4.2 Article

Seed sovereignty and agroecological scaling: two cases of seed recovery, conservation, and defense in Colombia

Journal

AGROECOLOGY AND SUSTAINABLE FOOD SYSTEMS
Volume 43, Issue 7-8, Pages 827-847

Publisher

TAYLOR & FRANCIS INC
DOI: 10.1080/21683565.2019.1578720

Keywords

Native and creole seeds; seed custodians; seed systems; depth scaling; agroecology

Funding

  1. Red de Semillas Libres de Colombia
  2. CONACyT

Ask authors/readers for more resources

By evaluating two grassroots organizations that belong to the Red de Semillas Libres de Colombia (RSLC; Free Seed Network of Colombia), we show how the recovery, conservation, and defense of native and creole seeds have two types of effects on agroecological scaling. The first is a horizontal or scaling out effect, given that these activities involve the adoption of agroecological practices which allow for spreading knowledge, principles, and practices among seed custodians, their local communities and organizations, and the networks of these organizations. The second is a deepening effect, given that: 1) seed custodianship reaffirms and/or generates new peasant and indigenous identities and ways of life; 2) seed recovery, conservation, and defense conform a multi-dimensional process that is material, political, and symbolic, which provides cultural and territorial rootedness, and 3) strengthening of the social-organizational fabric through collective actions and strategies by seed custodians in their territories in defense of native and creole seeds. These processes propitiate fertile conditions for scaling peasant agroecology and contribute to the construction of seed sovereignty, which is an essential aspect of struggles to preserve and reproduce and native and creole seeds.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.2
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Pensamiento Latinoamericano Agroecologico: the emergence of a critical Latin American agroecology?

Peter M. Rosset, Lia Pinheiro Barbosa, Valentin Val, Nils McCune

Summary: Latin America is recognized for its social movement organization and innovation, as well as dialogues among different types of knowledge. A specifically Latin American agroecology has emerged from these dynamics, which is politically charged and popularly organized. A survey of selected Latin American agroecologists is used to evaluate the existence and characteristics of such a critical Latin American agroecology.

AGROECOLOGY AND SUSTAINABLE FOOD SYSTEMS (2021)

Article International Relations

Critical Latin American agroecology as a regionalism from below

Peter M. Rosset, Lia Pinheiro Barbosa, Valentin Val, Nils McCune

Summary: Latin America has been a hub for social movements and innovation, fostering dialogue between different types of knowledge. A specifically Latin American agroecology has emerged as a form of regionalism from below, uniquely influenced by Latin American rural movements, intellectuals, and scientists, with a foundation in Critical Latin American Thought.

GLOBALIZATIONS (2022)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Agroecology from the ground up: a critical analysis of sustainable soil management in the highlands of Guatemala

Nathan Einbinder, Helda Morales, Mateo Mier y Teran Gimenez Cacho, Bruce G. Ferguson, Miriam Aldasoro, Ronald Nigh

Summary: A persistent problem in agricultural development is the disregard for local processes and cultures when introducing technologies. This article analyzes the agroecological soil management in the Maya-Achi territory of Guatemala, highlighting the importance of incorporating traditional knowledge and practices into sustainable farming systems. While some new practices have been adopted, the high abandonment rates and paternalistic extension methods suggest the need for better collaboration based on existing local knowledge. The findings emphasize the importance of introducing technologies that align with local needs and encourage synergistic learning processes.

AGRICULTURE AND HUMAN VALUES (2022)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Building an agroecological model to understand the effects of agrochemical subsidies on farmer decisions

David Bernal Hoyo, Omar Felipe Giraldo, Peter Rosset M, Oliver Lopez Corona, Julian Perez Cassarino, Sunil Nautiyal

Summary: This study presents a simple simulation model to explore the effects of agrochemical subsidies on farmers' decisions about their plots. The model suggests that using agrochemicals may lead to an unstable pattern in the economic and ecological balance, resulting in negative consequences for household savings and production.

