4.7 Article

Processing counterfactual and hypothetical conditionals: An fMRI investigation

Journal

NEUROIMAGE
Volume 72, Issue -, Pages 265-271

Publisher

ACADEMIC PRESS INC ELSEVIER SCIENCE
DOI: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2013.01.060

Keywords

Counterfactual thinking; Conditionals; Subjunctive mood; Indicative mood; fMRI

Funding

  1. Doctoral College Imaging the Mind of the Austrian Science Fund [FWF-W1233]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Counterfactual thinking is ubiquitous in everyday life and an important aspect of cognition and emotion. Although counterfactual thought has been argued to differ from processing factual or hypothetical information, imaging data which elucidate these differences on a neural level are still scarce. We investigated the neural correlates of processing counterfactual sentences under visual and aural presentation. We compared conditionals in subjunctive mood which explicitly contradicted previously presented facts (i.e. counterfactuals) to conditionals framed in indicative mood which did not contradict factual world knowledge and thus conveyed a hypothetical supposition. Our results show activation in right occipital cortex (cuneus) and right basal ganglia (caudate nucleus) during counterfactual sentence processing. Importantly the occipital activation is not only present under visual presentation but also with purely auditory stimulus presentation, precluding a visual processing artifact Thus our results can be interpreted as reflecting the fact that counterfactual conditionals pragmatically imply the relevance of keeping in mind both factual and supposed information whereas the hypothetical conditionals imply that real world information is irrelevant for processing the conditional and can be omitted. The need to sustain representations of factual and suppositional events during counterfactual sentence processing requires increased mental imagery and integration efforts. Our findings are compatible with predictions based on mental model theory. (C) 2013 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved:

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Neurosciences

Cloze enough? Hemodynamic effects of predictive processing during natural reading

Sarah Schuster, Nicole Alexandra Himmelstoss, Florian Hutzler, Fabio Richlan, Martin Kronbichler, Stefan Hawelka

Summary: This study investigated the hemodynamic effects of predictive processing during natural reading by combining fMRI and eye movement recordings. The results suggest an effect of precision on prediction update in higher (lexico-)semantic levels, but no disproportionate reading times on participants' eye movements were observed. The findings do not support discrete predictions, favoring the idea that multiple words are activated in parallel during reading.

NEUROIMAGE (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Preserved intention understanding during moral judgments in schizophrenia

Lisa Kronbichler, Renate Stelzig-Schoeler, Melanie Lenger, Stefanie Weber, Brandy-Gale Pearce, Luise-Antonia Reich, Wolfgang Aichhorn, Martin Kronbichler

Summary: The study found no significant differences in moral judgments between schizophrenia patients and healthy controls, and task performance was not related to symptom severity or medication. Furthermore, the study showed that patients did not have observable difficulties in integrating the protagonist's belief in the rating of the moral permissibility of the action-outcome.

PLOS ONE (2021)

Article Clinical Neurology

Cortical Morphometry and Its Relationship with Cognitive Functions in Children after non-CNS Cancer

Janine S. Spitzhuettl, Martin Kronbichler, Lisa Kronbichler, Valentin Benzing, Valerie Siegwart, Mirko Schmidt, Manuela Pastore-Wapp, Claus Kiefer, Nedelina Slavova, Michael Grotzer, Maja Steinlin, Claudia M. Roebers, Kurt Leibundgut, Regula Everts

Summary: Childhood cancer survivors may experience deficits in executive functions, however, no significant structure-function correlations were found. The treatment impacts on brain structures relevant to emotion processing.

DEVELOPMENTAL NEUROREHABILITATION (2021)

Article Clinical Neurology

Emotional Recognition in Patients With Mesial Temporal Epilepsy Associated With Enlarged Amygdala

Giorgi Kuchukhidze, Iris Unterberger, Elisabeth Schmid, Laura Zamarian, Christian Michael Siedentopf, Florian Koppelstaetter, Elke Gizewski, Martin Kronbichler, Gerhard Luef, Hennric Jokeit, Eugen Trinka

Summary: In this study, we found that unilateral mesial TLE and ipsilateral AE could lead to dysfunction in emotion recognition. Patients with right-side mTLE had more impaired perception and recognition of emotions compared to those with left-side mTLE. Patients also showed deficits in emotion recognition compared to healthy controls.

FRONTIERS IN NEUROLOGY (2022)

Article Geriatrics & Gerontology

The role of right supra-marginal gyrus and secondary somatosensory cortex in age-related differences in human emotional egocentricity

Federica Riva, Melanie Lenger, Martin Kronbichler, Claus Lamm, Giorgia Silani

Summary: Emotional egocentric bias is more prominent in children, adolescents, and older adults compared to young adults. The connectivity between the right supramarginal gyrus and somatosensory cortices acts as a partial mediator between age and emotional egocentric bias.

NEUROBIOLOGY OF AGING (2022)

Article Anesthesiology

Neuroscientific evidence for pain being a classically conditioned response to trauma- and pain-related cues in humans

Laila K. Franke, Stephan F. Miedl, Sarah K. Danboeck, Markus Grill, Michael Liedlgruber, Martin Kronbichler, Herta Flor, Frank H. Wilhelm

Summary: Psychological trauma is often accompanied by physical pain, with PTSD frequently co-occurring with chronic pain. Classical conditioning may explain the mechanism behind pain intrusions, where pain experiences can occur even without nociceptive input.
Article Behavioral Sciences

Oral Contraceptives Modulate the Relationship Between Resting Brain Activity, Amygdala Connectivity and Emotion Recognition - A Resting State fMRI Study

Shanice Menting-Henry, Esmeralda Hidalgo-Lopez, Markus Aichhorn, Martin Kronbichler, Hubert Kerschbaum, Belinda Pletzer

Summary: Recent research suggests that hormonal contraceptive users have reduced accuracy in recognizing emotions compared to naturally cycling women, and show alterations in amygdala volume and connectivity at rest. However, resting brain characteristics did not mediate oral contraceptive effects on emotion recognition performance. Sex and oral contraceptive use were found to moderate brain-behavior associations, with different patterns observed in different contraceptive users.

