ComebackXin 2023-04-23

It's too slow, I give up. Don't submit to such slow journals anymore. I'm ready to withdraw.

redefinemean 2023-03-16

How difficult is this?

csc2020 2023-02-07

The speed is really slow.
The reviewers are very responsible and provide helpful suggestions for improving the paper. However, the process of evaluating the paper and the reviewers' comments is too slow. It takes about 3-4 weeks for the authors to receive the review comments. I hope efficiency can be improved in the future.

csc2020 2023-02-07

Accept 2023-01-23
Awaiting Editor Decision 2023-01-03
Revision Received 2022-12-17
Minor Revision 2022-12-14 13:07:07
Awaiting Editor Decision 2022-10-27
Revision Received 2022-10-19
Major Revision 2022-09-16
Awaiting Editor Decision 2022-09-08
Awaiting Associate Editor Recommendation 2022-08-18
Under Review 2022-06-07
Associate Editor Assigned 2022-06-06
Waiting for Associate Editor Assignment 2022-06-04
Editor Assigned 2022-06-04
Waiting for Editor Assignment 2022-05-03
Submitted 2022-04-25

Translation:
Accept: 2023-01-23
Awaiting Editor Decision: 2023-01-03
Revision Received: 2022-12-17
Minor Revision: 2022-12-14 13:07:07
Awaiting Editor Decision: 2022-10-27
Revision Received: 2022-10-19
Major Revision: 2022-09-16
Awaiting Editor Decision: 2022-09-08
Awaiting Associate Editor Recommendation: 2022-08-18
Under Review: 2022-06-07
Associate Editor Assigned: 2022-06-06
Waiting for Associate Editor Assignment: 2022-06-04
Editor Assigned: 2022-06-04
Waiting for Editor Assignment: 2022-05-03
Submitted: 2022-04-25

csc2020 2023-01-24

Thank you, OP! I just received the acceptance email today. I hope everyone has good luck!

The process was indeed very long, but at the moment of receiving it, it feels like everything was worth it.

lzugeo 2022-12-09

@csc2020, major repairs mean acceptance, there should be no problem, just need to patiently wait.

csc2020 2022-12-08

Admiring the minor repair of the host. My major repair will return at the end of October, and I am still waiting for reviewer assignment, it is so slow that I feel like crying, I don't know when I will receive the comments for the second review...

lzugeo 2022-12-06

Update status: waiting for revision 2022-12-05 (Both reviewers have given minor revisions, so the editor gave the final minor revision, which went smoothly (#^.^#))

lzugeo 2022-12-01

Update status:
Meeting with the editor for decision on 2022-12-01.

Eachen 2022-11-22

Waiting for Editor Assignment 2022-11-21 14:13:16
Initial Quality Control Complete 2022-11-21 14:13:16
Initial Quality Control Started 2022-10-28 22:14:22
Author Approved Converted Files 2022-10-28 22:14:21
Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted 2022-10-28 22:13:05

Translation:
Waiting for Editor Assignment 2022-11-21 14:13:16
Initial Quality Control Complete 2022-11-21 14:13:16
Initial Quality Control Started 2022-10-28 22:14:22
Author Approved Converted Files 2022-10-28 22:14:21
Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted 2022-10-28 22:13:05

lzugeo 2022-11-16

@pearl Wang Chuan, no, first-time submission.

Pearl王川 2022-11-16

Is it a second repair?

Pearl王川 2022-11-16

Excuse me, is this the second time for repair?

lzugeo 2022-11-16

The speed is really slow.
Stage Start Date
Under Review 2022-11-16
Contacting Potential Reviewers 2022-11-14
Waiting for Reviewer Assignment 2022-11-14
Under Review 2022-11-13
Contacting Potential Reviewers 2022-11-08
Waiting for Reviewer Assignment 2022-10-17
Associate Editor Assigned 2022-10-17
Waiting for Associate Editor Assignment 2022-10-17
Editor Assigned 2022-10-17
Waiting for Editor Assignment 2022-09-22
Initial Quality Control Complete 2022-09-22
Initial Quality Control Started 2022-09-15

Pearl王川 2022-11-16

In the process of editing distribution, waiting for the final editing decision, will update if there is good news.

