Verified Reviews - WATER RESEARCH
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

JoJo 2023-08-06

2023.08.06 reject (English)

JoJo 2023-08-04

2023.08.04 editor assigned translates to: The editor was assigned on August 4, 2023.

修改昵称 2023-08-04

Did the boss submit it for review?

JoJo 2023-08-04

2023.07.31 Submitted to journal - This text has been submitted to the journal.
2023.08.01 Editor invited - The editor has been invited.

-.- 2023-08-01

I'm sorry, but you haven't provided any text to translate. Please provide the text you want to be translated into English.

修改昵称 2023-07-31

Brother, does "under review" mean rejection without any explanation?

等风来ambition 2023-07-14

Hello, colleague! I see that you also work in the field of water resources. This is my first time considering trying this journal, so I would like to consult with you about its difficulty level. I specialize in scenario simulation and regulatory schemes, using the SWAT model. I would like to know if it is worth giving it a try. Thank you very much! I look forward to your response.

等风来ambition 2023-07-14

Hello, I really want to ask you something. I am working on scenario-based simulation regulation plans and using the SWAT model. I would like to know if I can try using this journal. Thank you very much! Looking forward to your reply.

朱熹 2023-07-14

4.25 submit
4.27 editor invited
4.29 with editor
4.30 under review
5.20 with editor
5.28 with editor
5.30 Major revision (Deadline: 6.28)
6.25 Revised with editor
6.27 editor invited
7.1 editor assigned
7.2 under review
7.3 under review
7.14 accept

De-Frank 2023-07-12

2023-05-21 submit manuscript
2023-06-17 moderate revision
2023-07-06 submit revised manuscript-R1
2023-07-08 minor revision
2023-07-10 submit revised manuscript-R2
2023-07-12 accept
The overall speed is good, looking forward to publishing new achievements on WR this year.

2023-07-07

Did the status change later? How long did it take for it to change? My Editor Assigned has not changed for 12 days.

1221 2023-07-05

First review lasted nearly one month, major revisions were made, one rejection, minor revisions were made again, editor requested major revisions, a response of nearly 10,000 words was provided, the application time was extended and submitted, two people were selected for review, resulting in two rejections, sadly rejected after nearly 3 months, the reviewer had high requirements for innovation, hoping the next submission will be accepted.

霜山掮客 2023-07-05

This situation is when the chief editor invites the editor who is currently busy or temporarily not responsible for handling the manuscripts in this field. The editor will be reassigned.

zzy 2023-07-04

6.22 submit
6.27 editor invited
7.2 Editor Declined Invitation
Although I don't know why the editor declined to handle it, the speed is really slow. Anyway, let's just submit it for review and wait for it.

想要减肥的马里奥 2023-06-23

2023/5/30 - Submitted to Journal
2023/6/1 - With editor
2023/6/1 - Under review
2023/6/1 - Invitation accepted by reviewer
2023/6/2 - Invitation accepted by reviewer
2023/6/4 - Invitation accepted by reviewer
2023/6/20 - Reviewer submits response/comments
2023/6/22 - Reviewer submits response/comments
Waiting~ Hoping for a positive outcome.

我姓刘 2023-06-02

24 Apr 2023: Submission
26 Apr 2023: Editor invited
13 May 2023: Editor assigned
1 June 2023: Under review
WR is quite slow.

kxs149 2023-05-23

Graduation season is indeed slow. It has been two weeks since the resubmission was submitted, but it is still assigned to the editor.

我真的很不错腻 2023-05-23

404NotFound

小花不是笑话 2023-05-23

Number 10 has already been reviewed and completed. We can only wait patiently now, which is agonizing.

我真的很不错腻 2023-05-23

If it has been such a long time without an update, you can first check if the track link is a review complete. If it is, it means the review is done and you can proceed to editing. If not, it is possible that they are still looking for reviewers.

小花不是笑话 2023-05-23

09 May 2023 With Editor
23 May 2023 still With Editor

今天小杨学习了吗 2023-05-19

2023.05.04 with editor - Accepted with editor on May 4, 2023.
2023.05.08 reject - Rejected on May 8, 2023.

我姓刘 2023-05-18

24 Apr 2023 submit
26 Apr 2023 editor invited
13 May 2023 Editor Assigned
I don't know if I can wait for another chance to submit it.

我真的很不错腻 2023-05-15

Yeah, I don't know how I ended up rejecting it.

小花不是笑话 2023-05-15

What? Both major repairs and minor repairs can still be rejected?

KneeYu 2023-05-14

Rejected, transferred to sbb and submitted for review.

Xhmsm 2023-05-08

During the Chinese New Year period, it is slower and requires patience to wait.

2022.11.24 Submitted to Journal
2022.11.25 Editor Invited
2022.12.4 Editor Assigned
2022.12.5 Under Review
Several UR
2023.2.6 Under Review
2023.2.24 With Editor
2023.3.2 Major revision (one major revision and one minor revision)
2023.3.24 Resubmit
2023.3.24 Editor Invited
2023.3.28 Under Review
2023.4.5 Minor revision
2023.4.10 Resubmit
2023.4.11 Editor Invited
2023.4.12 Editor Assigned
2023.4.12 Accepted

紫薯天堂 2023-05-03

Hello, may I ask if there have been any changes in the status of "Submitted to Journal" since it went through major revisions? I have only submitted my manuscript for one week, and in the process, I had to resubmit it once to make formatting changes. After resubmission, the status has remained as "Submitted to Journal".

今天小杨学习了吗 2023-04-28

2023.02.28 Submitted to Journal
2023.03.01 Editor Invited
2023.03.02 Editor Assigned
2023.03.14 Under review
2023.03.18 Under review
2023.03.24 Under review
2023.03.28 Under review
2023.04.16 Under review
2023.04.19 Under review

Translation:
2023.02.28 Submitted to Journal
2023.03.01 Editor Invited
2023.03.02 Editor Assigned
2023.03.14 Under review
2023.03.18 Under review
2023.03.24 Under review
2023.03.28 Under review
2023.04.16 Under review
2023.04.19 Under review

小花不是笑话 2023-04-27

Apr 27, 2023 under review
A reviewer has agreed to review it.

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started