FRONTIERS IN BEHAVIORAL NEUROSCIENCE (2022)

Article Clinical Neurology

Emotional Word Processing in Patients With Juvenile Myoclonic Epilepsy

Lucas Johannes Rainer, Martin Kronbichler, Giorgi Kuchukhidze, Eugen Trinka, Patrick Benjamin Langthaler, Lisa Kronbichler, Sarah Said-Yuerekli, Margarita Kirschner, Georg Zimmermann, Julia Hofler, Elisabeth Schmid, Mario Braun

Summary: According to Panksepp's hierarchical emotion model, emotion processing relies on different brain regions. This study validates and extends this model in patients with JME. The results show that discrete emotions and affective dimensions are processed differently in different brain regions, and they are not affected by psychiatric conditions, seizure types, or duration of epilepsy.

FRONTIERS IN NEUROLOGY (2022)

Article Neurosciences

The gradient model of brain organization in decisions involving empathy for pain

Karin Labek, Elisa Sittenberger, Valerie Kienhoefer, Luna Rabl, Irene Messina, Matthias Schurz, Julia C. Stingl, Roberto Viviani

Summary: Influential models of cortical organization suggest a close relationship between heteromodal association areas and highly connected hubs in the default mode network. The gradient model of cortical organization proposes a similar relationship between these areas and highly connected hubs in the default mode network. By using a decision-making task and representational similarity analysis, the study explored the relationship between high-level representations of imminent pain in others and these areas. The findings suggest that task deactivations may indicate cortical areas that host high-level representations.

CEREBRAL CORTEX (2023)

Letter Anesthesiology

Reply to Quintner

Laila K. Franke, Stephan F. Miedl, Sarah K. Danboeck, Michael Liedlgruber, Markus Grill, Martin Kronbichler, Herta Flor, Frank H. Wilhelm

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

Differential Orbitofrontal Cortex Responses to Chocolate Images While Performing an Approach-Avoidance Task in the MRI Environment

Anja Lender, Janina Wirtz, Martin Kronbichler, Sercan Kahveci, Simone Kuehn, Jens Blechert

Summary: This study investigated the behavioral and neural correlates of approach behavior toward chocolate using fMRI and reaction times. The results showed an approach bias toward chocolate, which was associated with activity in the medial OFC. This study highlights the importance of stimulus-specific cognitive trainings for healthy consumption and self-regulation.

NUTRIENTS (2023)

Review Clinical Neurology

How do bipolar disease states affect positive and negative emotion processing? Insights from a meta-analysis on the neural fingerprints of emotional processing

Katharina Foerster, Lara. Z. Maliske, Matthias Schurz, Paula. M. Henneberg, Udo Dannlowski, Philipp Kanske

Summary: A systematic literature review and meta-analysis revealed that patients with manic bipolar disorder demonstrate increased emotional reactivity and decreased emotion regulation compared to healthy participants, particularly in the processing of negative stimuli. The findings emphasize the importance of longitudinal studies to further understand changes in emotion processing.

BIPOLAR DISORDERS (2023)

Article Clinical Neurology

Diagnosis and Prognosis in Disorders of Consciousness: An Active Paradigm fMRI Study

Laura Schnetzer, Verena S. Schaetzle, Lisa Kronbichler, Juergen Bergmann, Stefan Leis, Alexander B. Kunz, Julia S. Crone, Eugen Trinka, Martin Kronbichler

Summary: Diagnosing patients with disorders of consciousness can be prone to misdiagnosis. This study aims to determine the proportion of patients who display covert command following and evaluate the prognostic value of improved diagnosis. The researchers used functional MRI and a motor imagery task to identify patients with cognitive motor dissociation. The results showed that some patients exhibited covert command following, while others showed increased brain activation during rest. Additionally, 40% of patients showed significant activations in the whole brain analysis.

ACTA NEUROLOGICA SCANDINAVICA (2023)

Meeting Abstract Clinical Neurology

Emotion perception and recognition in juvenile myoclonic epilepsy

L. J. Rainer, G. Kuchukhidze, E. Trinka, M. Braun, M. Kronbichler, P. Langthaler, G. Zimmermann, S. Said-Yurekli, M. Kirschner, L. Zamarian, H. Jokeit, J. Hofler

EPILEPSIA (2022)

Meeting Abstract Neurosciences

Using Excitation/Inhibition Ratio to Optimize the Classification of Autism Spectrum Disorder and Schizophrenia

Lavinia Uscatescu, Christopher Hyatt, Martin Kronbichler, Vince Calhoun, Silvia Corbera, Kevin Pelphrey, Brian Pittman, Godfrey Pearlson, Michal Assaf

BIOLOGICAL PSYCHIATRY (2022)

Article Neurosciences

Solving large-scale MEG/EEG source localisation and functional connectivity problems simultaneously using state-space models

Jose Sanchez-Bornot, Roberto C. Sotero, J. A. Scott Kelso, Ozguer Simsek, Damien Coyle

Summary: This study proposes a multi-penalized state-space model for analyzing unobserved dynamics, using a data-driven regularization method. Novel algorithms are developed to solve the model, and a cross-validation method is introduced to evaluate regularization parameters. The effectiveness of this method is validated through simulations and real data analysis, enabling a more accurate exploration of cognitive brain functions.

NEUROIMAGE (2024)