4.3 Article

Good fire, bad fire: It depends on who burns

Journal

FLORA
Volume 268, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER GMBH
DOI: 10.1016/j.flora.2020.151610

Keywords

Wildfire; Cerrado; Integrated fire management; Rainforest; Savanna; Biodiversity conservation

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Fire can be extremely harmful to sensitive ecosystems such as rainforests while maintaining the structure and composition of savanna environments. That is because historically, rainforest species have not been subjected to recurring fires requiring physiological and structural survival adaptations. In savannas, in turn, fire is a natural component that has shaped the species evolution for thousands of years. Natural lightning fires in savannas are usually of low intensity, more patchy, less extensive and have potential to control the fuel accumulation. On the other hand, wildfires, which usually occur late in the dry season and are caused by humans, are more intense, severe and extensive. Thus, fire exclusion policies in fire-prone ecosystems can trigger fire regimes that are incompatible with biodiversity conservation. From this perspective, environmental managers and policy makers have been looking for more efficient fire management practices in protected areas by introducing a more integrated and adaptive approach. The new practices have already shown significant results not only in reducing the areas hit by high severity fires but also in the costs involving firefighting operations. In this article, we discuss the dual character of fire and potential negative effects on biodiversity when presented under inappropriate regimes.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Environmental Sciences

An evaluation of contemporary savanna fire regimes in the Canastra National Park, Brazil: Outcomes of fire suppression policies

Eugenia Kelly Luciano Batista, Jeremy Russell-Smith, Helena Franca, Jose Eugenio Cortes Figueira

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2018)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Understanding Brazil's catastrophic fires: Causes, consequences and policy needed to prevent future tragedies

Vania R. Pivello, Ima Vieira, Alexander Christianini, Danilo Bandini Ribeiro, Luciana da Silva Menezes, Christian Niel Berlinck, Felipe P. L. Melo, Jose Antonio Marengo, Carlos Gustavo Tornquist, Walfrido Moraes Tomas, Gerhard E. Overbeck

Summary: The unprecedented wildfires in Brazil have caused immense damages and shocked the world. Understanding the causes and consequences is crucial for developing successful management strategies. Historical perceptions and policies related to fire use and management in Brazil also need to be examined. Our review aims to provide valuable insights for academics, environmental managers, and decision-and policy-makers to address the increasing fire outbreaks in Brazilian biomes.

PERSPECTIVES IN ECOLOGY AND CONSERVATION (2021)

Review Ecology

In Case of Fire, Escape or Die: A Trait-Based Approach for Identifying Animal Species Threatened by Fire

Eugenia K. L. Batista, Jose E. C. Figueira, Ricardo R. C. Solar, Cristiano S. de Azevedo, Marina V. Beirao, Christian N. Berlinck, Reuber A. Brandao, Flavio S. de Castro, Henrique C. Costa, Lilian M. Costa, Rodrigo M. Feitosa, Andre V. L. Freitas, Guilherme H. S. Freitas, Conrado A. B. Galdino, Jose E. Santos Junior, Felipe S. Leite, Leonardo Lopes, Sandra Ludwig, Maria C. do Nascimento, Daniel Negreiros, Yumi Oki, Henrique Paprocki, Lucas N. Perillo, Fernando A. Perini, Fernando M. Resende, Augusto H. B. Rosa, Luiz F. F. Salvador Jr, Larissa M. Silva, Luis F. Silveira, Og DeSouza, Emerson M. Vieira, Geraldo Wilson Fernandes

Summary: Recent studies suggest that changes in fire regimes pose a significant threat to global biodiversity in the 21st century. To accurately identify species most at risk from fire, it is important to consider their physiological, ecological, and evolutionary traits along with their local fire exposure. A framework was developed to assess vulnerability to fire-induced stress in the Brazilian savanna, incorporating exposure (frequency, extent, and magnitude of fire) and sensitivity (biological, physiological, and behavioral traits). The Fire Vulnerability Index (FVI) categorizes species into four groups based on their vulnerability, from extremely vulnerable to least vulnerable, highlighting the need for a broader assessment method considering both traits and local fire exposure.

FIRE-SWITZERLAND (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Historical survey of research related to fire management and fauna conservation in the world and in Brazil

Christian Niel Berlinck, Luanne Helena Augusto Lima, Elildo Alves Ribeiro de Carvalho Junior

Summary: Fire plays a key role in affecting biodiversity structure and composition, with its effects depending on various factors. Research shows limited focus on the impact of fire on fauna and mammals, indicating the need to strengthen research in fire ecology and mammal studies.

BIOTA NEOTROPICA (2021)

No Data Available