司马圣 2023-08-06

I submitted my work on 7.12, just like you did, and it is still under review now.

AM123 2023-08-06

Perhaps only one reviewer's opinion has come back, and now we are waiting for the opinion of the second reviewer, so it has been RRC all along.

晋哥铁马 2023-08-06

23.8.6 Is RRC not taking a break for editing? [Sweating]

AM123 2023-08-04

What is the current situation?

晋哥铁马 2023-08-02

23.8.1 The date has been updated but it is still rrc.

U-lucky 2023-07-30

5.29 with Editor
6.4 with Editor
6.9 with Editor
6.11 under review
6.27 required reviews completed
7.9 compulsory major revision
7.22 submitted
7.25 with Editor
7.29 accept

Translation:
5.29 with Editor
6.4 with Editor
6.9 with Editor
6.11 under review
6.27 required reviews completed
7.9 compulsory major revision
7.22 submitted
7.25 with Editor
7.29 accept

晋哥铁马 2023-07-29

23.7.29 Still RRC, nervous _(:з」∠)_

张牧之* 2023-07-27

Excuse me, how is the RRC result? Could you please keep me posted?

晋哥铁马 2023-07-27

23.7.26 Required Reviews Completed
Could it be finished reviewing already? It seems a bit fast.

Yue z 2023-07-25

Indeed, so from Guotao to Outao, I have already made some profit.

晋哥铁马 2023-07-24

If we consider IF and partition, European ceramics are the best, while Chinese ceramics and American ceramics are similar.

Yue z 2023-07-23

Is Guo Tao stronger than Ou Tao now?

晋哥铁马 2023-07-21

23.7.12 submitted
23.7.15 with editor
23.7.17 under review

This article was rejected by Guo Tao for the reason of lacking TEM analysis; after adding it, it was submitted to Meitao, but they rejected it due to receiving too many articles recently; with a hopeful attitude, it was then submitted to Eurotao, at least it has reached the reviewer stage. Graduation is just one article away, hoping for a smooth acceptance, even if it requires major revisions.

shawlili 2023-07-11

2023.4.18 Second review rejected, only one reviewer, suspected to be European, reviewed very "strictly". The total time span is 5-6 months, so those who submit to this journal need to think carefully.

jiamaolee 2023-07-10

Does it take about 20 days for European Ceramic to be reviewed by the editors? This journal is too strict. 2-3 editors do preliminary review first, and it seems that each editor needs to spend more than 5 days on it.

科研农民工555 2023-07-08

How are things going now?

科研农民工555 2023-07-08

7.8号 under review translates to "Under review on the 7th of August."

科研农民工555 2023-07-06

Submitted the first draft on the 20th, still in the process with the editor today. I'm going crazy.

猜 2023-07-03

04/17 submitted
04/18 with editor
04/20 with editor
05/07 under review
06/03 compulsory major revision, only received feedback from one expert
06/16 submitted revision, with editor
06/17 compulsory minor revision, reviewer responded on the same day, very quick
06/18 submitted revision, with editor
06/19 under review
06/28 accept
The two rounds of initial review by the editor took a relatively long time, usually exceeding two weeks. The duration of the external review depends on the efficiency of the reviewers. I felt uneasy until I received the review comments, as the reviewers only provided feedback on the introduction and some parts of the discussion. I hope European Ceramic Society can continue to improve!

科研农民工555 2023-07-02

The second edit was made, but it has been staying at the second editor's place for almost a week now (received the second editor's email on the 26th).

Tanglong zhu 2023-06-25

Can everyone help me take a look? "小修" has been under review for 10 days and there is still no update. Is this normal?

Tanglong zhu 2023-06-25

04/21 submitted
04/23 with editor, Todd
04/27 with editor, Vignoles
05/09 under review
05/23 under review
06/09 compulsory minor revision
06/13 with editor
06/15 under review

Translation:
04/21 submitted
04/23 with editor, Todd
04/27 with editor, Vignoles
05/09 under review
05/23 under review
06/09 compulsory minor revision
06/13 with editor
06/15 under review

科研农民工555 2023-06-25

How are things now? I live upstairs, and I have encountered the same problem as you.

科研农民工555 2023-06-25

6.20 submit
6.21 with editor
6.25 still with editor. I heard that it has to go through three editors, it's so difficult, I haven't started yet! I'm worried about my first submission.

Let 2023-06-16

Has it been submitted for review? Otto's review process has become slower.

张现馨 2023-05-29

I would like to ask all the experts here, my May 8th submission is still "with editor" until now, May 29th. Does this mean it will be rejected?

neko 2023-05-13

This is normal, the process I followed when submitting also had the same steps. Just wait for another week and it should be ready for review.

Jinchao Zhao 2023-05-11

2022.10.8 submit
2022.10.10 with editor
2022.10.22 Under Review
10.31 Under Review
11.12 Under Review
11.20 Under Review
12.03 Under Review
12.09 Under Review
12.15 Under Review
12.23 Under Review
2023.1.7 Under Review
2023.1.13 Under Review
2023.1.20 Under Review
2023.1.27 Under Review
2023.1.30 Required Reviews Complete
2023.1.30 Reject (One reviewer accepted the review on the 27th, completed it in 3 days, but the comments were not relevant. It felt unprofessional.)
The first reviewer accepted the review and never completed it. Overall, it was a waste of time and almost caused a delay in graduation. I will never submit again.

青衫衫衫 2023-04-14

Do you know what's going on? First to the chief editor, then to the senior editor, and then to the editor. What's this situation? Can it be submitted for review?

青衫衫衫 2023-04-14

What does it mean to go through 3 rounds of editing? Can it be submitted for review? From chief editor to senior editor and then to editor, what does this mean?