4.5 Article

Intensity and temporal variability as components of stress gradients: implications for the balance between competition and facilitation

Journal

OIKOS
Volume 123, Issue 1, Pages 47-55

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/j.1600-0706.2013.00604.x

Keywords

-

Categories

Funding

  1. European Community's Seventh Framework Programme [266445, 287844]
  2. State Key Program of National Natural Science of China [31230014]
  3. National Natural Science Foundation of China [40901019, 31000203, 31000178]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The mechanisms regulating switches in species interactions along gradients of stress are yet to be fully elucidated. In particular, the role of temporal variability in environmental severity or consumer pressure has been not explored either empirically or theoretically. Here, through a spatially explicit model (i.e. a two-dimensional lattice), we show that variations in the temporal variance of environmental stress can be as important as those in the mean intensity in regulating the spatial distribution and coexistence range of species differing in their relative competitive ability and tolerance to stress, as well as the direction and magnitude of their interactions. In addition, our simulations suggest that enhanced temporal fluctuations in environmental stressors can enhance absolute levels of stress perceived by interacting species. This study shows that tests including both the mean and temporal variance of environmental stress will be key to forecast changes in species interactions under different scenarios of climate change.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Plant Sciences

Positive cascading effects of epiphytes enhance the persistence of a habitat-forming macroalga and the biodiversity of the associated invertebrate community under increasing stress

Chiara Ravaglioli, Joachim Langeneck, Antonella Capocchi, Alberto Castelli, Debora Fontanini, Paul E. Gribben, Fabio Bulleri

Summary: The presence of epiphyte Jania rubens can reduce light/UV stress for Halopithys incurva, allowing the latter to persist in shallow-water habitats. Positive feedback between H. incurva as the primary habitat-former and J. rubens as the secondary habitat-former generates facilitation cascade, increasing abundance and diversity of associated invertebrates in shallow habitat.

JOURNAL OF ECOLOGY (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

A multi-bioassay integrated approach to assess antifouling potential of extracts from the Mediterranean sponge Ircinia oros

Lucia De Marchi, Carlo Pretti, Alessia Cuccaro, Matteo Oliva, Federica Tardelli, Gianfranca Monni, Michele Magri, Fabio Bulleri

Summary: In this study, extracts from the Mediterranean sponge Ircinia oros were tested using a multi-bioassay approach to assess their antifouling potential. The effects of extracts were species-specific, with inhibitory effects on the growth of a marine diatom and toxic effects on different developmental stages of a brackish water serpulid. The proposed test battery can be considered a suitable tool for screening bioactivity of marine natural products.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE AND POLLUTION RESEARCH (2022)

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

Photo-physiology and morphology reveal divergent warming responses in northern and southern hemisphere seagrasses

Hung Manh Nguyen, Fabio Bulleri, Lazaro Marin-Guirao, Mathieu Pernice, Gabriele Procaccini

Summary: This study compared the response to thermal stress between northern and southern hemisphere seagrasses using four representative species. Results showed that warming had negative effects on southern hemisphere seagrasses but not on northern hemisphere seagrasses. Pioneer seagrasses exhibited better tolerance to warming compared to climax species.

MARINE BIOLOGY (2021)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Global COVID-19 lockdown highlights humans as both threats and custodians of the environment

