4.7 Article

Searching for geomagnetic spikes in numerical dynamo simulations

Journal

EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS
Volume 504, Issue -, Pages 72-83

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCIENCE BV
DOI: 10.1016/j.epsl.2018.09.037

Keywords

geodynamo simulations; secular variation; geomagnetic spikes; Earth's core

Funding

  1. Natural Environment Research Council [NE/L011328/1]
  2. US National Science Foundation [EAR1623786]
  3. NERC [NE/L011328/1] Funding Source: UKRI

Ask authors/readers for more resources

We use numerical dynamo simulations to investigate rapid changes in geomagnetic field intensity. The work is motivated by paleomagnetic observations of 'geomagnetic spikes', events where the field intensity rose and then fell by a factor of 2-3 over decadal timescales and a confined spatial region. No comparable events have been found in the historical record and so geomagnetic spikes may contain new and important information regarding the operation of the geodynamo. However, they are also controversial because uncertainties and resolution limitations in the available data hinder efforts to define their spatiotemporal characteristics. This has led to debate over whether such extreme events can originate in Earth's liquid core. Geodynamo simulations produce high spatio-temporal resolution intensity information, but must be interpreted with care since they cannot yet run at the conditions of Earth's liquid core. We employ reversing and non-reversing geodynamo simulations run at different physical conditions and consider various methods of scaling the results to allow comparison with Earth. In each simulation we search for 'extremal events', defined as the maximum intensity difference between consecutive time points, at each location on a 2 degrees latitude-longitude grid at Earth's surface, thereby making no assumptions regarding the spatio-temporal character of the event. Extremal events display spike-shaped time-series in some simulations, though they can often be asymmetric about the peak intensity. Maximum rates of change reach 0.75 mu Tyr(-1) in several simulations, the lower end of estimates for spikes, suggesting that such events can originate from the core. The fastest changes generally occur at latitudes > 50 degrees, which could be used to guide future data acquisitions. Extremal events in the simulations arise from rapid intensification of flux patches as they migrate across the core surface, rather than emergence of flux from within the core. The prospect of observing more spikes in the paleomagnetic record appears contingent on finding samples at the right location and time to sample this particular phase of flux patch evolution. (C) 2018 Published by Elsevier B.V.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Numerical Dynamo Simulations Reproduce Paleomagnetic Field Behavior

D. G. Meduri, A. J. Biggin, C. J. Davies, R. K. Bono, C. J. Sprain, J. Wicht

Summary: Numerical geodynamo simulations capture key aspects of paleosecular variation and time-averaged field behavior since 10 Ma, with models driven by compositional convection and specific dipolarity ranges showing the most accurate results. These findings provide valuable insights for next generation global paleomagnetic field model reconstructions.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

A regime diagram for the slurry F-layer at the base of Earth's outer core

Jenny Wong, Christopher J. Davies, Christopher A. Jones

Summary: Seismic observations suggest the presence of a stably-stratified region known as the F-layer at the base of Earth's outer core. By varying key parameters, a regime diagram shows the dynamics of the slurry F-layer, indicating the existence of a stably-stratified slurry in the Earth's core.

EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

The Conductive Cooling of Planetesimals With Temperature-Dependent Properties

M. Murphy Quinlan, A. M. Walker, C. J. Davies, J. E. Mound, T. Muller, J. Harvey

Summary: Modeling the planetary heat transport of small bodies in the early Solar System is key to understand the geological context of meteorite samples. Including temperature-dependence in the models is crucial for accurate interpretations of the origin of different classes of meteorites. The thermal properties of parent bodies play a significant role in the timing and depth of meteorite genesis.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-PLANETS (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Consistent and Contrasting Aspects of the Geomagnetic Field Across Epochs With Distinct Reversal Frequencies Revealed by Modeling the Kiaman Superchron

Daniele Brandt, Marcia Ernesto, Catherine Constable

Summary: This study presents an extensive directional paleomagnetic database of the Kiaman reversed superchron, with a constant behavior of concentrated and circular distributions at latitudes higher than 10 degrees. Through Giant Gaussian Process (GGP) models, the research found a covariant type that best explains the directional distribution of the Kiaman database. The results suggest that the correlations between Gaussian coefficients are valid for the last 10 Myr and the Kiaman superchron, and that the relative variability of the Kiaman field is lower compared to the past 10 Myr.

