4.6 Article

Kinetic characterization of microalgal-bacterial systems: Contributions of microalgae and heterotrophic bacteria to the oxygen balance in wastewater treatment

Journal

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL
Volume 165, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.bej.2020.107819

Keywords

Kinetic parameters; Microalgae-bacteria consortia; Photo-microbioreactor; Respirometry; Stoichiometric parameters; Wastewater

Funding

  1. DGAPA-UNAM (PAPIIT project) [IA100719]
  2. Fondo de Sustentabilidad Energetica SENER-CONACYT Mexico [247006]
  3. CONACYT [411041]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Metabolic activities of microalgae and heterotrophic bacteria were analyzed in terms of O-2 uptake and production rates to assess their contribution to the O-2 balance during wastewater treatment. Results showed that microalgae were the main O-2 consumers in the dark, while their oxygenation performance was superior to that of bacteria under light conditions.
Metabolic activities of microalgae and heterotrophic bacteria were characterized in terms of dissolved O-2 uptake and production rates under dark and light conditions, assessing the contribution of both microbial groups to the O-2 balance during wastewater treatment. Up to 13 kinetic and stoichiometric parameters were determined, allowing a quantitative description of the O-2 production and uptake dynamics. Under dark conditions, the maximum specific O-2 uptake rates for microalgae and bacteria were 14.73 +/- 2.02 mgO(2) gVSS(-1) h(-1) and 2.37 +/- 1.52 mgO(2) gVSS(-1) h(-1), respectively. Microalgae were therefore the largest O-2 consumers under dark conditions, being responsible for up to 86 % of the total heterotrophic respiration. Under light conditions (photosynthetic metabolism for microalgae and heterotrophic metabolism for bacteria), microalgae supported a maximum specific O-2 production rate of 13.76 +/- 1.48 mgO(2) gVSS(-1) h(-1), while bacteria supported a maximum specific O-2 uptake of 2.37 +/- 1.52 mgO(2) gVSS(-1) h(-1). The oxygenation performance of the microalgal community was therefore superior to the O-2 respiration of heterotrophic bacteria under light conditions. The kinetic characterization performed provides critical information about the photosynthetic oxygenation potential, microbial growth and heterotrophic O-2 uptake, which is essential for design, optimization, and modeling of wastewater treatment processes.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Environmental Sciences

Strategy for the formation of microalgae-bacteria aggregates in high-rate algal ponds

Antonio G. dos Santos Neto, Martin Barragan-Trinidad, Lourdinha Florencio, German Buitron

Summary: This work investigated the formation of aggregates used in wastewater treatment in high-rate algal ponds (HRAP). The study found that larger photogranules were observed in a continuous regime, and the protein fraction of extracellular polymeric substances played a crucial role in photogranules formation. Genetic sequencing also revealed the presence of different types of microalgae in the final biomass.

ENVIRONMENTAL TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

Study on manipulation of ruminal fermentation using a bioelectrochemical system

Mariana Aguilar-Gonzalez, German Buitron, Armando Shimada, Jorge Ayala-Sumuano, Laura Gonzalez-Davalos, Alfredo Varela-Echavarria, Ofelia Mora

Summary: The work aimed to modify the metabolic activity of rumen microorganisms by applying an electric potential, which resulted in enhanced production of acetate, propionate, and butyrate.

JOURNAL OF ANIMAL PHYSIOLOGY AND ANIMAL NUTRITION (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

Volatile Methyl Siloxanes as Key Biogas Pollutants: Occurrence, Impacts and Treatment Technologies

Laura Rivera-Montenegro, Edgardo Valenzuela, Armando Gonzalez-Sanchez, Raul Munoz, Guillermo Quijano

Summary: Volatile methyl siloxanes (VMS) generated from the metabolism of polydimethylsiloxanes (PDMS) in anaerobic digestion processes are biogas pollutants. In recent years, the widespread presence of VMS in different types of biogas has been demonstrated due to the intensive use of PDMS in various products. This review provides an overview of VMS concentrations in biogas, available physical-chemical technologies, and alternative biological processes for VMS removal. Critical research niches and challenges towards the consolidation of efficient and cost-effective VMS treatment systems are identified and discussed.

BIOENERGY RESEARCH (2023)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Wastewater treatment potential, light penetration profile and biomass settling performance of a photo-sequencing batch reactor

Alfonso Garcia, Edgardo Valenzuela, Alejandro Vargas, Ignacio de Godos, Raul Munoz, Meng Wang, Miguel Vital-Jacome, Guillermo Quijano

Summary: A photo-sequencing batch bioreactor (PSBR) was used to treat medium- and low-strength wastewaters, achieving a high removal efficiency of chemical oxygen demand. However, photoinhibition of nitrifying activity occurred under high irradiance conditions. A short settling time promoted the rapid formation of microalgal-bacterial aggregates (MABAs), and simulation of light penetration profiles proved to be a useful tool for identifying photoinhibition of nitrifying activity.

JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL TECHNOLOGY AND BIOTECHNOLOGY (2023)

Review Chemistry, Physical

Dark fermentation for H2 production from food waste and novel strategies for its enhancement

Edith Villanueva-Galindo, Miguel Vital-Jacome, Ivan Moreno-Andrade

Summary: Hydrogen can be produced from organic wastes through biological methods like dark fermentation, which have advantages in waste revalorization. However, the complex composition of food waste and the microbial dynamics involved in dark fermentation pose challenges to achieving maximum yields. Therefore, developing and evaluating novel strategies such as lactate-driven dark fermentation, bioaugmentation with native strains, metabolic engineering, and construction of synthetic microbiomes are innovative proposals to enhance H2 production from food waste.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HYDROGEN ENERGY (2023)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Label-free and portable field-effect sensor for monitoring RT-LAMP products to detect SARS-CoV-2 in wastewater

Bryan E. Alvarez-Serna, Roberto G. Ramirez-Chavarria, Elizabeth Castillo-Villanueva, Julian Carrillo-Reyes, Rosa Maria Ramirez-Zamora, German Buitron, Luis Alvarez-Icaza

Summary: The COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the importance of developing reliable and affordable technologies for pathogen detection in wastewater. In this study, a label-free and portable field-effect transistor (FET)-based sensor was introduced for detecting the N and ORF1ab genes of the SARS-CoV-2 genome. The sensor integrates reverse transcription loop-mediated isothermal amplification (RT-LAMP) reaction, achieving high specificity and cost-effectiveness. Real wastewater samples were used to evaluate the sensor, which demonstrated a limit of detection of 0.31 x 10-3 ng/mu L for end-point measurement. The sensor also showed real-time-like analysis capability, providing a good response after 15 min for concentrations as low as 0.37 ng/mu L. Therefore, the proposed EGFET sensor offers a powerful and straightforward method for detecting the presence of SARS-CoV-2 genome in wastewater.

TALANTA (2023)

Review Chemistry, Analytical

Degradation of viral RNA in wastewater complex matrix models and other standards for wastewater-based epidemiology: A review

Lizeth Parra-Arroyo, Manuel Martinez-Ruiz, Sofia Lucero, Mariel A. Oyervides-Munoz, Mollie Wilkinson, Elda M. Melchor-Martinez, Rafael G. Araujo, Karina G. Coronado-Apodaca, Hugo Velasco Bedran, German Buitron, Adalberto Noyola, Damia Barcelo, Hafiz M. N. Iqbal, Juan Eduardo Sosa-Hernandez, Roberto Parra-Saldivar

Summary: Wastewater-Based Epidemiology (WBE) is a powerful tool for pandemic surveillance, but the reliability of wastewater results is affected by numerous variables. More comprehensive models are needed to study viral RNA degradation in complex matrices, and wastewater indicators identified through analytical chemistry can be used as health indicators and to determine the initial viral RNA content.

TRAC-TRENDS IN ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Anaerobic methane oxidation: High-rate performance of a continuous bioreactor using nitrate and nitrite as electron acceptors

Jose A. Contreras, Edgardo I. Valenzuela, Patricia Bovio-Winkler, Claudia Etchebehere, Carmen Gabaldon, Guillermo Quijano

Summary: The anaerobic oxidation of methane coupled to denitrification (N-AOM) is a promising biotechnology for reducing the environmental impact of anaerobic effluents. In this study, a continuous N-AOM reactor was used to evaluate its performance, achieving methane elimination capacity values of 20-39 g m -3h- 1 with NO3- as the electron acceptor, and 48-61 g m -3h- 1 with a mixture of NO3- and NO2-. The pH value was found to be a critical factor influencing the process. Metagenomic analysis revealed potential metabolic mechanisms involved in N-AOM.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2023)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Automatic Analysis of Isothermal Amplification via Impedance Time-Constant-Domain Spectroscopy: A SARS-CoV-2 Case Study

Roberto G. Ramirez-Chavarria, Elizabeth Castillo-Villanueva, Bryan E. Alvarez-Serna, Julian Carrillo-Reyes, Lizeth Torres, Rosa Maria Ramirez-Zamora, German Buitron, Luis Alvarez-Icaza

Summary: The development of sensitive and affordable testing devices is crucial for public health protection, particularly in pandemics. This study presents an innovative method using electrochemical impedance measurements and the distribution of relaxation times model for monitoring genetic amplification products, specifically the RT-LAMP reaction. The method is successfully calibrated and demonstrated for SARS-CoV-2 detection in real wastewater samples, with a classification algorithm based on TCDS data to differentiate positive and negative samples. The TCDS-based approach offers a robust and specific mechanism for label-free and automated genetic detection assays.

