Gem and mineral identification using GL Gem Raman and comparison with other portable instruments

Several mainly silicate minerals in their gemstone varieties have been analysed by the Gem Raman portable system by Gemlab R&T, Vancouver, Canada, in order to ascertain the general performance of this relatively non-expensive tool developed exactly for the purpose of gemstone identification. The Raman spectra of gemstones acquired by this system have been subsequently critically compared with the data obtained by several other portable or handheld Raman instruments. The Raman spectra acquired with the Gem Raman instrument were typically of lesser quality when compared with the spectra taken by other instruments. Characteristic features such as steep baseline probably due to the fluorescence of the minerals, Raman bands much broader and therefore less resolved closely located Raman bands, and generally greater shifts of the band positions from the reference values were encountered. Some gemstone groups such as rubies did not provide useful Raman spectra at all. Nevertheless, general identification of gemstones was possible for a selection of gemstones.