xiaob 2023-08-08

I don't know, it's still the same state now.

Mr.E 2023-08-03

2023.07.01 resubmit - Please submit again by July 1st, 2023.
2023.07.03 awaiting reviewer scores - Currently waiting for scores from reviewers.
2023.07.25 awaiting ae recommendation - Currently waiting for a recommendation from the Associate Editor.
2023.07.27 awaiting co-eic recommendation, awaiting eic decision - Currently waiting for a recommendation from the Co-Editor-in-Chief and a decision from the Editor-in-Chief.
2023.08.02 conditionally accept - Accepted with conditions.

GREENY 2023-08-02

Excuse me, everyone. It has been over a month since the revised manuscript was resubmitted on June 24th for rejection. It is still in the review process. Haven't they found a reviewer yet?

多目标进化优化 2023-08-02

I had already agreed conditionally to return it, but they asked me to be a reviewer before I even won.

蓝色的风18 2023-08-01

The results came out last week, with major revisions. There were four reviewers: one accepted, one suggested minor revisions, one suggested major revisions, and one rejected the paper (likely due to not understanding the innovative aspects of the article in the field). It seems that it was difficult for the co-editors-in-chief to judge the value of the paper, so they took some time to carefully read the article. Therefore, the long waiting time for the co-editors-in-chief indicates a high probability of thorough evaluation of the content of the article.

学术学徒 2023-07-30

How long has this "Awaiting Co-EIC Recommendation" status been going on? It has been about ten days for me already. Does it mean the longer it takes, the bigger the problem?

金典喵 2023-07-29

2023.07.03 Conditionally accept with major mandatory changes
5 reviewers agree to accept, 1 reviewer raises 4 sharp opinions
2023.07.29 Resubmit after modification, In review process
Pay attention to the soft review reviewer!!!

xiaob 2023-07-29

2023.0729 - Awaiting Co-EIC Recommendation

xiaob 2023-07-29

2023.7.29Awaiting Co-EIC Recommendation

Translation: We are waiting for the recommendation from the Co-EIC (Co-Editor-in-Chief) on July 29, 2023.

xiaob 2023-07-29

2023.06.10 Submitted
2023.07.20 Awaiting Co-EIC Recommendation

蓝色的风18 2023-07-25

Generally, it is necessary to add a reviewer.

GREENY 2023-07-25

Is there a new reviewer after the rejection and resubmission?

GREENY 2023-07-25

Can I ask what happened afterwards?

mamba丶mentality 2023-07-22

Is EIC taking a break recently? I've been stuck on EIC for the past five to six days.

蓝色的风18 2023-07-20

Awaiting Co-EIC Recommendation. It's been almost a month... I guess this editor has gone on vacation.

heyhey 2023-07-16

Okay, okay, thank you, I guess yours will be soon too, wishing you a good result.

蓝色的风18 2023-07-16

Oh, then I guess mine will be soon too. Keep it up! My first TPEL is in the process of being revised and resubmitted, so I'll make sure to make good revisions.

heyhey 2023-07-16

I am submitting for the first time, received the result, got rejected, and then revised and resubmitted.

蓝色的风18 2023-07-14

Is it possible... are you also a revision draft?

heyhey 2023-07-13

We should be together, maybe we haven't even met.

多目标进化优化 2023-07-13

2022.05.29 Submission
2022.06.02 in review process
2022.06.04 awaiting reviewer scores
2023.07.07 awaiting AE recommendations
2023.07.08 awaiting EIC decision
2023.07.11 Conditionally accept with major mandatory changes (4 weeks)
4 reviewers, over 20 comments.

蓝色的风18 2023-07-13

No change, still co-EIC recommendation; I resubmitted it for the second time after modification... It wasn't this slow when I submitted it the first time.

heyhey 2023-07-13

What is your current status now?

PT-IGBT 2023-07-13

2023.5.30 submit
2023.7.10 Conditionally accept with major mandatory changes
Three reviewers, one with eight minor issues (grammar, format, wanting more design information), the other two directly gave "Nicely written paper that includes a lot of details." Relatively speaking, it was quite relaxed. The reviewer who asked questions also requested an additional experiment, which was a bit troublesome.
In fact, two Editors' Recommendations, one gave "accept with minor revision," and the other gave "conditionally accept." The editor's opinion is to maintain high quality with modifications.

SCI看看我 2023-07-12

2023.7.4 submitted
2023.7.6 awaiting AE assignment
2023.7.22 in review process

Translation:
2023.7.4 submitted
2023.7.6 waiting for AE assignment
2023.7.22 in the review process

SCI看看我 2023-07-12

Record the process of submitting my first PE article.

AlanM 2023-07-12

2023.03.06 submitted
2023.03.07 in review process
2023.03.10 awaiting reviewer scores
2023.04.14 Awaiting Co-EIC Recommendation
2023.04.15 Awaiting EIC Decision - Major review
2023.05.15 submitted - in review process
2023.05.16 awaiting reviewer scores
2023.06.19 awaiting AE recommendation
2023.07.04 Awaiting Co-EIC Recommendation
2023.07.06 Awaiting EIC Decision
2023.07.10 Accept with minor revisions or without change

Translated:

2023.03.06 submitted
2023.03.07 in review process
2023.03.10 awaiting reviewer scores
2023.04.14 Awaiting Co-EIC Recommendation
2023.04.15 Awaiting EIC Decision - Major review
2023.05.15 submitted - in review process
2023.05.16 awaiting reviewer scores
2023.06.19 awaiting AE recommendation
2023.07.04 Awaiting Co-EIC Recommendation
2023.07.06 Awaiting EIC Decision
2023.07.10 Accept with minor revisions or without change

heyhey 2023-07-11

No news yet, stay calm.

亮云飞羽2 2023-07-10

Have you got the results?

亮云飞羽2 2023-07-09

Can only wait, the further back, the more anxious my heart becomes. I don't know what the outcome will be.