CHEMOSENSORS (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

Metabolic Functional Profiles of Microbial Communities in Methane Production Systems Treating Winery Wastewater

Miguel Vital-Jacome, Julian Carrillo-Reyes, German Buitron

Summary: This study investigated the impact of process configuration and conditions on microbial communities and metabolic pathways in the anaerobic digestion of winery effluents. Four system configurations were analyzed for taxonomic and functional profiles using 16S rRNA gene sequencing and Tax4Fun2. The findings showed that different microbial communities and metabolic pathways were favored by different process configurations and conditions, highlighting the importance of assessing microbial functionality beyond their composition for the stability and performance of anaerobic digestion systems.

BIOENERGY RESEARCH (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Organic Leachate and Biogas Utilization in Outdoor Microalgae Cultivation Under Alkaline Conditions at Pilot-Scale

Antonio Velasco, Mariana Franco-Morgado, Alexis Saldivar, Yovany Cuetero-Martinez, German Buitron, Daniel de los Cobos-vasconcelos, Oscar Monroy, Armando Gonzalez-Sanchez

Summary: This study presents the performance of an outdoor pilot-scale system using a high rate algal pond interconnected to an absorption bubble column, which was seeded with a microalgal-bacterial consortium. Biogas and organic leachate were used as the sources of CO2 and nutrients, respectively. The system achieved high removal efficiencies for CO2 and H2S from biogas, but there was an accumulation of O2 due to microalgae photosynthesis. The biomass productivity was lower when using organic leachate compared to mineral salt medium, indicating limited nutrient bioavailability. The microalgal-bacterial community remained robust and stable throughout the operation of the system.

WASTE AND BIOMASS VALORIZATION (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Carbohydrates/acid ratios drives microbial communities and metabolic pathways during biohydrogen production from fermented agro-industrial wastewater

Valeria Fuentes-Santiago, Idania Valdez-Vazquez, Miguel Vital-Jacome, Marcela Zavala-Mendez, Elias Razo-Flores, Julian Carrillo-Reyes

Summary: The natural fermentation of agroindustrial effluents inhibits dark fermentation processes and reduces the availability of carbohydrates, competing with lactic acid bacteria. This study analyzed the effect of carbohydrates and lactate/acetate on hydrogen production, microbial dynamics, and metabolic pathways using model substrates and fermented agro-industrial wastewater. The results showed that lactic acid and acetate were preferred substrates for hydrogen production, achieving higher potential, rate, and yield compared to using only carbohydrates. The study also highlighted the importance of microbial interactions and metabolic profiles for the energetic valorization of fermented agroindustrial effluents through hydrogen production.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL CHEMICAL ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Biological CH4 production from H2/CO2 streams: Influence of trace metals concentration on the hydrogenotrophic process

Sigrid Mares, Ivan Moreno-Andrade, Guillermo Quijano

Summary: Hydrogenotrophic methanogens require trace metals for their metabolic activity, so the addition of these trace metals is necessary when using gas-phase bioreactors to produce methane from CO2 and H2 streams. This study investigated the kinetic effects of different concentrations of iron, zinc, molybdenum, cobalt, and nickel on hydrogenotrophic methane production. The dominant archaea in the culture were Methanolinea and Methanobacterium, with relative abundances of 67.16% and 28.15% respectively. The optimal concentrations of Fe, Zn, Mo, Co, and Ni were determined to be 1.479, 0.063, 0.011, 0.032, and 0.061 mg gVSS-1, respectively. Higher concentrations of trace metals led to inhibited performance in terms of lag phase duration, maximum methane production rate, and maximum volume of methane produced.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL CHEMICAL ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Removal of volatile methyl siloxanes in an anoxic two-phase partitioning bioreactor operated with hydrophobic biomass

Gratia Flores-Salgado, Jose A. Contreras, Jaime Perez-Trevilla, Guillermo Quijano

Summary: This study presents a next-generation two-phase partitioning bioreactor operated with hydrophobic biomass under anoxic conditions for the removal of volatile methyl siloxanes (VMS) commonly found in biogas. The addition of silicone oil boosted the reactor performance, resulting in improved removal efficiencies of octamethylcyclotetrasiloxane (D4) and decamethylcyclopentasiloxane (D5). Microbial attachment on the water/silicone oil interface was confirmed, and Mycobacterium was found to be the predominant genera attached to silicone oil.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2023)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Economic optimization of antibody capture through Protein A affinity nanofiber chromatography

