4.7 Article

500 m.y. of thermal history elucidated by multi-method detrital thermochronology of North Gondwana Cambrian sandstone (Eilat area, Israel)

Journal

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF AMERICA BULLETIN
Volume 121, Issue 7-8, Pages 1204-1216

Publisher

GEOLOGICAL SOC AMER, INC
DOI: 10.1130/B26473.1

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. Israel Science Foundation (ISF) [855/06]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Following the Neoproterozoic Pan-African orogeny, the Arabian-Nubian Shield of North Africa and Arabia was eroded and then covered by Cambrian sandstones that record the onset of platform sedimentation. We applied K-feldspar 40Ar/39Ar, zircon and apatite fission-track, and apatite (U-Th)/He thermochronology to detritus from Cambrian sandstones of southern Israel deposited at ca. 500 Ma. U-Pb detrital zircon ages from these sandstones predate deposition and record the earlier Neoproterozoic crustal evolution of the Pan-African orogens. 40Ar/39Ar ages from 50 single grains of K-feldspar yield a Cambrian mean of ca. 535 Ma. The 40Ar/39Ar age spectrum of a multi-grain K-feldspar aliquot displays diffusion behavior compatible with > 560 Ma cooling later affected by a heating event. Assuming that the high-temperature domains of the K-feldspars have not been affected by subsequent (hydro) thermal events, and taking previously published K-Ar and Rb-Sr ages from other parts of the East African Orogen at face value, these ages apparently record Pan-African thermal resetting below a thick volcano-sedimentary pile similar to the Saramuj conglomerate in Jordan and/or the Hammamat in Egypt. Detrital zircon fission-track (ZFT) ages cluster around 380 Ma, consistent with previous ZFT results from Neoproterozoic basement and sediments of the region, revealing that the Cambrian platform sequence experienced a middle Devonian thermal event and low-grade metamorphism. Regional correlation indicates that during Devonian time the sedimentary cover atop the Cambrian in Israel was never in excess of 2.5 km, requiring an abnormally steep geothermal gradient to explain the complete ZFT annealing. A basal Carboniferous unconformity can be traced from Syria to southern Saudi Arabia, suggesting that the observed Devonian ZFT ages represent a regional tectono-thermal event. Similar Devonian ZFT ages were reported from Arabian-Nubian Shield basement outcrops in the Eastern Desert, 500 km south of Eilat. The detrital apatites we studied all have extremely rounded cores suggestive of a distant provenance, but some grains also feature distinct euhedral, U-rich apatite overgrowth rims. Authigenic apatite may have grown during the late Devonian thermal event we dated by ZFT, coinciding with existing Rb-Sr ages from authigenic clays in the same deposits and leading to the conclusion that the Devonian event was probably hydrothermal. Like the ZFT ages, the detrital apatite fission-track (AFT) ages were also completely reset after deposition. Sixty single-grain detrital AFT ages group at ca. 270 Ma with significant dispersion. Inverse modeling of the AFT data indicate extended and/or repeated residence in the AFT partial annealing zone, in turn suggesting an episodic burial-erosion history during the Mesozoic caused by low-amplitude vertical motions. Seven detrital apatite (U-Th)/He ages scatter between 33 and 77 Ma, possibly resulting from extreme compositional zonation associated with the authigenic U-rich overgrowths. The ca. 70 Ma (U-Th)/He ages are more likely to be accurate, setting 1-2 km as an upper limit (depending on the geothermal gradient) on the post-Cretaceous exhumation of the Cambrian sandstone and showing no evidence for substantial denudation related to Tertiary rifting of the Red Sea.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Interpreting and reporting 40Ar/39Ar geochronologic data

Allen J. Schaen, Brian R. Jicha, Kip Hodges, Pieter Vermeesch, Mark E. Stelten, Cameron M. Mercer, David Phillips, Tiffany A. Rivera, Fred Jourdan, Erin L. Matchan, Sidney R. Hemming, Leah E. Morgan, Simon P. Kelley, William S. Cassata, Matt T. Heizler, Paulo M. Vasconcelos, Jeff A. Benowitz, Anthony A. P. Koppers, Darren F. Mark, Elizabeth M. Niespolo, Courtney J. Sprain, Willis E. Hames, Klaudia F. Kuiper, Brent D. Turrin, Paul R. Renne, Jake Ross, Sebastien Nomade, Herve Guillou, Laura E. Webb, Barbara A. Cohen, Andrew T. Calvert, Nancy Joyce, Morgan Ganerod, Jan Wijbrans, Osamu Ishizuka, Huaiyu He, Adan Ramirez, Jorg A. Pfander, Margarita Lopez-Martinez, Huaning Qiu, Brad S. Singer

Summary: The 40Ar/39Ar dating method is versatile and can provide precise age constraints for a wide range of materials, but age dispersion must be considered. The interpretation of dates depends on the geological problem being addressed and the assumptions associated with each data set, highlighting the need for collateral information to better constrain interpretation.

GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF AMERICA BULLETIN (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Maximum depositional age estimation revisited

Pieter Vermeesch

Summary: In a recent review, nine methods of estimating the maximum depositional age (MDA) of siliclastic rocks using detrital geochronology were compared, revealing biases in most methods. The Maximum Likelihood Age (MLA) algorithm, based on a binary mixture of distributions, was found to successfully estimate MDA with less bias than ad hoc methods. This approach has potential applications beyond detrital geochronology.

GEOSCIENCE FRONTIERS (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Measuring Ripple and Dune Migration in Coprates Chasma, Valles Marineris: A Source to Sink Aeolian System on Mars?

S. J. Boazman, J. M. Davis, P. M. Grindrod, M. R. Balme, P. Vermeesch, T. Baird

Summary: Active aeolian systems are present across the Martian surface, with dune fields commonly found in depressions such as craters and valleys. The study investigated dune migration in Coprates Chasma, revealing that topography plays a significant role in influencing local wind regimes and promoting dune migration. These findings expand our understanding of local winds in the Martian environment.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-PLANETS (2021)

Correction Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

IsoplotR: A free and open toolbox for geochronology (vol 9, pg 1479, 2018)

Pieter Vermeesch

GEOSCIENCE FRONTIERS (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Blowout Morphometrics and Mass Balances

Thomas R. Baird, Charles S. Bristow, Wanyin Luo, Erji Du, Robert G. Bryant, Thomas M. Mitchell, Pieter Vermeesch

Summary: The Gonghe Basin on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau has been greatly affected by climate change and anthropogenic activities, resulting in the formation of large blowouts. Various measurement techniques were used to investigate blowout scour hollows and depositional lobes, revealing differences in sediment volumes between the two. The evolution of the blowout dune field is hypothesized to be a result of either downwind aeolian instability propagation or upwind instability propagation from higher points in the landscape. Recent dating supports the latter hypothesis.

FRONTIERS IN EARTH SCIENCE (2021)

Review Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Provenance of Kalahari Sand: Paleoweathering and recycling in a linked fluvial-aeolian system

Eduardo Garzanti, Guido Pastore, Abi Stone, Shlomy Vainer, Pieter Vermeesch, Alberto Resentini

Summary: The Kalahari Basin's aeolian dune sand is mainly composed of quartz, with durable heavy minerals, distinguishing it from coastal dunefields in Namibia and Angola. The western Kalahari sand sea has a unique quartz-rich feldspatho-quartzose composition, indicating first-cycle provenance from the Damara Belt and Mesoproterozoic terranes. Composition varies at the edges of the sand sea, with Proterozoic supply locally and basaltic detritus dominant near Victoria Falls. Multiple episodes of fluvial and aeolian recycling have led to the current landscape, reflecting past weathering processes.

EARTH-SCIENCE REVIEWS (2022)

Article Geology

The Segmented Zambezi Sedimentary System from Source to Sink: 2. Geochemistry, Clay Minerals, and Detrital Geochronology

Eduardo Garzanti, Germain Bayon, Pedro Dinis, Pieter Vermeesch, Guido Pastore, Alberto Resentini, Marta Barbarano, Lindani Ncube, Helena Johanna Van Niekerk

Summary: Elemental geochemistry, Nd isotopes, clay minerals, and U-Pb zircon ages provide a comprehensive understanding of mud and sand composition in the Zambezi sediment-routing system. The study reveals the four major episodes of crustal growth in southern Africa and the dominant factors influencing the composition of the sediments.

JOURNAL OF GEOLOGY (2022)

Article Geology

The Variscan basement in the western shoulder of the Lusitanian Basin (West Iberian Margin): insights from detrital-zircon geochronology of Jurassic strata

Pedro A. Dinis, Pieter Vermeesch, Luis Duarte, Pedro Proenca Cunha, Marta Barbarano, Eduardo Garzanti

Summary: This research combines detrital zircon U-Pb signatures of Jurassic strata from the Lusitanian Basin with other geological data to reveal that the basin covers two distinct terranes of the Iberian Massif. The west-derived deposits show an abundance of <310 Ma ages, with evidence of a middle to late Permian thermal event in some areas.

