4.7 Article

Site-specific carbon footprints of Scandinavian wastewater treatment plants, using the life cycle assessment approach

Journal

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION
Volume 211, Issue -, Pages 1001-1014

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.11.200

Keywords

Methane emissions; Nitrous oxide emissions; Emission factors; Environmental assessment; EASETECH; Greenhouse gas reporting

Funding

  1. Innovation Fund Denmark (IFD) (Project LaGAS) [0603-00523B]
  2. Veolia Water Technologies (Kruger, AnoxKaldnes, The Veolia Group)
  3. Unisense Environment, DK
  4. Fluxsense

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The carbon footprints of seven wastewater treatment plants using different technologies in Denmark and Sweden were evaluated. The life cycle assessment approach was applied by using site-specific data including measured plant-integrated methane and nitrous oxide emissions. Four different functional units were adopted: 1 Mg of input material entering the wastewater treatment plant in 2015, and the removal of 1 kg of carbon, total nitrogen and phosphorus. The net carbon footprint values found in this study were between 0.15 and 0.66 kg CO2 (eq) (Mg of input material)(-1) depending on the treatment facility. Direct greenhouse gas emissions were the main contributors to the carbon footprint, accounting for between 44 and 71% of the total burden. The remaining share of the total burden (66 and 29%) was mainly made by energy consumption, chemicals used, and emissions from effluent and land application of biosolids. Direct greenhouse gas emissions were very sensitive model parameters driving result uncertainties. When default values from emission reporting guidelines were applied instead of measured greenhouse gas emission rates, the net carbon footprint was up to four times smaller or seven times larger. The consumption of electricity from the energy grid for plant operation had a great impact on the carbon footprint, due to differences between the energy systems. The share of electricity consumption to the total carbon footprint burden for the Swedish plants was only 2%, whereas it was between 16 and 28% for the Danish plants. This difference was due to the smaller carbon footprint potential of the electricity mix in Sweden than in Denmark. Normalisation of the carbon footprint to the plant pollution load, and the calculation of model uncertainty, allowed for a reliable comparison of plants operating within the same energy system. Finally, suggestions were provided for performing a sound carbon footprint evaluation of wastewater treatment plants. (C) 2018 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Engineering, Environmental

Methane emission dynamics from a Danish landfill: The effect of changes in barometric pressure

K. Kissas, A. Ibrom, P. Kjeldsen, C. Scheutz

Summary: This study investigates the temporal variability of methane emissions from an old landfill in Denmark, caused by changes in barometric pressure. Two different quantification techniques were used simultaneously and their results were compared. The study found significant spatial and temporal variations in methane emissions, influenced by changes in barometric pressure and wind speed. The study also identified seasonal variations in emissions, but no diurnal variability was observed.

WASTE MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Efficiency of gas collection systems at Danish landfills and implications for regulations

Zhenhan Duan, Peter Kjeldsen, Charlotte Scheutz

Summary: Landfills are a significant source of anthropogenic methane emissions globally. This paper examines the gas collection efficiencies of 23 Danish landfills and proposes using these values to regulate methane emissions in Denmark. The study finds that the gas collection efficiency in Danish landfills is lower than in Swedish, UK and US landfills, potentially due to factors such as shallow gas collection pipes, leakage from installations, and low gas production. It suggests using gas collection efficiency as a regulatory tool to achieve methane mitigation goals in landfills.

WASTE MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Methane emissions from Icelandic landfills - A comparison between measured and modelled emissions

C. Scheutz, A. Kjeld, A. M. Fredenslund

Summary: This study compares methane emissions from five Icelandic landfills and finds that the application of the IPCC FOD model for estimating landfill methane emissions in Iceland is appropriate.

WASTE MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Quantification of methane emissions from cattle farms, using the tracer gas dispersion method

Nathalia T. Vechi, Johan Mellqvist, Charlotte Scheutz

Summary: In Denmark, agriculture, particularly cattle farming, is the largest contributor to anthropogenic methane emissions. Methane emissions were measured at nine Danish cattle farms and found to be highest at locations with the highest number of animals. Results showed that current inventory models underestimate methane emissions, suggesting a need for improvements, especially in estimating emissions from beef cattle and manure management.

