4.5 Article

A simulation-based attempt to quantify the morphological component of size selection of Nephrops norvegicus in trawl codends

Journal

FISHERIES RESEARCH
Volume 101, Issue 3, Pages 156-167

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCIENCE BV
DOI: 10.1016/j.fishres.2009.09.017

Keywords

Selectivity; FISHSELECT; Nephrops norvegicus; Morphology; Trawl; Norway lobster

Categories

Funding

  1. European Commission
  2. Danish Ministry of Food, Agriculture, and Fisheries

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The selectivity for Nephrops (Nephrops norvegicus) in trawl codends generally is poor and the lack of steepness of the selection curve results in high discard rates and/or loss of legal-sized catch. This poor codend selectivity often is attributed to the irregular shape of Nephrops, which to some extent characterizes the problem as insoluble. In the present study, the FISHSELECT methodology was used to examine the selection process of the species in order to identify ways to improve selectivity. The use of three different modes of orientation for contact (contact modes) with the codend meshes explained most of the characteristics of the selection curves for Nephrops obtained experimentally. The contact mode with the smallest cross-section was optimal for mesh penetration and, when evaluated against experimental data, 87.5% of all Nephrops encountering the gear were estimated to meet the netting in this contact mode. The range of configurations of the meshes (e.g., opening angles in the diamond mesh netting) was determinative for the selectivity, and the selective process for Nephrops was found to take place along the entire length of the codend. Simulating selectivity in a diamond mesh codend in which the closed meshes in the forward part of the codend were replaced by more open meshes revealed that the selectivity for Nephrops can be efficiently improved. (C) 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Fisheries

A new method for estimating length-dependent capture modes in gillnets: a case study in the Danish cod (Gadus morhua) fishery

Esther Savina, Bent Herrmann, Rikke P. Frandsen, Ludvig A. Krag

Summary: This paper presents a new method for estimating the length-dependent fish capture modes in gillnets. The study focused on cod in commercial monofilament nylon gillnets and found that the capture modes were dependent on fish size. The findings have implications for improving gear selectivity and efficiency.

ICES JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Optimizing size selectivity and catch patterns for hake (Merluccius merluccius) and blue whiting (Micromesistius poutassou) by combining square mesh panel and codend designs

Elsa Cuende, Manu Sistiaga, Bent Herrmann, Luis Arregi

Summary: This study examines the size selectivity and catch patterns of different gear combinations in the Basque bottom trawl fishery. The results demonstrate the significant impact of design changes in square mesh panels and codends on the size selectivity and catch patterns of hake and blue whiting. The study suggests prioritizing research on codend size selectivity and the addition of selection devices once good selective properties are achieved.

PLOS ONE (2022)

Article Oceanography

Effect of ground gear modification on bycatch of rays in mediterranean bottom trawl fishery

Y. E. Fakioglu, H. Ozbilgin, G. Gokce, B. Herrmann

Summary: The study aimed to modify bottom trawl fishing gears to reduce the bycatch of slow-growing marine species such as rays and skates. Sea trials showed that the modified gear significantly reduced the capture probability of guitarfish and stingrays compared to the standard gear. The results for spiny butterfly ray were inconclusive. For most target species, there was no significant reduction in catch efficiency when using the modified gear, except for common sole. The technical measure of modifying bottom trawl gears has the potential to be an efficient and cost-effective way to reduce unwanted bycatch.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Oceanography

Reducing cod bycatch in flatfish fisheries

Juan Santos, Daniel Stepputtis, Daniel Oesterwind, Bent Herrmann, Uwe Lichtenstein, Constanze Hammerl, Uwe Krumme

Summary: This study developed and tested a simple roofless design concept to reduce cod bycatch in flatfish-directed trawl fisheries. The baseline roofless design consistently reduced cod bycatch by about 75%, with minimal impact on the catch of the target species flounder and plaice. The use of the baseline roofless concept could significantly increase fishing possibilities for flatfish.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

Estimating Discard Mortality in Commercial Fisheries without Fish Dying: A 3R Challenge

Niels Madsen, Rasmus Ern, Aage Kristian Olsen Alstrup

Summary: This paper focuses on the importance of discard survival studies (DSS) in EU fisheries and how to comply with animal welfare regulations in experiments. The field of DSS is influenced by animal research welfare requirements and is expected to become more restrictive in the future due to growing public concern for fish welfare.

ANIMALS (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Effect of Extension Piece Design on Catch Patterns in a Mediterranean Bottom Trawl Fishery

Andrea Petetta, Bent Herrmann, Massimo Virgili, Daniel Li Veli, Jesse Brinkhof, Alessandro Lucchetti

Summary: The study found that design changes that work for the codend of bottom trawls do not necessarily work for other parts of the trawl, and may even have negative effects.

