4.5 Article

A tool for productivity and cost forecasting of decentralised wood chipping

Journal

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS
Volume 12, Issue 3, Pages 194-198

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.forpol.2009.10.002

Keywords

Chipping; Productivity; Biomass; Modelling

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The growing interest in forest biomass has made chipping increasingly popular all across Europe. Many operators have equipped for the purpose, but the large variety of working conditions found in the European forests makes it difficult to correctly estimate the productivity of each specific operation, leading to uncertainty in crucial decisions. such as: operation scheduling, price setting. machinery selection and acquisition. In 2001, the Italian National Council for Research (CNR) and the University of California (UC) developed a spreadsheet freeware capable of returning reliable estimates of chipping productivity and cost, on the basis of user-defined input data. The model is still available from the CNR website and is the object of frequent downloading and inquiries. Such model contains a set of predictive equations derived from the results of 102 field trials, conducted with 30 different machines, under a range of working conditions. in order to facilitate comparison with other estimates and to achieve methodological transparency, the equations are assembled into a simple Microsoft Excel workbook, and the costs are calculated with standard costing methods currently used in Forest and Agricultural Engineering. Since then CNR has continued to work on the subject, with the goal of updating and refining the model. Such work has included 45 validation tests and a separate study on the delay (idle) time typical for different chipping operation layouts. The study was concluded in 2009 and confirms that the model developed by CNR can provide reliable estimates of chipper productivity under a range of operational conditions. Authors believe that such a model can assist European foresters in keeping ahead with the growing biomass sector, thus helping them to seize an important business opportunity. (C) 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Forestry

Manipulating grading strategy for the efficient harvesting of industrial poplar plantations

Raffaele Spinelli, Barnabas Kovac, Patrik Heger, David Helig, Balint Heil, Gabor Kovacs, Natascia Magagnotti

Summary: This study explored the optimization potential of short rotation poplar plantations by manipulating log specifications and grading instructions to decrease time consumption or increase log yield. The experiment indicated that abandoning the manufacturing of a second small log was not cost-effective, but decreasing small end diameter efficiently increased log yield without negative effects on harvesting productivity.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF FOREST ENGINEERING (2022)

Article Forestry

The Effect of Target Log Length on Log Recovery and Harvesting Cost: The Example of Short-Rotation Poplar Plantations

Raffaele Spinelli, Barnabas Kovac, Patrik Heger, David Heilig, Balint Heil, Gabor Kovacs, Natascia Magagnotti

Summary: This study found that shortening log length specifications can significantly increase log yield in low-yielding plantations, but it also comes with an increase in harvesting cost. Measures are suggested to mitigate the cost increment.

FORESTS (2022)

Article Agricultural Engineering

Productivity, cost and product quality of complete-tree processing in orchard termination operations

A. Assirelli, M. Brambilla, E. C. Leonello, N. Magagnotti, R. Spinelli

Summary: To minimize the burden on orchard termination and renewal, complete tree removal and processing is the most effective technique. However, specific biomass processing techniques are needed when dealing with rootstocks. This research aims to determine the efficiency of processing complete trees from orchard termination. The study found that combining a slow-speed shredder with a rotary sieve can effectively upgrade complete tree material into a viable fuel.

BIOMASS & BIOENERGY (2022)

Article Forestry

A cost-benefit analysis of pre-sorting using a feller-buncher in underdeveloped short rotation poplar plantations

Raffaele Spinelli, Natascia Magagnotti, Barnabas Kovac, Patrik Heger, David Heilig, Balint Heil, Gabor Kovacs, Matevz Mihelic

Summary: Early pre-sorting of log-trees and biomass-trees during tree crop harvesting can significantly increase the overall value of the harvest and reduce harvesting costs. This method decreases productivity for the initial feller-buncher machine, but results in a higher productivity for the processor machine. Additionally, pre-sorting makes whole-tree harvesting a cheaper option compared to cut-to-length system.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF FOREST ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Quantitative and qualitative workload assessment in steep terrain forest operations: fostering a safer work environment through yarder automation

Giovanna Ottaviani Aalmo, Raffaele Spinelli, Natascia Magagnotti, Rien Visser

Summary: Automation in forestry can reduce mental workload and improve productivity, but it is necessary to consider its impacts on other tasks.

