4.5 Article

EMMA, a Cost- and Time-Effective Diagnostic Method for Simultaneous Detection of Point Mutations and Large-Scale Genomic Rearrangements: Application to BRCA1 and BRCA2 in 1,525 Patients

Journal

HUMAN MUTATION
Volume 32, Issue 3, Pages 325-334

Publisher

WILEY-BLACKWELL
DOI: 10.1002/humu.21414

Keywords

BRCA1; BRCA2; screening; diagnosis; capillary electrophoresis; EMMA

Funding

  1. Medicen and la Region Ile de France
  2. ANR (Agence Nationale pour la Recherche)

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The detection of unknown mutations remains a serious challenge and, despite the expected benefits for the patient's health, a large number of genes are not screened on a routine basis. We present the diagnostic application of EMMA (Enhanced Mismatch Mutation Analysis (R), Fluigent, Paris, France), a novel method based on heteroduplex analysis by capillary electrophoresis using innovative matrices. BRCA1 and BRCA2 were screened for point mutations and large rearrangements in 1,525 unrelated patients (372 for the validation step and 1,153 in routine diagnosis) using a single analytical condition. Seven working days were needed for complete BRCA1/2 screening in 30 patients by one technician (excluding DNA extraction and sequencing). A total of 137 mutations were found, including a BRCA2 duplication of exons 19 and 20, previously missed by Comprehensive BRACAnalysis (R). The mutation detection rate was 11.9%, which is consistent with patient inclusions. This study therefore suggests that EMMA represents a valuable short-term and midterm option for many diagnostic laboratories looking for an easy, reliable, and affordable strategy, enabling fast and sensitive analysis for a large number of genes. Hum Mutat 32:325-334, 2011. (C) 2011 Wiley-Liss, Inc.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Oncology

Cancer Risks Associated With Germline PALB2 Pathogenic Variants: An International Study of 524 Families

Xin Yang, Goska Leslie, Alicja Doroszuk, Sandra Schneider, Jamie Allen, Brennan Decker, Alison M. Dunning, James Redman, James Scarth, Inga Plaskocinska, Craig Luccarini, Mitul Shah, Karen Pooley, Leila Dorling, Andrew Lee, Muriel A. Adank, Julian Adlard, Kristiina Aittomaki, Irene L. Andrulis, Peter Ang, Julian Barwell, Jonine L. Bernstein, Kristie Bobolis, Ake Borg, Carl Blomqvist, Kathleen B. M. Claes, Patrick Concannon, Adeline Cuggia, Julie O. Culver, Francesca Damiola, Antoine de Pauw, Orland Diez, Jill S. Dolinsky, Susan M. Domchek, Christoph Engel, D. Gareth Evans, Florentia Fostira, Judy Garber, Lisa Golmard, Ellen L. Goode, Stephen B. Gruber, Eric Hahnen, Christopher Hake, Tuomas Heikkinen, Judith E. Hurley, Ramunas Janavicius, Zdenek Kleibl, Petra Kleiblova, Irene Konstantopoulou, Anders Kvist, Holly Laduca, Ann S. G. Lee, Fabienne Lesueur, Eamonn R. Maher, Arto Mannermaa, Siranoush Manoukian, Rachel McFarland, Wendy McKinnon, Alfons Meindl, Kelly Metcalfe, Nur Aishah Mohd Taib, Jukka Moilanen, Katherine L. Nathanson, Susan Neuhausen, Pei Sze Ng, Tu Nguyen-Dumont, Sarah M. Nielsen, Florian Obermair, Kenneth Offit, Olufunmilayo Olopade, Laura Ottini, Judith Penkert, Katri Pylkas, Paolo Radice, Susan J. Ramus, Vilius Rudaitis, Lucy Side, Rachel Silva-Smith, Valentina Silvestri, Anne-Bine Skytte, Thomas Slavin, Jana Soukupova, Carlo Tondini, Alison H. Trainer, Gary Unzeitig, Lydia Usha, Thomas van Overeem Hansen, James Whitworth, Marie Wood, Cheng Har Yip, Sook-Yee Yoon, Amal Yussuf, George Zogopoulos, David Goldgar, John L. Hopper, Georgia Chenevix-Trench, Paul Pharoah, Sophia H. L. George, Judith Balmana, Claude Houdayer, Paul James, Zaki El-Haffaf, Hans Ehrencrona, Marketa Janatova, Paolo Peterlongo, Heli Nevanlinna, Rita Schmutzler, Soo-Hwang Teo, Mark Robson, Tuya Pal, Fergus Couch, Jeffrey N. Weitzel, Aaron Elliott, Melissa Southey, Robert Winqvist, Douglas F. Easton, William D. Foulkes, Antonis C. Antoniou, Marc Tischkowitz

JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY (2020)

Article Oncology

How to facilitate psychosocial adjustment in women tested for hereditary breast or ovarian cancer susceptibility? Insights from network analysis

Anne Bredart, Julia Dick, Alejandra Cano, Leonore Robieux, Antoine De Pauw, Rita Schmutzler, Dominique Stoppa-Lyonnet, Sylvie Dolbeault, Jean-Luc Kop

PSYCHO-ONCOLOGY (2020)

Letter Oncology

Universal Genetic Testing to Identify Pathogenic Germline Variants in Patients With Cancer COMMENT

Chrystelle Colas, Antoine De Pauw, Lisa Golmard

JAMA ONCOLOGY (2021)

Article Genetics & Heredity

Classification of 101 BRCA1 and BRCA2 variants of uncertain significance by cosegregation study: A powerful approach

Sandrine M. Caputo, Lisa Golmard, Melanie Leone, Francesca Damiola, Marine Guillaud-Bataille, Francoise Revillion, Etienne Rouleau, Nicolas Derive, Adrien Buisson, Noemie Basset, Mathias Schwartz, Paul Vilquin, Celine Garrec, Maud Privat, Mathilde Gay-Bellile, Caroline Abadie, Khadija Abidallah, Fabrice Airaud, Anne-Sophie Allary, Emmanuelle Barouk-Simonet, Muriel Belotti, Charlotte Benigni, Patrick R. Benusiglio, Christelle Berthemin, Pascaline Berthet, Ophelie Bertrand, Stephane Bezieau, Marie Bidart, Yves-Jean Bignon, Anne-Marie Birot, Maud Blanluet, Amelie Bloucard, Johny Bombled, Valerie Bonadona, Francoise Bonnet, Marie-Noelle Bonnet-Dupeyron, Manon Boulaire, Flavie Boulouard, Ahmed Bouras, Violaine Bourdon, Afane Brahimi, Fanny Brayotel, Brigitte Bressac de Paillerets, Noemie Bronnec, Virginie Bubien, Bruno Buecher, Odile Cabaret, Jennifer Carriere, Jean Chiesa, Stephanie Chieze-Valero, Camille Cohen, Odile Cohen-Haguenauer, Chrystelle Colas, Marie-Agnes Collonge-Rame, Anne-Laure Conoy, Florence Coulet, Isabelle Coupier, Louise Crivelli, Veronica Cusin, Antoine De Pauw, Catherine Dehainault, Helene Delhomelle, Capucine Delnatte, Sophie Demontety, Philippe Denizeau, Pierre Devulder, Helene Dreyfus, Catherine Dubois D'Enghein, Anais Dupre, Anne Durlach, Sophie Dussart, Anne Fajac, Samira Fekairi, Sandra Fert-Ferrer, Alice Fievet, Robin Fouillet, Emmanuelle Mouret-Fourme, Marion Gauthier-Villars, Paul Gesta, Sophie Giraud, Laurence Gladieff, Veronica Goldbarg, Vincent Goussot, Virginie Guibert, Erell Guillerm, Christophe Guy, Agnes Hardouin, Celine Heude, Claude Houdayer, Olivier Ingster, Caroline Jacquot-Sawka, Natalie Jones, Sophie Krieger, Sofiane Lacoste, Hakima Lallaoui, Helene Larbre, Anthony Lauge, Gabrielle Le Guyadec, Marine Le Mentec, Caroline Lecerf, Jessica Le Gall, Berengere Legendre, Clementine Legrand, Angelina Legros, Sophie Lejeune, Rosette Lidereau, Norbert Lignon, Jean-Marc Limacher, Doriane Livon, Sarab Lizard, Michel Longy, Alain Lortholary, Pierre Macquere, Audrey Mailliez, Sarah Malsa, Henri Margot, Veronique Mari, Christine Maugard, Cindy Meira, Julie Menjard, Diane Moliere, Virginie Moncoutier, Jessica Moretta-Serra, Etienne Muller, Zoe Neviere, Thien-vu Nguyen Minh Tuan, Tetsuro Noguchi, Catherine Nogues, Florine Oca, Cornel Popovici, Fabienne Prieur, Sabine Raad, Jean-Marc Rey, Agathe Ricou, Lucie Salle, Claire Saule, Nicolas Sevenet, Fatoumata Simaga, Hagay Sobol, Voreak Suybeng, Isabelle Tennevet, Henrique Tenreiro, Julie Tinat, Christine Toulas, Isabelle Turbiez, Nancy Uhrhammer, Pierre Vande Perre, Dominique Vaur, Laurence Venat, Nicolas Viellard, Marie-Charlotte Villy, Mathilde Warcoin, Alice Yvard, Helene Zattara, Olivier Caron, Christine Lasset, Audrey Remenieras, Nadia Boutry-Kryza, Laurent Castera, Dominique Stoppa-Lyonnet

