4.4 Review

Resolving structure and function of metaorganisms through a holistic framework combining reductionist and integrative approaches

Journal

ZOOLOGY
Volume 133, Issue -, Pages 81-87

Publisher

ELSEVIER GMBH
DOI: 10.1016/j.zool.2019.02.007

Keywords

Reductionism; Integrative approach; Holobiont; Adaptation; Model system; Model organism; Aiptasia; Hydra; Nematostella

Categories

Funding

  1. Boden Research Conference: Australian Academy of Science, Great Barrier Reef Foundation
  2. Ian Potter Foundation [CRC 1182]
  3. German Research Foundation
  4. King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST)
  5. DFG
  6. Canadian Institute for Advanced Research (CIFAR)

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Current research highlights the importance of associated microbes in contributing to the functioning, health, and even adaptation of their animal, plant, and fungal hosts. As such, we are witnessing a shift in research that moves away from focusing on the eukaryotic host sensu stricto to research into the complex conglomerate of the host and its associated microorganisms (i.e., microbial eukaryotes, archaea, bacteria, and viruses), the so-called metaorganism, as the biological entity. While recent research supports and encourages the adoption of such an integrative view, it must be understood that microorganisms are not involved in all host processes and not all associated microorganisms are functionally important. As such, our intention here is to provide a critical review and evaluation of perspectives and limitations relevant to studying organisms in a metaorganism framework and the functional toolbox available to do so. We note that marker gene-guided approaches that primarily characterize microbial diversity are a first step in delineating associated microbes but are not sufficient to establish proof of their functional relevance. More sophisticated tools and experiments are necessary to reveal the specific functions of associated microbes. This can be accomplished through the study of metaorganisms in less complex environments, the targeted manipulation of microbial associates, or work at the mechanistic level with the toolbox available in model systems. We conclude that the metaorganism framework is a powerful new concept to help provide answers to longstanding biological questions such as the evolution and ecology of organismal complexity and the importance of organismal symbioses to ecosystem functioning. The intricacy of the metaorganism requires a holistic framework combining reductionist and integrative approaches to resolve the structure and function of its member species and to disclose the various roles that microorganisms play in the biology of their hosts.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Biodiversity Conservation

The effects of marine heatwaves on acute heat tolerance in corals

Magena R. Marzonie, Line K. Bay, David G. Bourne, Andrew S. Hoey, Samuel Matthews, Josephine J. Nielsen, Hugo B. Harrison

Summary: Scleractinian coral populations are facing increasing exposure to temperatures above their upper limits, leading to declines in coral reef ecosystem health. Variations in thermal tolerance exist among species, individual coral colonies, and populations. This study conducted heat stress experiments to assess heat tolerance across a large environmental gradient. The results showed variations in heat tolerance among species and within reefs, with mild heatwave exposure positively correlated with heat tolerance over the past 35 years, but recent severe heatwaves showing a negative relationship. These findings suggest that marine heatwaves are selecting for tolerant individuals and populations, but recent severe heatwaves may compromise this adaptive potential.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Ecology

Heating rate explains species-specific coral bleaching severity during a simulated marine heatwave

Defne Sahin, Verena Schoepf, Karen Filbee-Dexter, Damian P. Thomson, Ben Radford, Thomas Wernberg

Summary: Marine heatwaves are becoming more frequent due to climate change, causing stress and mortality in marine ecosystems, including coral reefs. The impact of heatwaves on coral bleaching sensitivity varies depending on species and heating rate. This study found that faster heating rates lead to more severe bleaching and decline in coral health, and the use of heating rate can enhance predictions of the local impact of heatwaves on coral ecosystems.

MARINE ECOLOGY PROGRESS SERIES (2023)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Disparate population and holobiont structure of pocilloporid corals across the Red Sea gradient demonstrate species-specific evolutionary trajectories

Carol Buitrago-Lopez, Anny Cardenas, Benjamin C. C. Hume, Thierry Gosselin, Fabian Staubach, Manuel Aranda, Daniel J. Barshis, Yvonne Sawall, Christian R. Voolstra

Summary: Global habitat degradation has increased the need to study genetic connectivity and diversity of marine biota in order to guide conservation efforts. This study examined the population structure and holobiont assemblage of two common pocilloporid corals across the Red Sea. The results showed evidence for limited population differentiation in P. verrucosa, but complex population structure and genetic differentiation in S. pistillata, along with differences in reproductive mode and genetic adaptation at various sites. The study highlights the importance of multispecies investigations and networks of reef reserves in conserving genetic variants critical to the future survival of coral ecosystems.

