: 10.1016/j.ecolind.2016.04.043

Keywords

Fishing pressure indicators; Vessel monitoring system; Automatic identification system; VMS; AIS; Fisheries

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Different tracking devices are currently used to record the activity of fishing vessels in space and time and to analyse the pattern of fishing effort with respect to sea substrates, resources, or socio-economics factors. Among these devices, the Vessel Monitoring System (VMS) and the Automatic Identification System (AIS) represent the most interesting and fertile data sources for fisheries investigations but an integration of these two sources was never explored. Two large VMS and AIS datasets, covering the activity of the Italian fishing vessels with length-over-all >= 15 m for the whole year 2012, were used to perform the first assessment of the features characterizing each data source, and ultimately the properties of the estimators of ecological indicators of fishing pressure obtained using these data. In this way, a dataset related to five vessels equipped by a third high frequency device (the Fishing Observing System) was used as reference for a comparative analysis of fishing activity as reconstructed by VMS and/or AIS. Moreover, the ecological indicator 5 of fishing pressure as spatial extent of fishing activity (defined within the Data Collection Framework for Fisheries DCF) was used as a reference to test the separate and integrated usage of VMS and AIS data. Results evidenced important differences in spatial, temporal and fleet coverage between VMS and AIS. Namely, VMS is affected by a lower frequency with respect to AIS but covers a larger portion of the fleet. Furthermore, AIS mainly operates near the harbours, so that offshore activity is underrepresented. The integration of VMS and AIS data, however, allows valorising the strengths and minimizing the limits of each source. In fact, the assessment of the total spatial extent of fishing activities (as captured by the DCF indicator 5) is significantly improved by the integrated usage of VMS and AIS data. (C) 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Environmental Sciences

Scattered accumulation hotspots of macro-litter on the seafloor: Insights for mitigation actions

Alessandro Cau, Simone Franceschini, Davide Moccia, Pankaj A. Gorule, Blondine Agus, Andrea Bellodi, Rita Cannas, Laura Carugati, Danila Cuccu, Claudia Dessi, Martina F. Marongiu, Riccardo Melis, Antonello Mulas, Riccardo Porceddu, Cristina Porcu, Tommaso Russo, Maria Cristina Follesa

Summary: The analysis indicates that there is no temporal trend in the density and weight of seafloor macro-litter, but rather a spatial and bathymetric segregation of different litter categories. Different sources and physical features of macro-litter items lead to spatially segregated accumulation hotspots, with potential spots for future litter removal actions being shallower depths and closer to coastlines.

ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Disentangling beach litter pollution patterns to provide better guidelines for decision-making in coastal management

Lucio Brabo, Ryan Andrades, Simone Franceschini, Marcelo Oliveira Soares, Tommaso Russo, Tommaso Giarrizzo

Summary: This study assessed beach litter pollution in a prominent touristic site in Brazil and identified pollution hotspots and significant drivers using a delta-generalized additive modeling approach. The findings highlight the importance of factors such as beach extension, tourist attractions, wind angle, and distance to water bodies and villages in influencing the distribution of litter types.

MARINE POLLUTION BULLETIN (2022)

Article Fisheries

Little samplers, big fleet: eDNA metabarcoding from commercial trawlers enhances ocean monitoring

Giulia Maiello, Lorenzo Talarico, Paolo Carpentieri, Simone Franceschini, Lynsey R. Harper, Erika F. Neave, Olga Rickards, Alice Sbrana, Peter Shum, Virginia Veltre, Stefano Mariani, Tommaso Russo

Summary: This study tests an easy-to-use device for monitoring marine resources, which can quickly collect environmental DNA during normal fishing operations on bottom trawl fishing vessels. Through sample collection and genetic analysis, the study accurately identifies fish assemblages at different depths and discovers mesopelagic species that are not caught by bottom trawls. This promising method has the potential to be a valuable tool for monitoring catch composition, assessing stock distribution, and documenting changes in fish communities in the oceans.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Evaluation of the Economic Performance of Coastal Trawling off the Southern Coast of Sicily (Central Mediterranean Sea)

Federico Di Maio, Michele Luca Geraci, Danilo Scannella, Tommaso Russo, Fabio Fiorentino

Summary: This study analyzed the economic performances of four trawling fleets operating in the coastal waters along the southern coast of Sicily and potentially affected by the establishment of Fisheries Restricted Areas (FRAs). The results showed that two fleets had a short-term reduction in profits after the implementation of FRAs, while the other two fleets were expected to experience an increase in economic performances. Assessing the socio-economic impacts of the different fleets and planning compensatory measures are important considerations before adopting FRAs.

