4.7 Article

Is equilibrium in transport pure Nash, mixed or Stochastic?

Journal

Publisher

PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.trc.2014.09.002

Keywords

Experimental economics; Traffic equilibrium; Stochastic User Equilibrium; Fechner error; Scale parameter

Funding

  1. Exploratory Advanced Research Program of the U.S. Federal Highway Administration
  2. Center for Economic Analysis of Risk

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The classical theory of transport equilibrium is based on the Wardrop's first principle that describes a Nash User Equilibrium (UE), where in no driver can unilaterally change routes to improve his/her travel times. A growing number of economic laboratory experiments aiming at testing Nash-Wardrop equilibrium have shown that the Pure Strategy Nash Equilibrium (PSNE) is not able to explain the observed strategic choices well. In addition even though Mixed Strategy Nash Equilibrium (MSNE) has been found to fit better the observed aggregate choices, it does not explain the variance in choices well. This study analyses choices made by users in three different experiments involving strategic interactions in endogenous congestion to evaluate equilibrium prediction. We compare the predictions of the PSNE, MSNE and Stochastic User Equilibrium (SUE). In SUE, the observed variations in choices are assumed to be due to perception errors. The study proposes a method to iteratively estimate SUE models on choice data with strategic interactions. Among the three sets of experimental data the SUE approach was found to accurately predict the average choices, as well as the variances in choices. The fact that the SUE model was found to accurately predict variances in choices, suggests its applicability for transport equilibrium models that attempt to evaluate reliability in transportation systems. This finding is fundamental in the effort to determining a behaviourally consistent paradigm to model equilibrium in transport networks. The study also finds that Fechner error which is the inverse of the scale parameter in the SUE model is affected by the group sizes and the complexity of the cost function. In fact, the larger group sizes and complexity of cost functions increased the variability in choices. Finally, from an experimental design standpoint we show that it is not possible to estimate a noise parameter associate to Fechner error in the case when the choices are equally probable. (C) 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Management

Online incentive-compatible mechanisms for traffic intersection auctions

David Rey, Michael W. Levin, Vinayak V. Dixit

Summary: The study introduces novel online mechanisms for traffic intersection auctions where users bid for priority service. Two Markov chain models are proposed to determine the expected waiting time of participants in the auction, along with a mechanism to calculate incentive-compatible payments in the dynamic sense, maximizing social welfare in the long run. Findings suggest that the proposed online mechanisms are incentive-compatible in the dynamic sense, in contrast to static incentive-compatible mechanisms that may lead to misreporting by users.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2021)

Article Engineering, Civil

Autonomous Intersection Management for Connected and Automated Vehicles: A Lane-Based Method

Wei Wu, Yang Liu, Wei Liu, Fangni Zhang, Vinayak Dixit, S. Travis Waller

Summary: Most existing studies on AIM focus on algorithms for resolving conflicts among vehicles, while this paper proposes optimizing entrance and exit lanes to improve traffic efficiency. Two methods are developed for optimizing entering time and route choices, and a heuristic approach is adopted for real-time applicability.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INTELLIGENT TRANSPORTATION SYSTEMS (2022)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Road safety research in the context of low- and middle-income countries: Macro-scale literature analyses, trends, knowledge gaps and challenges

Milad Haghani, Ali Behnood, Vinayak Dixit, Oscar Oviedo-Trespalacios

Summary: This study analyzes the landscape and temporal trends of road safety research in low- and middle-income countries, highlighting the disproportionate representation of road users in road trauma statistics and the lack of progress in reducing deaths compared to high-income countries. The research emphasizes the need to intensify road safety research in LMICs to generate local knowledge and develop initiatives tailored to their unique needs. Additionally, the study identifies underrepresented areas of road safety research and examines patterns of authorship and co-authorship in LMIC studies. Efforts are hoped to invigorate road safety research and promote international collaborations in this field.

SAFETY SCIENCE (2022)

Article Economics

A game theoretical analysis of metro-integrated city logistics systems

Mingyou Ma, Fangni Zhang, Wei Liu, Vinayak Dixit

Summary: This study conducts a game theoretical analysis of metro-integrated logistics systems (MILS) and finds that introducing MILS has the potential to improve the performance of both metro company and logistics company.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART B-METHODOLOGICAL (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Quantum Fourier transform to estimate drive cycles

Vinayak Dixit, Sisi Jian

Summary: Drive cycles play a crucial role in energy consumption, emissions, and safety in vehicle systems. A quantum Fourier transform-based algorithm for drive cycle frequency estimation is proposed and proven to be exponentially faster than the classical Fourier transform and consistent in results. Additionally, a simple method is suggested to mitigate noise in quantum computers.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2022)

Article Economics

Should I stay or should I go? Congestion pricing and equilibrium selection in a transportation network

Enrica Carbone, Vinayak V. Dixit, E. Elisabet Rutstrom

Summary: This study examines reactions to congestion pricing in the commercial sector using a sequential experimental game. The findings show that congestion pricing leads to commercial activities relocating, and the adjustment process is costly to merchants. Consumer choices and reactions are also influenced.