JOURNAL OF IBERIAN GEOLOGY (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

A large West Antarctic Ice Sheet explains early Neogene sea-level amplitude

J. W. Marschalek, L. Zurli, F. Talarico, T. van de Flierdt, P. Vermeesch, A. Carter, F. Beny, V Bout-Roumazeilles, F. Sangiorgi, S. R. Hemming, L. F. Perez, F. Colleoni, J. G. Prebble, T. E. van Peer, M. Perotti, A. E. Shevenell, I Browne, D. K. Kulhanek, R. Levy, D. Harwood, N. B. Sullivan, S. R. Meyers, E. M. Griffith, C-D Hillenbrand, E. Gasson, M. J. Siegert, B. Keisling, K. J. Licht, G. Kuhn, J. P. Dodd, C. Boshuis, L. De Santis, R. M. McKay

Summary: Evidence suggests that during the Early to Middle Miocene, sea-level oscillations of approximately 40-60 m were caused by the loss of virtually all East Antarctic ice during peak warmth. The presence of a large West Antarctic Ice Sheet during the Early Miocene has been confirmed, highlighting a key step in the genesis of a marine-based West Antarctic Ice Sheet.

NATURE (2021)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Diffuser: A user-friendly program for diffusion chronometry with robust uncertainty estimation

Li-Guang Wu, Yang Li, Michael C. Jollands, Pieter Vermeesch, Xian-Hua Li

Summary: Chemical diffusion in minerals is a powerful tool for quantifying geological timescales. However, there is a lack of widely adopted programs for diffusion studies and the uncertainties associated with diffusion chronometry are often not robustly evaluated. This paper presents a user-friendly program, Diffuser, which standardizes diffusion chronometry and propagates uncertainties to derived timescales. Three examples demonstrate the program's ability to recover timescales with internal consistency, efficient computing, and easy-to-use features.

COMPUTERS & GEOSCIENCES (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Crustal evolution of Western Europe: Constraints from detrital zircon U-Pb-Hf-O isotopes

Dov Avigad, Avishai Abbo, Axel Gerdes, Axel K. Schmitt

Summary: The study focuses on detrital zircon from the black sand of the Rhone River delta in southern France, which provides important insights into the major episodes of European magmatism. The results show that the black sand samples represent magmatic events at 0.55 Ga (Cadomian), 0.45 Ga (Cenerian), and 0.31 Ga (Variscan). The Hf isotopes in the zircon suggest the involvement of continuous crustal reworking during European magmatic episodes. However, the oxygen isotope analysis indicates the presence of a significant sedimentary component in the genesis of European granitoids. The study concludes that the prevalent Hf-T-DM ages obtained are mixed and do not confirm the reworking of Mesoproterozoic crust in the region.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Revisiting the 1959 Hebgen Lake Earthquake Using Optical Image Correlation; New Constraints on Near-Field 3D Ground Displacement

Lucia Andreuttiova, James Hollingsworth, Pieter Vermeesch, Thomas M. Mitchell, Eric Bergman

Summary: Near-field surface displacement measurements allow us to quantify the on- and off-fault proportion of earthquake-related deformation. This study takes advantage of high-resolution historical aerial stereo-imagery to measure three-dimensional displacement using correlation of the orthorectified pre- and post-earthquake image mosaics. The results reveal new strike-slip ruptures possibly associated with the aftershocks.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2022)

Article Geography, Physical

Thermochronological constraints on Eocene deformation regime in the Long-Men Shan: Implications for the eastward growth of the Tibetan Plateau

Yuntao Tian, Yimin Liu, Rui Li, Xilin Sun, Zengjie Zhang, Andrew Carter, Pieter Vermeesch

Summary: Understanding the spatio-temporal distribution of strain during the Cenozoic growth of the Tibetan Plateau is crucial for understanding the geodynamic processes behind plateau formation. This study focuses on the eastern margin of the Tibetan Plateau and reveals significant along-strike changes in deformation style, as well as two tectonic transitions in the late Eocene and late Miocene. These findings have important implications for understanding the uplift history and strain distribution in the region.

GLOBAL AND PLANETARY CHANGE (2022)

Article Geology

THE ZAMBEZI DEEP-SEA FAN: MINERALOGICAL, REE, ZR/HF, ND-ISOTOPE, AND ZIRCON-AGE VARIABILITY IN FELDSPAR-RICH PASSIVE-MARGIN TURBIDITES

Eduardo Garzanti, Germain Bayon, Pieter Vermeesch, Marta Barbarano, Guido Pastore, Alberto Resentini, Bernard Dennielou, Gwenael Jouet

Summary: This study presents a comprehensive provenance study of the Zambezi deep-sea fan, revealing that sediment in this area comes not only from Africa but also from Madagascar Island. The composition of sediment from Madagascar shows significant differences in heavy minerals and geochemical signatures compared to African-derived sediment. The study also evaluates the anthropogenic impact on natural sediment fluxes by comparing Quaternary submarine deposits with modern Zambezi River sands.

JOURNAL OF SEDIMENTARY RESEARCH (2022)

No Data Available