Summary: Up to 80% of BRCA1 and BRCA2 genetic variants remain of uncertain clinical significance. Only pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants can guide breast and ovarian cancer prevention measures and treatment. The ongoing French national COVAR study aims to classify BRCA1/2 VUSs using a multifactorial model.

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF HUMAN GENETICS (2021)

Article Oncology

Information needs on breast cancer genetic and non-genetic risk factors in relatives of women with a BRCA1/2 or PALB2 pathogenic variant

Anne Bredart, Antoine De Pauw, Amelie Anota, Anja Tuchler, Julia Dick, Anita Muller, Jean-Luc Kop, Kerstin Rhiem, Rita Schmutzler, Peter Devilee, Dominique Stoppa-Lyonnet, Sylvie Dolbeault

Summary: The study found that female relatives were more likely to perceive a lack of information on non-genetic risk factors compared to genetic risk factors, and expressed a desire for more information. Higher education level was associated with lower perceived information on genetic risk factors, while younger age and lower engagement coping were related to lower perceived information on non-genetic risk factors.

BREAST (2021)

Article Genetics & Heredity

Novel germline MET pathogenic variants in French patients with papillary renal cell carcinomas type I

Molka Sebai, David Tulasne, Sandrine M. Caputo, Virginie Verkarre, Marie Fernandes, Celia Guerin, Fanny Reinhart, Severine Adams, Christine Maugard, Olivier Caron, Marine Guillaud-Bataille, Pascaline Berthet, Yves-Jean Bignon, Brigitte Bressac-de Paillerets, Nelly Burnichon, Jean Chiesa, Sophie Giraud, Sophie Lejeune, Jean-Marc Limacher, Antoine de Pauw, Dominique Stoppa-Lyonnet, Helene Zattara-Cannoni, Sophie Deveaux, Rosette Lidereau, Stephane Richard, Etienne Rouleau

Summary: Hereditary papillary renal cell carcinoma is a rare inherited renal cancer syndrome associated with activating germline pathogenic variants of the MET gene. A study on a large French patient series showed a correlation between MET pathogenic variants and characteristic presentation of PRCC1 tumors, highlighting the importance of broadening screening efforts.

HUMAN MUTATION (2022)

Article Oncology

Cancer Risks Associated With BRCA1 and BRCA2 Pathogenic Variants

Shuai Li, Valentina Silvestri, Goska Leslie, Timothy R. Rebbeck, Susan L. Neuhausen, John L. Hopper, Henriette Roed Nielsen, Andrew Lee, Xin Yang, Lesley McGuffog, Michael T. Parsons, Irene L. Andrulis, Norbert Arnold, Muriel Belotti, Ake Borg, Bruno Buecher, Saundra S. Buys, Sandrine M. Caputo, Wendy K. Chung, Chrystelle Colas, Sarah Colonna, Jackie Cook, Mary B. Daly, Miguel de la Hoya, Antoine de Pauw, Helene Delhomelle, Jacqueline Eason, Christoph Engel, D. Gareth Evans, Ulrike Faust, Tanja N. Fehm, Florentia Fostira, George Fountzilas, Megan Frone, Vanesa Garcia-Barberan, Pilar Garre, Marion Gauthier-Villars, Andrea Gehrig, Gord Glendon, David E. Goldgar, Lisa Golmard, Mark H. Greene, Eric Hahnen, Ute Hamann, Helen Hanson, Tiara Hassan, Julia Hentschel, Judit Horvath, Louise Izatt, Ramunas Janavicius, Yue Jiao, Esther M. John, Beth Y. Karlan, Sung-Won Kim, Irene Konstantopoulou, Ava Kwong, Anthony Lauge, Jong Won Lee, Fabienne Lesueur, Noura Mebirouk, Alfons Meindl, Emmanuelle Mouret-Fourme, Hannah Musgrave, Joanne Ngeow Yuen Yie, Dieter Niederacher, Sue K. Park, Inge Sokilde Pedersen, Juliane Ramser, Susan J. Ramus, Johanna Rantala, Muhammad U. Rashid, Florian Reichl, Julia Ritter, Andreas Rump, Marta Santamarina, Claire Saule, Gunnar Schmidt, Rita K. Schmutzler, Leigha Senter, Saba Shariff, Christian F. Singer, Melissa C. Southey, Dominique Stoppa-Lyonnet, Christian Sutter, Yen Tan, Soo Hwang Teo, Mary Beth Terry, Mads Thomassen, Marc Tischkowitz, Amanda E. Toland, Diana Torres, Ana Vega, Sebastian A. Wagner, Shan Wang-Gohrke, Barbara Wappenschmidt, Bernhard H. F. Weber, Drakoulis Yannoukakos, Amanda B. Spurdle, Douglas F. Easton, Georgia Chenevix-Trench, Laura Ottini, Antonis C. Antoniou