Amanda E. Bates, Richard B. Primack, Brandy S. Biggar, Tomas J. Bird, Mary E. Clinton, Rylan J. Command, Cerren Richards, Marc Shellard, Nathan R. Geraldi, Valeria Vergara, Orlando Acevedo-Charry, Zuania Colon-Pineiro, David Ocampo, Natalia Ocampo-Penuela, Lina M. Sanchez-Clavijo, Cristian M. Adamescu, Sorin Cheval, Tudor Racoviceanu, Matthew D. Adams, Egide Kalisa, Vincent Z. Kuuire, Vikram Aditya, Pia Anderwald, Samuel Wiesmann, Sonja Wipf, Gal Badihi, Matthew G. Henderson, Hanspeter Loetscher, Katja Baerenfaller, Lisandro Benedetti-Cecchi, Fabio Bulleri, Iacopo Bertocci, Elena Maggi, Luca Rindi, Chiara Ravaglioli, Kristina Boerder, Julien Bonnel, Delphine Mathias, Philippe Archambault, Laurent Chauvaud, Camrin D. Braun, Simon R. Thorrold, Jacob W. Brownscombe, Jonathan D. Midwood, Christine M. Boston, Jill L. Brooks, Steven J. Cooke, Victor China, Uri Roll, Jonathan Belmaker, Assaf Zvuloni, Marta Coll, Miquel Ortega, Brendan Connors, Lisa Lacko, Dinusha R. M. Jayathilake, Mark J. Costello, Theresa M. Crimmins, LoriAnne Barnett, Ellen G. Denny, Katharine L. Gerst, R. L. Marsh, Erin E. Posthumus, Reilly Rodriguez, Alyssa Rosemartin, Sara N. Schaffer, Jeff R. Switzer, Kevin Wong, Susan J. Cunningham, Petra Sumasgutner, Arjun Amar, Robert L. Thomson, Miqkayla Stofberg, Sally Hofmeyr, Jessleena Suri, Rick D. Stuart-Smith, Paul B. Day, Graham J. Edgar, Antonia T. Cooper, Fabio Cabrera De Leo, Grant Garner, Paulson G. Des Brisay, Michael B. Schrimpf, Nicola Koper, Michael S. Diamond, Ross G. Dwyer, Cameron J. Baker, Craig E. Franklin, Ron Efrat, Oded Berger-Tal, Ohad Hatzofe, Victor M. Eguiluz, Jorge P. Rodriguez, Juan Fernandez-Gracia, David Elustondo, Vicent Calatayud, Philina A. English, Stephanie K. Archer, Sarah E. Dudas, Dana R. Haggarty, Austin J. Gallagher, Brendan D. Shea, Oliver N. Shipley, Ben L. Gilby, Jasmine Ballantyne, Andrew D. Olds, Christopher J. Henderson, Thomas A. Schlacher, William D. Halliday, Nicholas A. W. Brown, Mackenzie B. Woods, Sigal Balshine, Francis Juanes, Mitchell J. Rider, Patricia S. Albano, Neil Hammerschlag, Graeme C. Hays, Nicole Esteban, Yuhang Pan, Guojun He, Takanao Tanaka, Marc J. S. Hensel, Robert J. Orth, Christopher J. Patrick, Jonas Hentati-Sundberg, Olof Olsson, Margot L. Hessing-Lewis, Nicholas D. Higgs, Mark A. Hindell, Clive R. McMahon, Rob Harcourt, Christophe Guinet, Sarah E. Hirsch, Justin R. Perrault, Shelby R. Hoover, Jennifer D. Reilly, Catherine Hobaiter, Thibaud Gruber, Charlie Huveneers, Vinay Udyawer, Thomas M. Clarke, Laura P. Kroesen, David S. Hik, Seth G. Cherry, Justin A. Del Bel Belluz, Jennifer M. Jackson, Shengjie Lai, Clayton T. Lamb, Gregory D. LeClair, Jeffrey R. Parmelee, Matthew W. H. Chatfield, Cheryl A. Frederick, Sangdon Lee, Hyomin Park, Jaein Choi, Frederic LeTourneux, Thierry Grandmont, Frederic Dulude De Broin, Joel Bety, Gilles Gauthier, Pierre Legagneux, Jesse S. Lewis, Jeffrey Haight, Zhu Liu, Jarod P. Lyon, Robin Hale, Dallas D'Silva, Ian MacGregor-Fors, Enrique Arbelaez-Cortes, Felipe A. Estela, Camilo E. Sanchez-Sarria, Michelle Garcia-Arroyo, Giann K. Aguirre-Samboni, Juan C. Franco Morales, Shahar Malamud, Tal Gavriel, Yehezkel Buba, Shira Salingre, Mai Lazarus, Ruthy Yahel, Yigael Ben Ari, Eyal Miller, Rotem Sade, Guy Lavian, Ziv Birman, Manor Gury, Harel Baz, Ilia Baskin, Alon Penn, Amit Dolev, Ogen Licht, Tabi Karkom, Sharon Davidzon, Avi Berkovitch, Ofer Yaakov, Raoul Manenti, Emiliano Mori, Gentile Francesco Ficetola, Enrico Lunghi, David March, Brendan J. Godley, Cecilia Martin, Steven F. Mihaly, David R. Barclay, Dugald J. M. Thomson, Richard Dewey, Jeannette Bedard, Aroha Miller, Amber Dearden, Jennifer Chapman, Lauren Dares, Laura Borden, Donna Gibbs, Jessica Schultz, Nikita Sergeenko, Fiona Francis, Amanda Weltman, Nicolas Moity, Jorge Ramirez-Gonzalez, Gonzalo Mucientes, Alexandre Alonso-Fernandez, Itai Namir, Avi Bar-Massada, Ron Chen, Shmulik Yedvab, Thomas A. Okey, Steffen Oppel, Volen Arkumarev, Samuel Bakari, Vladimir Dobrev, Victoria Saravia-Mullin, Anastasios Bounas, Dobromir Dobrev, Elzbieta Kret, Solomon Mengistu, Cloe Pourchier, Alazar Ruffo, Million Tesfaye, Mengistu Wondafrash, Stoyan C. Nikolov, Charles Palmer, Lorenzo Sileci, Patrick T. Rex, Christopher G. Lowe, Francesc Peters, Matthew K. Pine, Craig A. Radford, Louise Wilson, Lauren McWhinnie, Alessia Scuderi, Andrew G. Jeffs, Kathleen L. Prudic, Maxim Larrivee, Kent P. McFarland, Rodrigo Solis, Rebecca A. Hutchinson, Nuno Queiroz, Miguel A. Furtado, David W. Sims, Emily Southall, Claudio A. Quesada-Rodriguez, Jessica P. Diaz-Orozco, Ku'ulei S. Rodgers, Sarah J. L. Severino, Andrew T. Graham, Matthew P. Stefanak, Elizabeth M. P. Madin, Peter G. Ryan, Kyle Maclean, Eleanor A. Weideman, Kyle D. Kittelberger, Josip Kusak, Jeffrey A. Seminoff, Megan E. Hanna, Takahiro Shimada, Mark G. Meekan, Martin K. S. Smith, Mohlamatsane M. Mokhatla, Malcolm C. K. Soh, Roanna Y. T. Pang, Breyl X. K. Ng, P. Y-H Lee Benjamin, Adrian H. B. Loo, Kenneth B. H. Er, Gabriel B. G. Souza, Christopher D. Stallings, Joseph S. Curtis, Meaghan E. Faletti, Jonathan A. Peake, Michael J. Schram, Kara R. Wall, Carina Terry, Matt Rothendler, Lucy Zipf, Juan Sebastian Ulloa, Angelica Hernandez-Palma, Bibiana Gomez-Valencia, Cristian Cruz-Rodriguez, Yenifer Herrera-Varon, Margarita Roa, Susana Rodriguez-Buritica, Jose Manuel Ochoa-Quintero, Reut Vardi, Victor Vazquez, Christian Requena-Mesa, Miyako H. Warrington, Michelle E. Taylor, Lucy C. Woodall, Paris Stefanoudis, Xiangliang Zhang, Qiang Yang, Yuval Zukerman, Zehava Sigal, Amir Ayali, Eric E. G. Clua, Pamela Carzon, Clementine Seguine, Andrea Corradini, Luca Pedrotti, Catherine M. Foley, Catherine Alexandra Gagnon, Elijah Panipakoochoo, Celene B. Milanes, Camilo M. Botero, Yunior R. Velazquez, Nataliya A. Milchakova, Simon A. Morley, Stephanie M. Martin, Veronica Nanni, Tanya Otero, Julia Wakeling, Sarah Abarro, Cyril Piou, Ana F. L. Sobral, Eulogio H. Soto, Emily G. Weigel, Alejandro Bernal-Ibanez, Ignacio Gestoso, Eva Cacabelos, Francesca Cagnacci, Reny P. Devassy, Matthias-Claudio Loretto, Paula Moraga, Christian Rutz, Carlos M. Duarte

