博er 2023-08-03

Not necessary, the paper submitted recently has already been sent for review, and only one author has an ORCID.

rolin972 2023-08-02

Hello, I want to ask if it is necessary to wait for at least 3 months for a resubmission after rejection, as I saw in a journal. Because I saw that you submitted yours within 2 months.

Mr.ZHU 2023-07-30

AE gave a major overhaul, Shi Yang, the chief editor, gave me a position, I can't hold on anymore.
Why does China have to make it difficult for its own people?

小怪兽5541 2023-07-23

"Under review" has nothing to do with EIC anymore. Typically, one round takes place within one month.

陌路无悔 2023-07-23

Generally, it includes an introduction.

清晨看露 2023-07-21

If Shiyang hasn't made a decision, you can remind him. I have reminded him once before and then he made a major repair. His decision-making is just too slow.

博er 2023-07-19

May I ask if this TIE submission also needs to include a personal biography?

博er 2023-07-19

May I ask if the first draft of this TIE (Text In English) must include a character profile at the end of the article?

陌路无悔 2023-07-18

Similarly, in fact, the difficulty of letters is even greater.

nyannko 2023-07-18

Is there any difference between a letter and regular paper in terms of personal development, or do they both serve the same purpose?

LEEZHIHUI1997 2023-07-18

My EIC is also Shi Yang. How long does "under review" usually take? It has been almost a month for me now.

陌路无悔 2023-07-17

The 5th article has been rejected, with 6 attempts and 5 successes, including 1 letter. It feels like the number of manuscripts is increasing, and the requirements are getting higher. A major revision may result in rejection and resubmission. It is important to take the reviewer's comments seriously and thoroughly convince them if you disagree with their opinions.

yangJZ 2023-07-17

Another week has passed, and the editor-in-chief Shi Yang is waiting for a decision.

不会拉粑粑 2023-07-16

2022.9.12 submit - Submitted on September 12, 2022.
2023.2.16 major revision - Major revision requested on February 16, 2023.
2023.3.29 resubmit - Resubmitted on March 29, 2023.
2023.5.10 minor revision - Minor revision requested on May 10, 2023.
2023.6.4 resubmit - Resubmitted on June 4, 2023.
2023.7.13 accepted - Accepted on July 13, 2023.

Overall, the process took a bit long, particularly for the initial review and minor revisions. The main reason is speculated to be the rejection of one reviewer by the editor, leading to the need to find a new reviewer. In my case, the manuscript went through two rounds of under review during the initial review and minor revisions, likely due to this reason. It seems that the editor has significant authority, as they can potentially grant revision opportunities. There were four reviewers, two of whom were highly specialized, while the other two were somewhat less engaged. Overall, aside from the slow timeline, it was a good experience.

Kovalente 2023-07-16

When it had been about two months since awaiting AE recommendation, which was on Wednesday, I sent an email to follow up. Yesterday, it was awaiting EIC decision, and today the result came out and it was accepted.

不会拉粑粑 2023-07-13

It has been over 10 days since I completed the minor repairs and I am still waiting for the AE recommendation, but there has been no response.

yangJZ 2023-07-11

I have already arrived at Awaiting EIC Decision today and have been there for 8 days.

Kovalente 2023-07-10

I have been in this state for over a month...

yangJZ 2023-07-10

After the major repair, it has been more than a week since the status "Awaiting AE Recommendation". Is this situation normal? Have any of you experienced similar situations?

在读博士，求PE 2023-07-07

It feels that it mainly depends on the AE's intention. There is one reviewer who outright rejects it. In their first review, they thanked me for the great work but still wanted to reject it without any other reason. I wish everyone could avoid such reviewers.

在读博士，求PE 2023-07-07

2023.2.16 Awaiting Admin Processing
2023.2.17 In EIC office, Assigned to AE
2023.2.19 Under review
2023.3.24 Awaiting AE Recommendation
2023.3.27 Major revision (6 weeks, 4 reviewers, 24 comments)

2023.4.26 Revised, Assigned to AE
2023.4.26 Under Review
2023.5.27 Awaiting AE Recommendation
2023.5.29 Awaiting EIC Decision
2023.5.31 Minor Revisions

2023.6.16 Revised, Assigned to AE
2023.6.17 Under Review
2023.6.20 Assigned to AE
2023.6.23 Under Review
2023.7.5 Awaiting EIC Decision
2023.7.6 Accept

辣鸡研究僧 2023-07-04

20-Jun-2023 submitted
28-Jun-2023 under review
Unknown thereafter

小怪兽5541 2023-07-02

Submission Process:
2.1 Submission
2.3 in EIC office (EIC is Shi Yang, who is probably busy, the following rounds also stay with EIC for a long time)
2.21 assigned to AE
3.1 under review
3.28 changed to under review on the same day as awaiting AE recommendation
This means that the minimum number of reviewers required by the system has been reached, which is probably four, but AE chose to wait for more results.
4.3 awaiting AE recommendation
4.6 Under review and Awaiting EIC decision at the same time
(It is speculated that more reviewers accepted the review, but AE believed that the quantity was sufficient)
4.21 Major revision, six weeks, eight reviewers, very professional
5.30 Submit revised manuscript
5.31 under review
6.10 changed to under review again on the same day as awaiting AE recommendation
6.12 awaiting AE recommendation
6.15 Awaiting EIC decision
7.2 Accept

yuxxx111 2023-06-30

After 1 month of AE allocation, it is still under review.

Xiangkai Shen 2023-06-30

Status update:
As of 6.18, the status has changed to Awaiting EIC Decision. The final result has not been released yet.
What status are you in? Just wait patiently. Good luck!

yuxxx111 2023-06-29

Too slow...

yuxxx111 2023-06-29

Brother, has the thesis been accepted?

Carraway 2023-06-29

On June 27th, awaiting EIC decision, every moment of waiting is torturous.

Carraway 2023-06-29

Bro, do you have any results at the moment? Who is the editor-in-chief? My Tuesday is also EIC, it's super torturous.

Mr.ZHU 2023-06-27

Still no results, top-level torture.