AGRICULTURE ECOSYSTEMS & ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Annual upscaling of methane emission field measurements from two Danish landfills, using empirical emission models

K. Kissas, A. Ibrom, P. Kjeldsen, C. Scheutz

Summary: An empirical model was developed to estimate annual methane emissions from Danish landfills. The model accurately predicts short-term emission variability and addresses temporal variability caused by barometric pressure. The results show that emissions vary between different landfills and propose an optimized sampling strategy.

WASTE MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Agronomy

Determination of methane emissions from biogas plants, using different quantification methods

Marlies Hrad, Marion Huber-Humer, Torsten Reinelt, Bernhard Spangl, Claudia Flandorfer, Fabrizio Innocenti, Johan Yngvesson, Anders Fredenslund, Charlotte Scheutz

Summary: This study compared and validated the quantification of methane emissions using different methods at agricultural biogas plants. The results showed that on-site methods underestimated overall emissions, while off-site methods were more accurate. The study also highlighted the comparability of the methods between different plants.

AGRICULTURAL AND FOREST METEOROLOGY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Ammonia and methane emissions from dairy concentrated animal feeding operations in California, using mobile optical remote sensing

N. T. Vechi, J. Mellqvist, J. Samuelsson, B. Offerle, C. Scheutz

Summary: Dairy CAFOs in the San Joaquin Valley, California are significant sources of methane and ammonia emissions. Optical techniques using SOF and MeFTIR were employed to measure NH3 and CH4 concentrations. The NH3 emission rates were 101.9 +/- 40.6 kgNH3/h and CH4 emission rates were 437.7 +/- 202.0 kgCH4/h. NH3 emissions showed a diurnal pattern with lower nighttime emissions. Measured NH3 and CH4 emissions were higher than reported rates, but similar to airborne measurements. These new measurement methods provide high-resolution quantification of emissions over large areas.

ATMOSPHERIC ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Methane emissions from five Danish pig farms: Mitigation strategies and inventory estimated emissions

Nathalia T. Vechi, Nina S. Jensen, Charlotte Scheutz

Summary: This study investigated methane emissions from different pig farms in Denmark and compared them with inventory emission models. The results showed that manure management practices and pig types have an impact on methane emissions, and the inventory models underestimated the actual measurements.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Engineering, Environmental

The effect of barometric pressure changes on the performance of a passive biocover system, Skellingsted landfill, Denmark

K. Kissas, P. Kjeldsen, A. Ibrom, C. Scheutz

Summary: This study examined the performance of a passive biocover system at a Danish landfill. The effectiveness of the system was assessed by comparing methane emissions before and after biocover installation. It was found that the performance of the biocover system was influenced by barometric pressure changes, with higher oxidation efficiency achieved under increasing pressure.

WASTE MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

The Danish national effort to minimise methane emissions from biogas plants

Anders Michael Fredenslund, Einar Gudmundsson, Julie Maria Falk, Charlotte Scheutz

Summary: This study involved 69 biogas plants in Denmark, which represented 59% of the country's biogas production, in an effort to reduce methane emissions. Various measurements and assessments were conducted to determine emission rates, sources, and potential mitigation strategies. The findings showed variations in emission rates and losses between different types of plants, with pressure relief valves being a commonly observed source of leakage. The study also determined a national emission factor for Danish biogas production and demonstrated the effectiveness of mitigating actions in reducing emissions.

WASTE MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Methane losses from different biogas plant technologies

Viktoria Wechselberger, Torsten Reinelt, Johan Yngvesson, Deborah Scharfy, Charlotte Scheutz, Marion Huber-Humer, Marlies Hrad

Summary: This study investigates the methane (CH4) emissions from various biogas plant technologies in Austria, Germany, Sweden, and Switzerland. The results provide emission factors (EFs) for different components of biogas plants, helping to estimate emissions more accurately and identify low emission technologies.

WASTE MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Environmental assessment of landfill gas mitigation using biocover and gas collection with energy utilisation at aging landfills

C. Scheutz, Z. Duan, J. Moller, P. Kjeldsen

Summary: A life cycle-based environmental assessment was conducted to evaluate the mitigation of landfill gas emissions using biocover and gas collection with energy utilisation at aging landfills. The study found that biocover and gas collection systems with energy utilisation led to significant environmental improvements compared to the baseline scenario with no emission mitigation action. Scenarios representing biocovers with higher methane oxidation efficiencies were environmentally superior in terms of climate change impact compared to scenarios with longer gas collection and energy utilisation. Combining gas collection with energy utilisation and the subsequent installation of a biocover provided major improvements compared to scenarios with only gas collection and energy utilisation. It was concluded that a biocover, under the given assumptions, is more environmentally appropriate than gas collection and utilisation at aging landfills due to methane emissions escaping through the landfill cover.

