4.7 Article

Opposing effects of different soil organic matter fractions on crop yields

Journal

ECOLOGICAL APPLICATIONS
Volume 26, Issue 7, Pages 2072-2085

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1890/16-0024.1

Keywords

Africa; agroforestry; carbon; extracellular enzymes; legumes; microbes; soil organic matter

Funding

  1. NSF PIRE Grant [OISE-0968211]
  2. Lewis and Clark Fellowship
  3. Office Of The Director
  4. Office Of Internatl Science &Engineering [0968211] Funding Source: National Science Foundation

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Soil organic matter is critical to sustainable agriculture because it provides nutrients to crops as it decomposes and increases nutrient-and water-holding capacity when built up. Fast-and slow-cycling fractions of soil organic matter can have different impacts on crop production because fast-cycling fractions rapidly release nutrients for short-term plant growth and slow-cycling fractions bind nutrients that mineralize slowly and build up water-holding capacity. We explored the controls on these fractions in a tropical agroecosystem and their relationship to crop yields. We performed physical fractionation of soil organic matter from 48 farms and plots in western Kenya. We found that fast-cycling, particulate organic matter was positively related to crop yields, but did not have a strong effect, while slower-cycling, mineral-associated organic matter was negatively related to yields. Our finding that slower-cycling organic matter was negatively related to yield points to a need to revise the view that stabilization of organic matter positively impacts food security. Our results support a new paradigm that different soil organic matter fractions are controlled by different mechanisms, potentially leading to different relationships with management outcomes, like crop yield. Effectively managing soils for sustainable agriculture requires quantifying the effects of specific organic matter fractions on these outcomes.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Soil Science

Positive associations of soil organic matter and crop yields across a regional network of working farms

Emily E. Oldfield, Mark A. Bradford, Abigail J. Augarten, Eric T. Cooley, Amber M. Radatz, Timothy Radatz, Matthew D. Ruark

Summary: The increase in soil organic matter (SOM) is positively related to crop yields, although the growth tends to stabilize when SOM concentration reaches a certain level. Mineralizable C has a stronger relationship with crop yield than permanganate oxidizable C. In this region, mineral fertilizer, manure, and SOM show similar effects on crop yield, indicating that the combination of SOM and exogenous inputs plays an important role in agricultural productivity. The impact of SOM on crop yields varies depending on crop rotation.

SOIL SCIENCE SOCIETY OF AMERICA JOURNAL (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Estimating carbon storage in urban forests of New York City

Clara C. Pregitzer, Chloe Hanna, Sarah Charlop-Powers, Mark A. Bradford

Summary: Forests play a crucial role in mitigating the negative effects of climate change by absorbing carbon dioxide and storing carbon. Urban forested natural areas store significant amounts of carbon at rates similar to or higher than rural forests, with oak-dominated forests storing the most carbon. Our results suggest that natural area forests in cities are important for localized climate solutions and should be central to urban greening policies aiming to reduce the climate footprint of cities.

URBAN ECOSYSTEMS (2022)

Article Entomology

Myrmecochorous plants and their ant seed dispersers through successional stages in temperate cove forests

Mary Schultz, Robert J. Warren, James Costa, Beverly Collins, Mark Bradford

Summary: Anthropogenic disturbance can decrease woodland diversity, particularly impacting ant-dispersed plants. However, the abundance of myrmecochorous plants and their keystone seed-dispersing ants increases with time since the last disturbance. Moreover, the bait pattern and frequency do not significantly affect ant foraging interest.

ECOLOGICAL ENTOMOLOGY (2022)

Article Ecology

Diverging conditions of current and potential future urban forest patches

Danica A. Doroski, Mark A. Bradford, Marlyse C. Duguid, Richard A. Hallett, Clara C. Pregitzer, Mark S. Ashton

Summary: Forested natural areas in cities offer a variety of benefits, but understanding urban forest dynamics is crucial for managing these benefits. A study in New Haven, CT, found significant shifts in forest structure and composition within different patch sizes, with large patches dominated by native species, medium patches showing heterogeneity, and small patches playing a potential role as wildlife corridors.

ECOSPHERE (2022)

Review Ecology

Toward an improved understanding of causation in the ecological sciences

Ethan T. Addicott, Eli P. Fenichel, Mark A. Bradford, Malin L. Pinsky, Stephen A. Wood

Summary: Society increasingly calls for accurate predictions of complex ecosystem processes under new conditions to address environmental challenges. However, obtaining process-level knowledge for such predictions doesn't necessarily align with the prevalent use of correlative model selection criteria in ecology. Relying on information criteria may lead researchers to incorrect conclusions about cause-and-effect relationships. Bridging the gap between correlative inference and a process-based understanding of ecological systems is crucial.

FRONTIERS IN ECOLOGY AND THE ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Patterns and controls of aboveground litter inputs to temperate forests

Fiona Jevon, Alexander Polussa, Ashley K. Lang, J. William Munger, Stephen A. Wood, William R. Wieder, Mark A. Bradford

Summary: Aboveground litter production in forests is a crucial pathway for carbon and nutrient cycling, which is influenced by factors such as aboveground tree productivity, plant functional group, and climate. Climate and seasonality play a significant role in litter production, and there are notable differences in litter production between coniferous and deciduous forests.

BIOGEOCHEMISTRY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Coarse woody debris accelerates the decomposition of deadwood inputs across temperate forest

Mark A. Bradford, G. F. Ciska Veen, Ella M. Bradford, Kristofer R. Covey, Thomas W. Crowther, Nicholas Fields, Paul T. Frankson, Javier Gonzalez-Rivero, Fiona V. Jevon, Sara E. Kuebbing, Steven McBride, Jacqueline E. Mohan, Emily E. Oldfield, Angela M. Oliverio, Alexander Polussa, Corinna Steinrueck, Michael S. Strickland, Elisabeth B. Ward, Carl Wepking, Daniel S. Maynard

Summary: This study investigates the effect of downed coarse woody material (CWM) on the decomposition rates of fine woody material (FWM). The results show that the presence of CWM accelerates the decomposition of FWM, and this effect becomes stronger over time.