Yiran Qu, Innocent Bekard, Ben Hunt, Jamie Black, Louis Fabri, Sally L. Gras, Sandra. E. Kentish

Summary: This study compares the performance of a nanofiber device and a resin column for antibody capture. The nanofiber device has a larger housing volume and lower binding capacity, but comparable eluate purity to the resin column. It shows high stability, can be used for multiple cycles, and maintains consistent eluate quality when scaled up. The use of a single nanofiber device can significantly reduce costs compared to a resin column, especially when the number of batches is limited.

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

A two-phase approach optimizing productivity for a mAb-producing CHO cell culture process using dynamic response surface methodology models

Brandon Moore, Christos Georgakis, Chris Antoniou, Sarwat Khattak

Summary: Fed-batch cell culture processes are commonly used in biomanufacturing due to their simplicity and applicability in cGMP environments. However, the challenge lies in the changing physiochemical conditions within the bioreactor as the cell density changes. Traditional response surface models (RSMs) are commonly used for optimization but are limited by their use of time-invariant factors. Dynamic RSM (DRSM) models can predict the time-dependent impact of process inputs, allowing for optimization of process operations that change over time.

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Adsorption of Pb(II) and Cu(II) by succinic anhydride-modified apple pomace

Lin Li, Yunfan Bai, Chuhua Qi, Yile Du, Xiaoxiao Ma, Yutong Li, Pingping Wu, Shuangli Chen, Sijing Zhang

Summary: A succinic anhydride-modified apple pomace (SAMAP) was synthesized to address environmental issues caused by the accumulation of apple pomace and effectively treat heavy metal ions. SAMAP exhibited high adsorption capacity for Cu(II) and Pb(II), suggesting its potential application in wastewater treatment.

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

A risk-aware assessment for buffer recycling across unit operations for monoclonal antibody purification and its potential

Peter Satzer

Summary: Water for injection (WFI) production in the biopharmaceutical industry consumes excessive amounts of water and energy. Recycling buffers can potentially save up to 90% of resources, but achieving the full theoretical potential is impossible when a risk-aware design is used. Universal risk-based assessment is important for regulatory authorities to consider the implementation of such a strategy.

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Expression of ATP-binding cassette transporter proteins AatA or MdlB facilitates butyric acid production in Clostridium tyrobutyricum

Gaoya Sun, Lingkai Jin, Guangxue Wang, Xiaoge Wang, Jin Huang

Summary: In this study, heterologous expression and homologous overexpression of ABC transporter proteins AatA and MdlB were found to improve butyric acid production in C. tyrobutyricum. The overexpression of these proteins upregulated the expression levels of key enzymes in the acetate synthesis pathway and promoted the synthesis and secretion of acetic acid. Additionally, the increase in ATPase activity facilitated sugar utilization, induced extracellular secretion of acetate, and shortened fermentation periods.

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Transition of stability of putidaredoxin reductase by introducing proline

Taiki Okamura, Rina Aritomi, Takuya Matsumoto, Ryosuke Yamada, Hidehiko Hirakawa, Hiroyasu Ogino

Summary: In this study, proline was introduced to improve the stability of putidaredoxin reductase (PdR) in the Pseudomonas putida cytochrome P450 system. It was found that PdR_T221P had a longer half-life at high temperatures compared to wild-type PdR, but a shorter half-life in the presence of methanol. Molecular dynamics simulations supported these findings.

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Iron-carbon micro-electrolysis material enhanced high-solid anaerobic digestion: Performance and microbial mechanism

Yuying Hu, Xiaofan Wang, Shihao Zhang, Zimu Liu, Tengfang Hu, Xin Wang, Xiaoming Peng, Hongling Dai, Jing Wu, Fengping Hu

Summary: This study investigates the effect of iron-carbon micro-electrolysis (ICME) materials on high-solid anaerobic digestion (HSAD). The results show that ICME materials promote methane production in HSAD by increasing the attachment area of microorganisms and facilitating symbiotic metabolism of certain bacterial species. This study provides new insights into microbial mechanisms and enhances our understanding of ICME material enhancement in HSAD.

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

A model-based approach for evaluating the effects of sludge rheology on methane production during high solid anaerobic digestion: Focusing on mass transfer resistance

Jibao Liu, Yufeng Xu, Yuansong Wei

Summary: This study investigated the role of sludge rheology in anaerobic digestion (AD) and found that rheological properties increased with the increase of solid content, resulting in a negative effect on methane production. An extended ADM1 model revealed that enhanced sludge rheological properties increased mass diffusion resistance and reduced uptake rate of acetate.