THEORY AND DECISION (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Comparing and Contrasting the Impacts of Macro-Level Factors on Crash Duration and Frequency

Sai Chand, Zhuolin Li, Abdulmajeed Alsultan, Vinayak V. Dixit

Summary: This study explores the impact of various factors on vehicle crash duration and frequency at a macro-level, including demographic, vehicle utilization, environmental, and responder variables, as well as street network features. The analysis of over 95,000 vehicle crash records reveals that income, driver experience, and exposure have both positive and negative effects on crash duration, and that regions with a dense road network have shorter duration but higher frequency.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH AND PUBLIC HEALTH (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Link-level resilience analysis for real-world networks using crowd-sourced data

Chence Niu, Tingting Zhang, Divya Jayakumar Nair, Vinayak Dixit, Pamela Murray-Tuite

Summary: This study analyzes the speed fluctuation of real-world networks and evaluates the quantitative relationship between resilience and graph-based metrics and link attributes. The results indicate that graph-based metrics and attributes have a high impact on network resilience, but the relevance of different metrics and attributes to link resilience is different.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DISASTER RISK REDUCTION (2022)

Article Transportation

Examining the macro-level factors affecting vehicle breakdown duration

Sai Chand, Zhuolin Li, Vinayak V. Dixit, S. Travis Waller

Summary: This study investigates the impact of various factors on the duration of reported vehicle breakdowns at a macro-level, finding that street network characteristics and certain socio-economic factors have significant effects on the duration of breakdowns.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF TRANSPORTATION SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Impact of Connected Automated Buses in a Mixed Fleet Scenario With Connected Automated Cars

Amolika Sinha, Daniel Bassil, Sai Chand, Navreet Virdi, Vinayak Dixit

Summary: The study investigates the impact of connected automated buses in a mixed fleet with connected automated vehicles on the performance of urban transport systems. Results show that connected automated buses can significantly reduce travel time and standstill times, while also decreasing forced lane changes between vehicles and improving road safety.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INTELLIGENT TRANSPORTATION SYSTEMS (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Integrating a computable general equilibrium model with the four-step framework

Siroos Shahriari, Edward N. Robson, Jason Wang, Vinayak V. Dixit, S. Travis Waller, Taha H. Rashidi

Summary: Traditional transport models often do not account for broader changes in the economy, so there is a need for an integrated CGE and transport model to quickly assess the economic impacts of transport projects and policies.

TRANSPORTATION (2023)

Article Transportation Science & Technology

A Spatio-Temporal autocorrelation model for designing a carshare system using historical heterogeneous Data: Policy suggestion

Zesheng Cheng, Taha Hossein Rashidi, Sisi Jian, Mojtaba Maghrebi, Steven Travis Waller, Vinayak Dixit

Summary: This paper develops an innovative approach to estimating the actual demand at a carsharing station using carsharing records, spatio-temporal correlated variables, and emerging data sources. The paper also provides recommendations related to the operation policies of the service providers based on the analysis results.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART C-EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Are wildfire fatalities related to road network characteristics? A preliminary analysis of global wildfire cases

Chence Niu, Divya Jayakumar Nair, Tingting Zhang, Vinayak Dixit, Pamela Murray-Tuite

Summary: This study explores a novel graph-based connectivity index for road networks to measure the impact on global wildfire fatality events. The findings show a significant and systematic relationship between fatalities and a calibrated connectivity index across different wildfire events. This simple graph theoretic measure can assist planners in reducing vulnerability and increasing resilience in wildfire-prone areas.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DISASTER RISK REDUCTION (2022)

Article Engineering, Industrial

An integrated decision model for managing hospital evacuation in response to an extreme flood event: A case study of the Hawkesbury-Nepean River, NSW, Australia

Maziar Yazdani, Mohammad Mojtahedi, Martin Loosemore, David Sanderson, Vinayak Dixit

Summary: This paper addresses the increasing frequency and severity of floods and their impact on hospitals. It proposes an innovative hospital evacuation model that combines a flood simulator and a mathematical model to facilitate optimal evacuation planning under uncertain flood conditions. The model is validated through a case study in New South Wales, Australia, and it is found to generate effective plans for hospital evacuation in the shortest time possible during flood emergencies.

