4.5 Article

On-site analysis of Chinese Cloisonne enamels from fifteenth to nineteenth centuries

Journal

JOURNAL OF RAMAN SPECTROSCOPY
Volume 41, Issue 7, Pages 780-790

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1002/jrs.2516

Keywords

enamel; pigment; Raman spectroscopy; China; Cloisonnes

Categories

Funding

  1. TUB/TAK (The Scientific and Technological Research Council of Turkey)

Ask authors/readers for more resources

A selection of 22 rare Chinese cloisonne enamels, from fifteenth century to nineteenth century A.D., has been studied on-site in the storage rooms of the musee des Arts decoratifs in Paris. The Raman signatures of the transparent and/or opacified glass matrix are discussed and compared with those that were previously recorded on glazed pottery, enameled and stained glasses. Enamels mostly belong to lead-based potash-lime glasses. Three different compositions, lead-potash-lime (fifteenth, sixteenth, eighteenth and nineteenth century), soda-rich (sixteenth-seventeenth century) and soda-lime (seventeenth century) are identified according to the wavenumber maxima of the Si-O stretching and bending multiplets. Most of the pigment signatures are similar to those recorded on ceramic glazes and glass enamels, which proves the link between the technologies but a specific opacifier is observed: fluorite (CaF2). Naples Yellow pigment variations give characteristic signatures. Additionally, a comparison is made with Limoges enamels (sixteenth - nineteenth century A.D.). Copyright (C) 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Materials Science, Ceramics

'Blue-' and 'Brown-speckled' pottery from Qalhat, the Sultanate of Oman (13-16th centuries): Comparison with traditional Omani 19-20 century productions

Liliana Gianni, Helene Renel, Aleksandar Kremenovic, Philippe Colomban

Summary: Representative 'Blue speckled' and 'Brown speckled' wares from Qalhat and Bahla in Oman were analyzed using various techniques. The study revealed differences in composition, firing temperatures, and glaze types and compositions. It is suggested that the wares were locally produced, but the origin of the glazes used in the 'Blue speckled' wares remains uncertain.

BOLETIN DE LA SOCIEDAD ESPANOLA DE CERAMICA Y VIDRIO (2022)

Review Geochemistry & Geophysics

Cobalt and Associated Impurities in Blue (and Green) Glass, Glaze and Enamel: Relationships between Raw Materials, Processing, Composition, Phases and International Trade

Philippe Colomban, Burcu Kirmizi, Gulsu Simsek Franci

Summary: The article discusses the history of cobalt as a coloring agent for glass, glaze, and enamel, as well as the different forms of cobalt and its relationship with geological deposits and associated elements. It also highlights the importance of analytical tools and better understanding of cobalt ores.

MINERALS (2021)

Article Materials Science, Ceramics

Raman identification of the different glazing technologies of Blue-and-White Ming porcelains

Philippe Colomban, Anh-Tu Ngo, Howell G. M. Edwards, Linda C. Prinsloo, L. Valerie Esterhuizen

Summary: Shards of Blue-and-White Ming porcelain from shipwrecks of Portuguese ships found on the coasts of South Africa, as well as a shard from Mombasa (Kenya), were analyzed using optical microscopy, SEM-EDS, and Raman microspectroscopy. The study revealed differences in the composition of the porcelain body paste and types of glazes used, with blue decoration characteristic of materials rich in manganese.

CERAMICS INTERNATIONAL (2022)

Article Chemistry, Physical

The Technology Transfer from Europe to China in the 17th-18th Centuries: Non-Invasive On-Site XRF and Raman Analyses of Chinese Qing Dynasty Enameled Masterpieces Made Using European Ingredients/Recipes

Philippe Colomban, Michele Gironda, Divine Vangu, Burcu Kirmizi, Bing Zhao, Vincent Cochet

Summary: The study of two masterpieces from the Qing Dynasty revealed the technical characteristics and sources of the materials used in their production. The Qianlong ewer used cobalt imported from Europe, while the incense burner utilized Asian cobalt ores, reflecting the exchange of techniques during that period.

MATERIALS (2021)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Full Spectral Range Raman Signatures Related to Changes in Enameling Technologies from the 18th to the 20th Century: Guidelines, Effectiveness and Limitations of the Raman Analysis

Philippe Colomban

Summary: This study compares the Raman signatures of different colored enamels used in European, Chinese, and Japanese porcelains and enameled metalworks. The results show that Raman microspectroscopy can identify fingerprint spectra of milestone technologies and is a useful tool for detecting copies.

MATERIALS (2022)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Vibrational characterization of the various forms of (solvated or unsolvated) mobile proton in the solid state. Advantages, limitations and open questions

Philippe Colomban

Summary: A didactic review of vibrational spectroscopy procedures for studying mobile protonic species in solid hydrates, crystals and ceramics is proposed. Representative examples of materials are given, and the advantages of isotopic substitution and dilution measurements are discussed. The vibrational signatures of different proton species and the characterization of protonic species without or with weak vibrational signatures are presented. The presence of a strong incoherent inelastic neutron scattering background appears to be characteristic of proton conductors.