MOLECULAR ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Host transcriptomic plasticity and photosymbiotic fidelity underpin Pocillopora acclimatization across thermal regimes in the Pacific Ocean

Eric J. Armstrong, Julie Le-Hoang, Quentin Carradec, Jean-Marc Aury, Benjamin Noel, Benjamin C. C. Hume, Christian R. Voolstra, Julie Poulain, Caroline Belser, David A. Paz-Garcia, Corinne Cruaud, Karine Labadie, Corinne Da Silva, Cle'mentine Moulin, Emilie Boissin, Guillaume Bourdin, Guillaume Iwankow, Sarah Romac, Sylvain Agostini, Bernard Banaigs, Emmanuel Boss, Chris Bowler, Colomban de Vargas, Eric Douville, Michel Flores, Didier Forcioli, Paola Furla, Pierre E. Galand, Eric Gilson, Fabien Lombard, Stephane Pesant, Stephanie Reynaud, Matthew B. Sullivan, Shinichi Sunagawa, Olivier P. Thomas, Romain Trouble, Rebecca Vega Thurber, Didier Zoccola, Serge Planes, Denis Allemand, Patrick Wincker

Summary: Heat waves are causing declines in coral reefs globally. Coral thermal responses depend on multiple, interacting drivers, such as past thermal exposure, endosymbiont community composition, and host genotype. This study used DNA and RNA analysis to investigate gene expression patterns in Pocillopora corals across a historical thermal gradient, revealing the importance of host-photosymbiont specificity and host transcriptomic plasticity in thermal acclimatization.

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Building consensus around the assessment and interpretation of Symbiodiniaceae diversity

Sarah W. Davies, Matthew H. Gamache, Lauren I. Howe-Kerr, Nicola G. Kriefall, Andrew C. Baker, Anastazia T. Banaszak, Line Kolind Bay, Anthony J. Bellantuono, Debashish Bhattacharya, Cheong Xin Chan, Danielle C. Claar, Mary Alice Coffroth, Ross Cunning, Simon K. Davy, Javier del Campo, Erika M. Diaz-Almeyda, Jorg C. Frommlet, Lauren E. Fuess, Raul A. Gonzalez-Pech, Tamar L. Goulet, Kenneth D. Hoadley, Emily J. Howells, Benjamin C. C. Hume, Dustin W. Kemp, Carly D. Kenkel, Sheila A. Kitchen, Todd C. LaJeunesse, Senjie Lin, Shelby E. McIlroy, Ryan McMinds, Matthew R. Nitschke, Clinton A. Oakley, Raquel S. Peixoto, Carlos Prada, Hollie M. Putnam, Kate Quigley, Hannah G. Reich, James Davis Reimer, Mauricio Rodriguez-Lanetty, Stephanie M. Rosales, Osama S. Saad, Eugenia M. Sampayo, Scott R. Santos, Eiichi Shoguchi, Edward G. Smith, Michael Stat, Timothy G. Stephens, Marie E. Strader, David J. Suggett, Timothy D. Swain, Cawa Tran, Nikki Traylor-Knowles, Christian R. Voolstra, Mark E. Warner, Virginia M. Weis, Rachel M. Wright, Tingting Xiang, Hiroshi Yamashita, Maren Ziegler, Adrienne M. S. Correa, John Everett Parkinson

Summary: Genetic and functional variation in microeukaryotes can accumulate faster than morphological differences. Understanding the evolutionary history and ecology of such lineages requires examining diversity at multiple levels of organization. In the case of Symbiodiniaceae, molecular data have been used to describe phenotypes and make evolutionary inferences, but a lack of consensus among researchers has hindered progress in the field.

PEERJ (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Open science resources from the Tara Pacific expedition across coral reef and surface ocean ecosystems