ERGONOMICS (2023)

Article Forestry

Fuel and Time Consumption in Alpine Cable Yarder Operations

Raffaele Spinelli, Natascia Magagnotti, Giulio Cosola, Benjamin Engler, Stefan Leitner, Renato Vidoni

Summary: A survey conducted in northern Italy on 12 cable yarding operations revealed that the excavator-based processor was the main consumer of fuel, while the yarder accounted for less fuel consumption. The study also found that set up and dismantle, as well as commuting, occupied a significant share of total time, while relocation had a minimal impact on time and fuel use.

FORESTS (2022)

Article Forestry

On the Design of Hybrid Tower Yarder Drivetrains: A Case Study

Stefan Leitner, Massimiliano Renzi, Raffaele Spinelli, Renato Vidoni

Summary: This research focuses on the design of hybrid tower yarder drivetrains in the forestry sector to facilitate the transition to more sustainable equipment. Through simulation and data analysis, the best design and control algorithms are determined. The results confirm the feasibility of hybridization and the potential for energy recovery.

FORESTS (2022)

Article Forestry

Benefits and Limitations of Winch-Assist Technology for Skidding Operations

Rien M. M. Visser, Raffaele Spinelli

Summary: Skidders are cost-effective extraction machines. A study in Southland, New Zealand, compared the performance of a two-axle skidder with and without winch assistance on different slope trails. The study found that winch assistance improved productivity by 8% on a 30% slope trail, but had no positive effect on a 40% slope trail. Preliminary soil disturbance assessment showed low soil disturbance at the harvest site.

FORESTS (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Technodiversity-An E-Learning Tool as an Additional Offer for the Master's Degree and In-Company Training

Joern Erler, Raffaele Spinelli, Andreja Duka

Summary: This article presents a project proposal approved in the ERASMUS+ program for developing an e-learning tool for teaching forest technology at the Master's level. The article discusses the advantages and disadvantages of e-learning and provides a detailed overview of the development of course contents.

SUSTAINABILITY (2022)

Article Forestry

Characterizing cable-logging enterprises in Italy: production, workforce, equipment and potential for growth

Raffaele Spinelli, Natascia Magagnotti, Giulio Cosola

Summary: Interviews with 51 entrepreneurs revealed that cable-yarding specialist companies in Italy are typically small-scale businesses, employing 3 to 5 operators and producing about 5000 m(3) over bark annually. Their main equipment is tower yarders, supported by adapted farm tractors and excavators. Alpine entrepreneurs differ from non-alpine ones in terms of productivity and versatility due to differences in work environment. Non-alpine loggers face limitations such as fragmented private ownership, smaller hardwood trees, and less valuable timber products. However, further expansion of cable-logging south of the Alps could be achieved through the development of new equipment.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF FOREST ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Forestry

Productivity and cost assessment of two harvesting methods for medium-rotation poplar plantations

Raffaele Spinelli, Natascia Magagnotti, Barnabas Kovacs, Patrik Heger, Matevz Mihelic

Summary: The study compared the effectiveness of two different logging methods, cut-to-length (CTL) and whole-tree-harvesting (WTH), with two log length specifications (2 m vs. 4 m). The research aimed to determine which combination of method and log length resulted in lower costs and/or better log yield. The study found that CTL harvesting into 4-m long logs was the most effective solution, offering a better log yield compared to WTH and incurring similar harvesting costs. Shortening log length to 2 m increased harvesting costs by 25%.

SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF FOREST RESEARCH (2023)

Article Forestry

Seventeen Years of Forest Restoration with Small-Scale Technologies: Time and Fuel Consumption for Alternative Operations and Techniques

Natascia Magagnotti, Matevz Mihelic, Anna Perazzolo, Raffaele Spinelli

Summary: The study investigates the forest interventions conducted on small-scale forests by Forest Service crews in Verona, Italy, with a focus on restoring degraded forests. Data from 340 worksites over 17 years were used to analyze operational performance and trends. Most interventions involved thinning and conversion of softwood plantations and beech/mixwood coppice stands, with softwood thinning becoming more prevalent over time. Productivity varied between 1 and 8 m3 per worker day, with fuel consumption of 0.4 l m-3 or 38 l ha-1.