SOLID STATE IONICS (2023)

Article Materials Science, Ceramics

Non-Invasive On-Site pXRF Analysis of Coloring Agents, Marks and Enamels of Qing Imperial and Non-Imperial Porcelain

Philippe Colomban, Gulsu Simsek Franci, Jacques Burlot, Xavier Gallet, Bing Zhao, Jean-Baptiste Clais

Summary: On-site pXRF analysis is conducted on French collections of decorated porcelains from the Qing Dynasty to identify enamel types, ions and coloring phases, as well as differentiate between Chinese/Asian raw materials and those imported by European missionaries. The study focuses on cobalt-associated elements, impurities in the silicate matrix, and the use of gold or copper nanoparticles. Comparisons are made with previous measurements on Qing imperial porcelains, Cantonese productions, and blue-and-white wares from different museums and collections.

CERAMICS-SWITZERLAND (2023)

Article Spectroscopy

Raman identification of pigments and opacifiers: Interest and limitation of multivariate analysis by comparison with solid state spectroscopical approach-I. Lead-tin and Naples Yellow

Jacques Burlot, Divine Vangu, Ludovic Bellot-Gurlet, Philippe Colomban

Summary: This study analyzes the yellow pigments of enameled objects from 18th century French and Chinese productions and identifies different types of Raman signatures. The combination of spectral decomposition parameters and PCA analysis proves effective in categorizing the pigments.

JOURNAL OF RAMAN SPECTROSCOPY (2023)

Article Spectroscopy

Raman identification of pigments and opacifiers: Interest and limitation of multivariate analysis by comparison with solid state spectroscopical approach-II. Arsenic-based opacifiers and relation with cobalt ores

Jacques Burlot, Divine Vangu, Ludovic Bellot-Gurlet, Philippe Colomban

Summary: Raman analysis is utilized to study the phases observed in the different colored enamels of French and Chinese objects from the 18th century. The effectiveness of a solid-state spectroscopic approach and a multivariate chemometric approach is compared. The incorporation of spectra from similar phases in the literature is crucial for obtaining quality results. The combination of visual observation and multivariate analysis reveals that different production techniques result in variations in the peaks associated with the main As-O stretching vibration. Arsenic-based opacifiers are detected in the enamelled artifacts, both in French and Chinese objects.

JOURNAL OF RAMAN SPECTROSCOPY (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Timurid, Ottoman, Safavid and Qajar Ceramics: Raman and Composition Classification of the Different Types of Glaze and Pigments

Philippe Colomban, Gulsu Simsek Franci

Summary: Raw materials play a significant role in determining the composition and properties of fired ceramics. Raman analysis was used to characterize the micro- and nanostructures of glazes from various regions, revealing three different types of glazes and identifying specific color compositions. Different pigments and opacifiers were also identified. The results provide insights into the production and connection between different ceramic artifacts.

MINERALS (2023)

Article Humanities, Multidisciplinary

pXRF Data Evaluation Methodology for On-Site Analysis of Precious Artifacts: Cobalt Used in the Blue Decoration of Qing Dynasty Overglazed Porcelain Enameled at Customs District (Guangzhou), Jingdezhen and Zaobanchu (Beijing) Workshops

Philippe Colomban, Gulsu Simsek Franci, Michele Gironda, Pauline d'Abrigeon, Anne-Claire Schumacher

Summary: Raman and XRF analyses have shown that it is possible to identify specific phases and elements used in ceramics made with European recipes and ingredients. The study focused on ceramics produced in the Forbidden City during the Qing Dynasty and in Guangzhou, and found that they used the same raw materials. The study also observed some artifacts with anachronistic characteristics that suggest they were produced around 1850.

HERITAGE (2022)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Distinguishing Genuine Imperial Qing Dynasty Porcelain from Ancient Replicas by On-Site Non-Invasive XRF and Raman Spectroscopy

Philippe Colomban, Michele Gironda, Gulsu Simsek Franci, Pauline D'Abrigeon

Summary: This study applies non-invasive on-site portable techniques, Raman microscopy, and X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy to analyze imperial bowls and decorated dishes from the Qing Dynasty. The findings reveal variations in coloring agents and glaze compositions, highlighting the uniqueness of each object instead of small-scale production.

MATERIALS (2022)

Article Humanities, Multidisciplinary

On-Site Identification of Pottery with pXRF: An Example of European and Chinese Red Stonewares

Gulsu Simsek Franci, Philippe Colomban

Summary: The invention of European hard porcelain, which imitates Chinese porcelain, began with the development of red porcelain technology by Johann Friedrich Bottger in Meissen, Saxony. This study compares the chemical characteristics of European and Chinese red stoneware using on-site characterization techniques. The results show significant differences between Dutch objects and others, and provide a methodology for distinguishing the provenance and authenticity of artifacts.

HERITAGE (2022)

Article Humanities, Multidisciplinary

Non-Invasive Raman Analysis of 18th Century Chinese Export/Armorial Overglazed Porcelain: Identification of the Different Enameling Techniques

Philippe Colomban, Anh-Tu Ngo, Nicolas Fournery

Summary: Six rare porcelains from the Qing Dynasty were analyzed using non-invasive Raman microspectrometry. The study found that European ingredients and/or recipes were used, indicating China's role as both an importer of European know-how and an exporter of enameled products with imported technologies during the 18th century. Different recipes or raw materials may be the signature of different workshops.

HERITAGE (2022)

No Data Available