Summary: This study aims to provide precise age-specific risk estimates of cancers other than female breast and ovarian cancers associated with pathogenic variants (PVs) in BRCA1 and BRCA2 for effective cancer risk management.

JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY (2022)

Article Genetics & Heredity

Genetic clinicians' confidence in BOADICEA comprehensive breast cancer risk estimates and counselees' psychosocial outcomes: A prospective study

Anne Bredart, Antoine De Pauw, Anja Tuehler, Inge M. M. Lakeman, Amelie Anota, Kerstin Rhiem, Rita Schmutzler, Christi J. van Asperen, Peter Devilee, Dominique Stoppa-Lyonnet, Jean-Luc Kop, Sylvie Dolbeault

Summary: Counseling for familial breast cancer focuses on communicating gene test results, but risk prediction models have become more complex by including non-genetic risk factors and polygenic risk scores. This study found that genetic clinicians appear confident with comprehensive risk models, which seem to only affect perceptions of older counselees.

CLINICAL GENETICS (2022)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Assessment of psychosocial difficulties by genetic clinicians and distress in women at high risk of breast cancer: a prospective study

Anne Bredart, Jean-Luc Kop, Anja Tuchler, Antoine De Pauw, Alejandra Cano, Julia Dick, Kerstin Rhiem, Peter Devilee, Rita Schmutzler, Dominique Stoppa-Lyonnet, Sylvie Dolbeault

Summary: This study examined how often genetic clinicians correctly identify psychosocial difficulties in women at high breast cancer risk and found that clinicians generally underestimated these difficulties. Counselees' distress levels remained stable throughout the counseling process, regardless of the accuracy of clinicians' assessments and the genetic test result disclosure. Psychological referral was more frequently needed for difficulties in the emotions domain.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF HUMAN GENETICS (2022)

Article Genetics & Heredity

Enhancing the BOADICEA cancer risk prediction model to incorporate new data on RAD51C, RAD51D, BARD1 updates to tumour pathology and cancer incidence

Andrew Lee, Nasim Mavaddat, Alex P. Cunningham, Tim Carver, Stephanie Archer, Fiona M. Walter, Marc Tischkowitz, Jonathan Roberts, Juliet Usher-Smith, Jacques Simard, Marjanka K. Schmidt, Peter Devilee, Vesna Zadnik, Hannes Jurgens, Emmanuelle Mouret-Fourme, Antoine De Pauw, Matti Rookus, Thea M. Mooij, Paul P. D. Pharoah, Douglas F. Easton, Antonis C. Antoniou

Summary: This study extended the BOADICEA models by incorporating the effects of pathogenic variants in recently established breast cancer and EOC susceptibility genes, as well as age-specific pathology distributions and continuous risk factors. The results showed that these extensions can provide more personalized cancer risk assessment for pathogenic variant carriers and inform better choices for screening, prevention, and risk factor adjustment.

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL GENETICS (2022)

Article Oncology

Association and performance of polygenic risk scores for breast cancer among French women presenting or not a familial predisposition to the disease

Yue Jiao, Therese Truong, Severine Eon-Marchais, Noura Mebirouk, Sandrine M. Caputo, Marie-Gabrielle Dondon, Mojgan Karimi, Dorothee Le Gal, Juana Beauvallet, Edith Le Floch, Claire Dandine-Roulland, Delphine Bacq-Daian, Robert Olaso, Juliette Albuisson, Severine Audebert-Bellanger, Pascaline Berthet, Valerie Bonadona, Bruno Buecher, Olivier Caron, Mathias Cavaille, Jean Chiesa, Chrystelle Colas, Marie-Agnes Collonge-Rame, Isabelle Coupier, Capucine Delnatte, Antoine De Pauw, Helene Dreyfus, Sandra Fert-Ferrer, Marion Gauthier-Villars, Paul Gesta, Sophie Giraud, Laurence Gladieff, Lisa Golmard, Christine Lasset, Sophie Lejeune-Dumoulin, Melanie Leone, Jean-Marc Limacher, Alain Lortholary, Elisabeth Luporsi, Veronique Mari, Christine M. Maugard, Isabelle Mortemousque, Emmanuelle Mouret-Fourme, Sophie Nambot, Catherine Nogues, Cornel Popovici, Fabienne Prieur, Pascal Pujol, Nicolas Sevenet, Hagay Sobol, Christine Toulas, Nancy Uhrhammer, Dominique Vaur, Laurence Venat, Anne Boland-Auge, Pascal Guenel, Jean-Francois Deleuze, Dominique Stoppa-Lyonnet, Nadine Andrieu, Fabienne Lesueur