SUSTAINABILITY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Defend as You Can, React Quickly: The Effects of the COVID-19 Shock on a Large Fishery of the Mediterranean Sea

Tommaso Russo, Elena Catucci, Simone Franceschini, Lucio Labanchi, Simone Libralato, Evelina Carmen Sabatella, Rosaria Felicita Sabatella, Antonio Parisi, Fabio Fiorentino

Summary: This paper analyzes the impact of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus pandemic and related measures on the Italian fleet of trawlers and explores the influence of market and economic drivers on fishing effort and strategy. The results demonstrate that the consequences of the COVID-19 shock have been diverse, with some fishermen and their commercial network successfully mitigating the impact and returning catch and effort to previous levels.

FRONTIERS IN MARINE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

Ask the shark: blackmouth catshark (Galeus melastomus) as a sentinel of plastic waste on the seabed

Alice Sbrana, Alessandro Cau, Davide Cicala, Simone Franceschini, Tommaso Giarrizzo, Maria Flavia Gravina, Alessandro Ligas, Giulia Maiello, Marco Matiddi, Antonio Parisi, Paolo Sartor, Mario Sbrana, Umberto Scacco, Tommaso Valente, Claudio Viva, Tommaso Russo

Summary: The presence of plastic waste in the marine environment has raised concerns in the scientific community. Scientists have used the feeding habits of the blackmouth catshark to indirectly assess the accumulation of macroplastics on the seafloor. It was discovered that there is a significant relationship between the amount of macroplastics on the seabed and the frequency of plastic ingestion by the blackmouth catshark.

MARINE BIOLOGY (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Accounting for environmental and fishery management factors when standardizing CPUE data from a scientific survey: A case study for Nephrops norvegicus in the Pomo Pits area (Central Adriatic Sea)

Matteo Chiarini, Stefano Guicciardi, Silvia Angelini, Ian D. Tuck, Federica Grilli, Pierluigi Penna, Filippo Domenichetti, Giovanni Canduci, Andrea Belardinelli, Alberto Santojanni, Enrico Arneri, Nicoletta Milone, Damir Medvesek, Igor Isajlovic, Nedo Vrgoc, Michela Martinelli, Pierluigi Carbonara

Summary: This study investigated the spatial distribution and abundance of the Norway lobster Nephrops norvegicus in the Central Adriatic Sea, and how they are influenced by environmental and fishery variables. By standardizing Catch Per Unit Effort (CPUE), the variability not directly related to fish abundance was removed. Significant drivers of catch distribution were found to be bathymetry, fishing pressure, dissolved oxygen, and salinity. The predictions from this study provide valuable information for evaluating the status of this important marine resource.

PLOS ONE (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Looking for a Simple Assessment Tool for a Complex Task: Short-Term Evaluation of Changes in Fisheries Management Measures in the Pomo/Jabuka Pits Area (Central Adriatic Sea)

Matteo Chiarini, Stefano Guicciardi, Lorenzo Zacchetti, Filippo Domenichetti, Giovanni Canduci, Silvia Angelini, Andrea Belardinelli, Camilla Croci, Giordano Giuliani, Paolo Scarpini, Alberto Santojanni, Damir Medvesek, Igor Isajlovic, Nedo Vrgoc, Michela Martinelli

Summary: The Before-Intermediate-After Multiple Sites (BIAMS) analysis was used to evaluate the effects of fishery management measures in the Pomo/Jabuka Pits area. The analysis identified early effects on species abundance and inferred potential interactions among adjacent areas.

SUSTAINABILITY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Interactive effects of fishing effort reduction and climate change in a central Mediterranean fishing area: Insights from bio-economic indices derived from a dynamic food-web model

Davide Agnetta, Fabio Badalamenti, Francesco Colloca, Gianpiero Cossarini, Fabio Fiorentino, Germana Garofalo, Bernardo Patti, Carlo Pipitone, Tommaso Russo, Cosimo Solidoro, Simone Libralato

Summary: This study develops a calibrated dynamic model to evaluate the effects of mixed fisheries and climate change on the Sicily Channel food web. The results show that reducing bottom trawling effort has positive impacts on the biomass of many functional groups, but negative impacts on trawler's catches and economic incomes. However, in the long term, the biomass of commercial species recovers, making exploitation of marine resources more sustainable.

FRONTIERS IN MARINE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Detection of community-wide impacts of bottom trawl fishing on deep-sea assemblages using environmental DNA metabarcoding

Edward Good, Luke E. Holman, Antonio Pusceddu, Tommaso Russo, Marc Rius, Claudio Lo Iacono

Summary: Using environmental DNA (eDNA) and taxonomic identification of meiofauna communities, this study finds that benthic trawling has community-wide impacts on deep-sea assemblages, with different trawling intensities leading to distinct communities.