Pearl王川 2022-11-16

Waiting for Associate Editor Assignment 2022-11-16 01:29:46
Editor Assigned 2022-11-16 01:29:46
Waiting for Editor Assignment 2022-10-21 09:34:47
Initial Quality Control Complete 2022-10-21 09:34:47
Initial Quality Control Started 2022-10-16 14:24:06
Author Approved Converted Files 2022-10-16 14:24:03
Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted 2022-10-16 10:13:34

Translation:
Waiting for Associate Editor Assignment - November 16, 2022 at 01:29:46
Editor Assigned - November 16, 2022 at 01:29:46
Waiting for Editor Assignment - October 21, 2022 at 09:34:47
Initial Quality Control Complete - October 21, 2022 at 09:34:47
Initial Quality Control Started - October 16, 2022 at 14:24:06
Author Approved Converted Files - October 16, 2022 at 14:24:03
Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted - October 16, 2022 at 10:13:34

qlj 2022-11-15

This editor took less than 15 minutes to review and basically rejected it.

qlj 2022-11-15

Looking for an editor took more than 40 days...

Stage Start Date
Waiting to Send Decision to Author 2022-11-15
Decision Made; E-mail Confirmation Sent 2022-11-15
Awaiting Editor Decision 2022-11-15
Waiting for Associate Editor Assignment 2022-11-15
Editor Assigned 2022-11-15
Waiting for Editor Assignment 2022-10-03
Initial Quality Control Complete 2022-10-03
Initial Quality Control Started 2022-09-26
Author Approved Converted Files 2022-09-26
Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted 2022-09-26

alley077 2022-09-26

The text translates to: "The revised submission was rejected directly, stating that the article had a narrow focus, lacked innovation, and did not meet the requirements. It was suggested to submit to another journal. The whole process took 26 days (feeling frustrated)."

csc2020 2022-06-07

Hello, after I submitted it, I have been waiting for reviewer assignment for a month, but the status hasn't changed. However, the "Days in Folder" has become 1. What is the situation? Please help me understand...

huanglr500 2022-04-24

I have also encountered the same situation. After three months of submission, the feedback I received was a rejection. They requested me to send it to a language editing company for language revision before resubmitting. However, after submitting it again as per their instructions, there has been no further update or change in status.

温柔善良帅气 2022-04-23

Manuscript Ready for Publication 2022-04-22
Revision Received; Under Review 2022-04-11
Waiting for Revision 2022-04-07
Revision Received; Under Review 2022-03-03
Waiting for Revision 2022-02-15
With Editor for Decision 2022-02-08
Under Review 2021-12-21
Contacting Potential Reviewers 2021-12-14
Waiting for Reviewer Assignment 2021-11-17

Major revisions turned into minor revisions and accepted. This journal is faster than I expected. Although this article has indeed tortured me for a long time. It was initially submitted to NS and sent for review, but was rejected. After being rejected by various sub-journals, it was finally accepted by the geoscience journal of EF AUG, which has high recognition. The second time was "tortured" by the AGU reviewers. Thanks to the reviewers! Their suggestions were very professional and greatly improved the paper!

张 2022-04-21

Excuse me, I have been searching for potential reviewers for 3 months. Did the manuscript get submitted for review or are you still looking for someone? Is there a status called "under review"?

画长空 2022-04-08

1. The first review took 7 and a half months, with the first 6 months spent on finding reviewers.
2. The review process took three months.

The reviewers raised very professional questions and had high requirements for the charts.

张 2022-04-07

Is there a status of "under review"? It has been three months since my manuscript is in the status of "finding reviewers". Has it not found any reviewers yet, or has it already been reviewed?

遥感人 2021-08-15

Throw it over, it hasn't been reviewed yet. Two months later, they told me that the language and presentation of the article were not good, and it was directly rejected without review. Does it take two months to consider not submitting it for review? This is wasting other people's time.

xljya 2021-07-20

找审稿人找了好久... translates to "It took a long time to find reviewers..." in English.

ZhengkangZUO 2021-03-16

January 7th: submit
February 26th: minor revision
March 6th: accept