SAFETY SCIENCE (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Pre-Disaster Resilient Road Network Investment Strategy With Uncertainty Quantification

Chence Niu, Sisi Jian, Divya Nair, Vinayak Dixit

Summary: Extreme events, such as disasters and severe road accidents, have become common and pose a threat to many lives. Efficient evacuation is crucial, necessitating planning and development of transport infrastructure resiliency. This study formulates a bi-level multi-objective model to optimize pre-disaster investment in the road network considering different levels of disaster damage. Using realistic speed data, the study explores the relationship between vulnerability and reliability to make informed investment decisions. The findings provide a theoretical basis for authorities to make pre-disaster road network investments.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INTELLIGENT TRANSPORTATION SYSTEMS (2023)

Article Transportation Science & Technology

3-Strategy evolutionary game model for operation extensions of subway networks

Yue Zhao, Liujiang Kang, Huijun Sun, Jianjun Wu, Nsabimana Buhigiro

Summary: This study proposes a 2-population 3-strategy evolutionary game model to address the issue of subway network operation extension. The analysis reveals that the rule of maximum total fitness ensures the priority of evolutionary equilibrium strategies, and proper adjustment minutes can enhance the effectiveness of operation extension.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART C-EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES (2024)

Article Transportation Science & Technology

Integrated optimization of container allocation and yard cranes dispatched under delayed transshipment

Hongtao Hu, Jiao Mob, Lu Zhen

Summary: This study investigates the challenges of daily storage yard management in marine container terminals considering delayed transshipment of containers. A mixed-integer linear programming model is proposed to minimize various costs associated with transportation and yard management. The improved Benders decomposition algorithm is applied to solve the problem effectively and efficiently.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART C-EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES (2024)

Article Transportation Science & Technology

Range-constrained traffic assignment for electric vehicles under heterogeneous range anxiety

Zhandong Xu, Yiyang Peng, Guoyuan Li, Anthony Chen, Xiaobo Liu

Summary: This paper studied the impact of range anxiety among electric vehicle drivers on traffic assignment. Two types of range-constrained traffic assignment problems were defined based on discrete or continuous distributed range anxiety. Models and algorithms were proposed to solve the two types of problems. Experimental results showed the superiority of the proposed algorithm and revealed that drivers with heightened range anxiety may cause severe congestion.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART C-EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES (2024)

Article Transportation Science & Technology

Demand forecasting and predictability identification of ride-sourcing via bidirectional spatial-temporal transformer neural processes

Chuanjia Li, Maosi Geng, Yong Chen, Zeen Cai, Zheng Zhu, Xiqun (Michael) Chen

Summary: Understanding spatial-temporal stochasticity in shared mobility is crucial, and this study introduces the Bi-STTNP prediction model that provides probabilistic predictions and uncertainty estimations for ride-sourcing demand, outperforming conventional deep learning methods. The model captures the multivariate spatial-temporal Gaussian distribution of demand and offers comprehensive uncertainty representations.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART C-EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES (2024)

Article Transportation Science & Technology

Partial trajectory method to align and validate successive video cameras for vehicle tracking

Benjamin Coifman, Lizhe Li

Summary: This paper develops a partial trajectory method for aligning views from successive fixed cameras in order to ensure high fidelity with the actual vehicle movements. The method operates on the output of vehicle tracking to provide direct feedback and improve alignment quality. Experimental results show that this method can enhance accuracy and increase the number of vehicles in the dataset.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART C-EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES (2024)

Article Transportation Science & Technology

Dynamic routing for the Electric Vehicle Shortest Path Problem with charging station occupancy information

Mohsen Dastpak, Fausto Errico, Ola Jabali, Federico Malucelli

Summary: This article discusses the problem of an Electric Vehicle (EV) finding the shortest route from an origin to a destination and proposes a problem model that considers the occupancy indicator information of charging stations. A Markov Decision Process formulation is presented to optimize the EV routing and charging policy. A reoptimization algorithm is developed to establish the sequence of charging station visits and charging amounts based on system updates. Results from a comprehensive computational study show that the proposed method significantly reduces waiting times and total trip duration.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART C-EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES (2024)