Summary: The three breast cancer polygenic risk scores (PRS) were associated with breast cancer risk in French women, but the predictive performance varied among different populations. The PRS were useful for women with a strong family history and no BRCA1/2 pathogenic variant, as well as those carrying a predicted pathogenic variant in a moderate-risk gene (ATM, CHEK2 or PALB2). Further research on the application of these scores in different populations is warranted.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF CANCER (2023)

Article Genetics & Heredity

Hereditary cancer predispositions: Comparison of multigene panel sequencing on fresh-frozen breast/ovarian tumor versus blood

Mathias Schwartz, Virginie Moncoutier, Adrien Peytral, Jessica Le Gall, Voreak Suybeng, Melanie Pages, Julien Masliah-Planchon, Olfa Trabelsi-Grati, Samia Melaabi, Celine Callens, Ivan Bieche, Helene Delhomelle, Antoine De Pauw, Claire Saule, Emmanuelle Mouret-Fourme, Marion Gauthier-Villars, Bruno Buecher, Chrystelle Colas, Dominique Stoppa-Lyonnet, Lisa Golmard

Summary: Multigene panel sequencing is used to diagnose hereditary predispositions in breast or ovarian cancer patients, while BRCA1/BRCA2 testing is for therapeutic purpose. However, tumor genomic instability creates challenges in accurately detecting germline pathogenic variants through tumor testing. Somatic copy number variants and variant allele frequency can mask or distort the detection of germline pathogenic variants.

CLINICAL GENETICS (2023)

Meeting Abstract Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

A novel germline pathogenic variant MET c.3389T>C p.(Leu1130Ser) identified in french population

Molka Sebai, Marie Fernandes, Sandrine M. Caputo, Virginie Verkarre, Fanny Reinhart, Severine Adams, Christine Maugard, Olivier Caron, Marine Guillaud-Bataille, Pascaline Berthet, Yves-Jean J. Bignon, Jean Chiesa, Thierry Frebourg, Sophie Giraud, Sophie Lejeune, Jean-Marc M. Limacher, Antoine de Pauw, Dominique Stoppa-Lyonnet, Helene Zattara-Cannoni, Sophie Deveaux, Rosette Lidereau, Stephane Richard, David Tulasne, Etienne Rouleau

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF HUMAN GENETICS (2022)

Meeting Abstract Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Specific phenotype of germline MET mutations in papillary renal cell carcinoma type 1: about a large french series of 158 patients

Molka Sebai, David Tulasne, Sandrine M. Caputo, Virginie Verkarre, Marie Fernandes, Fanny Reinhart, Severine Adams, Christine Maugard, Olivier Caron, Marine Guillaud-Bataille, Pascaline Berthet, Yves-Jean J. Bignon, Jean Chiesa, Thierry Frebourg, Sophie Giraud, Sophie Lejeune, Jean-Marc M. Limacher, Antoine de Pauw, Dominique Stoppa-Lyonnet, Helene Zattara-Cannoni, Sophie Deveaux, Rosette Lidereau, Stephane Richard, Etienne Rouleau

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF HUMAN GENETICS (2022)

Article Oncology

Outcomes of Patients with Metastatic Castration-Resistant Prostate Cancer According to Somatic Damage DNA Repair Gene Alterations

Zoe Neviere, Elodie Coquan, Pierre-Emmanuel Brachet, Emeline Meriaux, Isabelle Bonnet, Sophie Krieger, Laurent Castera, Dominique Vaur, Flavie Boulouard, Alexandra Leconte, Justine Lequesne, Anais Lelaidier, Agathe Ricou, Florence Joly

Summary: This study aimed to evaluate the relationship between somatic DNA damage repair gene mutations and the response of mCRPC patients to standard therapies. The results showed that mCRPC patients with BRCA1/2 and ATM mutations had a longer response to standard therapies.

CURRENT ONCOLOGY (2022)

No Data Available