Fabien Lombard, Guillaume Bourdin, Stephane Pesant, Sylvain Agostini, Alberto Baudena, Emilie Boissin, Nicolas Cassar, Megan Clampitt, Pascal Conan, Ophelie Da Silva, Celine Dimier, Eric Douville, Amanda Elineau, Jonathan Fin, J. Michel Flores, Jean-Francois Ghiglione, Benjamin C. C. Hume, Laetitia Jalabert, Seth G. John, Rachel L. Kelly, Ilan Koren, Yajuan Lin, Dominique Marie, Ryan McMinds, Zoe Meriguet, Nicolas Metzl, David A. Paz-Garcia, Maria Luiza Pedrotti, Julie Poulain, Mireille Pujo-Pay, Josephine Ras, Gilles Reverdin, Sarah Romac, Alice Rouan, Eric Roettinger, Assaf Vardi, Christian R. Voolstra, Clementine Moulin, Guillaume Iwankow, Bernard Banaigs, Chris Bowler, Colomban de Vargas, Didier Forcioli, Paola Furla, Pierre E. Galand, Eric Gilson, Stephanie Reynaud, Shinichi Sunagawa, Matthew B. Sullivan, Olivier P. Thomas, Romain Trouble, Rebecca Vega Thurber, Patrick Wincker, Didier Zoccola, Denis Allemand, Serge Planes, Emmanuel Boss, Gaby Gorsky

Summary: The Tara Pacific expedition conducted a comprehensive study of coral ecosystems in the Pacific Ocean from 2016 to 2018. The expedition collected nearly 58,000 samples from 32 islands, including corals, fish, plankton, and seawater, for advanced analysis. The methodology of the sampling process is described, and the different datasets generated by the expedition are made accessible. The released datasets provide valuable environmental context data and have the potential to address various scientific questions.

SCIENTIFIC DATA (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Integrative omics framework for characterization of coral reef ecosystems from the Tara Pacific expedition

Caroline Belser, Julie Poulain, Karine Labadie, Frederick Gavory, Adriana Alberti, Julie Guy, Quentin Carradec, Corinne Cruaud, Corinne Da Silva, Stefan Engelen, Paul Mielle, Aude Perdereau, Gaelle R. Samson, Shahinaz E. Gas, Christian R. Voolstra, Pierre E. Galand, J. Michel Flores, Benjamin C. C. Hume, Gabriela Perna, Maren Ziegler, Hans-Joachim Ruscheweyh, Emilie Boissin, Sarah Romac, Guillaume A. Bourdin, Guillaume Iwankow, Clementine Moulin, David A. Paz Garcia, Sylvain Agostini, Bernard Banaigs, Emmanuel Boss, Chris Bowler, Colomban de Vargas, Eric Douville, Didier Forcioli, Paola Furla, Eric Gilson, Fabien Lombard, Stephane P. Pesant, Stephanie Reynaud, Shinichi Sunagawa, Olivier Thomas, Romain Trouble, Rebecca Vega Thurber, Didier H. Zoccola, Claude Scarpelli, E' Krame Jacoby, Pedro Oliveira, Jean-Marc Aury, Denis Allemand, Serge Planes, Patrick Wincker

Summary: Coral reef science aims to understand coral health and resilience to combat reef loss caused by environmental stress. The intricate symbiotic interactions within the coral holobiont play a vital role in coral resilience. The Tara Pacific project utilizes advanced sequencing technologies to study the biodiversity and complexity of coral holobionts across the Pacific Ocean, providing valuable insights for future investigations of coral reef dynamics and their future in the Anthropocene.

SCIENTIFIC DATA (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Excess labile carbon promotes diazotroph abundance in heat-stressed octocorals

Nan Xiang, Achim Meyer, Claudia Pogoreutz, Nils Raedecker, Christian R. R. Voolstra, Christian Wild, Astrid Gaerdes

Summary: Nitrogen limitation is essential for stable coral-algal symbioses. Recent studies have shown that enrichment of labile dissolved organic carbon (DOC) or heat stress can increase the abundance and activity of diazotrophs, destabilizing the coral-algal symbiosis.

ROYAL SOCIETY OPEN SCIENCE (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Molecular insights into the Darwin paradox of coral reefs from the sea anemone Aiptasia

Guoxin Cui, Migle K. Konciute, Lorraine Ling, Luke Esau, Jean -Baptiste Raina, Baoda Han, Octavio R. Salazar, Jason S. Presnell, Nils Raedecker, Huawen Zhong, Jessica Menzies, Phillip A. Cleves, Yi Jin Liew, Cory J. Krediet, Val Sawiccy, Maha J. Cziesielski, Paul Guagliardo, Jeremy Bougoure, Mathieu Pernice, Heribert Hirt, Christian R. Voolstra, Virginia M. Weis, John R. Pringle, Manuel Aranda

Summary: Symbiotic cnidarians, such as corals and anemones, have evolved efficient molecular mechanisms for nutrient distribution and recycling in order to thrive in nutrient-poor ocean environments. Using the sea anemone Aiptasia, researchers have discovered that glucose and the presence of algae induce the up-regulation and relocalization of glucose and ammonium transporters, which are critical for symbiont functioning and organism-wide nitrogen assimilation. These findings provide insight into the molecular mechanisms underlying nitrogen conservation and recycling in symbiotic cnidarians.