Summary: The global lockdown due to COVID-19 pandemic has impacted human interactions with nature, resulting in immediate effects on wildlife and environmental threats. Reports from around the world indicate a mix of positive and negative impacts on conservation and illegal activities.

BIOLOGICAL CONSERVATION (2021)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

The role of environmental conditions in regulating long-term dynamics of an invasive seaweed

C. Ravaglioli, Lisandro Benedetti-Cecchi, Iacopo Bertocci, Elena Maggi, M. Uya, Fabio Bulleri

Summary: This study reveals the importance of seasonal and interannual variations in regulating the temporal patterns of Caulerpa cylindracea abundance. Lower seawater temperature in spring and summer, along with higher autumn wind speed and spring precipitation, are associated with higher peak abundance of the invasive seaweed.

BIOLOGICAL INVASIONS (2022)

Article Biology

Unveiling the complexity and ecological function of aquatic macrophyte-animal networks in coastal ecosystems

Federica Manca, Clelia Mula, Camilla Gustafsson, Achille Mauri, Tomas Roslin, David N. Thomas, Lisandro Benedetti-Cecchi, Alf Norkko, Giovanni Strona

Summary: Network theory provides innovative tools to explore complex ecological mechanisms regulating species associations and interactions. However, the application of network approaches is unevenly distributed across different study systems, with aquatic macrophyte-animal associations in coastal environments being largely neglected. Network analysis has the potential to broaden our understanding of coastal ecosystems and their response to anthropogenic disturbance and environmental change.