SMALL-SCALE FORESTRY (2023)

Article Forestry

Assessing the resprouting vigour of an Italian coppice stand after alternative felling methods

Benno Eberhard, Natascia Magagnotti, Rodolfo Picchio, Raffaele Spinelli

Summary: Coppice management is becoming more popular due to its ability to meet multiple demands in modern forestry. Mechanization is needed to improve profitability, and this study found that there were no significant differences in the resprouting ability of stumps between using an excavator mounted disc saw and an excavator mounted hydraulic shear.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Economics

Whose forest? A two-level collective action perspective on struggles to reach polycentric governance

Sara Lorenzini, Nadia von Jacobi

Summary: This paper fills the gap in the literature on polycentric governance by focusing on the micro-processes of conflict that precede its establishment. Through a comparative analysis of four case studies, the authors find that conflict can lead to negotiations and the eventual establishment of common procedural rules, which can sustain polycentric governance.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2024)

Article Economics

Was stakeholder participation in the PEFC revision process successful in Slovakia?

Hubert Palus, Lenka Marcinekova, Jaroslav Salka

Summary: The complexity and comprehensiveness of sustainability issues in forest certification schemes require knowledge based and transparent decision-making processes, which involve open and multi-stakeholder participation. This study examines the latest PEFC national sustainable forest management standard revision process in Slovakia from the viewpoint of stakeholder participation. The results highlight the importance of stakeholder understanding, trust, and satisfaction in the effectiveness of the revision process.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2024)

Article Economics

Developing community-based criteria for sustaining non-timber forest products: A case study with the Missanabie Cree First Nation

Nicholas Palaschuk, Jason Gauthier, Ryan Bullock

Summary: Non-timber forest products (NTFPs) are important for the spiritual and cultural identity of Indigenous communities, but current forest policies in Canada do not adequately protect these resources. This research used a participatory approach and community interviews to document local criteria, elements, and values related to NTFP development and conservation. The resulting framework can guide decision making and promote socio-economic benefits for the Missanabie Cree First Nation.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2024)

Article Economics

The coalitional politics of the European Union Regulation on deforestation-free products

Laila Berning, Metodi Sotirov

Summary: This paper analyzes the coalition politics driven by beliefs and interests in the new European Union Regulation on deforestation-free products (EUDR). The study identifies pro-regulation and contra-regulation coalitions and highlights the strategic alliance formed between pro-EUDR business actors and other pro-coalitions. Despite opposition from a weaker contra-regulation coalition, the EUDR was ultimately institutionalized as a compromise solution accommodating different beliefs and interests of state and non-state actors.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2024)

Article Economics

Is there a future for smallholder farmers in bioeconomy? The case of 'improved' seeds in South Punjab, Pakistan

Mehwish Zuberi, Michael Spies, Jonas o. Nielsen

Summary: Smallholder farmers play a crucial role in agrarian value chains in the Global South, but they are often neglected in technology-oriented agricultural interventions. However, they face challenges such as lack of resources, established crop rotation patterns, and market and climatic factors.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2024)

Article Economics

Harnessing the full potential of a global forest-based bioeconomy through non-timber products: Beyond logs, biotechnology, and high-income countries

James Chamberlain, Carsten Smith-Hall

Summary: More countries are adopting novel approaches to transition to a forest-based bioeconomy, which can address global challenges such as sustainable forest management, poverty alleviation, and climate change mitigation. Utilizing non-timber forest products is crucial for the realization of a forest-based bioeconomy.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2024)

Article Economics

Commercial timber plantations and community livelihoods: Insights from comparative case studies in southern Laos

Keith Barney

Summary: The social impacts of industrial wood plantations in Southeast Asia, specifically in Laos, are debated. This study finds that under certain conditions, these plantations can positively contribute to local livelihoods, but there are still issues of land dispossession and inadequate compensation.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2024)