WASTE MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Agricultural Engineering

Measurements of methane emissions from manure tanks, using a stationary tracer gas dispersion method

Nathalia T. Vechi, Charlotte Scheutz

Summary: This study developed a new approach, the stationary tracer dispersion method (STDM), to measure methane emissions from farm-scale manure storage tanks. The method was validated through controlled gas release experiments and showed a relatively stable methane recovery rate. The study also found a strong correlation between methane emissions and atmospheric and manure temperatures.

BIOSYSTEMS ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Methane and ethane emission quantifications from onshore oil and gas sites in Romania, using a tracer gas dispersion method

Antonio Delre, Arjan Hensen, Ilona Velzeboer, Pim van den Bulk, Maklawe Essonanawe Edjabou, Charlotte Scheutz

Summary: This study quantified the site-specific methane and ethane emission rates from the onshore oil and gas sector in Romania using the mobile tracer gas dispersion method. The results showed that the emission rates varied among different sites and regions, with methane emissions being negatively correlated to wastewater production and ethane emissions being relatively low compared to literature values.

ELEMENTA-SCIENCE OF THE ANTHROPOCENE (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Relative evaluation of probabilistic methods for spatio-temporal wind forecasting

Lars odegaard Bentsen, Narada Dilp Warakagoda, Roy Stenbro, Paal Engelstad

Summary: This study investigates uncertainty modeling in wind power forecasting using different parametric and non-parametric methods. Johnson's SU distribution is found to outperform Gaussian distributions in predicting wind power. This research contributes to the literature by introducing Johnson's SU distribution as a candidate for probabilistic wind forecasting.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Comparison of ethane recovery processes for lean gas based on a coupled model

Xing Liu, Qiuchen Wang, Yunhao Wen, Long Li, Xinfang Zhang, Yi Wang

Summary: This study analyzes the characteristics of process parameters in three lean gas ethane recovery processes and establishes a prediction and multiobjective optimization model for ethane recovery and system energy consumption. A new method for comparing ethane recovery processes for lean gas is proposed, and the addition of extra coolers improves the ethane recovery. The support vector regression model based on grey wolf optimization demonstrates the highest prediction accuracy, and the multiobjective multiverse optimization algorithm shows the best optimization performance and diversity in the solutions.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

A novel deep-learning framework for short-term prediction of cooling load in public buildings

Cairong Song, Haidong Yang, Xian-Bing Meng, Pan Yang, Jianyang Cai, Hao Bao, Kangkang Xu

Summary: The paper proposes a novel deep learning-based prediction framework, aTCN-LSTM, for accurate cooling load predictions. The framework utilizes a gate-controlled multi-head temporal convolutional network and a sparse probabilistic self-attention mechanism with a bidirectional long short-term memory network to capture both temporal and long-term dependencies in the cooling load sequences. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness and superiority of the proposed method, which can serve as an effective guide for HVAC chiller scheduling and demand management initiatives.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

The impact of social interaction and information acquisition on the adoption of soil and water conservation technology by farmers: Evidence from the Loess Plateau, China

Zhe Chen, Xiaojing Li, Xianli Xia, Jizhou Zhang

Summary: This study uses survey data from the Loess Plateau in China to evaluate the impact of social interaction on the adoption of soil and water conservation (SWC) technology by farmers. The study finds that social interaction increases the likelihood of farmers adopting SWC, and internet use moderates this effect. The positive impact of social interaction on SWC adoption is more pronounced for farmers in larger villages and those who join cooperative societies.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2024)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Study on synergistic heat transfer enhancement and adaptive control behavior of baffle under sudden change of inlet velocity in a micro combustor

Chenghua Zhang, Yunfei Yan, Kaiming Shen, Zongguo Xue, Jingxiang You, Yonghong Wu, Ziqiang He

Summary: This paper reports a novel method that significantly improves combustion performance, including heat transfer enhancement under steady-state conditions and adaptive stable flame regulation under velocity sudden increase.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2024)