网往狠 2023-05-15

I want to ask, did you mark the modifications made in the response to the editor and the revised manuscript with different colors?

eric678 2022-05-13

Brothers, what kind of replies did you receive when you rushed for the manuscript? Let's add each other as friends and communicate.

JamesBD 2022-05-10

It has been 11 months already, and the status is still "Under review." I have been pushing for an update every month, but it hasn't been helpful. Brothers who are in a hurry, please consider carefully before applying...

silkyrose 2022-03-28

After an 8-month long trial, one reviewer gave a rejection, but they must recommend their method to me.

xing 2022-03-17

First review took over 9 months, with two reviewers. One gave minor revisions and the other rejected it outright. The comments from the rejecting reviewer were rubbish and completely unconvincing. They questioned some commonly used models, but if they didn't understand, they could have asked for clarification. These reviewers are truly frustrating. Maybe it's because the editor has been constantly pushing them, and they are getting impatient. Let's submit it to another journal! (PS: It's possible that the editor has been constantly reminding the reviewers, and they are getting a bit impatient.)

xing 2022-03-11

The first review took 9 months, but the situation finally changed today. With an Associate Editor, the journal review process is too long.

JamesBD 2022-03-10

Thrown away for more than 9 months, the status has always been "Under review" without any changes. I have sent emails in between to urge for updates, but all I received were official responses with no useful information.

silkyrose 2022-03-05

It has been 7 months. I couldn't help but urge again. The reply said that a new AE has been replaced.

做个好梦 2022-03-01

2022.2.28 Accept - This text does not require translation as it is already in English.

silkyrose 2022-02-14

It has been seven months already. If you don't come back soon, I plan to withdraw the submission. I can't wait any longer.

JamesBD 2022-02-14

I can only say that the review of your paper is really fast. I have submitted mine for almost 9 months and still haven't received any feedback from the first review. I have sent reminders in between, but it doesn't seem to have any effect.

大杆子 2022-02-04

This damn journal is too fast. It was submitted at the end of September, first reviewed in December, revised at the end of December, and accepted at the end of January. It took 4 months in total. This paper was rejected after two revisions in TPDS. TPDS rejected my application after 2 and a half years.

xing 2022-01-21

It has been almost 8 months since it was submitted, but there is still no news from the first trial. It's too slow.

做个好梦 2021-12-14

On December 5th, I submitted my application and on December 12th, I received the first trial result. It required 2 major repairs and 1 minor repair. Currently, I am undergoing the major repairs, and the process is taking an extremely long time.

xing 2021-12-10

Six months have passed since the first trial, and there is still no news. The time is too long.

JamesBD 2021-11-19

How long have you been a judge?

做个好梦 2021-11-06

If it can be done in more than a month, then reject it if you want to. Can you give me a straight answer?

paper boy 2021-10-10

The free pages are limited to 12 pages, and additional pages will incur layout fees. The speed is relatively slow, but this is how Trans works!

JJJtu 2021-10-09

Mainly, I didn't make it to the awards, but honestly speaking, compared to TSC, this is already fast enough.

大杆子 2021-10-08

Is this still slow? Probably a master's student... It takes at least 7 months for the first review of TPDS and TSC... This journal is considered fast.

JJJtu 2021-10-04

The top journal in the field of cloud computing is indeed very slow in terms of the review process, but in the end, trans is still very happy!
Submitted on February 1, 2021
First review comments received on April 1, 2021
Revised on June 24, 2021
Second review comments received on July 13, 2021
Revised on August 6, 2021
Accepted on October 1, 2021

xing 2021-09-26

I have also been four months, still no news.

Matthew_90 2021-09-16

It has been 5 months and the status is still "under review", so slow!

Matthew_90 2021-08-29

After submission, it has been under review status for over four months without any changes.

xing 2021-08-26

How many months is your first trial?

silkyrose 2021-08-03

It's okay, the limitation is on page 18 of the journal (extra charges between 12-18), and we're still far from page 14.

xing 2021-06-21

It is not clear whether it is under review or not, but once the external review is completed, it will directly become awaiting decision.

做个好梦 2021-06-17

After submitting to TCC, the status is under review. It has been over a month and it is still under review. Does anyone know if the article has been sent for external review?

Mag 2021-01-21

Three reviewers, minor+major+reject. The feedback from the reject reviewer was still helpful. Although the Associate Editor suggested a revise & resubmit, the Editor-in-Chief still made a decision to reject, which was quite frustrating. I sent an email to the Editor-in-Chief requesting permission to resubmit, but did not receive a response, so I decided to submit to another journal.