GEOCHEMISTRY GEOPHYSICS GEOSYSTEMS (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Dynamo constraints on the long-term evolution of Earth's magnetic field strength

Christopher J. Davies, Richard K. Bono, Domenico G. Meduri, Julien Aubert, Samuel Greenwood, Andrew J. Biggin

Summary: The researchers investigate the variation of Earth's magnetic field strength over geological time by combining numerical geodynamo simulations with theoretical scaling laws. They find that both scaling laws, despite uncertainties from different heating modes and boundary conditions, are compatible with the power-law behavior exhibited by the internal field and core-mantle boundary fields. The QG-MAC-free scaling matches Earth's modern CMB field, while the QG-MAC-fixed prediction overestimates palaeointensities over the last 3.5 Gyr.

GEOPHYSICAL JOURNAL INTERNATIONAL (2022)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

On the evolution of thermally stratified layers at the top of Earth's core

Sam Greenwood, Christopher J. Davies, Jon E. Mound

Summary: This study focuses on the thermal origin of the stable layer at the top of Earth's outer core and conducts a systematic investigation into the core's thermal evolution. The findings show that many scenarios for the history of CMB heat flow leading to thermal stratification are inconsistent with exponential trends from mantle evolution models.

PHYSICS OF THE EARTH AND PLANETARY INTERIORS (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Influence of Thermal Stratification on the Structure and Evolution of the Martian Core

Sam Greenwood, Christopher J. Davies, Anne Pommier

Summary: The study suggests that the Martian core is currently fully conductive with temperatures above 1940 K. All models are consistent with a range of k(c)=16-35 W m(-1) K-1. Models with an activation volume of 6 (0) cm(3) mol(-1) require a mantle reference viscosity of 10(19)-10(20)(10(20)-10(21)) Pa s.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Towards reconciling experimental and computational determinations of Earth's core thermal conductivity

Monica Pozzo, Christopher J. Davies, Dario Alfe

Summary: The thermal conductivity of Earth's core is a critical parameter that affects core cooling rate, inner core age, and geodynamo power. Recent studies have shown a wide range of values for core thermal conductivity due to challenges in extrapolating to core liquid conditions of pressure, temperature, and composition. This study uses density functional theory calculations to determine the thermal conductivity and resistivity of FeSi alloys, and finds that resistivity increases with Si composition and reduces thermal conductivity. Analysis of possible errors in the calculations shows that experimental and corrected calculations are consistent within uncertainties. Core thermal history models based on the corrected estimates of thermal conductivity support previous findings of inner core formation around 400-700 million years ago and an early molten lower mantle.

EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS (2022)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Combined dynamical and morphological characterisation of geodynamo simulations

Takashi Nakagawa, Christopher J. Davies

Summary: Numerical dynamo simulations can produce fields similar to the geomagnetic field, but they cannot fully replicate the physical conditions of Earth's core. Recent research has shown that simulations can approach the Quasi-Geostrophic with Magnetic, Archimedean, and Coriolis (QG-MAC) force balance observed in Earth's core. However, the relationship between the QG-MAC balance and the morphological features of the simulated fields is not yet well-established. In this study, compliance criteria for field morphology and scale-dependent force balances were used to assess a suite of simulations. The results show that most compliant simulations that approach a realistic magnetic Reynolds number are in QG-MAC balance. Simulations that achieve excellent morphological compliance, QG-MAC balance, and high Reynolds number are confined to a specific range of dipolarity.

EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Powering Earth's Ancient Dynamo With Silicon Precipitation

Alfred J. Wilson, Monica Pozzo, Dario Alfe, Andrew M. Walker, Sam Greenwood, Anne Pommier, Christopher J. Davies

Summary: The Earth's core has been generating a global magnetic field for at least 3.5 billion years, sustained by the growth of the inner core. Previous models suggested that there might have been insufficient power for the geodynamo prior to the formation of the inner core. However, the precipitation of silicon from the liquid core could potentially offer an alternative power source for the ancient magnetic field. This study presents the first ab initio determination of the silicon partition coefficient at core-mantle boundary conditions and confirms its thermodynamic description integrated into a model of coupled core-mantle thermal evolution. The results demonstrate that models incorporating silicon precipitation can satisfy various constraints and support the presence of an ancient geodynamo.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2022)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

The New Core Paradox: Challenges and Potential Solutions

P. Driscoll, C. Davies

Summary: The persistence of the geomagnetic field conflicts with the highly thermally conductive core, making core convection and dynamo action difficult. Parameters such as mantle viscosity ratio, core thermal conductivity, and core radiogenic heat rate were explored to understand core evolution. Previous models failed to reproduce the present-day inner core size and dynamo, but a potentially new solution involving a hot initial core and lower melting temperature deserves further investigation.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SOLID EARTH (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Longitudinal structure of Earth's magnetic field controlled by lower mantle heat flow

Jonathan E. E. Mound, Christopher J. J. Davies

Summary: Thermal interactions between Earth's core and mantle play a crucial role in maintaining the geomagnetic field, but their specific effects on magnetic field behavior are still uncertain. Through numerical dynamo simulations, researchers successfully reproduced Earth-like conditions and revealed how the mantle controls core dynamics. By comparing these simulations to global magnetic field models, they found that the long-term geomagnetic signatures are characterized by equatorial patches of reverse flux. Additionally, the simulations suggest that the present-day geomagnetic field may be unusual.

NATURE GEOSCIENCE (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Can homogeneous nucleation resolve the inner core nucleation paradox?

Alfred J. Wilson, Dario Alfe, Andrew M. Walker, Christopher J. Davies

Summary: The formation of Earth's solid inner core is a significant event in the evolution of the deep Earth and the generation of the geomagnetic field. Previous studies have underestimated the cooling required for the inner core nucleation, leaving a gap in our understanding of deep Earth evolution. This paper explores untested iron-rich systems to better understand the nucleation process and provides new insights into the formation of Earth's inner core.

EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Fast Directional Changes during Geomagnetic Transitions: Global Reversals or Local Fluctuations?

Stefano Maffei, Philip W. Livermore, Jon E. Mound, Sam Greenwood, Christopher J. Davies

Summary: Paleomagnetic studies in Central and Southern Italy revealed extreme directional changes in the geomagnetic field during its last reversal about 780,000 years ago. The observed changes may be localized and transient, rather than indicative of global variations. The amount of kinetic energy required to instantaneously reproduce these changes differs depending on whether they are considered global or local in nature.

GEOSCIENCES (2021)

Article Materials Science, Multidisciplinary

Probing the nucleation of iron in Earth's core using molecular dynamics simulations of supercooled liquids

Alfred J. Wilson, Andrew M. Walker, Dario Alfe, Christopher J. Davies

Summary: Classical nucleation theory predicts average waiting times for systems to freeze as they are cooled below the melting temperature, but for systems at low to moderate undercooling, waiting times are too long for freezing to be observed via simulation. This study develops a new approach to estimate waiting times at temperatures closer to the melting point using statistics on solidlike particles in molecular dynamic simulations of supercooled liquids. The method allows characterization of nucleation behavior at small undercooling conditions without prior thermodynamic insight.

PHYSICAL REVIEW B (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Eoarchean ultramafic rocks represent crustal cumulates: A case study of the Narssaq ultramafic body, southern West Greenland

Lingyu Zhang, Kristoffer Szilas

Summary: This study presents new petrological and geochemical data for the Narssaq Ultramafic Body (NUB) in the Itsaq Gneiss Complex of SW Greenland. The results indicate that the ultramafic rocks of NUB are not mantle residues, but instead represent crustal cumulates derived from high-Mg magmas.

EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS (2024)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Iron isotope evidence in continental intraplate basalts for mantle lithosphere imprint on heterogenous asthenospheric melts

Rong Xu, Sarah Lambart, Oliver Nebel, Ming Li, Zhongjie Bai, Junbo Zhang, Ganglan Zhang, Jianfeng Gao, Hong Zhong, Yongsheng Liu

Summary: This study investigated the iron isotope compositions of Cenozoic basalts in Southeast China, finding significant variations related to different types of basalts and their respective sources.

EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS (2024)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Shallow sources of upper mantle seismic anisotropy in East Africa

C. J. Ebinger, Miriam C. Reiss, Ian Bastow, Mary M. Karanja

Summary: The East African rift system is formed above mantle upwellings and the formation of rifts is related to lithospheric thinning and magmatic activity. The amount of splitting varies spatially and the fast axes are predominantly parallel to the orientation of the rifts. Thick lithospheric modules have less splitting and different orientations, which may indicate mantle plume flow. Splitting rotates and increases in strength as it enters the rift zones, suggesting that the anisotropy is mainly present at shallow depths.

EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS (2024)

Correction Geochemistry & Geophysics

Serpentinite fluids and slab-melting in the Aleutian arc: Evidence from molybdenum isotopes and boron systematics (vol 603, 117970, 2023)

Ekaterina Rojas-Kolomiets, Owen Jensen, Michael Bizimis, Gene Yogodzinski, Lukas Ackerman

EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS (2024)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Concordance of V-in-olivine and Fe-XANES oxybarometry methods in mid-ocean ridge basalts

Robert W. Nicklas, Igor S. Puchtel, Ethan F. Baxter

Summary: Oxygen fugacity is a fundamental parameter for understanding redox processes in igneous systems. This study compares the Fe-XANES oxybarometry method with the V-in-olivine method for evaluating fO(2) in MORB lavas. The results show that the V-in-olivine method is not applicable to samples with low MgO content, and that the majority of Archean komatiite sources have lower fO(2) than modern MORB.

EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS (2024)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Calcium isotopes track volatile components in the mantle sources of alkaline rocks and associated carbonatites

Chunfei Chen, Stephen F. Foley, Sebastian Tappe, Huange Ren, Lanping Feng, Yongsheng Liu

Summary: The volatile components CO2 and H2O play a major role in mantle melting and heterogeneity. In this study, Ca isotopes were used to trace the lithological heterogeneity in alkaline magmatic rocks. The results revealed the presence of K-richterite and carbonate components as the source of alkaline magmas with low delta 44/40Ca values. These findings highlight the importance of Ca isotopes as a robust tracer of lithological variation caused by volatiles in the Earth's upper mantle.

EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS (2024)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Cosmogenic (un-)steadiness revealed by paired-nuclide catchment-wide denudation rates in the formerly half-glaciated Vosges Mountains (NE France)

Timothee Jautzy, Gilles Rixhon, Regis Braucher, Romain Delunel, Pierre G. Valla, Laurent Schmitt, Aster Team

Summary: Although the current approach to estimate catchment-wide denudation rates using only 10Be concentrations has made significant progress in geomorphology, this study argues for the inclusion of 26Al measurements and testing of steady-state assumptions in slow eroding, formerly glaciated landscapes. The study conducted measurements of both 10Be and 26Al in stream sediments from the Vosges Massif in France and found that elevation, slope, channel steepness, and precipitation were the primary factors controlling denudation rates. The study also revealed a significant relationship between the extent of past glaciation and the cosmogenic (un-)steadiness in the stream sediments.

EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS (2024)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Linking rates of slab sinking to long-term lower mantle flow and mixing

Erik van der Wiel, Douwe J. J. van Hinsbergen, Cedric Thieulot, Wim Spakman

Summary: Numerical models of Earth's mantle dynamics can predict the vigour and mixing of mantle flow, and the average slab sinking rates are an unexplored parameter that can provide intrinsic information on these characteristics. Through numerical experiments, it has been found that slab sinking rates are strongly correlated with mantle convection and mixing, and may explain geochemical observations from hotspot volcanoes.

EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS (2024)