BIOLOGICAL REVIEWS (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Heterogeneity within and among co-occurring foundation species increases biodiversity

Mads S. Thomsen, Andrew H. Altieri, Christine Angelini, Melanie J. Bishop, Fabio Bulleri, Roxanne Farhan, Viktoria M. M. Fruhling, Paul E. Gribben, Seamus B. Harrison, Qiang He, Moritz Klinghardt, Joachim Langeneck, Brendan S. Lanham, Luca Mondardini, Yannick Mulders, Semonn Oleksyn, Aaron P. Ramus, David R. Schiel, Tristan Schneider, Alfonso Siciliano, Brian R. Silliman, Dan A. Smale, Paul M. South, Thomas Wernberg, Stacy Zhang, Gerhard Zotz

Summary: Habitat heterogeneity is a primary driver of biodiversity patterns, but its universal role has not been fully understood due to a lack of coordinated experiments. This study conducted 22 experiments to assess the impact of habitat heterogeneity on biodiversity across different ecosystems and regions, and found that positive and additive effects were common across the three axes of heterogeneity. These findings provide mechanistic insights into the importance of habitat heterogeneity in promoting biodiversity through facilitative interactions.

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2022)

Review Biodiversity Conservation

Impacts of artificial light at night in marine ecosystems-A review

Laura F. B. Marangoni, Thomas Davies, Tim Smyth, Airam Rodriguez, Mark Hamann, Cristian Duarte, Kellie Pendoley, Jorgen Berge, Elena Maggi, Oren Levy

Summary: The globally widespread adoption of Artificial Light at Night (ALAN) has led to a renewed research focus on its impacts in the marine environment. This review presents the current understanding of ALAN impacts in diverse marine ecosystems and species, including seabirds, sea turtles, and corals. ALAN can mask navigation, change predation patterns, disrupt coral spawning synchronization, and inhibit zooplankton migration. While mitigation measures are recommended, barriers to implementation are poorly understood. Addressing knowledge gaps would aid in predicting and mitigating ALAN impacts in the marine realm.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Short-term stability of rocky intertidal biofilm to nitrogen and phosphorus pulses

L. Rindi, L. Benedetti-Cecchi

Summary: This study experimentally assessed the effects of nitrogen and phosphorus inputs on the stability of phototrophic rocky intertidal biofilm. The results showed that regardless of concentration, nitrogen and phosphorus inputs increased the sensitivity of the biofilm without altering its resilience.

MARINE ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Ecology

Spatial correlation reverses the compound effect of multiple stressors on rocky shore biofilm

Luca Rindi, Jianyu He, Lisandro Benedetti-Cecchi

Summary: Understanding the impact of multifactorial fluctuating environments on species and communities is a major challenge. This study investigated the influence of spatial correlation between warming and sediment deposition on the biomass and photosynthetic activity of rocky intertidal biofilm using field experiments and simulations. The results showed that the spatial correlation between the two climate variables determined the nonlinear response of biofilm biomass, but not photosynthetic activity, to fluctuating levels of warming and sediment deposition. Negative spatial correlation buffered against extreme levels of warming and sediment deposition.

ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2022)

Article Ecology

Epilithic Bacterial Assemblages on Subtidal Rocky Reefs: Variation Among Alternative Habitats at Ambient and Enhanced Nutrient Levels

Joseph Elsherbini, Christopher Corzett, Chiara Ravaglioli, Laura Tamburello, Martin Polz, Fabio Bulleri

Summary: Temperate rocky reefs support diverse habitats including macroalgal forests, algal turfs, and sea urchin barrens. The composition of epilithic microbial biofilms (EMBs) plays a crucial role in macroalgal recruitment, but their role in regulating the stability of alternative habitats remains unknown. A study on shallow rocky reefs in the Mediterranean compared EMB structure in different habitats under ambient and enhanced nutrient levels. Results showed distinct microbial communities in different habitats, with moderate nutrient enhancement having minimal effects on EMBs. Understanding the role of EMBs in habitat stability and reverse shifts is important.

MICROBIAL ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Ecology

Subtle differences in growth rate drive contrasting responses of ephemeral primary producers to recurrent disturbances

Iacopo Bertocci, Elena Maggi, Claudia Scire Scappuzzo, Luca Rindi, Lisandro Benedetti-Cecchi

Summary: Although the importance of time after disturbance is well known, there are few studies on how differences in growth rate affect species recovery in relation to the interval between disturbances. This study examined the response of two primary producers to different disturbance regimes. The results showed that one species was able to persist regardless of disturbance frequency, while the other species could not withstand any disturbance regime.

ECOSPHERE (2023)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Avoiding Paper Parks: A Global Literature Review on Socioeconomic Factors Underpinning the Effectiveness of Marine Protected Areas

Antonio Di Cintio, Federico Niccolini, Sara Scipioni, Fabio Bulleri

Summary: Marine protected areas (MPAs) are important for preserving marine biodiversity and resources. However, some MPAs fail to achieve their conservation and socioeconomic targets. To understand the factors contributing to MPA success, a global literature review was conducted. The study found that stakeholder involvement, communication, enforcement, and monitoring are critical for MPA success.

SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

No Data Available