MARINE POLLUTION BULLETIN (2022)

Article Fisheries

Improving knowledge of Funiculina quadrangularis and vulnerable marine ecosystems in the south Adriatic

Vesna Macic, Nikola Dordevic, Mirko Durovic, Slavica Petovic, Tommaso Russo

Summary: The Adriatic Sea is highly exploited, but the South Adriatic Sea remains largely unexplored. Human impacts are causing loss of flagship species and threatening ecosystem functioning. Further research and international cooperation are needed to protect vulnerable species and areas.

MEDITERRANEAN MARINE SCIENCE (2022)

Review Environmental Sciences

Advancing fishery-independent stock assessments for the Norway lobster (Nephrops norvegicus) with new monitoring technologies

Jacopo Aguzzi, Damianos Chatzievangelou, Nathan J. Robinson, Nixon Bahamon, Alan Berry, Marc Carreras, Joan Batista Company, Corrado Costa, Joaquin del Rio Fernandez, Ahmad Falahzadeh, Spyros Fifas, Sascha Floegel, Jordi Grinyo, Jonas Pall Jonasson, Patrik Jonsson, Colm Lordan, Mathieu Lundy, Simone Marini, Michela Martinelli, Ivan Masmitja, Luca Mirimin, Atif Naseer, Joan Navarro, Narcis Palomeras, Giacomo Picardi, Cristina Silva, Sergio Stefanni, Maria Vigo, Yolanda Vila, Adrian Weetman, Jennifer Doyle

Summary: The article introduces how innovative ecological monitoring technologies can be used to improve the accuracy of stock assessments for the Norway lobster. By using robotic platforms, telemetry, environmental DNA, and Artificial Intelligence tools, it is possible to better observe and count the lobsters and their burrow systems, as well as provide important insights into their burrowing behavior.

FRONTIERS IN MARINE SCIENCE (2022)

Review Biology

Established and Emerging Research Trends in Norway Lobster, Nephrops norvegicus

Jacopo Aguzzi, Simona Violino, Corrado Costa, Nixon Bahamon, Joan Navarro, Damianos Chatzievangelou, Nathan. J. J. Robinson, Jennifer Doyle, Michela Martinelli, Colm Lordan, Joan. B. B. Company

Summary: This study used VOSviewer software to investigate the research status of Norway lobsters by analyzing scientific literature published in SCOPUS. The analysis revealed that research focused on fishery performance, biological cycles, and physiology and ecotoxicology. However, there is limited knowledge about how the burrowing behavior of Norway lobsters is influenced by environmental conditions and its impact on stock assessment, which may be due to the underutilization of advanced monitoring technologies.

BIOLOGY-BASEL (2023)

Article Fisheries

An approach to map and quantify the fishing effort of polyvalent passive gear fishing fleets using geospatial data

Nuno Henriques, Tommaso Russo, Luis Bentes, Pedro Monteiro, Antonio Parisi, Ramiro Magno, Frederico Oliveira, Karim Erzini, Jorge M. S. Goncalves

Summary: The use of tracking devices has allowed for an expansion in our understanding of fishing activities. This paper proposes a methodology to map and quantify the fishing effort of passive fishing gears used by a multi-gear fleet. This approach can be adapted to other passive fisheries and provides valuable information for improved management.

ICES JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Fisheries

Changes in Abundance and Distribution of the Sea Pen, Funiculina quadrangularis, in the Central Adriatic Sea (Mediterranean Basin) in Response to Variations in Trawling Intensity

Michela Martinelli, Lorenzo Zacchetti, Andrea Belardinelli, Filippo Domenichetti, Paolo Scarpini, Pierluigi Penna, Damir Medvesek, Igor Isajlovic, Nedo Vrgoc

Summary: Marine ecosystem is affected by bottom trawling in the exploitation of marine resources, therefore, management should consider sensitive species as indicators of ecosystem health. Epibenthic organisms, such as sea pens, are commonly used to assess benthic conditions, especially in areas with intense trawling activities. The nursery for European hake, Pomo/Jabuka Pits fishing ground, in the Adriatic Sea, is home to a small but dense population of Norway lobster and abundant pink shrimp. Through UnderWater TeleVision surveys conducted from 2012 to 2019, the abundance and distribution of Funiculina quadrangularis, a sea pen, were quantified in relation to changes in the spatial and temporal distribution of fishing efforts. The results showed that the closure of fisheries can lead to an increase in F. quadrangularis density, indicating the positive influence of management measures on epibenthic communities and the potential of sea pens as indicators of habitat impact and/or recovery.