SCIENCE ADVANCES (2023)

Article Ecology

Wound healing and regeneration in the reef building coral Acropora millepora

Jane Xu, Oliver Mead, Aurelie Moya, Cuneyt Caglar, David J. J. Miller, Marcin Adamski, Maja Adamska

Summary: Branching scleractinian corals are niche-constructing organisms with the ability to regenerate quickly. This study identified genes involved in the regeneration process and found similarity to genes involved in wound healing and regeneration in other species. Comparing results from different experimental conditions demonstrated the feasibility of using corals as experimental models in fundamental biology research.

FRONTIERS IN ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Rapid grain boundary diffusion in foraminifera tests biases paleotemperature records

Arthur Adams, Damien Daval, Lukas P. Baumgartner, Sylvain Bernard, Torsten Vennemann, Deyanira Cisneros-Lazaro, Jaroslaw Stolarski, Alain Baronnet, Olivier Grauby, Jinming Guo, Anders Meibom

Summary: According to isotope exchange experiments on foraminifera tests, the paleoseawater temperature record can be biased by up to 1 degrees C due to grain-boundary diffusion alone. The oxygen isotopic compositions of fossil foraminifera tests provide a continuous proxy record of deep-ocean and sea-surface temperatures over the past 120 million years. Through incubating foraminifera tests in O-18-enriched artificial seawater analogues, it has been shown that the oxygen isotopic composition of translucent calcite tests can be altered at low temperatures through rapid oxygen grain-boundary diffusion without visible ultrastructural changes.

COMMUNICATIONS EARTH & ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Effect of Gel Exposition on Calcium and Carbonate Ions Determines the Stm-l Effect on the Crystal Morphology of Calcium Carbonate

Miroslawa O. Rozycka, Klaudia Bielak, Maciej Ptak, Benjamin Jost, Gabriela Melo Rodriguez, Joachim Schoelkopf, Jaroslaw Stolarski, Piotr Dobryszycki, Andrzej Ozyhar

Summary: The biomineralization of fish otoliths is regulated by macromolecules, such as proteins, particularly intrinsically disordered proteins like the Starmaker-like protein. Bioinspired mineralization experiments were conducted to investigate the effects of this protein on calcium carbonate biominerals, considering prior exposure to calcium or carbonate ions. The presence of the Starmaker-like protein significantly affected the morphology and protein distribution within the crystals, highlighting the importance of environmental conditions on its action.

BIOMACROMOLECULES (2023)

Correction Marine & Freshwater Biology

Impacts of coral bleaching on pH and oxygen gradients across the coral concentration boundary layer: a microsensor study (vol 37, pg 1169, 2018)

Verena Schoepf, Christopher E. Cornwall, Svenja M. Pfeifer, Steven A. Carrion, Cinzia Alessi, Steeve Comeau, Malcolm T. Mcculloch

CORAL REEFS (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Corals at the edge of environmental limits: A new conceptual framework to re-define marginal and extreme coral communities

Verena Schoepf, Justin H. Baumann, Daniel J. Barshis, Nicola K. Browne, Emma F. Camp, Steeve Comeau, Christopher E. Cornwall, Hector M. Guzman, Bernhard Riegl, Riccardo Rodolfo-Metalpa, Brigitte Sommer

Summary: The worldwide decline of coral reefs has led to renewed interest in coral communities at the edge of environmental limits. These communities have potential to function as resilience hotspots and climate change refugia, providing insights into future coral reef conditions. However, inconsistent definitions and usage of terms like "marginal" and "extreme" have posed challenges for categorizing and synthesizing data about these poorly studied communities. Therefore, a new conceptual framework is proposed to redefine marginal and extreme coral communities based on environmental conditions and ecological criteria.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Correction Multidisciplinary Sciences

Deoxygenation lowers the thermal threshold of coral bleaching (vol 12, 18273, 2022)

Rachel Alderdice, Gabriela Perna, Anny Cardenas, Benjamin C. C. Hume, Martin Wolf, Michael Kuhl, Mathieu Pernice, David J. Suggett, Christian R. Voolstra

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2023)

No Data Available