FRONTIERS IN MARINE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Ecology

Accounting for Uncertainties in Biodiversity Estimations: A New Methodology and Its Application to the Mesopelagic Sound Scattering Layer of the High Arctic

Bent Herrmann, Kristine Cerbule, Jure Brcic, Eduardo Grimaldo, Maxime Geoffroy, Malin Daase, Jorgen Berge

Summary: Measures of biodiversity are crucial for monitoring ecosystems. Marine faunal biodiversity is often quantified using samples collected through trawling. To track changes in biodiversity, samples are collected from multiple stations. Estimation of biodiversity indices must account for spatial-temporal variation and uncertainty in sample size. The nested bootstrapping method presented here addresses these uncertainties and allows for inference of biodiversity changes.

FRONTIERS IN ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2022)

Article Fisheries

Fixed mesh shape reduces variability in codend size selection

Zita Bak-Jensen, Bent Herrmann, Juan Santos, Nadine Jacques, Valentina Melli, Jordan P. Feekings

Summary: This study found that the commonly used diamond-mesh codends in demersal trawls tend to have varying mesh geometry during fishing, resulting in an unclear size selection process. By comparing experimental tests, it was discovered that rigid codends with constant mesh geometry have better stability in size selection for Atlantic cod. These findings can guide the design of more suitable codends in future research.

CANADIAN JOURNAL OF FISHERIES AND AQUATIC SCIENCES (2022)

Article Fisheries

Managing size selectivity: the relevance of compulsory and alternative selection devices in the Northeast Atlantic bottom trawl fishery

Jesse Brinkhof, Manu Sistiaga, Bent Herrmann, Eduardo Grimaldo, Roger B. Larsen

Summary: The use of compulsory selectivity gear configuration in the bottom trawl fishery in the Northeast Atlantic has shown problems with performance and efficiency. A recent study compared different gear configurations and found that an alternative codend with shortened lastridge ropes and a thinner twine improved size selectivity. The study also suggested that the abundance of cod below minimum legal size in the fishing area was low, and spatial and seasonal closures combined with flexible selection devices and modern monitoring tools could be an alternative to rigid enforcement of selective fishing gear.

ICES JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Oceanography

The effect of grid size on catch efficiency and by-catch in the demersal trawl fishery for Norway pout (Trisopterus esmarkii)

Jesse Brinkhof, Eduardo Grimaldo, Bent Herrmann, Hermann Pettersen

Summary: This study compared the effectiveness of two different sizes of sorting grids in Norway pout fishery, finding that increasing grid area can reduce unwanted by-catch species without affecting the catch efficiency of target species.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

T90 Codends Improve the Size Selectivity and Catch Efficiency of Shrimp Trawl Fisheries for Southern Velvet Shrimp (Metapenaeopsis palmensis) in the South China Sea

Bingzhong Yang, Bent Herrmann

Summary: This study tested and compared the size selectivity and catch efficiency of four codends for shrimp trawl fishery in the South China Sea. The results showed that increasing mesh sizes or applying specific mesh shapes can improve catch efficiency and size selectivity. Based on the findings, the T0 codend with a mesh size of 35 mm or the T90 codend with a mesh size of 30 mm are recommended as potential choices to mitigate the issue of undersized individuals. This study has important implications for gear-based management in the specific shrimp trawl fishery of the South China Sea.

SUSTAINABILITY (2022)

Article Fisheries

Escape, discard, and landing probability of Nephrops norvegicus in the Mediterranean Sea creel fishery

Marina Masanovic, Bent Herrmann, Jure Brcic

Summary: This study presents a framework for integrating both the size selection processes occurring in the creel on the seabed and the fisher on the vessel. It predicts the impact of mesh size and shape on the size selection in creel fishery targeting the Norway lobster. The research demonstrates the contribution of both processes and suggests an optimal creel mesh size for efficient selection of the targeted sizes of Nephrops.

CANADIAN JOURNAL OF FISHERIES AND AQUATIC SCIENCES (2022)

Article Engineering, Marine

Understanding the effect of design parameters on the filtration efficiency of trawls intended for commercial harvesting of zooplankton

Eduardo Grimaldo, Bent Herrmann, Enis N. Kostak, Jesse Brinkhof

Summary: A major challenge for the aquaculture sector is finding sustainable and cost-effective raw materials for feed. This study aimed to develop a more energy-efficient and efficient trawl for harvesting zooplankton. The results showed that the filtration efficiency of the net increased with increasing flow velocity and decreasing solidity and taper angle.

