Maurelle 2023-07-24

Gave a lot of advice, a total of 5 reviewers, the comments were all very detailed, maybe it's because the writing is not very good, hahaha.

确定是Ada 2023-07-03

Partners can also consider the special issue organized by Professor Tan at Peking University. The second volume is now available, which is related to the field of artificial intelligence and has a fast processing time, typically around one month. The special issue is titled "Advances in Swarm Intelligence, Data Science, and Their Applications, Volume II." You can find more information and access the special issue through the following link: https://www.mdpi.com/journal/electronics/special_issues/lc19mt0k3c. We hope this is helpful.

clin123 2023-05-30

Take note, submitted on May 26th, 2023, Under Review, currently still not assigned.
On June 6th, 2023, Under Review, it shows the Editor.

sk8兔兔酱 2023-05-05

Record it down.
2023.4.25 Submit manuscript.
2023.5.5 Assign editor.

sk8兔兔酱 2023-05-05

May I ask how long it took for each of you to be assigned as editors? It has been 10 days for me and I am still "not assigned" and "under review". Why is the assignment of editors for this journal so slow?

sk8兔兔酱 2023-05-04

Is it still not assigned to AE after 25 days? Is this journal so unreasonable?

Maurelle 2023-05-04

I have been in the "Under review" state for 25 days already.

sk8兔兔酱 2023-05-02

The manuscript has been submitted for a week, and the status has been "AE: Not Assigned" and "Under Review" all along. Does this mean that the editor has not been assigned yet? Is this normal?

Maurelle 2023-04-09

Hello, may I ask if there is a page requirement when submitting a contribution?

Maurelle 2023-04-09

May I ask if there is a page limit for submissions? It seems that other IEEE journals state that the paper should not exceed 12 pages. I couldn't find any related requirements on this journal's website.

NOWISGOOD 2022-12-13

How long did it take for you to receive the proof after accepting? I also accepted, it has been two months and I still haven't received the proof.

NOWISGOOD 2022-12-13

How long did you receive the proof after accepting it? I also accepted it, but it has been two months and I still haven't received the proof.

Nostalld 2022-12-11

23-Dec-2021 Posting
19-Apr-2022 First Review
05-Sep-2022 Second Review
08-Sep-2022 Accepted

小崔说事 2022-11-19

The translation of the given text into English is: "Submission is under review (capitalized), it has been almost a month, I don't know if it has been sent for review? What is the status of being sent for review?"

qqaa 2022-11-15

Is it normal for AE to be under review for half a month? Is it still being reviewed or has it not been reviewed yet?

Qi` 2022-11-03

Submission Experience:
2022.4.19 submitted
2022.6.20 major revision
2022.8.19 resubmitted
2022.10.19 accepted
Hope it is helpful for you.

Montoo 2022-10-13

2021.12.20 Post
2022.4.5 Major Revision
2022.5.31 Submission of revision
2022.9.14 Minor Revision
2022.9.22 Submission of Revision
2022.9.24 Accepted

NOWISGOOD 2022-10-11

Hope can help more people.

ws2022 2022-09-26

Hello, may I ask how long it takes for you to return after the second review and minor repairs? It seems like the process of minor repairs to final review takes a relatively long time.

ws2022 2022-09-26

Oh, sorry. Your minor revision will take three days. May I ask if you have received the comments from the third review? Are the comments from the second review easy to address? Should I make major revisions in the second review, even though there are only three issues? These issues might be difficult, so it's better to make major revisions. Would you prefer to have fewer issues? Because even after the second review, major revisions are still needed.

ws2022 2022-09-26

Hello, may I ask if you have returned from the third review? How long did it take for the second review and minor revisions?

Sakuya 2022-09-14

The given text "Accept (14-Sep-2022)" is already in English.

ws2022 2022-09-09

Hello, may I ask if you submitted a contribution? Your first review seems to have been fast.

Nostalld 2022-09-08

5-Sep-2022: Second review comments returned, two accepted, one minor revision.
8-Sep-2022: Revised manuscript returned, awaiting results of minor revision.

Sakuya 2022-08-15

Please add some more information. The review process is not really fast. The first review took four months, and the second review took three months. In the communication with the editor, I learned that the normal review period is three months. It may be because my field is relatively niche, and out of the three reviewers, only one or two are experts in my field. One of them highly appreciated my article, while the other was more critical. However, after a major revision, both reviewers acknowledged my efforts. Although the latter believed that there is still room for improvement in my experimental section, they also recognized my hard work. The last reviewer is probably not from the same field, but they were responsible and asked for clarification on certain details they were not familiar with (which turned out to be common knowledge in the field). In the end, only this reviewer provided two minor suggestions during the second review, and I was able to make the revisions and resubmit within half a day. I am not sure how long the review process for minor revisions will be, but I believe it will only involve the reviewers who had comments. I don't think it will take too long. Anyway, let's wait and see.

Sakuya 2022-08-12

2022.8.12 Second review, minor revisions, two accepted.

zzrzzr 2022-07-20

The review comments are very professional. In the first review, there were five review comments, all of which were minor revisions. After making the revisions, three acceptance comments were received within two months, and the editor accepted them directly.

JamesBD 2022-07-17

How long does it usually take for your article to be accepted after the second round of revisions?

up. 2022-06-28

The reviewer's comments are quite professional, and they can discover some hidden problems well. According to the revisions suggested by the reviewer, the quality of the article has been significantly improved.
Subject: Computer Science - Information Systems
Submitted: September 2021
Accepted: June 2022.

JamesBD 2022-06-16

Has your second review opinion come back?