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Synergistic action of Acinetobacter baumannii and Talaromyces sp.: Function of enzymes in crude oil degradation

Xiaoyan Liu, Zongze Chen, Dewen Kong, Xinying Zhang, Chuanhua Wang, Yongqi Wang

Summary: This study explored the role of intracellular and extracellular enzymes of Acinetobacter baumannii and Talaromyces sp. in the degradation of crude oil. The extracellular enzymes of Talaromyces sp. were more effective in degrading n-alkanes, while those of Acinetobacter baumannii had a better effect on aromatic hydrocarbons. The degradation enzyme systems of both bacteria and fungi complemented each other, improving the overall degradation ability.

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Biochar enhances microbial degradation of phenol in water: Response surface optimization

Jing Dong, Lingli Xu, Yuxiang Liu, Li Ren, Ke Yuan

Summary: The utilization of biochar-immobilized microorganisms is an effective method for eliminating phenol from water. The high susceptibility of bacteria to environmental factors is a challenge for practical implementation. In this study, biochar was used to reduce microbial susceptibility and enhance phenol removal. The addition of biochar altered the dominant species of phenol-degrading bacteria and response surface analysis indicated the significant influence of biochar pyrolysis temperature and experimental temperature on phenol removal rate.

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Removal of metalloids and heavy metals from acid mine drainage using biosynthesized Fe/Cu NPs

Zibin Pan, Mengying Liu, Zuliang Chen

Summary: This study successfully removed metalloids and heavy metals from acid mine drainage (AMD) using bio-synthesized Fe/Cu nanoparticles (Fe/Cu NPs). The Fe/Cu NPs showed high removal capacities and the presence of organic substances contributed to their stability.

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Treatment of printing and dyeing wastewater using Fenton combined with ceramic microfiltration membrane bioreactor

Guangbing Liu, Han Zhang, Jincan Huang, Lu Zhang, Teng Zhang, Xuemin Yu, Weijing Liu, Chunkai Huang

Summary: This study investigated the effect of Fenton pre-treatment on the treatment efficiency of printing and dyeing wastewater (PDW) using two anaerobic/aerobic-membrane bioreactors (A/O-MBRs). The results showed that Fenton pre-treatment significantly improved the removal efficiency of COD and AOX in PDW, and reduced membrane fouling. The Shannon indices and metagenomics analysis indicated that the microbial diversity in anaerobic flocs was higher than that in aerobic flocs, and EC3.1.1.45 and pcaI were identified as key functional genes.

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Industrial internet of things: What does it mean for the bioprocess industries?

Lidia Borgosz, Duygu Dikicioglu

Summary: The Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) is a system that connects devices and provides real-time insight into industrial processes. However, the complexity and regulatory requirements of the biomanufacturing sector make it challenging to implement IIoT. There is a need for universal solutions to overcome this challenge and advance the field of biomanufacturing.

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Enhanced degradation of phenols and quinoline in coal gasification wastewater by iron-carbon multiple micro-electric field coupled with anaerobic co-digestion

Yajie Li, Weikang Kong, Yuyao Zhang, Huarui Zhou, Hongbo Liu, Salma Tabassum

Summary: In this study, the iron-carbon multi-micro electric field coupling anaerobic co-digestion technique was used to treat coal gasification wastewater (CGW). The experimental results showed that under optimal operating conditions, this technique can significantly reduce the toxicity of the wastewater and achieve high removal efficiencies. Additionally, the analysis of microbial communities revealed that the coupling system promotes direct interspecies electron transfer.

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Progressive pollution abatement in raw dairy wastewater induced by the algae Poterioochromonas malhamensis with a high-value biomass yield

Aparecido Nivaldo Modenes, Debora Gozzi Fernandes, Daniela Estelita Goes Trigueros, Matheus Guilherme Amador, Fernando Rodolfo Espinoza-Quinones, Taysa de Souza Braniz, Adilson Ricken Schuelter, Glacy Jaqueline da Silva, Lucimar Pereira Bonett

Summary: This study aimed to systematically remove organic pollutants from raw dairy wastewater with high concentrations of COD, TOC, and TN using Poterioochromonas malhamensis algae strains. The results showed that the biomass yield rate using FP-PBRs was 10% higher than tubular PBRs, and the organic pollution in wastewater was significantly reduced with a decrease of about 98% in COD, 95% in TN, and 92% in TOC.

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)