OCEAN ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Model uncertainty versus variability in the life cycle assessment of commercial fisheries

Giovanni Codotto, Massimo Pizzol, Troels J. Hegland, Niels Madsen

Summary: The results of life cycle assessment (LCA) studies are influenced by modeling choices and data used. This study investigates the combined effect of modeling choices and variability on the uncertainty of LCA results of fish products.

JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Fisheries

Lack of independence: An insidious and subtle pitfall in model fitting

Miguel Petrere Jr, Davi Butturi-Gomes

Summary: This short communication aims to raise awareness about the misuse of confidence intervals in Ecology and Fisheries statistical models that ignore the lack of independence.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Inclusion of ageing error and growth variability using a bootstrap estimation of age composition and conditional age-at-length input sample size for fisheries stock assessment models

Peter-John F. Hulson, Benjamin C. Williams

Summary: This study evaluates the impact of considering ageing error and growth variability on the determination of input sample size (ISS) in statistical catch-at-age assessment models. The results show that including these sources of uncertainty decreases the ISS determined through bootstrap methods. This indicates that there is more variability in age composition and conditional age-at-length data than previously accounted for. Including these sources of uncertainty improves the estimation of ISS and subsequently improves the quality of stock assessment models.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

The good practices of practicable alchemy in the stock assessment continuum: Fundamentals and principles of analytical methods to support science-based fisheries management under data and resource limitations

Jason M. Cope

Summary: Fishery resource assessment is a complex and challenging task, but with the use of different analysis methods and tools, effective management guidance can be provided even with limited data and resources.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Genomics goes deeper in fisheries science: The case of the blackspot seabream (Pagellus bogaraveo) in the northeast Atlantic

Regina L. Cunha, Joana I. Robalo, Sara M. Francisco, Ines Farias, Rita Castilho, Ivone Figueiredo

Summary: Recent advances in genomics have greatly contributed to the assessment of fish stocks by providing precise identification of genetic boundaries. This study used a genotyping-by-sequencing approach to reveal the existence of an additional genetic cluster of blackspot seabream in the northeast Atlantic, which was not previously identified. Factors such as ocean circulation patterns and local upwelling may play a role in the genetic differentiation observed in this study.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Good Practices for estimating and using length-at-age in integrated stock assessments

Huihua Lee, Mark N. Maunder, Kevin R. Piner

Summary: Estimating growth is important for fish population assessment. Integrated assessment models and the influence of misfitting size composition data have renewed interest in how growth is modeled. The available data types control how the length-at-age relationship is estimated. Estimating length-at-age is complex due to multiple sources of biological variability and difficulties in obtaining representative samples.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Role of material properties in acoustical target strength: Insights from two species lacking a swimbladder

A. Ladino, I. Perez-Arjona, V. Espinosa, M. Chillaron, V. Vidal, L. M. Godinho, G. Moreno, G. Boyra

Summary: This study examines the acoustic properties of skipjack tuna and Atlantic mackerel, both bladderless pelagic fish species, and explains the significant differences observed. The research shows that the differences in material properties of their tissues predict a more than 10 dB greater reduced target strength in skipjack compared to mackerel at certain frequencies.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Marine megafauna interactions with the Peruvian artisanal purse-seine fleet

Nelly Pena-Cutimbo, Cristel Cordero-Maldonado, Clara Ortiz-Alvarez, Joanna Alfaro-Shigueto, Jeffrey C. Mangel

Summary: Bycatch is a global problem for marine megafauna. This study assessed the bycatch interactions of the Peruvian artisanal purse-seine fishery in 2019 and found that all taxa groups were affected by bycatch. Dusky dolphins, guanay cormorants, and eagle rays were the most frequently reported bycatch species.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Analysis of the positioning factors affecting the sustainable fishing gear-Set net

Jen-Ming Liu, Po-Yuk So

Summary: The set-net fishery is an environmentally friendly fishery posing little risk to the marine ecosystem. This study identified ocean temperature, sea surface factors, and climatic factors as the main factors affecting the installation of set-nets.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Behavioural patterns, spatial utilisation and landings composition of a small-scale fishery in the eastern Mediterranean

Josie L. Palmer, Carina Armstrong, Hasan D. Akbora, Damla Beton, Cigdem Caglar, Brendan J. Godley, Kristian Metcalfe, Meryem Ozkan, Robin T. E. Snape, Annette C. Broderick

Summary: Small-scale fisheries are vital for global food security and cultural heritage, but the lack of information hampers effective management and mitigation of ecological impacts. This study provides the first comprehensive overview of the small-scale fishery fleet in Northern Cyprus. The fleet operates mainly over the continental shelf, using static and demersal gear types, and catches a diverse range of species, some of which are threatened. The findings can be used to improve fisheries management and conservation measures.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)