AGROECOLOGY AND SUSTAINABLE FOOD SYSTEMS (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

Peasant Resilience: Decolonization and Re-conceptualization

Teresita Santiago Vera, Peter Michael Rosset, Antonio Saldivar Moreno, Victor Ernesto Mendez

Summary: The objective of this article is to re-examine and begin to decolonize the concept of resilience from a peasant perspective. The concept of resilience must be reformulated based on an understanding of the peasant condition, informed by decolonial thought, and with methodologies for epistemic decolonization. Peasant resilience is significantly related to relative autonomy.

ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

Social principles of emancipatory agroecologies

Omar Felipe Giraldo, Peter Michael Rosset

Summary: This article critiques the attempts to institutionalize agroecology and argues for the radical political, economic, organizational, methodological, pedagogical and philosophical differences between false agroecologies and emancipatory agroecologies. The principles presented in the article aim to guide the building of truly transformative and revolutionary agroecological processes, emphasizing the importance of questioning structures, shaping economies based on use value, and building capacity to struggle and transform.

DESENVOLVIMENTO E MEIO AMBIENTE (2021)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

From rainforest to table: Lacandon Maya women are critical to diversify landscapes and diets in Lacanja Chansayab, Mexico

Lucia Perez-Volkow, Stewart A. W. Diemont, Theresa Selfa, Helda Morales, Alejandro Casas

Summary: This study investigated the role of women in the food system in Lacanja Chansayab, Mexico. The research found that women play a central role in the kitchenspace, possessing intricate knowledge of their environment and playing key roles in the production, obtaining, and transformation of biodiversity. Traditional food is crucial for maintaining biocultural memory and establishing relationships with other-than-human beings. However, serving traditional foods can also lead to discrimination against their families, even from within their own community.

AGRICULTURE AND HUMAN VALUES (2023)

Article Anthropology

Emancipatory agroecologies: social and political principles

Omar Felipe Giraldo, Peter Michael Rosset

Summary: This article examines how government policies, international agency projects, and many NGOs strip agroecology of its potential for emancipation. They reinforce or create dependencies, individualize communities, convert use values into exchange values, incorporate people into hierarchical structures of domination, promote the belief that people must be saved from poverty through the intervention of a benefactor, and promote acting based on capitalist economic rationality. On the other hand, emancipatory agroecologies are radically transformative processes summarized in seven principles.

JOURNAL OF PEASANT STUDIES (2023)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Campesino a Campesino (peasant to peasant) processes versus conventional extension: a comparative model to examine agroecological scaling

David Bernal, Omar Felipe Giraldo, Peter M. M. Rosset, Oliver Lopez-Corona, Julian Perez-Cassarino

Summary: An important question in agroecology is how to achieve scaling through social process methodology. The Campesino a Campesino (CaC) methodology has achieved great success in multiplying agroecological practices among peasants, but many experiences still rely on the conventional extension model of technical assistance. CaC, on the other hand, establishes a network of farmers who share their own practices, with the technician acting as a facilitator. In this article, a model based on the experience of the National Association of Small Farmers (ANAP) in Cuba is presented, comparing CaC with conventional extension and exploring the properties that make CaC a more effective, less costly, and more dynamic methodology for scaling agroecology.

AGROECOLOGY AND SUSTAINABLE FOOD SYSTEMS (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

Raising native bees: an agroecological pedagogy with roots

Yorlis Luna Delgado, Elda Miriam Aldasoro Maya, Eric Vides Borrel, Helda Morales, Peter Rosset

Summary: This paper explores how the breeding of native bees in Nicaragua promotes the learning of agroecology. It is found that the breeding of native stingless bees serves as a motivating factor for adopting agroecological principles.

REVISTA BRASILEIRA DE EDUCACAO DO CAMPO-BRAZILIAN JOURNAL OF RURAL EDUCATION (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Food Sovereignty and Food Security: Livelihood Strategies Pursued by Farmers during the Maize Monoculture Boom in Northern Thailand

Sayamol Charoenratana, Cholnapa Anukul, Peter M. Rosset

Summary: Northern Thailand is facing controversies over changing cropping patterns, particularly caused by the expansion of maize monocropping by peasant farmers. Various alternative development programs have been introduced to address illegal crops substitution and environmental issues. Different livelihood strategies can be pursued by peasant families, with food sovereignty and mixed strategies showing greater benefits but limited by land tenure security and community resource management.

SUSTAINABILITY (2021)

No Data Available