一小只可爱 2023-08-03

Reply [anvien]:

Why do you say that? This can be said that this journal is not friendly. I replied to the questions from the first three reviewers for dozens of pages. During the second review, the fourth reviewer only mentioned the lack of innovative points without pointing out the substantial issues of the article. However, the editor accepted his opinion. May I ask if this esteemed reviewer has any title or if he has a conflict of interest with my institution? Why doesn't the editor consider the problems and opinions of the other three reviewers? Since they are not adopted, why do they still let the reviewers work for free? They are also obligated to review without any reviewing fees. Others have to spend time reading an academic junk that is destined to be rejected. It is not excessive to comment and vent a little.

Uaremyinspiration 2023-08-03

This number should be the overall number for submitting to this journal. My initial submission number was 16xxx, and the second revision submission was 18xxx.

lvjj 2023-08-01

Just invested, the article number has reached over 18,000. Does anyone know what is going on?

anvien 2023-07-15

Is it appropriate to say that it is because of rejection?

一小只可爱 2023-07-14

The second review process, from submission to final rejection, took three months! There was no change in the reviewer.

7517 2023-07-12

Did you spend four days reviewing it?

wangmu 2023-07-11

May I ask if it is necessary to select "Agree to preprints" as the last item on the first page when submitting a manuscript?

wangmu 2023-07-11

Do I have to choose to agree to preprints when submitting a manuscript?

北葵 2023-07-09

2023.03.06 - submitted
2023.03.12 - Immediate Reject - Scope/Format
2023.04.14 - resubmitted
2023.04.18 - Reject and Invite to Resubmit
2023.06.29 - resubmitted
2023.07.07 - awaiting recommendation
2023.07.08 - awaiting decision
2023.07.09 - accept

电气汪汪 2023-07-09

Normal, already submitted for review, just waiting for feedback.

frank.l.mi 2023-07-07

I want to ask, if I submitted my work the previous day and it was once labeled as "submit" in the morning, but later in the afternoon it changed to "Peer Review," does it mean it's not accepted?

MJITG 2023-07-04

May I ask how long it took you from submission to awaiting?

MJITG 2023-07-04

What date did the brother vote?

戈登弗里曼1002 2023-07-02

2023.5投 (投:投稿) - Submitted in May 2023
2023.7仍在同行评审 - Still under peer review in July 2023

Dr.YangHu 2023-06-29

Hello, may I ask where I can download the LaTeX template for this journal?

Dr.YangHu 2023-06-29

Hello, may I ask where can I download the LaTeX template for this journal?

Dr.YangHu 2023-06-29

May I ask where can I download the LaTeX template for this journal? Please, I beg you. Thank you for providing it.

wangmu 2023-06-21

May I ask if it is necessary to choose to agree to preprints when submitting a manuscript?

HiScorpio 2023-06-12

The website address of the upstairs is this: https://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/tcas2.

wyq517 2023-06-12

Does anyone know if its submission website has changed? I don't know where to check the status of the article I submitted before.

woshiyigekeyanren 2023-06-10

It has been over two months since my submission was rejected and I resubmitted it. It is still under review, and despite my reminders, I haven't received any response. It's really frustrating.

Ivan凡 2023-06-09

May I ask if you have received the result for your "awaiting decision"? How many days have you been waiting?

Ivan凡 2023-06-09

May I ask if you have received the result of your awaiting decision? How many days have you been waiting? Thank you.

MrAKA 2023-06-07

It depends on the situation. My case should be under review again. If it's a minor issue, the AE may decide on their own.

giggsht 2023-06-06

Hello, may I ask if the revised version will still be sent to the previous reviewer for review?

MrAKA 2023-06-06

Previously, my senior colleagues would receive their reviews within three months. However, mine took over five months for review. Fortunately, it was finally accepted. I have attached the review progress for reference, and please consider carefully if you are in urgent need of the progress.

Submission: December 15, 2022
Rejection and resubmission: March 6, 2023
Revision: April 4, 2023
Minor revision: May 4, 2023
Revision: May 5, 2023
Acceptance: May 25, 2023

The period for "awaiting recommendation" was about five days, and "awaiting decision" took two to three days.

CQXW 2023-06-03

May I ask how long it will take to receive the decision after "awaiting decision"?

CQXW 2023-06-03

Excuse me, it has been 3 days since awaiting decision. How much longer do I need to wait?

Ivan凡 2023-06-02

May I ask if you have started the second round of reviewing? Also, how long does the second review usually take? Thank you!

Jun Zhao 2023-05-31

Trash journal, the editor is always that person from a certain university, feels completely irresponsible.
In the second review, there were four reviewers, three of them agreed to accept and publish, but one reviewer simply said that the innovation was not enough, and the editor directly rejected the submission, wasting half a year of my time.
Feels like there's an inside story, the reviewer who rejected the submission didn't point out any substantial issues, the editor is very irresponsible!
This journal doesn't deserve to be called a trans-class journal at all, I will never submit to it again in the future.