FISHES (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Identification of critical ecological restoration and early warning regions in the five-lakes basin of central Yunnan

Yongcui Lan, Jinliang Wang, Qianwei Liu, Fang Liu, Lanfang Liu, Jie Li, Mengjia Luo

Summary: This study focuses on the five major plateau lake basins in central Yunnan, China, and constructs an ecological security pattern using the source-resistance surface-corridor-pinch point framework. The study simulates land use/cover change in the region and identifies early warning regions where future urban expansion poses a threat to current ecological source areas and corridors.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Active microeukaryotes hold clues of effects of global warming on benthic diversity and connectivity in the coastal sediments

Pingping Huang, Feng Zhao, Bailing Zhou, Kuidong Xu

Summary: This study investigates the distribution of benthic microeukaryotes in the China Seas and finds that they can stride over the ecological barrier of 32 degrees N. The study also highlights the significant influence of depth, temperature, and latitude on communities in the China Seas.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Which bird traits most affect the goodness-of-fit of species distribution models?

Federico Morelli, Yanina Benedetti, Jesse Stanford, Leszek Jerzak, Piotr Tryjanowski, Paolo Perna, Riccardo Santolini

Summary: Species distribution models (SDMs) are numerical tools used for predicting species' spatial distribution. This study found that ecological characteristics, such as habitat specialization, play a role in improving the accuracy of SDMs.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Exploring the spatiotemporal evolution dynamic and influencing factor of green ecology transition for megacities: A case study of Chengdu, China

Xiaoxuan Wu, Hang Liu, Wei Liu

Summary: Global climate change, urbanization, and economic development have increased the need for sustainable human development, urban ecological governance, and low-carbon energy transformation. This study analyzes the green ecological transition in Chengdu based on panel data from 2010 to 2020, exploring its spatiotemporal evolution and key factors. The results show an overall upward trend in Chengdu's green ecological development and positive spatial autocorrelation in certain districts.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

A multi-indicator approach to compare the sustainability of organic vs. integrated management of grape production

Castaldi Simona, Formicola Nicola, Mastrocicco Micol, Morales Rodriguez Carmen, Morelli Raffaella, Prodorutti Daniele, Vannini Andrea, Zanzotti Roberto

Summary: Sustainable agricultural practices are increasingly important for global and national environmental policies and economy. This study compared the sustainability of grape production under integrated and organic management using multiple indicators. The results showed that organic management was more beneficial for most environmental aspects of the agroecosystem compared to integrated management, without affecting grape yield.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Comparing ground below-canopy and satellite spectral data for an improved and integrated forest phenology monitoring system

Gaia Vaglio Laurin, Alexander Cotrina-Sanchez, Luca Belelli-Marchesini, Enrico Tomelleri, Giovanna Battipaglia, Claudia Cocozza, Francesco Niccoli, Jerzy Piotr Kabala, Damiano Gianelle, Loris Vescovo, Luca Da Ros, Riccardo Valentini

Summary: Phenology monitoring is important for understanding forest functioning and climate impacts. This research compares the phenological behavior of European beech forests using Tree-Talker (TT+) and Sentinel 2 satellite data. The study finds differences in the information derived by the two sensor types, particularly in terms of season length, phenology changepoints, and leaf period variability. TT+ with its higher temporal resolution demonstrates precision in capturing the phenological changepoints, especially when satellite image availability is limited.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Assessing the coupling coordination dynamics between land use intensity and ecosystem services in Shanxi's coalfields, China

Huanhuan Pan, Ziqiang Du, Zhitao Wu, Hong Zhang, Keming Ma

Summary: The land use and cover changes resulting from coal mining activities and ecological restoration have had a significant impact on ecosystem services in mining areas. This study investigates the relationship between ecosystem services and land use intensity in coal mining areas, emphasizing the importance of understanding this interdependence for balanced human-land system development. The research examines the evolving relationship across different reclamation stages in Shanxi, China, using a coupling coordination degree model. The findings suggest the need for timely and judicious reclamation of coalfields, considering the land's bearing capacity.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

An investigation on the impact of blue and green spatial pattern alterations on the urban thermal environment: A case study of Shanghai

Jingjuan He, Yijun Shi, Lihua Xu, Zhangwei Lu, Mao Feng

Summary: This study examines the spatial interplay between changes in the blue-green spatial distribution and modifications in land surface temperature grades in Shanghai. The findings reveal that the transformation of the blue-green spatial pattern differs between different sectors of the city, and the impact on the thermal environment varies spatially.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Prediction of phytoplankton biomass and identification of key influencing factors using interpretable machine learning models

Yi Xu, Di Zhang, Junqiang Lin, Qidong Peng, Xiaohui Lei, Tiantian Jin, Jia Wang, Ruifang Yuan

Summary: This study analyzed the response relationship between phytoplankton growth and water environmental parameters in the Middle Route of the South-to-North Water Diversion Project in China using long-term monitoring data and machine learning models. The results revealed the differences between monitoring sites and identified the key parameters that affect phytoplankton growth.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)