BIOGEOCHEMISTRY (2023)

Letter Ecology

Reply to Gilbert, Eyster, and Zipkin

Ethan T. Addicott, Eli P. Fenichel, Mark A. Bradford, Malin L. Pinsky, Stephen A. Wood

FRONTIERS IN ECOLOGY AND THE ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Biogenic factors explain soil carbon in paired urban and natural ecosystems worldwide

Manuel Delgado-Baquerizo, Pablo Garcia-Palacios, Mark A. Bradford, David J. Eldridge, Miguel Berdugo, Tadeo Saez-Sandino, Yu-Rong Liu, Fernando Alfaro, Sebastian Abades, Adebola R. Bamigboye, Felipe Bastida, Jose L. Blanco-Pastor, Jorge Duran, Juan J. Gaitan, Javier G. Illan, Tine Grebenc, Thulani P. Makhalanyane, Durgesh Kumar Jaiswal, Tina U. Nahberger, Gabriel F. Penaloza-Bojaca, Ana Rey, Alexandra Rodriguez, Christina Siebe, Alberto L. Teixido, Wei Sun, Pankaj Trivedi, Jay Prakash Verma, Ling Wang, Jianyong Wang, Tianxue Yang, Eli Zaady, Xiaobing Zhou, Xin-Quan Zhou, Cesar Plaza

Summary: This study compared soil samples from urban and natural ecosystems and found that the soil microbiome is an essential driver of soil carbon in urban greenspace under warming. This research is significant in highlighting the importance of considering the soil microbiome in urban management strategies to maintain soil carbon and related ecosystem services.

NATURE CLIMATE CHANGE (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Quantifying the Effects Sizes of Common Controls on Methane Emissions From an Ombrotrophic Peat Bog

M. A. Taylor, M. A. Bradford, W. Arnold, D. Takahashi, T. Colgan, V. Davis, D. Losos, J. Peccia, P. A. Raymond

Summary: Northern wetlands and bogs are significant sources of biogenic methane (CH4) emissions, which affect climate. Quantifying the effects of controls on bog CH4 emissions is challenging due to their spatial and temporal heterogeneity. To address this, we established 55 measurement plots with extensive spatial and temporal coverage in an ombrotrophic bog. Our data showed that temperature had the strongest control on CH4 emissions, while water table depth (WTD) and vegetation composition had smaller effects. Despite the large effect of temperature, the controls we measured explained only about 29% of the variance in CH4 fluxes. Highly-replicated, local designs can provide valuable data for refining our understanding of wetland CH4 emissions.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-BIOGEOSCIENCES (2023)

Article Soil Science

Optimizing Sampling Strategies for Near-Surface Soil Carbon Inventory: One Size Doesn't Fit All

Charles Bettigole, Juliana Hanle, Daniel A. Kane, Zoe Pagliaro, Shaylan Kolodney, Sylvana Szuhay, Miles Chandler, Eli Hersh, Stephen A. Wood, Bruno Basso, Douglas Jeffrey Goodwin, Shane Hardy, Zachary Wolf, Kristofer R. Covey

Summary: Soils, as the largest pool of terrestrial carbon, have lost significant stocks due to human activity. Changes in land management offer opportunities for large-scale carbon sequestration in soils. This study compares different sampling techniques for soil carbon inventory and finds that Conditioned Latin Hypercube Sampling (cLHS) and grid sampling are most efficient across various sites and strata sizes. The number of strata chosen in K-means stratification significantly affects sample efficiency, emphasizing the need for adaptive sampling methodologies.

SOIL SYSTEMS (2023)

Article Agronomy

Potential for biochar carbon sequestration from crop residues: A global spatially explicit assessment

Shivesh Kishore Karan, Dominic Woolf, Elias Sebastian Azzi, Cecilia Sundberg, Stephen A. Wood

Summary: Global warming requires urgent action to reduce and remove carbon dioxide emissions. Biochar, produced from crop residues, offers a promising solution for climate change mitigation. Using a high spatial resolution global dataset, it is found that crop residues generate approximately 2.4 Pg C annually. Taking into account limitations on residue harvesting and livestock usage, the global biochar production potential decreases to 0.51 Pg C/year. Twelve countries have the potential to sequester over one fifth of their current emissions through biochar production.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY BIOENERGY (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Depth-dependent effects of ericoid mycorrhizal shrubs on soil carbon and nitrogen pools are accentuated under arbuscular mycorrhizal trees

Elisabeth B. Ward, Alexander Polussa, Mark A. Bradford

Summary: Plant mycorrhizal associations impact the accumulation and persistence of soil organic matter, which can affect how ecosystems respond to global changes. The co-occurrence of trees and shrubs with different mycorrhizal associations can influence soil organic matter pools, but more research is needed to understand these effects.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Soil Science

Testing the feasibility of quantifying change in agricultural soil carbon stocks through empirical sampling

M. A. Bradford, L. Eash, A. Polussa, F. V. Jevon, S. E. Kuebbing, W. A. Hammac, S. Rosenzweig, E. E. Oldfield

Summary: There is disagreement about the potential of regenerative management practices to sequester enough soil organic carbon to mitigate climate change. This study evaluates the feasibility of quantifying change through sampling data from cropland fields and finds that higher sampling densities and field numbers can accurately quantify management effects on soil organic carbon change.

GEODERMA (2023)

No Data Available